News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by malandrew on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:06PM (#26352553)
some transactions are zero some (pareto optimal) and some are not (nash equilibria).

The easiest observable way to see that the economy is not zero sum once you take into account delta T (time) is that the economy grows and can grow both faster or slower than population growth. If it was truly zero-sum in aggregate, the size of the economy and wealth would always be strictly proportional to population.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:18PM (#26352633)
Does this model include energy that continuously decays into higher entropy states?

You need to model energy alongside an economy and population.

Logically, If you limit energy, you limit the size of the economy. Therefore, energy is an important variable in any economic model.

To not include such a factor in your model means your model is inaccurate.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by incongruity on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:03AM (#26352952)
1) All models are wrong but some are useful.

2) What you are espousing here really isn’t all that useful other than as a way of playing “ooh gotcha” in arguments with others

3) Energy is only zero sum in closed systems and the earth is not a closed system. The overwhelming majority of our energy comes from a source outside our ecosystem and a non-zero amount also escapes from our planet. Ergo, it’s not a closed system and your zero sum notions do not necessarily always apply.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:18AM (#26353035)
1. Except your model is missing an extremely important figure. Modern economies thrive off of the energy variable. This is not some missing detail, it is critical.

2. No it is useful and highly practical. See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26352352

3. Energy is limited in the amount that arrives from the sun per day and the amount we have the ability to extract from the earth and the sun and the wind per day. The limit is evident by the fact you have to pay for it. If it were unlimited, your energy bill would be zero.

There does exist products on earth that while not technically unlimited can be practically considered unlimited. One such example is the air you breath. Energy is NOT an example of this.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by hippira on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:13AM (#26353793)
I want to chip in here and say that accouting for limited resources in an economic model is definitely useful, because the negate ( not accounting for limited resources ) has led to the environmental disaster that we find ourselves in right now.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by incongruity on Friday March 05, 2021 @07:36AM (#26356142)
That’s an eminently reasonable proposition but that is far far from insisting on dogmatic application of a zero-sum rule where it demonstrably does not apply.

One of the most interesting proofs of this is the measurable change in the Earth’s albedo due to climate change (and the downward spiral that creates). If we can demonstrate notable changes in how much energy is retained or lost, globally, that destroys the notion of this being a closed system. Similarly, the sun itself is known to be variable in its total energy output so there is no reasonable assurance of a constant amount of energy into or out of our global system. We can’t really control how much energy is produced but it is false to assert that all energy is used as well - there is notable margin for good or for bad here - and because of that, the zero-sum claim is just silly.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#26357876)
What confuses people is the fact that for many things if energy isn’t used it is actually completely lost, hence people believe that this “lost” energy constitutes a possible unlimited potential supply. Sure it can constitute such a thing if you can find a way to utilize this lost energy. Currently there’s no way to utilize hence it’s not a factor.

Ephemeral supply and wasted energy only limits supply even further. Here’s a very simple way to think about it that gets rid of the associated complexities :

The fact that you pay for energy and the fact that energy outages can occur when usage exceeds supply means that energy is limited and therefore zero sum. In fact the attempt to try to reason your way to another conclusion is the silly endeavor.

The economy is zero sum because the actual key measurement of all economic goods is the lowering of entropy which is directly done by energy utilization which is directly limited.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by malandrew on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:47AM (#26358924)
The economy is a concept that exists strictly on Earth (until someone like Musk colonizes Mars). A huge portion of our energy comes from the Sun both in the form of plant matter from agriculture and from solar power as we increasingly build solar panels to harvest the Sun's energy. The simple fact that we can take this exogenous source of energy and feed it into our economy to grow it means that yes, it's zero sum if you consider the Universe, but from the perspective of the economy here on Planet Earth, that economy getting energy for free and grow in excess of your zero sum thinking.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#26359198)
No. First off net useable energy is constantly decreasing in the universe. Entropy will always increase until all energy available for use in the universe is zero. The universe is not a zero sum game. It is negative and in the end everyone loses.

The earth receives energy from the sun at a limited rate. The limit on the rate and limits on our technology in order to extract this energy functions as a practical limit.

Zero sum games are used colloquially in the context of transactional games. When a resource is limited in this context the game is zero sum. Someone loses during the creation and exchange of an economic product.

The context of increasing technology or resource discovery is separate from this topic and not what people mean when they say the economy is “not zero sum”. People are referring to the transaction and creation of said economic product and the economic actors in the economy at the current point in time. What they mean is a “transaction” in the game where I trade you an extra pizza for your extra shoe results in both of us receiving a net gain. My claim is that this transaction does not result in a net gain because both products are tied to a limited resource whether it be material or energy. You took a piece of the energy pie now someone else has no pie.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by incongruity on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:31PM (#26359445)
This is some time cube level self rationalizing wackiness. Seriously - If energy is lost, that contradicts your previous claims.

You like you use language reminiscent of thermodynamics but you seem to suffer significant misapprehension of the laws of thermodynamics.

Energy is never lost in a universal sense or within a closed system. So, for you to say energy is lost if not used is either a violation of the laws of thermodynamics or admission that the earth’s ecosystem and all human endeavors therein are not a closed system. Just as energy can be lost from that system, it can be added from external sources (primarily the sun). So for any resource/bit of energy, unlike your previous statements, either I use it, you or anyone else not me uses it, or it’s lost to waste/eventually leaked from the system or it’s stored and used later (or likely some combination of all four of those). If it were zero-sum, it would be 1&2 only and no energy would ever be added to the system. That’s not the case for earth and human endeavors.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:58PM (#26359784)
Your first sentence is a rude insult. There’s no need for that on HN.

I’m using entropy in terms of statistical mechanics. Probability is the more viable explanation for entropy, not some random thermodynamic law. Those laws are archaic explanations of what entropy is.

I’m also not talking about just energy. I’m talking about available energy. Energy can’t be created or destroyed but it can increase in entropy and become unusable and unavailable.

The limit I’m referring to here is rate of available energy. Energy on the earth is constantly being rendered unusable through entropy increasing naturally or through the transfer of low entropy from energy to low entropy economic products. Energy is also being replenished by the sun at a fixed rate.

The usage rate and replenishment rate form an effective limit on aggregate available energy as a limited rate, making its rate of usage in an economic transaction effectively capped and therefore zero sum by definition.

There’s no time cube antics here that’s just rude. The real antic here is how you can think that people can just play the economic game and continuously benefit from repeated transactions to infinite without any actual physical price that was paid. Physical limits exist and that is not wackiness... that is common sense. Although, your reply that will follow this statement will be 100% wackiness if you want any chance at vindicating yourself.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by malandrew on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:50AM (#26353277)
> Does this model include energy that continuously decays into higher entropy states?

Nope, it doesn't. You're not wrong. You're just being pedantic. For all intents and purposes for the discussion we're having here this continuous decay into higher entropy states is a non-issue. Within the sphere of the humans involved in free exchange, it's not zero sum even if it is zero sum when you take into account the entirety of the physical world.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @01:05AM (#26353374)
I'm not being pedantic.

I think it's reasonable to involve all humans effected by an exchange.

If a corporation purchases water rights in an area from the government and suddenly deprives the poor farmers in the area from using the water to grow their food does this make the farmers a negligible part of the equation? In my opinion: No.

You can create your box so that it only fits the participants of the transaction but that would be a fantasy. There are great real world zero sum costs to almost everything in an economy.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by malandrew on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:42AM (#26358860)
Your examples are pretty much strictly isolated to limited extractable natural resources. This is but a tiny sliver of all economic activity.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:54AM (#26358999)
No. That’s just one example in response to your attempted boxing of all economic consequences into the “participants” of a transaction. The example falsifies your claim from ever being true.

My claim is that all economic activity is tied to energy and that energy is limited and usage of said limited energy in one place prevents usage elsewhere. Try to find an example that falsifies my claim. You can’t.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by chordalkeyboard on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:54PM (#26352885)
Pareto improvements are positive sum.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by ZWoz on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:18AM (#26353824)
Pareto improvements are theoretical concept. neonological argues here, that those are impossible in reality. I think this is pretty hard to argue one or other way, because side effects of our activities aren't always obvious. Things like tumbleweed in northern america or any accidentally imported plant/animal is good example about costs, that arrive later and for other people. Though I think there is possible to construct some clear Pareto improvement cases, like early improvements of internal combustion engine, where I don't see possibility of negative effects, only additional power out of same amount of fuel.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:52AM (#26358181)
From certain perspectives increasing available energy or increasing energy efficiency is a net positive. But the modus operandi of humans is to pay for goods because of limited supply.

The game is basically zero sum but occasionally you roll some dice and if it lands on a 6 you can increase the total sum. However the game in between the dice rolls is zero sum. To frame it in a real world example: you still pay for energy as if it was limited even though nuclear fusion has the potential to make it unlimited.

Growth in terms of resource discovery and better technology is not zero sum. But exchanges and transactions in terms of current available resources and technology is zero sum.

That should help setup a dichotomy and clarify things.

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by malandrew on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:52AM (#26353290)
Thanks for the correction. That said I would say "pareto improvements can be positive sum" since they can be but aren't necessarily so.
Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by chordalkeyboard on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:32PM (#26363093)
My understanding is that pareto improvements are positive sum by definition.

>> Given an initial situation, a Pareto improvement is a new situation where some agents will gain, and no agents will lose. [0]

Neonological seems to believe that pareto improvements are not possible because of negative externalities. Maybe they are right but positive externalities also need to be accounted for.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_efficiency

Re:Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay by neonological on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @10:21AM (#26412139)
One way to see that the externality is overall negative is to make a small model of the economy with even tighter limits on the energy resource. You can literally hold this model in your head. We both agree that energy is a limited resource and that usage of a limited resource prevents others from using that resource and is thus zero sum.

Just replace all available energy with a free triple A battery gifted to you by the government per day. That battery can’t even push your car 100 meters. If you can’t drive then the suburban layout of US cities can’t even function. Every aspect of the economy will grind to a near standstill.

Energy is the primary resource that drives everything in an economy, everything. Because energy is limited the game in every economy is in actuality overall zero sum.

Because energy is relatively abundant right now, certain models of the economy sort of do work for certain scenarios when they don’t account for energy. But I think these models are still bad because, practically, even differences in energy utilization correlate with how technically advanced an economy is.

Once energy is used up, then all economies are basically dead. There is no positive externality here. Every economic transaction involves energy and is thus zero sum. If the United States uses up all the oil in the world to build its advanced economy then other countries and people in the future and past cannot build that same economy because there is no oil. Zero sum.