News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by arcticbull on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:08PM (#26693626)
Interesting because the average transaction size, quantity of first party sales and quantity of resales have all fallen off a cliff over the last few weeks. I guess the memo hasn’t made it all the way to Dubai haha. [1] Probably more money laundering haha.

Good for her though!

[1] https://nonfungible.com/market/history

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by dcolkitt on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:11PM (#26693647)
And what a relief it's been for the rest of us non-NFT Ethereum users. Gas fees were even under 100 Gwei today!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by umvi on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:48PM (#26693504)
Sounds like the sale went at least partially to Laina (the girl in the picture)? It sounds like Bad Luck Brian similarly sold his meme.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by fotta on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:54PM (#26693547)
Good for her. If people are willing to pay the money then I don’t see a reason why she shouldn’t get her bag.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by hellbannedguy on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM (#26693614)
“ NFTs do not confer ownership—Morris cannot prevent anyone from spreading the meme, nor can the new owner of the NFT. But it certifies authenticity, like a digital autograph from Morris herself.”

I still don’t get it.

I said this here about bitcoin years ago, and was completely wrong though. So many nights thinking about putting together a rig, but laziness, or doubt, prevented me from mining.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by arcticbull on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:13PM (#26693659)
No you were right about Bitcoin but wrong about the rationality of markets.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by dwaltrip on Sunday April 04, 2021 @11:09PM (#26694926)
This sounds contradictory to me. Are you saying the bitcoin is a temporary delusion that will somehow fade away at some point? What will cause this so-called delusion to break?

Btw, I'm not a bitcoin booster. I think the technology is interesting. Economically, I'm not too sure. Non-productive deflationary assets seem bad. I think it may be some sort of monetary tragedy of the commons. But there are some natural limitations that may prevent from spiraling too far out of control.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ikerdanzel on Monday April 05, 2021 @08:00AM (#26697877)
Exchange to conventional money like USD and Yen. These can be made illegal. USA has precedent for doing this with gold when it threaten their money supply creation ability. If there is no legal ways to convert all these digital coins to fiat currencies, their value will collapse to niche market valuation. It won't disappear completely, just enough to make it small like say total market valuations for baseball or pokemon card collections. Bitcoin technology depends on 1 fundamental flaw that is exponentially increasing demand on energy to hash. Essentially it is inflation of "energy money" to "digital money" for hashing "nothing". The demand is not triggered from population itself but the #1 increasing tech capability, and #2 algorithm itself that double the difficulties of hashing rate. Think of demand of toilet paper, that people need to buy not because they need it but the toilet consume more at a doubling rate whether you poop or not. And then itself become valuable when your neighbor willing to change it for fiat currencies. The moment government make it illegals, the value drop. Black market will exist but then law enforcers specializing to catch "digital exchange criminals" will be established.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by avidiax on Sunday April 04, 2021 @09:16PM (#26694400)
It's not that different than buying an original artwork. It's not as though you couldn't get a copy of the Mona Lisa that is technically superior (i.e. larger, no defects, modern materials, doesn't require absurd security, etc.).

The original artwork is an assemblage of atoms touched by the original creator, just as these NFTs are an assemblage of math touched by the original creator. The main distinction in my mind is that an NFT is not intrinsic to the original work. It wasn't created as a consequence of making the original.

We could create intrinsic NFTs if we wanted to. Something like a digital photo digitally signed by the author, with the outer 1% of the pixels cropped off and added to the NFT block, just as the back and unseen edges of paintings are used to prove provenance.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by vsareto on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:12PM (#26693655)
We should just start selling PGP private keys. NFTaaS
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by doggodaddo78 on Monday April 05, 2021 @11:17AM (#26700143)
Let's see how many my AMD 96-thread EPYC server can generate in an hour. We'll make millions!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by spiritplumber on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:47PM (#26693499)
I wonder if this is some sort of tax dodge.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by colechristensen on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:37PM (#26693794)
The intersection of cryptocurrencies and expensive art... it’s like what part of this isn’t some kind of fraud?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by doggodaddo78 on Monday April 05, 2021 @11:20AM (#26700185)
It's shady af rich people (drug dealers, actual princes, Nigerian princes, human traffickers, pimps, illicit arms dealers, stolen property dealers, and some Wall St.-types with gains they don't want to report) instead of burying or stashing money in cash houses or art, they just buy some crypto-backed nothings.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by proc0 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:08PM (#26693624)
I was about to comment along these lines. One thing is digital art, but a screenshot? Uh, something is fishy here, but maybe not and I'm missing something that is making this valuable? IDK
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by doggodaddo78 on Monday April 05, 2021 @11:23AM (#26700237)
It's apparent more and more that the image or digital deliverable itself is worthless, it's just the semi-"public" key while the private crypto signature is the crypto-backed part that is an exchange of actual currency. So, it doesn't matter what's exchanged, so long as it's sufficiently unique. I mean, you could auction a dick pic and it would still work.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by proc0 on Monday April 05, 2021 @01:01PM (#26701574)
Agreed, but it implies that piece of digital work has inherent value of some kind, otherwise it's just a vector for sending or storing money. I guess the question why would someone think it's worth that much? It seems equivalent to buying a house for some ridiculous amount and then "donate" it to someone. It's really the fact that it amounts to a picture of someone... I think it follows all celebrities can now NFT all their pictures and movie screenshots... something that by itself seems worthless since actors perform in a film, and the story is the central piece of artwork I think (in most movies). Anyway, it's interesting regardless.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by TameAntelope on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:06PM (#26693972)
So did she approach the NFT organization or did they approach her? It mentions Bad Luck Brian and Nyan Cat but were they specifically involved in getting Morris to sell?

It’s wonderful press for NFTs, but was it organic?

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by tediousdemise on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:16PM (#26693680)
I wonder if they’ll teach about memes in history classes in 100 years. By then, anti-meme and anti-hate speech laws will have likely gripped the globe, and they’ll be learning about us Web 2.0 savages. /s
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ModernMech on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM (#26693616)
I can't believe the Department of Internet Money as depicted on South Park in 2008 (where viral internet stars went to collect their earnings) turned out to be real. Blows my mind.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by doggodaddo78 on Monday April 05, 2021 @11:15AM (#26700116)
"Here, I have this limited-edition bathroom rug from my master bedroom, serial #3, and you can have it for the low, low price of $85,500."
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by chriselles on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:00PM (#26693935)
I wonder if we’re going to look back and refer to this as the Mona Lisa Meme?

I’m only half joking.

I wonder which one would win in terms of reach between this meme and the Mona Lisa?

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by jariel on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:05PM (#26693610)
To be clear - does the NFT come along with the publishing rights?

Because that would make it different than regular NFT.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by detaro on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:13PM (#26693661)
See "Collectors rights" in the platforms ToS: https://foundation.app/terms

he Collector’s limited license to display the Digital Artwork, includes, but is not limited to, the right to display the Digital Artwork privately or publicly: (i) for the purpose of promoting or sharing the Collector’s purchase, ownership, or interest, (ii) for the purpose of sharing, promoting, discussing, or commenting on the Digital Artwork; (iii) on third party marketplaces, exchanges, platforms, or applications in association with an offer to sell, or trade, the Digital Artwork; and (iv) within decentralized virtual environments, virtual worlds, virtual galleries, virtual museums, or other navigable and perceivable virtual environments.

Collectors have the right to sell, trade, transfer, or use their Digital Artwork, but Collectors may not make “commercial use” of the Digital Artwork.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by arcticbull on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:11PM (#26693648)
Almost certainly not haha, and good luck with enforcement. Remember Reddit’s reaction when the EU tried to “ban memes?”
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by randyrand on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:47PM (#26693500)
Couldnt I just create another NFT of the same image with maybe a slightly different color?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by naniwaduni on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:48PM (#26693507)
You could, technically, create another NFT of the exact same image. It just won't be the same NFT.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ASalazarMX on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:00PM (#26693582)
I'm seriously starting to think that selling UUIDs of virtual things could really take off. I'd call them "Green Carbon Tokens" because despite their carbon print being negligible, 50% of the profits would be used for carbon capture.

My database would be a text file that anyone could download and verify.

Edit: I mean plain UUIDs, so you could create billions with the same carbon used to create a NFT, and the signed text file counts as distributed because anyone can have a copy, I couldn't tamper with it and not be caught.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by sp332 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:07PM (#26693981)
Before the recent bubble with insane NFT valuations, this is mostly what they were used as. E.g. putting a QR code with a NFT link inside a limited-run t-shirt. Practically just an inventory tag.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by lostcolony on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM (#26693615)
This is nearly that, except the distributed ledger says who owns the particular 'UUID' (not actually a UUID). So we don't have to trust you to be honest with that database.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ytpete on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:23PM (#26693720)
But of course, the other difference is a dramatically higher energy cost. You could never sell any kind of "green carbon tokens" on the blockchain...
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by snissn on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:35PM (#26693781)
do it!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by norswap on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:03PM (#26693592)
You could even create a NFT of the exact same picture, probably.

But you'd expose yourself to a lawsuit because you don't own the copyright to the original picture, and if you sell for a high enough price, it might actually be worth the bother to the copyright holder.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by chrisco255 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:08PM (#26693627)
No, these memes are widely circulated and are even monetized through sites like knowyourmeme.com. You could mint an NFT of a meme you didn't create, but it won't sell for much, because people will know it's not minted by the creator. In this case these NFTs are only valuable in sofar as their provenance is verified.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by sp332 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:08PM (#26693992)
Copyright and other rights are not transferred with the NFT. So legally, that Dubai company doesn't even have the right to any copies of the photo that they may have.

Edit: this case might have been covered by a separate contract, but it's still not part of the NFT transaction. https://foundation.app/terms

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by dls2016 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:59PM (#26693929)
But if you don’t host the image, and only re-sell the URL, then where’s the infringement?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by erik_seaberg on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:35PM (#26693782)
Anyone could mint a token on another platform, but https://foundation.app/terms committed Laina not to participate. I guess they might sue for breach if she did, because it would hurt their perceived legitimacy?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by X6S1x6Okd1st on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:14PM (#26693665)
If you want to pay the minting fee sure, I doubt that people could care to buy your knock off though
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by Tenoke on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:58PM (#26693576)
Sure, but just as me creating a Mona Lisa-lookalike painting I doubt you'd get a buyer.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ASalazarMX on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM (#26693619)
This is not like painting actual Mona Lisas, but assigning serials to virtual things, like copies of a Mona Lisa picture, to create artificial scarcity.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by wokwokwok on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:10PM (#26694006)
Please correct the title: it was sold for 200 ETH, not $411,000.

These are not the same things, and it is (to my understanding) actually very difficult to convert large volumes of ETH into actual money.

One bunch of crypto coins was swapped for another, that’s all.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by downandout on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:17PM (#26694058)
It is not remotely difficult to convert large amounts of ETH into actual money. Certainly not $400K worth. The market is enormous, and a conversion like this could be done in seconds on a number of exchanges. My arb bot managed to make about $60K over the course of 2 very lucky days about a month ago on the Binance Smart Chain. Converting BNB to ETH on the main chain, then cashing it in for fiat, couldn't have been easier. It didn't come close to causing a ripple in the market.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by amelius on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:48PM (#26693508)
Why would HN be interested in this? Oh wait, it's about making money without doing any actual work.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by dang on Monday April 05, 2021 @01:13AM (#26695572)
"Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by ASalazarMX on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:13PM (#26693660)
Making money via marketing, with a possibility of tax evasion / money laundering, which is even better.

Edit: Sorry commenter below, I edited my comment without reading the responses, and now your looks redundant, but you were first.

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by arcticbull on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:14PM (#26693667)
NFTs are also great for money laundering!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by stcredzero on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:38PM (#26693808)
I would be very disturbed, if it turned out that all the memes were eventually owned by organized crime!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by shoulderfake on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:21PM (#26693711)
Can you elaborate on how this is done
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by papercrane on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:49PM (#26693866)
Simplest thing would be a criminal "buying" an NFT from themselves with ill-gotten currency from an anonymous wallet not publicly associated with themselves and then claim the profit as capital gains.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by late-stage- on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:09PM (#26693633)
Hahaha, underrated comment
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by gerdesj on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:46PM (#26693855)
There was a lot of work involved - someone else's!

OK that's facile. NFTs are a thing. They are legitimised by a blockchain, which is quite a statement in itself (my words)!

NFTs are a thing that is messing with everyone's concept of normal, from young to old. This is not just the cool kids doing stuff - "Groove it dadyo" and all that bollocks. It is quite a neat way of using a blockchain to do something slightly more useful than the usual gambling. It's still gambling though.

The really rubbish bit is still Proof of Work vs Proof of Steak (mmmm steak) sorry Stake. How many unicorns were burned to prove that n owns a particular NFT? If n had instead paid cash they might have felled a couple of small trees but not an entire forest but then they would not be in possession of a NFT. They would still have the forest ...

Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000 by __blockcipher__ on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:56PM (#26693898)
> It is quite a neat way of using a blockchain to do something slightly more useful than the usual gambling. It's still gambling though.

This is nonsense. It's just another form of hysterical speculation.

The key to speculation is, if you know you're doing it, more power to you. But there are a lot of marks that think they're actually participating in something "legitimate".

This applies to more than just NFTs of course. One of the funnier things I stumbled across recently is "hoge" coin, which is a crypto "currency" that disincentivizes actually transacting in it, because every time you move money around you have to permanently burn off some of that money. See https://hoge.finance/. It reminds me of China's stock market where you can buy as much as you want, you just better not short sell and tank the price :)