Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by randyrand on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:47PM
(#26693500)
Couldnt I just create another NFT of the same image with maybe a slightly different color?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by naniwaduni on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:48PM
(#26693507)
You could, technically, create another NFT of the exact same image. It just won't be the same NFT.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by ASalazarMX on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:00PM
(#26693582)
I'm seriously starting to think that selling UUIDs of virtual things could really take off. I'd call them "Green Carbon Tokens" because despite their carbon print being negligible, 50% of the profits would be used for carbon capture.
My database would be a text file that anyone could download and verify.
Edit: I mean plain UUIDs, so you could create billions with the same carbon used to create a NFT, and the signed text file counts as distributed because anyone can have a copy, I couldn't tamper with it and not be caught.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by sp332 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:07PM
(#26693981)
Before the recent bubble with insane NFT valuations, this is mostly what they were used as. E.g. putting a QR code with a NFT link inside a limited-run t-shirt. Practically just an inventory tag.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by lostcolony on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM
(#26693615)
This is nearly that, except the distributed ledger says who owns the particular 'UUID' (not actually a UUID). So we don't have to trust you to be honest with that database.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by ytpete on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:23PM
(#26693720)
But of course, the other difference is a dramatically higher energy cost. You could never sell any kind of "green carbon tokens" on the blockchain...
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by snissn on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:35PM
(#26693781)
do it!
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by norswap on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:03PM
(#26693592)
You could even create a NFT of the exact same picture, probably.
But you'd expose yourself to a lawsuit because you don't own the copyright to the original picture, and if you sell for a high enough price, it might actually be worth the bother to the copyright holder.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by chrisco255 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:08PM
(#26693627)
No, these memes are widely circulated and are even monetized through sites like knowyourmeme.com. You could mint an NFT of a meme you didn't create, but it won't sell for much, because people will know it's not minted by the creator. In this case these NFTs are only valuable in sofar as their provenance is verified.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by sp332 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @08:08PM
(#26693992)
Copyright and other rights are not transferred with the NFT. So legally, that Dubai company doesn't even have the right to any copies of the photo that they may have.
Edit: this case might have been covered by a separate contract, but it's still not part of the NFT transaction. https://foundation.app/terms
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by dls2016 on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:59PM
(#26693929)
But if you don’t host the image, and only re-sell the URL, then where’s the infringement?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by erik_seaberg on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:35PM
(#26693782)
Anyone could mint a token on another platform, but https://foundation.app/terms committed Laina not to participate. I guess they might sue for breach if she did, because it would hurt their perceived legitimacy?
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by X6S1x6Okd1st on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:14PM
(#26693665)
If you want to pay the minting fee sure, I doubt that people could care to buy your knock off though
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by Tenoke on Sunday April 04, 2021 @06:58PM
(#26693576)
Sure, but just as me creating a Mona Lisa-lookalike painting I doubt you'd get a buyer.
Re:Overly Attached Girlfriend NFT Sells for $411,000
by ASalazarMX on Sunday April 04, 2021 @07:07PM
(#26693619)
This is not like painting actual Mona Lisas, but assigning serials to virtual things, like copies of a Mona Lisa picture, to create artificial scarcity.