America's won too much, even when we're wrong or stupid, and our historical frame has suffered.
Who care about the conqueror and winners of wars if they aren't literate?
Winning is what mattered in that case. There's gotta be a Mao quote for that, barrels of guns or something.
All economic products cost energy to generate and all energy is limited in totality by the available energy on earth.
When someone uses this energy, another person cannot use it.
This holds true even for the most abstract product. Say the economic product of poetry produced/sung by a poet.
The poet needs energy to sustain himself and the time needed to produce the poem. When he uses that energy, entropy increases and someone else now cannot use it.
That is zero sum.
The transaction you are describing is the equivalent of two people taking gold from limited reserves and trading that gold. The fact of the matter is, the gold is still missing from the shared reserve regardless of how fair the trade was.
The loser here is other person who could've potentially used that limited resource for his own gain.
Sure there's locally optimal resource distribution that results in a less optimal global distribution.
Sure you're right that entropy wins in the end and the total energy of the universe is fixed.
But there are plenty of transactions and projects we can engage in that result in more value for all participants across the entire lifecycle.
As long as the rate of extraction of energy is lower than the rate of replenishment of energy then that net transaction seemingly produces a net gain.
However the minute Rate of extraction of energy exceeds the rate of replenishment someone loses because the energy you use cannot be used by someone else. For example the entire population of the world using as much energy as the people in the United States is unsustainable.
In short the participants in the transaction didn't lose. Someone else outside of the transaction lost.
Energy is therefore limited and, as illustrated above, a highly practical concept.
You are correct that the about of energy available for human consumption is finite in a given moment in time. Every choice for how energy is distributed collapses other possibilities. Yet, the ability of humans to capture and direct energy ever grows with the passage of time.
Up until about 3-4 generations ago, our species depended on beating other creatures to move us around, and burning trees for warmth. Now the same planet with the same or less resources is able to provide ~250 times more usable energy.
Technological growth is luck and also likely limited. The zero sum nature of the economy comes from the context of a transaction.
Transactions and exchanges are zero sum, technological growth is not. But increasing technology is both a combination of luck and arguably limited.
It seems simpler to consider that those who give are more likely to receive. Even a primordial entity in nature understands that the act of helping others helps itself.
"The universe is a zero-sum system" is a true statement, but utterly useless - a tautology that has no relevance to the discussion.
The entire culture of the United States from all the art, to all the technology, to all the food to all the music is sustained by this same energy.
It is not sustainable for everyone in the world to use the same amount of energy that is used by the United States. This is literally the definition of zero sum.
In fact it is well known that entire civilizations have fallen because they've used up all available energy reservoirs. The most famous example is the Rapa Nui people on Easter Island. Easter Island collapsed because the situation was not only zero sum but even negative as high entropy energy is not useful to any participant in the game.
What people don't realize is that the economy is limited by physical actuality. It is not simply supply, demand and your limitless "imagination" on what you can potentially deem as "valuable". Supply and demand alone is a short sighted measure. The better metric for intrinsic value must include energy/entropy in the equation.
There is a limit and that limit practically effects everything around you.
We are not really energy constrained and simply using the available energy more efficiently can leave all parties better off on all but maybe billion year timelines.
What available energy means is energy "available" for extraction. Not total energy that exists in the earth.
>Some have failed because their use of energy outpaced their ability to extract available energy.
This is just word play. You know what I mean. But we can still play the game if you want.
Basically if the civilization can't extract energy then the energy isn't "available." That's what the word available means.
> The entire planet could run for 100 years on just the toxic waste from a single US nuclear plant.
Uh no. If we replaced all current world power with copies nuclear plants running in the US we'd be out of nuclear resources in a year.
With breeder reactors and ocean water we have about 60,000 years available. A far cry from "millions of years"
If nuclear power becomes this common and available in our lifetimes then yes energy can be in a practical sense unlimited and negligible foot note in the economic equation.
However this power is not yet "available" (keyword) so until then energy is a huge part of the economic equation.
>We are not really energy constrained and simply using the available energy more efficiently can leave all parties better off on all but maybe billion year timelines.
You're talking about potential and things that are currently unavailable. I'm talking about history, the status quo and "available energy."
So we're not at odds here, just talking about different things.
Why would governments and scientists spend so much money on Fusion if Nuclear was the definitive answer? It doesn't matter. Whatever your stance is on the topic you can't change the fact that there exists huge political opposition against Nuclear power. The political opposition if anything makes the line of reasoning completely relevant.
We could argue whether fusion is nuclear or not, but I'm wondering where all this is headed.
The main point for this specific thread is that the economy is zero sum because everything relies on energy and energy is limited. Nuclear energy as it currently exists and what it potentially could or could not be does not change the equation.
The root post is another topic, I was simply responding to someone who said the economy was not zero sum and telling him that, that statement is categorically wrong. Then it spawned an avalanche of replies from people who disagree. What was just a small tangential reply is now a giant sub thread.
It's worth pointing out that the energy consumption of the US (and other developed economies) per capita has been decreasing for decades[0], and, moreover, the World Energy Council predicted that global demand for energy will peak in 2030.[1]
[0] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Total-Primary-Energy-con...
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/oct/10/global-dema...
The amount of satisfaction you have is arbitrary and your own personal opinion. It's valid to you but not a valid part of the discussion because it's so arbitrary.
It could be that in reality the satisfaction I gain from art is worth 999 trillion dollars. If it's true then it's true but is it worth discussing? No.
The critical point here is that even things of value that people believe to be seemingly abstract are connected to a physical and limited resource.
This is not just pedantry. Art such as Opera or symphonies or blockbuster movies require a huge energy hungry economy to produce.
You can't get most of the art you "enjoy" from human powered economies like tribals still living in the Amazon rain forest. None of the "art" mentioned above can ever come out of economies like that. You can't even get children's drawings (art) like you do from modern economies because tribal economies can't even produce crayons or paper.
There is a huge correlation between the quality of the abstract things you enjoy and the energy required to produce it. It's just a general correlation but it's a correlation nonetheless.
So rather then call it strange. Take it as new insight. You once considered "art" to some abstract concept that you "enjoy". Now you know that art is also a low entropy configuration of paint. Lowering entropy costs energy therefore most abstract things are always related to energy. You can still enjoy a painting, but now you are armed with additional knowledge.
Greater knowledge means things that were previously mysterious can now be viewed in a more technical light. You can call it strange or you can call it learning something new. It's up to you.
Either way you are still free to enjoy your art as if it was worth 999 trillion dollars.
I do agree that the quality of art is roughly proportional to the size of the economy that "spins it off" so to speak. Obviously hunter gatherers are not going to produce great art without surplus goods or division of labor.
At base I think we can't just write off human pleasure because some of it varies based on the individual. Economists estimate things like this all the time. I enjoy my favorite music albums very much, much more than say a $10 album cost, but if it cost instead $300 and my choice was between an album or a bicycle you can bet I would buy fewer albums no matter how much I liked them, so we can at least bound my enjoyment at $10 - $300 and realistically much narrower.
I do admit most of my favorite poetry and literature was produced by great imperial powers, even if by relatively impoverished or humble members of that society. There is something to this- whether Rome, Song China or Colonial Britain lots of good art and luxury is created by conquest.
The sun hitting the planet at a given moment is on the order of 100 petawatts. Human energy utilization is on the order of 15 terawatts. It's a really good thing that it isn't zero sum.
We use a fraction of the energy hitting the earth because we can only extract a fraction of it. In this case rate of replenishment functions as a limit. If our rate of usage exceeds the rate in which we can viably extract useful energy from the sun then that means not everyone can have access to this energy. This is a limit. Zero Sum.
If Energy truly was unlimited nobody would be paying for it.
Trees don't pay for energy.
Trees compete for light. The taller trees win, the shorter trees are deprived of sunlight and therefore are the losers.
Any economic model of society that doesn't involve the zero sum nature of reality is highly highly inaccurate.
Are your comments meant to be some kind of elaborate satire?
So I have 5 fish. I put a fish flake in the tank. The game the fish play with the flakes is zero sum. Only one fish can get the flake. Next time, I put two flakes in the fish tank. The economy has increased by 2x! But only two fish get a flake so the game is still zero sum.
What if I put 30 flakes into the tank? The biggest fish beats up all the other fish and eats all 30 flakes. The game is still zero sum.
Increasing the size of the economy does not change the nature of the zero sum game.
I can triple the size and value of the fish tank economy just like how Reddit can increase the value of GameStop. The fact of the matter is it’s all still a zero sum game.
If I'm moving from the UK to the US, and someone else is moving from the US to the UK, then I really need USD and that person really needs GBP.
We can then trade USD for GBP and both be better off as a result.
The transaction was demonstrably positive sum in utility terms.
Simply by obtaining these resources others are deprived. The people who are deprived are the losers, the people who aren't are the winners.
It doesn't matter if you need things at different times. When you the trace the source of everything you that "need" you will find that at the root of it all is a limited resource.
A product is either limited by an actual concrete supply or if the product is abstract it is limited by energy.
When you trace the origin of everything back all the way to inception you will find a limit.
You pay for energy. So just how high is the limit practically speaking? Think about it. It'd be pedantry if I argued with you over oxygen, but Energy is nowhere near as seemingly limitless as oxygen.
Keep in mind this conversation began because someone said "America has won too much".
The origin of energy in the universe is not known and the beauty of the universe is your opinion and not relevant to this conversation.
There are several things about energy that are always true as far as we know:
1. We cannot created or destroy it.
2. There seems to be a fixed amount of energy in the universe.
3. As energy rises in entropy either through inevitably or usage it becomes unusable to us. You can heat your room with a heater but you can never recapture that heat to reheat your room again. Therefore “available energy” is limited.
All of my statements can be derived from the “axioms” above. Concepts like beauty or the origin of energy is not derivable from anything we currently know.
Context is relevant.
The Sahara radiates more energy into space every night than the human race utilized that day.
Why am I still paying for energy if it's unlimited?
Because energy is still limited.
The energy radiated by the Sahara is not "available" therefore not part of what I meant when I said "available energy on earth."
The easiest observable way to see that the economy is not zero sum once you take into account delta T (time) is that the economy grows and can grow both faster or slower than population growth. If it was truly zero-sum in aggregate, the size of the economy and wealth would always be strictly proportional to population.
You need to model energy alongside an economy and population.
Logically, If you limit energy, you limit the size of the economy. Therefore, energy is an important variable in any economic model.
To not include such a factor in your model means your model is inaccurate.
2) What you are espousing here really isn’t all that useful other than as a way of playing “ooh gotcha” in arguments with others
3) Energy is only zero sum in closed systems and the earth is not a closed system. The overwhelming majority of our energy comes from a source outside our ecosystem and a non-zero amount also escapes from our planet. Ergo, it’s not a closed system and your zero sum notions do not necessarily always apply.
2. No it is useful and highly practical. See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26352352
3. Energy is limited in the amount that arrives from the sun per day and the amount we have the ability to extract from the earth and the sun and the wind per day. The limit is evident by the fact you have to pay for it. If it were unlimited, your energy bill would be zero.
There does exist products on earth that while not technically unlimited can be practically considered unlimited. One such example is the air you breath. Energy is NOT an example of this.
One of the most interesting proofs of this is the measurable change in the Earth’s albedo due to climate change (and the downward spiral that creates). If we can demonstrate notable changes in how much energy is retained or lost, globally, that destroys the notion of this being a closed system. Similarly, the sun itself is known to be variable in its total energy output so there is no reasonable assurance of a constant amount of energy into or out of our global system. We can’t really control how much energy is produced but it is false to assert that all energy is used as well - there is notable margin for good or for bad here - and because of that, the zero-sum claim is just silly.
Ephemeral supply and wasted energy only limits supply even further. Here’s a very simple way to think about it that gets rid of the associated complexities :
The fact that you pay for energy and the fact that energy outages can occur when usage exceeds supply means that energy is limited and therefore zero sum. In fact the attempt to try to reason your way to another conclusion is the silly endeavor.
The economy is zero sum because the actual key measurement of all economic goods is the lowering of entropy which is directly done by energy utilization which is directly limited.
The earth receives energy from the sun at a limited rate. The limit on the rate and limits on our technology in order to extract this energy functions as a practical limit.
Zero sum games are used colloquially in the context of transactional games. When a resource is limited in this context the game is zero sum. Someone loses during the creation and exchange of an economic product.
The context of increasing technology or resource discovery is separate from this topic and not what people mean when they say the economy is “not zero sum”. People are referring to the transaction and creation of said economic product and the economic actors in the economy at the current point in time. What they mean is a “transaction” in the game where I trade you an extra pizza for your extra shoe results in both of us receiving a net gain. My claim is that this transaction does not result in a net gain because both products are tied to a limited resource whether it be material or energy. You took a piece of the energy pie now someone else has no pie.
You like you use language reminiscent of thermodynamics but you seem to suffer significant misapprehension of the laws of thermodynamics.
Energy is never lost in a universal sense or within a closed system. So, for you to say energy is lost if not used is either a violation of the laws of thermodynamics or admission that the earth’s ecosystem and all human endeavors therein are not a closed system. Just as energy can be lost from that system, it can be added from external sources (primarily the sun). So for any resource/bit of energy, unlike your previous statements, either I use it, you or anyone else not me uses it, or it’s lost to waste/eventually leaked from the system or it’s stored and used later (or likely some combination of all four of those). If it were zero-sum, it would be 1&2 only and no energy would ever be added to the system. That’s not the case for earth and human endeavors.
I’m using entropy in terms of statistical mechanics. Probability is the more viable explanation for entropy, not some random thermodynamic law. Those laws are archaic explanations of what entropy is.
I’m also not talking about just energy. I’m talking about available energy. Energy can’t be created or destroyed but it can increase in entropy and become unusable and unavailable.
The limit I’m referring to here is rate of available energy. Energy on the earth is constantly being rendered unusable through entropy increasing naturally or through the transfer of low entropy from energy to low entropy economic products. Energy is also being replenished by the sun at a fixed rate.
The usage rate and replenishment rate form an effective limit on aggregate available energy as a limited rate, making its rate of usage in an economic transaction effectively capped and therefore zero sum by definition.
There’s no time cube antics here that’s just rude. The real antic here is how you can think that people can just play the economic game and continuously benefit from repeated transactions to infinite without any actual physical price that was paid. Physical limits exist and that is not wackiness... that is common sense. Although, your reply that will follow this statement will be 100% wackiness if you want any chance at vindicating yourself.
Nope, it doesn't. You're not wrong. You're just being pedantic. For all intents and purposes for the discussion we're having here this continuous decay into higher entropy states is a non-issue. Within the sphere of the humans involved in free exchange, it's not zero sum even if it is zero sum when you take into account the entirety of the physical world.
I think it's reasonable to involve all humans effected by an exchange.
If a corporation purchases water rights in an area from the government and suddenly deprives the poor farmers in the area from using the water to grow their food does this make the farmers a negligible part of the equation? In my opinion: No.
You can create your box so that it only fits the participants of the transaction but that would be a fantasy. There are great real world zero sum costs to almost everything in an economy.
My claim is that all economic activity is tied to energy and that energy is limited and usage of said limited energy in one place prevents usage elsewhere. Try to find an example that falsifies my claim. You can’t.
The game is basically zero sum but occasionally you roll some dice and if it lands on a 6 you can increase the total sum. However the game in between the dice rolls is zero sum. To frame it in a real world example: you still pay for energy as if it was limited even though nuclear fusion has the potential to make it unlimited.
Growth in terms of resource discovery and better technology is not zero sum. But exchanges and transactions in terms of current available resources and technology is zero sum.
That should help setup a dichotomy and clarify things.
>> Given an initial situation, a Pareto improvement is a new situation where some agents will gain, and no agents will lose. [0]
Neonological seems to believe that pareto improvements are not possible because of negative externalities. Maybe they are right but positive externalities also need to be accounted for.
Just replace all available energy with a free triple A battery gifted to you by the government per day. That battery can’t even push your car 100 meters. If you can’t drive then the suburban layout of US cities can’t even function. Every aspect of the economy will grind to a near standstill.
Energy is the primary resource that drives everything in an economy, everything. Because energy is limited the game in every economy is in actuality overall zero sum.
Because energy is relatively abundant right now, certain models of the economy sort of do work for certain scenarios when they don’t account for energy. But I think these models are still bad because, practically, even differences in energy utilization correlate with how technically advanced an economy is.
Once energy is used up, then all economies are basically dead. There is no positive externality here. Every economic transaction involves energy and is thus zero sum. If the United States uses up all the oil in the world to build its advanced economy then other countries and people in the future and past cannot build that same economy because there is no oil. Zero sum.
A big counter-example is Sima Qian, who was given the choice of being executed or castrated by the Han Emperor. Because he made a promise to his father to write a history of China, he chose castration, and is now considered the father of Chinese history.
The U.S.A. celebrates one Christopher Columbus with his very own holiday.
Both men did rather similar things, with the one exception of course that the latter won his genocide campaigns and racial superiority wars, and the former lost them.
The total death toll of W.W.2. is 75 million on all sides, for comparison.
[1]: https://www.businessinsider.com/climate-changed-after-europe...
I have no idea what your currency is and who is on it.
My currency is American and every single one of them has more native bodies on them than Columbus. President's day has zero people protesting against it.
Like I said, history is written by the winners.
On American currency, Washington, Jefferson and Jackson (!) are most relevant although they're obviously not the only authority figures that were all about taking land.
The first ~12 presidents or so are each responsible for more atrocities against natives than Columbus could ever have done on the one crappy island he occupied for a few years. You don't go from 13 coastal colonies to "sea to shining sea" without breaking a few eggs.
What do you base the idea upon that it was mostly disease and not warfare?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_disease_and_ep...
This source suggests that the estimate is that 25–50% of members of most tribes were felled by disease. Given that 90% of the population was felled overall, it seems unlikely that most were felled due to disease.
Sources of death, wider timeframe:
* Disease
* Columbus on one tiny island
* Spaniards in general who are not Columbus (who was italian but sponsored by Spain)
* British/Americans
Disease sounds like #1 from what I can tell. Spaniards might edge out Americans, or maybe we're worse, I don't know. We left fewer survivors but they were in a larger area. Columbus for a few years on one island is clearly last place.It claims that 55 million of the population of 60 million was killed by “violence and disease”.
> Following Christopher Columbus' arrival in North America in 1492, violence and disease killed 90% of the indigenous population — nearly 55 million people — according to a study published this year.
Given that the other source claims that 25-50% of most tribes was lost to disease, I find the idea that disease caused almost all of the deaths to be unsupported unless you have something else than “general knowledge” which is contradicted by sources, which, admittedly, are estimates as they always are.
Columbus did his share of wrongs, but he wasn't responsible for a genocide.
I'm not being facetious in giving you a let-me-Google-that-for-you link (normally when one does that it's to sort of hint at someone they are too lazy to look up a technical question).
But in this case it's an honest invitation to do some basic research yourself. If I gave you specific links it could be cherry-picked links to highly skewed content to people with ideological axes to grind.
History (outside of government-sponsored and civic-minded textbooks) tends to be pretty grim and filled with bloodshed and injustice and this is no exception.
Your original comment doesn't state it's position clearly. I'm parsing it as a kind of exasperated disbelief in someone perceived to be making a ridiculous claim.
If instead this is a debate about the exact meaning and semantics of the use of the word 'genocide' feel free to ignore this.
Edit: updated link
If I recall, that book's source was the writings of a Columbus critic of the time (a monk I think?)
Are there any other sources that discuss Columbus and his interactions with native populations?
That's utter nonsense, and actually echos one of the propaganda lines that an actual totalitarian regime uses to deflect criticism of its actual oppressive polices. You're also forgetting that lots of people buy into totalitarian government propaganda, and push it voluntarily (from stuff like this https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/business/china-internet-c... to nationalist internet trolls to Red Guards).
Real totalitarian regimes do stuff like this (https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/26/business/china-online-cen...) and worse. Your so-called "worse" regime just occasionally has bosses fire employees for saying something impolitic and business that refuse to carry certain items (with the effect of only making them slightly harder to buy).
This moralizing aspect runs very deep in the US, and religious, righteous fervor is more widespread than one might think, covering much of non-church-going population. Human imperfection is still seen as a degeneration or a disease; it's just being Catholic, or Black, or gender-queer is not seen as an imperfection any more. But breastfeeding a baby in public still is :(
While I get your point, intentional misinformation and disinformation is evil.
OTOH for the most part, when my neighbors spread disinformation, they are not doing it intentionally, so my neighbors aren't evil. It's often by glossing over subtleties like this that those in power divide those they would rule; there are some communists who would like to overthrow the government; all communists are socialists; therefore anyone who ever professes a socialist view wants to overthrow the government.
> an authoritarian regime always started with moralizing everything, always started with telling its citizens to hate their neighbors
Authoritarian regimes start with telling citizens to hate their neighbors; moralizing is just one of the more convenient ways to to accomplish this. The anti-Jewish rhetoric in Nazi Germany definitely had a moralizing component (particularly ascribing the vice of greed), but it also spared no opportunity to portray them as inferior while simultaneously playing on envy.
Actually HUAC and Nazi anti-Jewish propaganda point to another important commonality: those to be attacked were "Un-American" or "Un-German." I'm more concerned with the degree to which both the right and left attempt to de-legitimize the other side than I am about ebay choosing which books they stock.
See the trap? If you deny you're racist, it's proof that you're actually even more racist.
The second part I want to point out, as someone who actually read this absolute rubbish, is that D'Angelo is absolutely hardcore racist. She, for example, spends an intro to a chapter explaining how she was invited to some event at a public park, and upon arrival, she saw two large groups of people, one black, the other white. For a brief moment, she describes, she was stricken with anxiety, worried that the group she was meeting might be the black group.
She extrapolates her own internal racism to the default state of all white people.
Seriously, read the book. She's out of her tree. Anybody recommending this book either hasn't read it and is virtue signalling, or has read it and is so deep into the magisterium of the Church of Woke that they're not worth trying to save.
She’s taken negative characteristics, ascribed them to a group of people based on skin color, and implied that it’s a good thing to try and be “less white.” Its bigotry plain and simple and I’m actually taken aback that I have to explain it to you.
Are you merely pretending to not see the problem?
Of course they are. Why play this game of pretend?
And in what world is it "harmful" to "pretend" something true, namely that "white" is no shorthand (let alone an "effective" one) for "prejudice + institutional power"?
Is white history not steeped in colonialism? Did colonialism not lead to institutional power? Does that power still not exist?
How did the current set of elites get their elite status? Sheer luck and determination?
Your other reply... Needs some citations, cause it’s really quite false.
1. There's no good reason to assign the sweeping and inherently-fuzzy category "white" to mean "prejudice + institutional power". Even given your (oversimplified) observation about colonialism, that's neither a necessary nor sufficient reason to apply a label that will be inherently over-generalized. It is simple historic fact that many "white" (per current definition) peoples had no role in colonialism and enjoyed no (local or global) institutional power. If this claim is mystifying to you, you may need to learn about white people outside of America or western Europe. So, the proposed semantic shortcut is inherently unjust to a portion of humanity. To the degree that this (arbitrary aesthetic) choice does harm... it is, in itself, racist.
2. To make the argument above, does not require "pretending colonialism wasn't a thing." Those are separate debates.
3. But even setting aside #1 & #2, it is, of course, far more debatable how current elites got their status. What frame are you using? The US? "The west"? The world? I would say that even the presumption that "current elites" can reasonably be described as "white" would be quite wrong in all three cases (escalatingly so, in order). But the notion that dominance was wholly established by extractive colonialism is something that could only pass for true in a deeply incestuous echo chamber. By the time colonialism even started there were already wide gaps in technological and economic development of various societies, and given how development has unfolded, it's likely the gaps we see today would exist even without colonial interference. Differential development since colonialism ended also attests to the fact that colonialism and hard force are only factors in development, not determinants. Finally, all this ignores the broad strokes of human history: across all geographies and times, human societies have discriminated against and dominated each other. Maybe occasionally, maybe perpetually, but it's basically always there. At a certain point, it became possible to do so at longer distances, at larger scale and across larger cultural experience gaps -- but human awfulness didn't start 15th century. So again, making motivated aesthetic choices about naming descriptions of social systems and types of interpersonal behavior after an identity group that does not actually map to them is aptly described as racist. Not under the new, stipulative definition, which runs afoul of all these issues, but under the older and more useful definition that could be summarized as "harming or hating people on the basis of their race/skin color".
1. Which white people are you referring to that don’t have a hand in colonialism? You think it’s too fuzzy? Who specifically is unjustly included in that term?
2. How the current elites got there is very relevant for why institutions are the way they are.
3. Frame is: the world. More specifically the English, French, German, Dutch, Danish, Spanish, Italian, Belgium, Russian empires that colonised the world, and invented the idea of “white supremacy” (named by them!) and only recently (last 50-60 years) been removed as an “official hurdle” to non white races. Civil rights act (because people of colour were not considered “a man” under the constitution) in the US, the abolition of “White Australia Policy” (Of note given Australia was a black nation in near Asia), end of Apartheid in South Africa . But that was official definitions, not cultural which still linger today, as can be seen in the economic disparity between “whites” and everyone else in post colonial nations unless they’ve worked super hard to undo it...
1. The most direct answer is most of the people of Eastern, Central and Southern Europe. Draw a circle from Estonia, to Czechia, down the east Adriatic coast, around Greece and Georgia. That's a lot of people and a lot of peoples. Many have immigrated to the US or western Europe and have established lives in the multicultural societies where they (today but not always historically) get counted as "white". The more complicated answer would also include some peoples from Central and South America. Many peoples there who consider themselves "white", through evolution of cultural identities after colonialism. It's not as simple as "Oh, well there were white colonizers and everyone else" -- the "mestizo" identity has grown and changed but it's very much it's own thing. Finally, even among the obviously-colonist nations, there have always been underclasses who had no say in managing their societies or what those societies did overseas. This observation is anathema to those who want to draw neat circles around societies and label them colonizers, racists, etc... but as a simple matter of fact, there plenty of super "white" British/French/Dutch/etc people who lived at the height of colonialism and still had nothing to do with it, whether they would have wanted to or not.
2. Sure, it's relevant. But, again, the discussions of how accurate it is to make sweeping claims about "white" people or countries do not necessitate any kind of colonialism denial. This was in response to your comment upthread which implied that discussing the harms of "white = prejudice + institutional power" necessitates ignoring colonialism. It doesn't.
3. Helpful clarifications, but you didn't respond to the arguments. A) "Current elites" are diverse, both within multicultural societies like the US and around the globe. Maybe that distribution isn't "perfect" (begging what that would mean...) but it's factually wrong to call those elites, as a category, white. B) 15th-19th century colonialism was a continuation of the prior state of the world (across cultures, societies, geographies). The unusual thing was the technology that propelled it to a larger scale, as well as the subsequent phase change in civilization (caused by industrialization and globalization) which ended those norms of dominance and conquest. C) It's an extraordinary claim (though extraordinarily popular in the canonical liberal-progressive worldview) that extractive colonialism was the sole (or even primary) driver of current inequalities. Those gaps were already huge when colonialism started (and hence why it worked so effectively). Culture (at various level of 'zoom' with respect to that concept), education, technology, social values... tons of things play a role in differential development. To group all current disparities and wave your hands while mumbling "something something colonialism" does not establish a rigorous model of what causes differential development.
To sum it all up: It's a simple fact that lots of "white" people had nothing to do with colonialism, nor even had an opportunity to design or perpetrate any colonialism. That alone makes demonizing the category with moralizing labels a harmful decision.
Add the much more complicated subject of determining what drives or has driven disparities in various cases, and it becomes extremely questionable to claim that "white = prejudice+power" is a necessary or even useful tool for analyzing social relations and designing solutions.
Your imaginary line encompasses a tiny proportion of “white”.
So, please comment on what the civil rights act was doing, or the “White Australia Policy” without making any racial reference? What did Australia even mean by “White”!? Last I checked both those countries were democracies and those policies (or lack there of) were voted on... so which people couldn’t participate? Oh yeah the people of colour! Because they were excluded.
The elite in all of the colonialist countries are still White... in America, they are White, in Australia they are White, despite both countries having an exclusively non-White population before colonisation. Until recently it was the case in places like Hk and Singapore... White isn’t my term, it’s theirs. Go to China where there are signs like “whites only, no yellow!” On the old colonial buildings. Or South Africa or Australia with specific reference to whites and “non-whites”. Or Jim Crow in the US... like which make believe world are you talking about?
“White” is the name established by those with institutional power for the group their prejudice favored, other racial identifiers were ascribed to (and, through shared experience of racism from the White group, became identities for) various groups that their prejudice operated against, whereas White became an identity for those whose shared experience was being the beneficiaries of that institutionalized prejudice.
In the case of "white", "black", "brown" and so on, those definitions also changed considerably over time. Then, at some point, the efforts to intentionally draw hard lines around petered off and lost support.
Those labels are still used because they do have some kind of descriptive capacity, even if solely because of momentum from old habits.
Crucially: none of this is responsive to my point. There's no good reason, today, to assign "white" to mean "prejudice + institutional power" in a general sense. It's not necessary to do so. Doing so is not sufficient to address and unpack all the dimensions of prejudice and institutional inequality as they take place today. But doing so does incur all the imprecision-based racist harms that I described in my post.
No, I'm not talking about some vague various-periods-of-time generality.
Every concrete identity current in American society, including “White”, is a product of White supremacy, and currently reflects identification with shared experience under White supremacy, which, for those the White, is being on the side of prejudiced institutional power.
Whiteness as a racial identity (not as an ancestry, not as description of skin color, but as a racial identity) is, entirely, about prej5 plus institutional power.
"White" has changed in definition over time. English expanded to include French, expanded to include Irish/Scottish, expanded to include Germanic/Nordic, expanded to include Slavic, expanded to include (some) Hispanics... it's pretty much always been changing.
And for a good 50 years, it's just devolved into a term of convenience. We haven't had concerted "racial construction" for decades.
You paint a totalizing picture that's dusty, faded and old. It's not a relevant stance in today's America, except insofar as it enables these totalizing activist narratives (for political and economic purposes, every time).
Yes, you are.
> Your other reply... Needs some citations
Done.
It’s just another framing that gives you an exemption to discriminate based on skin color and pretend you’re doing it for good reasons.
My opinion: putting aside the discussion of the new definitions merits and shortcomings, we can still easily call DiAngelo presumptuous, essentialist and nontrivially bigoted.
Everyone knows what Rayiner meant when he said racist. That's what the word means.
Nonsense.
A white student is four times less likely to be admitted to a top university than a black student with the same grades and test scores.
A white student is significantly less likely to be admitted to medical school than a comparable black student.
There are literally hundreds of race-based scholarships exclusively for nonwhite students, and none exclusively for white students.
That's to say nothing of the thousands of special programs, events, job fairs, awards, and career opportunities that exist exclusively for nonwhite students and workers.
https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/med1.jpg
https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/med-1.png
https://s3.amazonaws.com/media.thecrimson.com/photos/2018/10...
https://www.scholarships.com/financial-aid/college-scholarsh...
Note that the handful of scholarships listed under "Caucasian" do not appear to be actually exclusive. For example, for Journalism Institute for Media Diversity Scholarships:
> Members of racial, ethnic and other underrepresented groups are particularly urged to apply as are those interested in studying the importance of diversity in the nation's media to this country's future well being.
From No Longer Separate, Not Yet Equal: Race and Class in Elite College Admission and Campus Life by Espenshade and Radford:
> The black preference at public schools is equivalent on average to 3.8 ACT points. In other words, a black applicant who receives a score of 27 on the ACT test would have the same chance of admission to a public NSCE institution as a white candidate with an ACT score of 30.8, other things in model 2 the same... The second column of Table 3.5 indicates the size of admission preferences at private NSCE institutions. Once again, black applicants receive the largest admission bonus—equivalent to 310 SAT points. A black candidate with an SAT score of 1250 could be expected to have the same chance of being admitted as a white student whose SAT score is 1560, all other things equal in model 5.
Let's look at China between 1949 and 1978. You would be Chinese version of Dalits if your parents or grandparents were landlords, farmers who owned property, counter-revolutionaries (whatever that is), bad influencers, rightist, or an intellectual. You would need to accept that you were born evil. If you denied that you were a bad guy, well, then you just proved that you were a worse person as you wouldn't even accept that you needed "transformation". Tens of thousands of people were exile to Gulag-like places and died there. Students in elementary schools could beat their principals to death for they were counter revolutionary. Millions people were striped their properties and basic rights. It was a scar cutting deep into generations of Chinese people. Oh by the way, you can attack anyone for being a "rightist", and you automatically became morally superior.
Now, how is bullshit like white fragility different China's Five Black Categories in those dark years? Just replace "rightist" with "racist", and I can't tell the difference.
It veers into talking about Jewish conspiracies on sentence 1.
Is this a troll?
I'm far from woke but this is pretty littered with dog whistles and paranoid exaggerations. And, more to the point, it's no more rigorous than DiAngelo's work.
This is a bad scene and a bad source.
So if you listened to Voice of America, you would be convicted. If you questioned scientists for telling you that an acre of rice fields could easily produce 30,000 KGs of grains, you would be punished. If you lived in East Germany during cold war, of course your neighbor was so evil that it was your duty to spy on them and to report them. Oh and yes, many people were executed for questioning the ideology of Pol Pot. Guess how many people during the Pol Pot era believed that their neighbors deserved the death?
But of course, the US is the lighthouse of righteousness and justice and democracy, right? Our government didn't do anything wrong, right? It's just a few congressmen asking companies to be responsible for the evil disinformation and misinformation, right? The 1619 Project won Pulitzer because its narrative was for our own conscience, right? We teach kids critical race theory so they can hate an entire race but it's for our own good, right? We did all these for our moral high ground, what's wrong with it, right?