News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:11PM (#26533000)
They were balancing it against what they saw in Italy: allowing the virus to get out of hand and overwhelm the hospital system and your death rate from covid jumps into the double digits. Kids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by reaperducer on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#26533197)
Kids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too.

Kudos for expressing an unpopular opinion.

I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion, largely thanks to pseudo-news web sites trying to grab clicks on the internet.

The school district where I live put out a press release lamenting an 18% increase in student suicide in 2020. Reading to the end, you find out that the actual numeric increase was something like 2. Two dead kids isn't good in any way. But when the number of suicides reaches a meaningful fraction of the number of COVID deaths, then I'll take it seriously.

Having to stay home for a year is nothing — absolutely nothing — compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like).

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by heavyset_go on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:50PM (#26533873)
> I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion, largely thanks to pseudo-news web sites trying to grab clicks on the internet.

Certain news sites in my state spent 2020 lamenting about how the lockdown is causing overdose deaths to skyrocket. Well, 2021 rolls around and the 2020 overdose death statistics were calculated, and there were about a dozen more overdose deaths in 2020 than in 2019, a change that is statistically insignificant when comparing it to the tens of thousands of overdoses that occurred in the state each year in 2019 and 2020, or to the tens of thousands of people who died from COVID there in 2020.

For whatever reason, the types of people who shared such news in 2020 were not the kind of people who gave two shits about addiction and its effects on others before the pandemic. I say this as a person who has struggled with addiction in the past and has lost numerous people I care about to it. It seems to me that the overdose stats were merely a tool to be used to complain about policy that they disliked.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by the_only_law on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:09PM (#26535331)
> For whatever reason, the types of people who shared such news in 2020 were not the kind of people who gave two shits about addiction and its effects on others before the pandemic.

You’ll find this is common with a lot of political subjects, I could name a few that come up HN seemingly weekly now. Pick up a cause when it's politically convenient, drop it afterwards. I don’t trust anyone or their intentions when it comes to these sort of things.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by harambae on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:33PM (#26543099)
>2021 rolls around and the 2020 overdose death statistics were calculated, and there were about a dozen more overdose deaths in 2020 than in 2019

Do you have a citation for this? All statistics I have seen are the exact opposite, showing wildly worse OD stats for 2020 than 2019 [0]

Now some synthetic opioid OD stats could be affected by availability and popularity having little to do with COVID, so lets look at a more historically available drug...

"Overdose deaths involving cocaine also increased by 26.5 percent" [0].

How do you explain that one? And it's not that clubs and raves are finding some new popularity, they've been shut down absent a recent and limited subset of Florida towns.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/p1218-overdose-death...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by heavyset_go on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:41PM (#26544937)
Check your citation, it refers to overdose deaths nationwide between the period of June 2019 until May 2020. The vast majority of those deaths occurred before there were lock downs in the end of March and beginning of April 2020.

Your stats include about a month or two of lock downs at most.

My stats refer to the period between January 2020 and the end of December 2020 in a single state. I'm not about to dox myself, but we can use another state's data to illustrate the same point. In NJ, there were 3,021 overdose deaths in 2019, and in 2020, there were 3,046 overdoses, an increase of only 25 deaths[1], or 0.83%.

> "Overdose deaths involving cocaine also increased by 26.5 percent" [0]. How do you explain that one?

Cocaine and psychostimulants are becoming increasingly popular year-over-year. For example, the CDC reports that psychostimulant overdose deaths increased by 37% in 2017[2], and drug overdose deaths involving cocaine increased by more than 34%.

The CDC reports that from 2009 to 2018, cocaine overdose deaths nearly tripled[3], and between 2014 and 2018, the rate of drug overdose deaths involving cocaine with opioids increased at a faster pace than the rate of cocaine deaths without opioids. If you look at the compiled data[3], between 2015 and 2018, cocaine overdose deaths skyrocketed.

Part of the trend might be related to increasingly adulterated cocaine[4] with fentanyl and designer stimulants over the past few years.

[1] https://whyy.org/articles/n-j-saw-a-slight-uptick-in-drug-ov...

[2] https://www.cdc.gov/drugoverdose/data/otherdrugs.html

[3] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db384.htm

[4] https://khn.org/news/not-yesterdays-cocaine-death-toll-risin...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:37PM (#26543939)
> And it's not that clubs and raves are finding some new popularity

There's been a resurgence in underground raves.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by p1necone on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:02PM (#26535303)
Frothing covid deniers/lockdown protestors will cling on to anything that lets them win arguments with people on the internet. Assuming these people and the news outlets they frequent are communicating in good faith is a fools errand.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by antiterra on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:26PM (#26535444)
> I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion

Tacky childish mocking of valid concern over the mental health of children, some of whom are truly not doing well, is a garbage take. There are kids crying on a daily basis because of this Zoom shit and the expectations placed on them. While they will (likely) survive, it’s not good for them. I’ve seen kids test scores decline, parents enduring outright mutiny and violence from their children. I’ve seen single parents trying to work from home while their kids, who were already struggling when they had someone to pay attention to them, are screaming at the top of their lungs and breaking things.

Mental health issues can persist even in privileged circumstances, and deserves our concern. The existence of worse suffering doesn’t make current circumstances magically better. In a way, your take feels like the mental health counterpart to ‘it’s just the flu’ style arguments.

I also believe that, during wartime, a lot of children were able to go outside and play with other children.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by uzakov on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:16AM (#26538815)
> Tacky childish mocking of valid concern over the mental health of children, some of whom are truly not doing well, is a garbage take. There are kids crying on a daily basis because of this Zoom shit and the expectations placed on them. While they will (likely) survive, it’s not good for them. I’ve seen kids test scores decline, parents enduring outright mutiny and violence from their children. I’ve seen single parents trying to work from home while their kids, who were already struggling when they had someone to pay attention to them, are screaming at the top of their lungs and breaking things.

Could this be a cultural or geographical thing? Having lived both in Asia and Europe and also visited USA on a number of occasion I find that kids misbehaving in front of parents is more common in EU than Asia.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by threeseed on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:12AM (#26538393)
You need to put it in the context of over 500,000 Americans dead from COVID.

A proportion of which are directly and indirectly caused by the behaviour of young people.

So yes mental health of children is important but for many people not as important as staggering numbers of people dying.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by frockington1 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:08AM (#26539218)
That context makes it seem worse. We are making children lose an entire year of education because 0.1% of Americans died, most of which are old and fat. Should we shut down every year for obesity?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by threeseed on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:32AM (#26539404)
Most of them aren’t losing a year of education. Just face to face education.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by frockington1 on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:34AM (#26539423)
Test scores are plummeting, particularly math. Damage like this will snowball for years
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by jjeaff on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @09:13PM (#26562392)
So will 500,000 early deaths. The psychological toll on families as well as the economic fallout.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by antiterra on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @04:02PM (#26559693)
Analyzing the risk factors and suggesting a prioritization is very different than mocking people with valid concerns about children.

The "caused by the behaviour of young people" thing is a weird non-sequitur. Are you suggesting 10-year-olds share culpability for spread caused by the spring break behavior of high-school students?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by DiggyJohnson on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:02PM (#26535297)
I was briefly a pandemic student last fall, and am closely connected with a relatively large network of current students who I communicate with regularly (aka my friends).

This is incredibly frustrating to read. Among students, the relevance of this topic - mental health issues spiking do to online curriculum - is painfully obvious. And yes, we are balancing this against the realized danger/negative health consequences of the pandemic.

I understand that this is anecdotal, but it seems that large, robust data sets are not convincing for you.

From what perspective are you writing? Do you have children in school? Do you feel that rising suicidality correlates with a broader issue that suggests some amount of increased suffering in the larger population?

> compared to what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals

Are you saying that we can't aspire to manage crises better than some historical bar? Why does this comparison appear here?

I am genuinely curious, and I hope you understand that my questions are genuine. I just rarely come across a comment that so confidently disagrees with things that are extremely obvious to me. Cheers

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by cylinder on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:09PM (#26535334)
Sounds to me they likely don't have children. Even one week at home for my kid is damaging let alone a year. The kids weren't spreading covid to teachers. Teachers could have worn respirators and been fine.

Governments should have kept covid out but harming children in this way to make up for disastrous decisions and behaviours of adults is unacceptable.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by blackoil on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:36AM (#26538563)
You should figure out why your child's household is so toxic. My son spent about 6 months last year at home. Between daily online classes, video calls with friends/cousins and activities at home. He was missing school/outside but I don't see any lasting negative impact of it.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by cylinder on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @08:22AM (#26566227)
you're an ass. my child is a toddler. they need to be exploring and interacting with other children, in person, playing, learning and receiving stimuli, not locked at home staring at screens.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by quesera on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:46PM (#26535571)
> Even one week at home for my kid is damaging let alone a year.

What do you do during school vacations, and summer?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by antepodius on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:20PM (#26535795)
The kid can go outside, go to establishments with friends...
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by lazyasciiart on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:39AM (#26537179)
Kids should have been going outside throughout the pandemic, and seeing the small group that their family had chosen to isolate with. Of course, most families appear to have chosen to keep their kids inside and not have any isolation partners, which is strange but hardly the fault of the schools.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by r00fus on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:16AM (#26537083)
Then blame the clown politicians who failed to adequately handle the virus in 2020.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by stolenmerch on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:12PM (#26534623)
Not only unpopular, but probably prematurely incorrect.

"Mental health consequences of the COVID-19 crisis including suicidal behavior are likely to be present for a long time and peak later than the actual pandemic."

https://academic.oup.com/qjmed/article/113/10/707/5857612

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:36PM (#26536267)
I didn't argue that there wouldn't be mental health consequences or that they wouldn't continue past covid. Just that "no mental health consequences" wasn't an option on the table, and not having lockdowns leaves you with 10s millions dead on top of probably worse mental health consequences.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tacocataco on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:19AM (#26537738)
So will this peak be worse then having a normal school year along side a increase in covid deaths?

This was a "trolly problem" situation. The least worse option had to be selected.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by s1artibartfast on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:29PM (#26535857)
For what it is worth, the total COVID death count for under 18 in the US is 200. This includes children with serious risk factors eg cancer, immune disorders, etc
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by GlennS on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:03AM (#26537315)
This is just a part of the picture (although it's a good number to see).

You also need to know whether children spread the disease.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by colordrops on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:14AM (#26537358)
Not according to several studies shared by epidemiologists that are parents at my kids' school. The only place they saw spread from children was at schools in Israel early in the pandemic where kids were crammed close together when waiting.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by threeseed on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:15AM (#26538415)
a) There is evidence of children spreading COVID-19, "children under 15 were about half as likely as adults to be infected, and only half as likely as adults to transmit the virus to others". [1]

b) In order to have children at school, you need teachers at school. In order to have teachers at school, you need public transport. Suddenly, you have a significant amount of people moving around spreading the virus.

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/we-now-kn...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:21AM (#26542097)
A 75% reduction in transmission is as good as many of the vaccines. It is also below the threshold COVID needs to spread through the population.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by mancerayder on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:57PM (#26533957)
>I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion, largely thanks to pseudo-news web sites trying to grab clicks on the internet.

You do realize you're replying to a Reuters article about mental health results, not predictions.

Quite a hyperbolic and probably politically inclined comment.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by concordDance on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:37AM (#26537815)
> Having to stay home for a year is nothing — absolutely nothing — compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like).

I don't think you can be this confident. Young humans deal particularly poorly with social isolation and those previous upheavals didn't have that as the main feature.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by XorNot on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:16PM (#26533565)
It's also worth pointing out that at sample sizes like that (2), you don't have a sample. You have an anomaly at best.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:30PM (#26533696)
You have a scale for comparing absolute rates, which is the gist of what the parent is talking about, I think.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by isoskeles on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:46AM (#26537214)
> "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion

Wow what a brave thing to do, arguing with a straw man.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Amezarak on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:56AM (#26539578)
> Having to stay home for a year is nothing — absolutely nothing — compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like).

Suicide rates actually dropped during the world wars. People are able to handle war much better than social isolation.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by mrslave on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:40AM (#26536930)
Darrell Huff - How To Lie With Statistics[0]. And the first chapter or two of David Spiegelhalter - The Art of Statistics[1] has a good example of absolute vs relative rates/probabilities with respect to medicine. Pretty basic an important issue to understand.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/51291.How_to_Lie_with_St... [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/43722897-the-art-of-stat...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Wolfenstein98k on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:52PM (#26535237)
The false assumption here is that making kids stay home for a year saves a single life from covid.

It doesn't - the kids have a better survival rate than they do from the flu, and the people who are at risk are overwhelmingly not getting it from kids.

Do a cost-benefit analysis. Keeping kids in detention fails it every time.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by schrodinger on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:10PM (#26535735)
Couldn’t a kid go to school, pick it up, recover flawlessly since kids do, but give it to their overweight parent who dies? It’s not just the kids…
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Wolfenstein98k on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:01PM (#26536065)
That is a risk, but that risk needs to be weighed against the known risk of keeping them detained.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by CodeMage on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:18AM (#26537095)
Because a kid will recover more easily from feeling responsible for their parent's death than they will from extended but finite lockdown?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Monday March 22, 2021 @07:41PM (#26549020)
Of course not, but that assumes the first outcome is as likely a result of no-lockdown as the second is of lockdown.

In reality you need to consider probabilities. What if there are thousands of times more kids in the second category than the first?

This is a pattern of thinking that I’ve seen a lot on the pro-lockdown side: reasoning from the axiom that a human being dying has infinite negative utility. While normally a good policy heuristic in practice when all else is equal, it of course can’t be strictly true. If it were, then it would be worth it for everyone in the world to experience unbounded misery if that extended the life of one person by one day.

Clearly that is absurd. So the moral calculus must be more nuanced than “if it saves lives, it must be worth it”.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Wolfenstein98k on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:22AM (#26540402)
I keep saying "do the cost-benefit" because you should do the cost-benefit.

One option harms every child and potentially saves some parents' lives.

The other harms practically no children and will likely lead to some more parents dying, although the data is unclear (as death rates in states with much more open schools is not consistently higher).

Harm all kids to save a few parents on the margin...potentially? Do the cost-benefit.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by schrodinger on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @01:20AM (#26563876)
> The other harms practically no children and will likely lead to some more parents dying

Really? You think that a parent dying harms "practically no children"?

For christ's sake, I lost my father at 25 years old (10 years ago) and it still hurts me daily (at 35 now).

Your calculus is just plain fucking cold.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by pooper on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:19PM (#26536173)
I have exactly zero sympathy for the children not being able to go to school in person. Schools aren't in my opinion places where we park children through the day. We have completely overloaded schools to be anything and everything children and it is ridiculous.

If there needs to be outrage, it should be against monopolies like Comcast which has said it will expand data caps to more markets this year. I for one would support life in prison for the current Comcast CEO as well as dismantling the company and making an example out of it.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by undefined1 on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:01PM (#26535685)
is there evidence that schools have meaningfully contributed to Covid spread?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Fomite on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:01PM (#26536062)
https://amp.freep.com/amp/4733689001

"The total number of COVID-19 outbreaks statewide rose this week by 9% over last week to 645. The biggest proportion of outbreaks are tied to the K-12 school setting, Lyon-Callo said.

Children ages 10-19 now have the highest COVID-19 case rate in Michigan, a rate that "is increasing faster than that of other age groups" she said. School-related outbreaks, she explained, aren't all tied to the classroom setting. Many are linked to sports and other gatherings among students."

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Rebelgecko on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:37AM (#26537168)
FWIW, public schools in my state are closed and <19s are still one of the biggest demographics for COVID cases[1]. And that's without the semi-mandatory testing that Michigan has for students.

[1]: Frustratingly, everyone uses different age buckets for reporting. So the state uses ranges like 0-17, 18-50, 50-65 etc. But looking at the individual counties that have a bit more granularity, under 19s appear to be one of the top demographics despite having some of the fewest tests. However I haven't bothered to normalize for population or anything like that

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by testesttest on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:57PM (#26533390)
> compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like).

You could say that for all of covid. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_and_anthropogen...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by aaron695 on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:04PM (#26536076)
>> Kids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too.

> Kudos for expressing an unpopular opinion.

Here's a real unpopular opinion - "Epstein did nothing wrong"

Here's a popular opinion people hide behind saying it's unpopular - "Epstein didn't kill himself"

"unpopular opinion" <==> "I know I'll be downvoted"

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by hiram112 on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:59PM (#26533981)
Well let's say there was one extra suicide caused by lockdowns. And we know that something like 2/3 of Covid "deaths" are occurring in nursing homes among very elderly who, statistically, might live a year or so longer had they not got Covid.

If we're comparing years of life, isn't one 16 year old worth 60-70 85 year olds in nursing homes? Maybe more because one year in the life of an 84 year old who's already experienced a full life is worth a lot less than a 16 year old going on 17. Societally wise, it's much worse to sacrifice a young person for an 80 year old who's essentially a burden on the rest.

This comparison of the value of a life is morbid, but we've been making decisions like this anyway, even if the media has refused to speak of it openly.

And of course this assumes that all these lockdowns, school closings, etc. made any difference. Again, we can debate that and both sides have data to make their case.

So yeah, maybe one or two suicides and the massive increase of unknown mental health issues weren't a good tradeoff for the unknown number of mostly elderly whose lives were extended a year or two.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by ipaddr on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:21PM (#26535415)
Lockdowns have made a big difference. Places like New Zealand have 0 cases. The half lockdowns have lower but mixed results.

An 80 year old has a lot of life in them. Some may have a year or two but others will have 20 or 30 years left.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by chii on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:35PM (#26535898)
even if the 80 yr old has 20 yrs of life left, it still means that a 16 yr old is worth at least 3 80 yr olds.

and the 80 yr olds do not contribute to the economy or work, and is indeed a "burden" (sad to say, but they can't really sustain themselves without external resources, as their economic value output is zero). The 16 yr old will likely contribute to society for 40 years at least.

i'm not saying the lockdowns weren't necessary - they were. I'm saying that the costs are high, and society has asked the young to make a sacrifice for the elderly, and yet has not gotten much in return. At least some token appreciation for them is the least that can be done. After all, we praise the servicemen/women for their war efforts, well into their years, and i don't see this as being that different.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by ipaddr on Sunday March 21, 2021 @11:15PM (#26536491)
The long term damage to those who catch it seems high in many cases including the young. The majority of people getting covid are young so the impact is not understood and not nil.

I'm not sure the young are making anywhere near same sacrifice compared to the war effort in terms of lives and limbs and post war mental effects.

The really young are the future. Anyone in there late teens and 20s is past that point. The work from home training/conditioning the younger generation received will payoff when they reach 20. While your generation may struggle with the isolation by preparing the next generation those issues will disappear reaping larger economic benefits.

In terms of praise, remember all age groups are staying home. Appreciation should first be given to the soldiers (nurses,people who put themselves in danger) but appreciation should be given to everyone who stayed at home, everyone who convinced someone stop doing something that would spread this and everyone who did all they could to stop the spread.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tdfx on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:33AM (#26542263)
> The long term damage to those who catch it seems high in many cases including the young.

> While your generation may struggle with the isolation by preparing the next generation those issues will disappear reaping larger economic benefits.

It feels inconsistent that you're dismissing the long term effects of one potential problem (isolation) while using the potential harm of another (undemonstrated, theoretical long term damage to young people from COVID infection) to argue your point.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by polishdude20 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:10AM (#26537055)
I think the return you get from saving the elderly is the example that is shown to the young. The example shows the young that life when you're elderly isn't miserable and people WILL care for you. Society doesn't take care of the elderly solely for the elderly's sake. The bigger benefit is the example it makes to the younger generations who will be elderly themselves in due time. I can imagine in a society where I see the elderly treated badly, I probably won't have much hope for when id get to that state.

It's like saying "when you're older, we will treat you like shit" and people going back to society and saying "if you're gonna treat me like shit, I'm not going to be a productive member of society like you want me to"

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by anarticle on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:44AM (#26542427)
I'm not sure where to start on this comment other than to say this is the most ghoulish thing I've read on hacker news in a long time.

I hope, that if my "economic output" is zero I don't get ground up into protein so I can have a contribution to society.

A token of appreciation from previous generations is the infrastructure built to benefit from. Like say planting a tree, whose economic output might be zero but you can enjoy it long after the person who planted it died. Not everyone that went before you has mortgaged the future to buy a yacht, maybe show some perspective?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by woolcap on Monday March 22, 2021 @09:14AM (#26540311)
I find it repugnant to define the 'worth' of an individual solely in terms of 'economic output.' The elderly have much to offer society. I think of my own parents, now into their 80s. They planned well, are not an economic burden to their children, and continue to contribute in meaningful ways to their family and their community. Any 'burden' they may be in my life is far outweighed by what they sacrificed and provided for me throughout my life so far.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by throwaway8581 on Monday March 22, 2021 @11:03AM (#26541831)
New Zealand is an island (two islands) that never had massive community spread. Once you cross into community spread you can't go back to being in a place like New Zealand. In most countries, there was wide community spread before anyone was even thinking about lockdowns.

Also, the average length of stay in a nursing home is under a year. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/45950714_Length_of_...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Talanes on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:31AM (#26537138)
The parent comment specified elderly in nursing homes, which is statistically correct. The 80 year old with 30 years of nursing home life ahead of them is a wealthy anomaly.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tdfx on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:55PM (#26535637)
There's a term for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year

And the fact that the majority of COVID-19 deaths are people with very few quality-adjusted life years remaining is almost entirely missed by the media coverage.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nradov on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:28PM (#26533136)
Do you have any proof that that would have increased depression rates in children relative to what we see today?

And an 8 digit body count would be impossible in the US for a disease with a >99% survival rate. So quit the hyperbole.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by heavyset_go on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:33PM (#26534777)
There's about a 3% death rate[1] when hospitals aren't flooded with sick people, and the death rate hits double digits when the healthcare system is DDOS'd by sick patients, as we've seen in Italy. The hospitalization rate is about 10%.

If everyone in the US got COVID, and 1% of them died, that would be 3.3 million people dead and over 30 million hospitalized. If the death rate is 3%, 9.85 million would die. I don't think there are 30 million hospital beds in the US, so that figure could reach over 10 million, which is 8 digits.

However, while you're busy focusing on digits, you're missing the overall point.

[1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by usaar333 on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:11PM (#26536123)
3% CFR, not IFR. Even Spain hit only a 1.2% IFR early in the pandemic (https://covid19-projections.com/about/#assumptions)

The worst-case realistic number of deaths for the US is around 1.2 million. With hospital collapses, maybe double that. 10 million is not possible.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by olliej on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:05AM (#26537032)
I'm fairly certain that the "only" 6 digit death rate we've currently had has had a negative impact on the families and friends of the affected.

If you have been left untouched by it, then good for you, but you shouldn't be assuming that that applies to everyone.

The mortality rate in the US is 1.8%. That is 542k dead out of 29.8 million cases.

That's nearly 30 million cases with all the lockdowns, mask rules, etc.

Even with that minor amount of 9% infected, LA hospitals ran out of capacity, morgues overflowed, etc. Try to imagine if we didn't try to limit the spread - by among other things closing schools.

NZs recent outbreak started from a couple of kids in a school of only 13-1500 students, and with lockdowns that dwarf anything the US did they only just managed to control it, getting to something like 100 positive cases because they didn't want to lock down completely.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nradov on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:39AM (#26539974)
Your numbers are incorrect. The case numbers are meaningless because there have been so many infections that were never officially counted as cases. Antibody seroprevalence studies have shown that the true number of cases is 2 or 3 times higher.

Schools in Florida have been open for months and they aren't overwhelmed.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by olliej on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:07PM (#26558992)
Those numbers come directly from the CDC…
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by wernercd on Monday March 22, 2021 @12:59AM (#26537009)
CFR vs IFR

https://www.methodsman.com/blog/case-fatality-rate-vs-infect...

What I can tell you is that the CDC now provides an “infection fatality rate” parameter in it’s planning scenarios. They range the IFR from 0.5% in their best-case scenario to 0.8% in the worst-case scenario.

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...

https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20201030/covid-19-infection-...

A new study conducted by researchers at Imperial College London found the COVID-19 infection fatality ratio is about 1.15% of infected people in high-income nations and 0.23% in low-income nations.

The new study confirms that the coronavirus is deadlier for older people, with the risk of death doubling for every eight years of aging and ranging from 0.1% for people under 40 and 5% among people over 80 years old. The disparity between high and low-income nations is due largely to facts that high-income nations tend to have larger number of elderly in their populations whereas low-income nations’ population tend to skew youngers.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:38PM (#26533218)
What proof would you believe without empirically letting the death rate get into the double digits to begin with?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by stickfigure on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:22PM (#26533622)
At this point we have enough data. The CDC gives an approximate IFR of 0.7% in the US. That would translate to low 7 digits. Also, it's very heavily weighted to the 70+ population.

Strictly speaking from a kid's perspective, it would mostly be the experience of losing a grandparent early. It would be sad (as death almost always is) but probably not life-changing.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:26PM (#26533658)
> At this point we have enough data. The CDC gives an approximate IFR of 0.7% in the US. That would translate to low 7 digits. Also, it's very heavily weighted to the 70+ population.

..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity.

> Strictly speaking from a kid's perspective, it would mostly be the experience of losing a grandparent early. It would be sad (as death almost always is) but probably not life-changing.

And teachers, and looking at how the breakdown of Italian hospitals meant a huge spike in deaths in the 40+ crowd that would have been just fine if they instead had capacity, a ton of dead parents, aunts and uncles to deal with too.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by whatthesmack on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:55PM (#26533920)
> ..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity.

My understanding is that lockdowns didn't really change things significantly, so the "with lockdowns in effect" is not really relevant. See California (extreme lockdowns from the top) vs Florida (a bit of lockdown from the top) and their associated infection rate per 100k, which is nearly the same.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by danielheath on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:10PM (#26535338)
Down here in Victoria, Australia: despite over 20k infections, a prolonged lockdown let us eliminate COVID entirely.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by selectodude on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:12PM (#26535751)
That and closed borders. There are some benefits to being an island with zero land borders.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:18PM (#26534167)
You would be mistaken then. Government interventions like lockdowns and school closings were a very good response.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/eabd9338

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by JoshuaDavid on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:58PM (#26536410)
So do you think Florida is lying and underestimating the number of COVID deaths to greater extent than California is, or the California is exaggerating the number of COVID deaths, or maybe that there's a difference in behavior between Floridians and Californians (maybe California had stricter laws but Floridians act more responsibly in terms of disease prevention).

If you don't have such an explanation, and California, with some of the most stringent measures in the US, had similar outcomes to Florida, with a much laxer approach, I'm not sure how you come to the conclusion that California's approach was "very good".

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by ryandrake on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:22AM (#26537404)
There was no actual lockdown in any state in the USA, including California. There were instead these totally unenforced stay at home “orders” and mask “mandates” which people ignored with no consequences. It’s no surprise that the disease spread rampantly through all 50 states. I live in California and there was nothing stringent about the measures—while many people voluntarily followed them, they were routinely ignored by enough people to make them worthless.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by JoshuaDavid on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:45AM (#26537853)
Alright, so after seeing what government interventions, at least in the US, looked like in practice, would you agree with the statement "Government interventions like lockdowns and school closings were a very good response."?

Because that is the comment I was responding to, which was itself a response to a comment comparing the outcomes of Florida and California. "Nowhere in the US, and very few western countries, had a sufficient response" is a valid position, and probably accurate (with the caveat that I'm not confident that a sufficient response was even possible in the US), but it wasn't really the point under discussion.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by ryandrake on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:15AM (#26538040)
I’m saying that government interventions were tragically insufficient in all 50 states. The difference between CA’s and FL’s responses was the difference between doing next to nothing and doing nothing. It’s not a surprise that the virus spread similarly out of control in both states.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by olliej on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:08AM (#26537044)
Because lockdowns only work if you actually lockdown.

That and yes, FL clearly lied and has fired people for indicating correct numbers. This is not helped by many US states that try to record CV19 deaths as being due to "underlying conditions" instead of covid.

If you go to hospital due to covid, and then die, whatever other conditions you have aren't relevant, covid is what killed you.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by manwe150 on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:48AM (#26537224)
Or maybe something like temperature or humidity, since California is also doing much worse than Florida (27% v 17%) for simple excess deaths this year: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/01/14/us/covid-19-d...

I think it is clear we still don’t understand fully the driving risk and safety factors across different regional areas, let alone continents and hemispheres. I don’t know how we ever could at this time or what we could do about it.

Edit: And examining average death rate instead provides a different story as well: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-03-09/covid-19...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nradov on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:42AM (#26539996)
People who claim the Florida state government is lying are no different from QAnon conspiracy theorists. Where is your hard data? What are the real numbers? Where are they hiding the bodies?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:40PM (#26543979)
Did you miss that whole "police raids of epidemiologists who don't want to edit the data" thing that happened in Florida?

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/dec/07/florida-poli...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:53PM (#26533901)
> ..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity.

“Want to buy this vampire repelling rock?”

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:11PM (#26534105)
School closings have been shown to be one of the most effective government interventions.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/eabd9338

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by dcolkitt on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:50PM (#26535597)
That paper is obviously data mined and using extremely sketchy statistical methodology. They’re fitting 100+ parameter model on a dataset of a few dozen countries.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by rimliu on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:03PM (#26534965)
There are many studies showing just the opposite.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nathannecro on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:21PM (#26535411)
Would you like to cite them?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by AshWolfy on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:29PM (#26535462)
Then show them, and we will judge for ourselves. You can find studies showing nearly anything.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by curryst on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:14PM (#26534142)
> ..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity.

Lockdowns likely wouldn't affect IFR. It's a measure of fatality, not of infection rate, unless you think lifting the lockdown would cause a dramatic shift in infections to more vulnerable populations.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:16PM (#26534151)
The IFR they're quoting is the death rate per infection.

It's not infections/population.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by dragonwriter on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:58PM (#26535668)
> The CDC gives an approximate IFR of 0.7% in the US

The IFR isn't a static figure. If the actual incidence goes up to the point hospitals are overwhelmed, so does the IFR, by an enormous amount (so does the fatality rate of unrelated conditions, because resource exhaustion hits all conditions for which the same resources are used, not just COVID.)

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by saiya-jin on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:01PM (#26533999)
Do your numbers account for all the indirect consequences? Hospitals overwhelmed means people with some issues refusing to get that exam that would diagnose early cancer / small heart attack / some other underlying condition. Regular checks hugely postponed or cancelled. People with existing mental issues are a story on its own.

From what I recall, I've read some interviews with heads of cancer clinics in Czech republic which is hit pretty hard, and they reported that they don't see many new patients in early stages of cancer anymore, people who come to them are mostly late stage which manifests hard, and they often go straight to palliative care. Is this some peer-reviewed study published in Nature with nice numbers and graphs? Of course not, we'll get to those numbers maybe 10 years after covid is under control, maybe. But its real people dying out there, mostly quietly without much media attention.

Pregnancy is a serious situation with covid, it can lead to many complications, abortion, and in case of serious complications for the mother, doctors at least here in Switzerland either perform abortion / force early delivery depending on age, since mother can't manage to breath on support enough for both of them (my wife is pregnant right now and senior doctor and we both got covid some 2 months ago, so this is something we checked on pretty intensively... luckily so far so good).

There is no win, we all take a heavy mental toll in confinement / job uncertainty or loss. But the risks are real on the other side too and its not so clearly cut for everyone. I don't have a clear answer on this myself.

EDIT: related to original topic - we caught covid from our little son going to kindergarden. In semi/hard lockdown, small kids going to schools is by probably the strongest infection vector. They can't keep the discipline as well as adults can. Heck, most adults can't keep up the discipline 1+ year consistently.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tehjoker on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:06AM (#26537039)
It's pretty incredible how easily hundreds of thousands of excess deaths, each of which is a full human life, becomes a statistic to some people let alone the millions. Don't we teach students in history classes about how easily people allow themselves to justify mass death when it is convenient?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nucleardog on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:29AM (#26538127)
Yep this.

If you actually stop and think about the value of a life in a real sense instead of from an abstract or monetary perspective, you're either absolutely horrified by all of this and your path is clear, or you're a monster.

For the past year I just look at my wife and look at my kid and imagine what it would be like to lose them. I would do _anything_ to protect them. I know what losing other family members to COVID feels like. I've seen first hand what it does to people (friends and family).

Almost every one of those five hundred and fifty thousand people (in the US alone) that have died from COVID meant just as much to someone. I want to afford them the same respect and put in at least a minimal effort to protect their family just the same.

To me, any argument based around what essentially amounts to an inconvenience being too much to ask to prevent those deaths just makes me disgusted. Dressing it up in some rationality by demanding absolute and incontrovertible scientific proof of efficacy is nothing but a flimsy excuse.

Approaching all of this with some empathy makes it easier on yourself and leads to better outcomes for everyone. I'm not stuck at home in the face of statistics and arguments about how I should be able to do whatever I want and damn everyone else paying the consequences. I'm at home because I don't want people to suffer.

It sucks some days, but it's easy to keep going when I know it could be the reason _my own child_ doesn't grown up without a father. It's easy to keep going when it could be the reason someone else doesn't have to go through that either.

So I lost a year of hanging out with friends and had to cut my hair in the utility sink instead of going to the hair dresser. That's such a small fucking price to pay relative to what this could cost someone it's not even a fucking question.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by cap1434 on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:28AM (#26541299)
I would recommend you subscribe to your own advice and approach the disastrous side effects of these lockdowns with empathy instead of just chalking it up to an "inconvenience". There are people dying due to these policies and lockdowns and others will suffer long term negative effects. It's not just an inconvenience. People with preexisting conditions (depression, suicidal thoughts, addiction, violent/murderous) make up a significant percentage of the population. These policies will be a major factors in some percentage of them dying. They will also be a major factor in increasing the number of people with these conditions (more people will become depressed, suicidal, form addictions). Others will face years of mental and physical suffering due to economic effects.

It's essentially the same argument you are trying to make in favor of the lockdowns. Without the lockdowns, families will have to bury their loved ones and grow up without grandma/grandpa around. Other people will have long term health effects from catching this virus. With the lockdowns, some people will have to bury their (usually much younger) loved ones and grow up without brother/sister/son/daughter/friend around. Others will have long term mental health effects.

My cousin overdosed in May 2020. He had battled with addictions for a while before lockdowns but nothing to the point that we thought it would kill him. He went off the rails being forced to isolation and is now dead. His family had to bury him with no one else allowed to be present. In the same way that it's easy to overlook the impact of the virus if it has not severely impacted your family, its easy to overlook the lockdown effects if you and your family have not been severely impacted.

Stopping to think about the value of a life in a real sense should horrify you by all of the deaths and suffering caused by the virus but it should also horrify you to think of the value of the lives taken/affected by these sudden policy implementations. It does not make you a monster to consider both sides.

As for the clear path in terms of policies, both sides of the coin should be considered to the degree of certainty we know the risks to be. Unfortunately, this usually does require you put abstract/monetary/years-of-life-lost statistics in play.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by iso1631 on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:47AM (#26538640)
A single death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Spooky23 on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:46PM (#26533828)
It’s easy to Monday morning quarterback when we’ve had a year of figuring out how to treat the disease and reduction in use of ventilators, which was killing people.

Last June, my aunt in nyc was stacking bodies like cordwood in the back of trailers. They weren’t all 90 year old diabetics with copd.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by sokoloff on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:08PM (#26533494)
It’s not even clear that the hospitalization rate for COVID cases is over 10%, let alone the case-fatality-rate. In fact, it’s pretty clear that it’s not.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:16PM (#26533571)
Tell that to Italy. Their death rate was in the double digits when hospital capacity was overrun.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by dcolkitt on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:54PM (#26535626)
The death rate in April was high because we didn’t understand how to treat Covid. The primary issue is that almost every hospitalized person was being put on a ventilator. But since then, we’ve learned that ventilators were actually iatrogenic and leading to much higher death rates.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by kibibyte on Sunday March 21, 2021 @11:18PM (#26536499)
Where can I find a source for this? This is new information to me, and searching "covid ventilator" is just bringing up the same studies about how patients who get ventilated have higher mortality, which isn't saying the same thing.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Izkata on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:51AM (#26540091)
April last year: https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/08/doctors-say-ventilators-...

The short version:

Blood oxygen levels were falling into "should be dead" levels never really seen before (even though they were otherwise alert and fine and had no other hypoxia indicators), which caused doctors to panic about pneumonia and not being able to breathe, and put people on ventilators prematurely. However, it wasn't really having an effect, so the ventilators kept getting turned up to their maximum setting, which puts too much pressure on the lungs and causes additional permanent damage. In most people this caused a turn for the worse instead of recovery.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by kibibyte on Tuesday March 23, 2021 @03:49AM (#26552198)
This is very interesting. Thank you.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tehjoker on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:11AM (#26537058)
Just anecdotally, since I am close with a doctor, they stopped rushing to vent and now they treat with Remdesivir and steroids. Looking at the graphs for my state, we have about half the critical care rate at similar or greater detected cases than the spring, so better treatment seems to be a 2xish improvement for hospitalized patients?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by lazyasciiart on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:49AM (#26537232)
They vent at the same point as before, based on breathing. But they were telling people not to come in until they were having difficulty breathing, because they didn't have any early treatment or any space. Having access to remdesivir/steroids would mean people should come in for treatment early, but it only helps if given very early. But if infection numbers were large enough then we probably wouldn't manage to treat everyone early enough, so it would cut the rate of severe cases by an unknown amount.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by manwe150 on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:06AM (#26537327)
Is Remdesivir still in wide use? I know it was given emergency approval in the US, but I thought wider trials were now thought to show a lack of demonstrable results.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by lazyasciiart on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:48AM (#26537560)
Good point, I haven't kept up with it and was assuming it works to focus on one argument. I'm not a medical researcher and the evidence seems pretty ambiguous at this point. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by afarrell on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:03AM (#26538736)
How much more slowly would we have learned to treat Covid if the many more of the hospital staff studying it were dying and drunk with fatigue?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tinus_hn on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:56PM (#26533940)
When compared to people tested positive, when they only had resources to test the people they were pretty sure were infected.

Their death rate in April was the same as the peak of the second wave in December.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:03PM (#26534018)
They had already instituted a heavy lockdown by April.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tinus_hn on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:26PM (#26534242)
Not sure what that has to do with anything, but if April’s not it, when was that double digit death rate?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:29PM (#26534271)
End of March. Which is what led to the extremely heavy lockdowns in April.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tinus_hn on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:48PM (#26534420)
So, end of March was 900 people dying a day, December was 1000 people dying in a day.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:55PM (#26534477)
Yes, after a year of treating the illness now each patient takes less hospital resources. They were able to get the death rate from 900/day during a time with 5000 new infections per day, down to about the same daily death rate with 25,000 new infections per day.

This is kind of my point.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tinus_hn on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:35PM (#26534792)
You don’t know anything about the amount of infections in March other than that it was more than 5000 per day, because there was a shortage of testing kits, which is my point.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by sokoloff on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:57PM (#26534502)
The denominator for that calculation was not “all COVID infections”.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by jansan on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:49PM (#26533859)
Their hospitals are overrun every second winter, dude. They had as much a medical system problem as they had a COVID-19 problem. Check this article from 2018.

https://time.com/5107984/hospitals-handling-burden-flu-patie...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by heavyset_go on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:55PM (#26534931)
> Their hospitals are overrun every second winter, dude

No, they aren't. Your article is talking about the 2017-2018 flu season, which was an anomaly when it came to hospitalizations and deaths. Both hospitalizations and deaths that season were about double what they normally are[1]. About 61k people died in the US during that flu season, where about 20k-35k normally die. There were 810k hospitalizations, while hospitalizations usually fluctuate between 250k-500k.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/past-seasons.html

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:54PM (#26533914)
That doesn't affect my point. They're a case study not in the sense of "look how easy it is for hospitals to be overrun", but instead "look what an absolute tragedy it is when hospital are overrun". Of course the country predisposed to hospital overruns hit that issue first.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:51PM (#26533883)
The death rate from Covid is not double digits in Italy or any other country. Where are your numbers coming from?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:57PM (#26533953)
The death rate in Italy was in the double digits during the period of their hospitals being overrun last spring. Then they initiated heavy lockdowns, and got their death rate back under control.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:02PM (#26534007)
Link sources.

Prediction: you are quoting the meaningless CFR number rather than reliable estimates of IFR.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:15PM (#26534144)
Early on, like in March of last year when Italy hit their double digit death rate, CFR was very meaningful. It's only when the breakdown was so bad that they couldn't meaningfully trace anymore that CFR stopped mattering.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by makomk on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:05PM (#26534574)
Italy stopped having meaningful Covid tracing well before their first detected Covid-related death in February last year. They'd reported zero cases in the weeks leading up to it and there are a whole bunch of reasons to suspect that was a massive, massive underestimate. (I think they also imposed measures like school closures pretty soon after this. It didn't seem to help much.)
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by pqs on Monday March 22, 2021 @04:41AM (#26538202)
Writing from Spain. Schools are open since September, with measures such as masks, isolated groups that don't mix during recreation time, etc. It has been shown that schools are not a major vector of propagation and that kids can safely go to school. Here what has an impact in the propagation of the virus is opening bars and restaurants and allowing people to move between counties (comarca) or regions.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by wisty on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:31PM (#26533153)
Covid barely spreads through children. It spreads through travel and large gathering of adults.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#26533193)
There's pretty much no evidence for that. Kids are asymptomatic and the virus is so out of control that it's difficult to track down the graph of infections from kids is all.

Additionally teachers and school staff tilt pretty heavily to high risk groups. Watching so many of the adults die in their life would absolutely give kids depression too.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by oceanplexian on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:40PM (#26534341)
Maybe it's a pet peeve of mine but the onus is not on public health institutions to prove or disprove a negative. Saying "There's not evidence of the virus _not_ spreading in Cohort X" is an almost impossible position. If you have evidence to show it's spreading, then present it, and make public policy decisions based on said evidence. If you don't have evidence, then you should not be making policy.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:42PM (#26534366)
Here's direct evidence: school closures are one of the most effective government interventions.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/eabd9338

What I have an issue with is people stating crazy stuff like "covid barely spreads through children" even though they have no real data on it.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by oceanplexian on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:56PM (#26534489)
If you read between the lines the study makes quite a few points consistent with my argument:

> Primary schools may be generally less affected than secondary schools (20, 25–28), perhaps partly because children under the age of 12 are less susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 (29).

The study also goes on to state, in a profound bit of self-awareness:

> Our approach cannot distinguish direct effects on transmission in schools and universities from indirect effects, such as the general population behaving more cautiously after school closures signaled the gravity of the pandemic. Additionally, because school and university closures were implemented on the same day or in close succession in most of the countries we studied, our approach cannot distinguish their individual effects

And:

> (iii) Our results cannot be used without qualification to predict the effect of lifting NPIs. For example, closing schools and universities in conjunction seems to have greatly reduced transmission, but this does not mean that reopening them will necessarily cause infections to soar.

Like stated above, this doesn't prove or disprove a negative. If someone comes out with a direct, causative relationship between re-opening schools and increased infections, and that is reproducible, sure, make policy decisions based on that information. But otherwise, if we are blindly making decisions that can affect the health and development of children, we better have data to back up those decisions.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by esyir on Monday March 22, 2021 @05:16AM (#26538422)
The clear solution is to test. Look for a suitable district that wants to open up the schools, open them up for a bit and do a rapid lockdown if it instigates an outbreak.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by wizzard on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:02AM (#26537306)
It's a pet peeve of mine for people to make a bold statement like "Covid barely spreads through children" when there's no scientific consensus yet.

I want it to be true, but it would be pretty incredible if it were. There are probably other factors at play.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by AshWolfy on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:33PM (#26535482)
Thats not true when it comes to public health, often it is better policy to act as though the worst case scenario is true, because the consequences of overreacting are far less bad than the consequences of underreacting
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by Izkata on Monday March 22, 2021 @08:59AM (#26540164)
> Kids are asymptomatic

Yeah, and that's why it's not really a thing. Large amounts of asymptomatic spread turned out to be an early fear that wasn't true: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/08/asymptomatic-coronavirus-pat...

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by CodeMage on Sunday March 21, 2021 @09:03PM (#26535704)
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by enw on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:09AM (#26537674)
Why can’t we optimize the care process of COVID patients so that they don’t become a bottleneck?

Surely with so many similar cases the processes could be streamlined?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by oblio on Monday March 22, 2021 @03:18AM (#26537732)
How?

Should we ask TSMC for 3nm MDs?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by swayvil on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:43PM (#26533262)
Yet Florida is perfectly ok.

Obviously this "8 digit body count" concept is a load of that which makes the grass grow green.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:46PM (#26533288)
I would use many phrases to describe Florida's covid response, but "perfectly ok" would not be one of them.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nradov on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:59PM (#26533415)
A better description of Florida would be "perfectly average". In deaths per capita they are right in the middle of US states. Obviously Florida could have done better, but many other states have done far worse.

https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by dehrmann on Sunday March 21, 2021 @05:22PM (#26534201)
The big, open question is why Florida and California have seen such similar case rates despite radically different approaches.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nostrademons on Sunday March 21, 2021 @06:22PM (#26534682)
There's less difference than their public policies might suggest. Reportedly lots of senior citizens in Florida voluntarily social-distanced themselves from everybody. The press reported on square dancing and packed beaches, but the anecdotes I heard were that vulnerable individuals were taking things very seriously (despite the lack of restrictions) and self-quarantining away from everyone else.

Meanwhile, in SoCal, basically nobody followed the mask mandates and social distancing restrictions. The rules were more like guidelines, and guidelines that were ignored. They also have a lot more problems with overcrowding, with immigrant populations that need to work, etc. So in terms of what people were actually doing, SoCal was actually engaging in significantly riskier behavior than Florida.

If you compare Bay Area, where people largely did follow the mask & social distancing guidelines, with Florida or SoCal, the death rates are not the same. SF and San Mateo counties had approximately 1/3 as many deaths/1M as the U.S. (and Florida) average; Santa Clara had about 1/2 as many.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 21, 2021 @07:53PM (#26535241)
The vulnerable voluntarily self-isolating, while the less vulnerable live more normal lives, is a very desireable outcome, and much better than a blanket lockdown, which imposes restrictions on large subsections of the population which are not vulnerable.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nostrademons on Sunday March 21, 2021 @08:08PM (#26535327)
Depends on your threat model. If you're worried about old people dying from COVID directly, then yes, it makes sense. If you're worried about the hospitals being overwhelmed and then people dying from car crashes and heart attacks, then targeted self-isolation of vulnerable people isn't going to help as much.

As a healthy 30-something, my chance of dying from COVID is about 1:3000, about 300x better than an 80-year-old. However, my chance of being hospitalized from COVID is about 3%, which is only about 7x better than the 80-year-old. The hospitals were overwhelmed, here (Bay Area) and in many other cities. Even now (2 months after the Christmas/January surge) Santa Clara County still has 21% of its ICU beds taken up by COVID patients.

U.S. life expectancy dropped by a full year during COVID. We were concerned about the 0.1 year declines in 2016-2018 from the opioid epidemic (which did affect young people), and this was 10x that. It'll be interesting to see how all-cause mortality has varied among different states in 2020-2021.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by CryptoPunk on Monday March 22, 2021 @06:37AM (#26538952)
Interesting point.

One thing I'd add is that the loss of education and economic wealth from the lockdown is going to impact life expectancy for years to come, so that also needs to be taken into account.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by usaphp on Sunday March 21, 2021 @10:06PM (#26536090)
> Meanwhile, in SoCal, basically nobody followed the mask mandates and social distancing restrictions.

Huh? I’m from SoCal and almost everyone wears masks here all the time, all shops require masks on entrances, so I’m not sure where this narrative comes from?

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by nostrademons on Monday March 22, 2021 @02:19AM (#26537384)
I've had multiple friends in LA say (around November-January) that people were basically ignoring the mask mandate and having a bunch of parties anyway. Perhaps it's different now; this is before the huge outbreak and lockdown.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by jacobolus on Sunday March 21, 2021 @11:00PM (#26536419)
Indeed, San Francisco has dramatically better Covid outcomes than almost all large US cities.

The thing SF screwed up worst was opening indoor restaurants/bars for a couple months in the Autumn, which alongside holiday gatherings/winter weather resulted in a more than 10x increase in cases during that time (thankfully starting from a very low baseline). I would guess that mistake is responsible for more than half of all Covid deaths in the city, as both before and after that period (after suitably offsetting the data by a couple weeks to account for delay between action and visible outcomes) case rates were steadily declining.

SF also did a poor job, especially early on, at getting targeted testing and outreach to working class neighborhoods.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by monocasa on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:04PM (#26533465)
The ones above Florida are either the dense area of the NY extended metro that got hit early and had trouble getting it back under control, or states ideologically aligned with Florida.

Just because they're in the middle doesn't make it a good response.

Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by whatthesmack on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:58PM (#26533964)
It also doesn't necessarily make it a bad response. But when you factor in more than simply one detail (COVID vs COVID+economy+mental health), it starts to look like a good response.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by JeremyBanks on Sunday March 21, 2021 @03:50PM (#26533323)
it's okay because only one in one thousand people have died
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:54PM (#26533915)
Indeed, a 1 in 1000 chance of dying isn’t worth upending civilization over. You get fewer than 100 years on this earth regardless, to put it in perspective.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by tehjoker on Monday March 22, 2021 @01:16AM (#26537085)
Thinking back to other periods of world history I learned about in school, I can easily see how people managed to rationalize away hundreds of thousands or millions of deaths in the name of convenience.
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by umanwizard on Monday March 22, 2021 @10:09AM (#26540983)
Can you elaborate?
Re:As U.S. schools shuttered, student mental health cratered... by jansan on Sunday March 21, 2021 @04:51PM (#26533881)
While on average, every year roughly 1 in 85 people dies.