News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by varispeed on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#26824230)
I found that the chips for a project that I am working on are no longer available and I got the lead time of 13 months, without guarantee. It essentially means that I have to redesign the project using different part which may take me few months and I have no guarantee the other chip I choose will be available. The problem is, however, that I can see those chips available in their thousands on aliexpress and similar sites for 10x the price. I also read on forums that Chinese entrepreneurs buy all the chips and stockpile them. Is this some new kind of war?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by nickff on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#26824380)
Those AliExpress chips may not be genuine. Buying from unauthorized distributors has always been risky, and some companies (especially Chinese ones) have been know to stamp blank or generic parts with whatever part number you're looking for. The really tricky vendors will put a few (10-50) genuine parts at the beginning and end of a reel (to pass validation testing), with defective or fake ones in between. Non-genuine parts may also be lower-spec versions of what they are labelled as (like a slower microcontroller or a higher offset op-amp).
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Syonyk on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:44PM (#26824571)
For a fun set of reads on this ("Label the chips as what the buyer wants regardless of what they actually are") from a decade ago, Sparkfun got some "fake" ATMega 328p chips in that, in fact, were nothing remotely resembling an ATMega 328p.

In the words of someone after they'd puzzled out the puzzle, "...so it looks like that die in the picture is pre-release engineering material. Where the hell did you find that?"

https://www.sparkfun.com/news/350

https://www.sparkfun.com/news/364

https://www.sparkfun.com/news/384

https://www.sparkfun.com/news/395

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by jandrese on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:19PM (#26825634)
I'm guessing it's a sample run and the company realized there was a bug in the silicon and told the fab to destroy the rest of the samples. Instead someone at the fab set them aside for the future when they need some raw material to scam people with.

I find it strange that whoever decided to do this kept the correct datecode on the packaging. Presumably they didn't label them as ATMega 328s until the order came in, it would have been trivial to change the datecode to something reasonable for that chip.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Scoundreller on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:04PM (#26824814)
A proper scale should be able to detect weak effort fraud like this.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Syonyk on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:22PM (#26825003)
A proper scale can detect all sorts of weak effort fraud.

Years back, I talked to someone who had done some analysis on some of the "fake silver/gold" bars floating around places (I think they were common on Silk Road for a while?). Apparently some of the people faking metal bars didn't actually bother learning what a "Troy Ounce" was.

There was a "10 oz" bar that was 10 ounces - 283.5 grams. Except, in metals, "oz" means Troy Ounce - so it should have been 311 grams. You could literally feel that it was light if you were used to dealing with metals.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dan-robertson on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:29PM (#26825723)
I suspect it wasn’t really trying to defraud people who know what a Troy Ounce is. I’d find it believable if people thought fake bars at 311g were frauds for not weighing 10oz.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by routerl on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:06PM (#26824837)
This was a great read, thanks!
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by danmur on Friday April 16, 2021 @09:15AM (#26833477)
That's super interesting, thank you!
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by segfaultbuserr on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:59PM (#26827665)
It's a gray market. Sometimes, I mean sometimes, these chips are real and they usually come from a "leak" in the supply chain - unauthorized resales by small vendors, or "unwanted" surplus from a previous order or production run. Usually they exist only in small quantities and are stored and handled in unknown conditions, it's not something you want to use in production. But it explains why the AliExpress vendors always have some components when major distributors are out of stock (e.g. You can do it too - just order all the remaining stock of a rare chip from Digikey and put them on eBay...)

For example, I heard that a common practice in Shenzhen is selling reels of genuine components, but the "lot number" (serial number) on the labels are removed, so the manufacturers cannot trace these unauthorized resales back to the source. Another example, in a personal hobby project I needed to use a specialized controller that is not available on the public market, but a AliExpress vendor has them, it's likely surplus from somewhere.

> I can see those chips available in their thousands on aliexpress and similar sites for 10x the price

The quantity is not always real, sometimes they just put a random number here. And even when it's accurate, the sales occur via various online and offline channels simultaneously.

---

Disclaimer: It's extremely risky to order components from an unknown source, I do not endorse doing it. And my hypothesis on their origins is my speculation, so take a grain of salt.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Badfood on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:53AM (#26829642)
Random story... I bought some resistor kits from aliexpress. I noticed the few I used were super accurate. So I tested a bunch. They were all accurate to, not sure exactly but let's say 0.1% ish. I went and measured a bunch of 1% ones from digikey,and they were around 0.5 to 1%.

I guess they were tight tolerance ones that made it into a ultra cheap smd kit.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by segfaultbuserr on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:04AM (#26830111)
It's what happens when you buy random components, occasionally you get lucky ;-)

There's a saying I've heard before: How many 1% resistors can you find in a bag of 5% resistors? None. The 1% resistors were already sorted out and sold as such. I'm not sure how true it is, but if it's true, perhaps a bunch of higher-precision resistors somehow made their ways into a resistor kit not because of random chance, but because they were surplus...

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by rcxdude on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:14PM (#26836570)
Resistors are so dirt cheap nowadays it's not generally cost effective to make 1% resistors by selecting from a process which makes 5% ones. It's much cheaper to just tune the process so you always get 1% without needing to do the selection. And when you get to higher precisions you have a trimmable design where you adjust the resistance with a laser to get it in spec.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Scoundreller on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:04AM (#26830108)
I like to think we’ve gotten so good at making something as basic as a resistor that modern/established manufacturers are so consistent there practically is near-zero tolerance for error.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by swiley on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:08PM (#26826134)
This is why buying chips off amazon isn't always a great idea.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by pojzon on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:04PM (#26824812)
Its not war, just a good way to make a lot of money now. You buy cheap and sell absurdly high (10-20x the price). People still buy because they have no other option.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by a9h74j on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:21PM (#26827399)
In a way, having a 1-2 year manufacturing plan can be like pre-selling many still-discrete still-not-in-hand components in advance. In other words, short-selling.

Your BOM can be 1000 vulnerabilities to a focussed short-squeeze.

I suppose this is a predictable and reportable business risk.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by bsder on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:33PM (#26828341)
> I also read on forums that Chinese entrepreneurs buy all the chips and stockpile them. Is this some new kind of war?

I suspect it isn't just the Chinese speculating right now.

I do suspect that the Chinese are probably the only place in the world that had rolls of random semiconductors tucked away in various factories not being used. So, some of these are genuine--most are probably fake. Caveat emptor.

However, I'm am totally down with everybody who depends on Always Late Inventory(tm) getting a rude awakening. The problem is that the lesson won't stick.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by latch on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:37AM (#26830359)
It's democracy when it works in our favor, and war when it works against us.

People in Bolivia and Peru struggle to afford local food (e.g., Quinoa) because they're outbid (by money, but certainly not necessity).

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by toomanybeersies on Friday April 16, 2021 @10:24AM (#26834259)
The quinoa story isn't quite that simple. For a time, it was actually beneficial to the traditional growers: https://nacla.org/news/2018/03/12/quinoa-boom-goes-bust-ande...
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by ChuckNorris89 on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:20AM (#26831081)
That's the funny thing about democracy: It mostly works in favor of those with capital.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by tkinom on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:19PM (#26824258)
High tech version of "toilet paper hoarding"
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by throwaway189262 on Saturday April 17, 2021 @01:09AM (#26841729)
This is multi-pronged. Chip manufacturing output isn't flexible, and in the last year we've had:

* COVID stay at home * Every kid wants to be a streamer * E-sports becoming a real sport * 2 new console releases * Amazing new CPU's from AMD * Amazing new graphics cards from AMD/Intel. * Another crypto boom/bubble (depending on who you ask)

All these factors have put pressure on chip production.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by swiley on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:10PM (#26826152)
The difference here is that people are used to not being able to buy chips at costco/wallmart so you might have a chance at selling your stock.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by temp667 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#26824375)
China def is stockpiling more chips I think. The Huawei situation really brought home to china how the US or others could basically try and cut them off and they are doing a lot of things to reduce that potentially impact (all out on chip mfg, chip orders etc) so having stock may be of benefit to them in that environment.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by baybal2 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:42PM (#26824540)
Not stockpiling, a lot of people just do actual hoarding, and speculation.

Buying out all stocks of some rare MCU which only has probably few million units on the market at any given time at $0.1 just to resell for a few dollars later is quite real given the unprecedented squeeze.

How much would a car company pay for a rare, out of stock chip which is the only thing missing in a car worth $100k?

There is murmur in Chinese BBSes frequented by industry insiders about distributors intentionally either stuffing their part stock counts, or diminish them to play the price.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Scoundreller on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:02PM (#26824797)
So Martin Shkreli, but instead of pharma, chips.

And designing products around perceived availability that doesn’t actually exist.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:06PM (#26824840)
Just-in-time manufacturing is pre-medidated on the idea that whatever you need is available immediately for a fair price.

I think we'll see some of this in the future where a company's only purpose may be to hedge on bets on what will be unavailable in the near future for "a fair price"

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by jaggederest on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:02PM (#26827687)
A "market-maker", in the form of a financial firm that just skims pennies off, but for chip supply, instead of other financial instruments :)
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:37PM (#26829148)
I wouldn't be surprised if it ends up being like buying power "in bulk" where you pay a little more but there's a guarantee that when "the chips are down" (sorry, couldn't resist), the company will eat the difference.

I do think the market won't use these suppliers a lot just like the US-made masks which got millions of orders but only after china stopped sending stuff.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by neonological on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:52PM (#26825358)
After China restricted other companies from entering their own market then the only fair thing to do is to restrict Chinas' access to other markets.

I'm not a trump supporter but he did the right thing on this front.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by echelon on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:11PM (#26825549)
It's a totally fair game.

> I'm not a trump supporter but he did the right thing on this front.

It's a shame you have to admit that. I'm a liberal and think we should be putting a hard squeeze on unilateral trade. This policy makes sense for the US and other countries regardless of your party.

You can see that the US is starting to ramp up hard core. With international navies now sailing into the South China sea and a deafening rise of anti-CCP news and (admittedly) some propaganda, player two has finally entered the game.

I live near an air force base and over the last few weeks have seen (and definitely heard!) an almost daily fighter jet exercise. This hasn't happened in years.

China is going to be in a very tough spot soon.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by neonological on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:09PM (#26826147)
>It's a shame you have to admit that. I'm a liberal and think we should be putting a hard squeeze on unilateral trade. This policy makes sense for the US and other countries regardless of your party.

People like to join teams. So if I have an opinion that's not part of the "team" or part of the "other" team then people like to attack those opinions. That's why I make sure I say something along the lines of "Hey, I'm not on the other team, but I have a different opinion."

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by _carbyau_ on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:41PM (#26829179)
This "join teams" thing is a constant frustration.

If there is a problem, the best solution likely frustrates either team, at least a little.

And so time is wasted in bullshittery rather than getting on with the job.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by _Understated_ on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:38AM (#26831686)
> I live near an air force base and over the last few weeks have seen (and definitely heard!) an almost daily fighter jet exercise. This hasn't happened in years.

Funny you should mention that... I live in the UK and a few weeks ago there were military maneouvers near my house. I've been here 18 years and this is the first time they've happened.

Happened across the country too.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by deevolution on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:38PM (#26885170)
When the trading stops, the bloodshed starts and bodies flop.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Badfood on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:59PM (#26829295)
I had the same thing. 18k available on digikey. I even still had the browser window open, and the next day 0 available. I found arrow had 26 and everyone else zero. I managed to get enough for testing but will have to redesign now, but how to redesign for a chip I know will be available. I guess I need to buy a reel before designing. This sucks tbh
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Scoundreller on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:06AM (#26830126)
I wonder if OEMs are resorting to buying stock off digikey instead of from the manufacturer because they’re not manufacturing (enough).
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by foobarian on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:28PM (#26825706)
Heh. Let me tell you about how I tried to buy a new Nvidia RTX 3090...
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dheera on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:00AM (#26830503)
I really don't understand why Nvidia doesn't just give every buyer a test to see their knowledge of either ML or gaming skill before allowing purchase of a GPU.

Either

(a) submit a history of gaming high scores with dates

(b) a Github repo with Tensorflow or Pytorch code that has commits from at least a year or two ago

(c) play a hard in-browser game to show your skill

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by WanderPanda on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:34AM (#26830730)
What is it that I do not get about this joke?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dheera on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:36AM (#26830749)
That wasn't intended to be a joke. It might sound comical but it would solve the problem and would probably the first solution an 8-year-old would think of.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by z0xz0xz0x on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:31AM (#26841591)
I don't think mentioning that an 8-year-old thinking of this idea actually helps your argument in this case
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by acidbaseextract on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:14AM (#26831482)
Which points out the the real answer to the question: Nvidia doesn't want it solved. Not just that they don't care, but they're making more money now — so they don't want it solved.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dheera on Friday April 16, 2021 @11:34AM (#26835163)
Not really, they're selling out and making the same amount of money because the crypto-nuts buying and hoarding them are still buying them at list price. And they are not making use of 90% of the features available on the cards.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by feu on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:21PM (#26839214)
Are gamer or ML engineer dollars worth more than those of the general public?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by ahoka on Friday April 16, 2021 @07:49AM (#26832719)
What about resale? Would you forbid that too? How would they enforce it?

Buying a 3090 is not a basic need.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by voldacar on Friday April 16, 2021 @09:41PM (#26840922)
Or they could just you know, increase the price until quantity demanded = quantity supplied
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by rfoo on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:42AM (#26830791)
(c) could be cheated away, and (a) and (b)... I don't know, I guess if NVDA does this my best option is to sell my ML toy project repos to gamers :P
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by deevolution on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:43PM (#26885202)
That is just a horrible suggestion... Doesn't matter what rules or what level of enforcement you take to try to control prices/allocate resources... people will find a loophole to get around your authoritarian restrictions, and rightly so.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by hoseja on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:08AM (#26831445)
You mean like the Verified Actual Gamer program Linus Tech Tips is doing?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by pvarangot on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:15PM (#26825585)
Old-new stock and "unofficial" chips and parts has been a thing for like ever. Now I hear of more "mainstream" projects having to tap into that market but it has always been there.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by salmo on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:03PM (#26827274)
My boss at an internship bought like 20 NE2000 NICs for cheap somewhere in the late 1990's. We were confused when we would plug a second one in and it all went to heck no matter which 2 NICs we used.

We realized they all had the same MAC address. So we just overrode the MAC in the OS and got them to work.

Someone cloned a card perfectly :)

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by makomk on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:11PM (#26827331)
This happens a lot with cheap clone Bluetooth dongles for some reason - they all have the same MAC address, or one of a handful of addresses with some of the newer ones.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by simlevesque on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:37PM (#26827511)
> Old-new stock

Most commonly referred to as New-old stock (NOS).

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by thorwasdfasdf on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:04PM (#26825480)
according to one news outlet, I heard, the chinese have a long history of double ordering chips. Now, the strategy final pays off, as they can continue development. Most businesses don't double order because of the additional costs, now they're hurting more.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by cbozeman on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:00PM (#26827670)
> I can see those chips available in their thousands on aliexpress and similar sites for 10x the price. I also read on forums that Chinese entrepreneurs buy all the chips and stockpile them. Is this some new kind of war?

No, this is just good old-fashioned capitalism.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by deevolution on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:50PM (#26885235)
What's the alternative? only people deemed "essential" are allocated a GPU? how are you going to enforce that? by invading China and seizing the means of production?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by La1n on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:57PM (#26825413)
>entrepreneurs buy all the chips and stockpile them. Is this some new kind of war?

No, that's capitalism.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by bin_bash on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:30PM (#26829111)
arbitrage is probably a better description
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by coliveira on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:43PM (#26825258)
> Is this some new kind of war?

No, this is called capitalism! Everyone should be proud.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Guthur on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:52PM (#26825362)
You show a distinct lack of understanding of what capitalism is.

I can very easily hoard goods in a controlled centralised economy as well, the only major downside is the governmnent will likely throw me in some Gulag if they caught me.

It's actually market forces, nothing whatsoever to do with capital.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by KptMarchewa on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:40PM (#26825865)
One of the most common themes of propaganda in communist Poland was how speculants are responsible for all shortages.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by socialdemocrat on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:09PM (#26828575)
That is just disingenuous. If capitalism made no difference then governments would not have enacted things like rationing during times of shortage. It is a well known problem in a capitalist system that when products get in extreme shortage, the system kind of fails and you rely on planned economics, in the form of rationing.

Not saying planned economics is some sort of silver bullet, only that it has uses in extreme situations.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Guthur on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:02AM (#26829313)
Again, utter nonsense. This is human psychology reacting to a market, and nothing to do with the control of capital.

In a centralised capital control economy such as communism it is well documented that there was hoarding as well, communism never removed the human component no matter how much they tried.

Centralised planning fails utterly as the complexities of the supply systems are way beyond are current abilities to project. And fully planned economies have well documented failures anyway so your comment about this being a problem of capitalist systems is fully disingenuous; or maybe they were just not socialist enough, right?.

What we had here in this instance for semiconductors was a confluence of factors that I doubt anyone would have planned for. Also I feel much of it is sensationalized. We are talking super high end consumer electronics for the most part. The leading few nodes of production are mostly Apple for example and the further back in the production node you go the more players and capacity is available.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by remarkEon on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:33AM (#26830338)
>Centralised planning fails utterly as the complexities of the supply systems are way beyond are current abilities to project.

The price signal being the major data input that informs production plans. In centrally planned economies, they basically just guess. They'll lie to you and say it's possible to "predict" demand. And when supply constraints happen, well I'll be damned it's the friends of all the Party members that get their share first.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by throwaway4good on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:23PM (#26824300)
Yeah. It is called the US-China tech war.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by xyzzy21 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:35PM (#26836828)
Sadly I would not trust those Chinese chips. This is where 99% of counterfeit chips come from and often they either are sub-par to original specs or they don't function at all.

We have a similar situation - 13 month lead times. In one case we were able to substitute a $1 part for a $150 military version. The other situation can't be fixed so easily: Xilinx FPGAs. Each unit of our product has 120 of them and we are building dozens just for orders this year.

We've already had our assembly house lose $10K of parts through employee theft as well. They still don't know "how it happened" but honestly only a handful of people would know they were valuable and know how to fence them! Probably not minimum wage employees to be honest.

It probably is an angle to the war.

That and shutting down low-tech supply chains for routine things like TP - just so people know, the dominant standard supply chain for paper products is to use US/Canadian and Malay/Indonesian or Brazilian (tropical) wood chips, shipping these to China to make raw paper rolls, then bringing it back to the US to be cut into TP et al.

It's easy to disrupt things without even shutting down the supply chain - MOST JIT (just-in-time) supply chains (which are 99% of all supply chains today) are tuned to accept no more than 5%-10% volume variance so you can shut down supply chains by forcing the variance to 20%-30% without even going to 100% off.

This is part of what happened to TP in 2000; the other part was the fact that commercial and residential TP supply chains can not be mutually substituted - BY LAW.