An Apple branded TV, even if it is without the TV part or just a monitor would have to be at least 2-3x the price of today's similar TV sets. And if anything OP were only willing to paid an extra $100 is probably why Apple didn't make one.
Some of the TV in the industry isn't just on Low Margin. They are entering negative margin territory if you are discounting Data Selling and software / partner sponsorship.
Unless the cost electronic part continue to raise to the point where Apple has an advantage with their SoC.
I think one of their original purpose or intention for ProXDR was the use the Dual Layer LCD technology to create something like a true Reference Display Monitor. But the technology and cost never got to that point. At least I hope they could continue their investment in that area even if they do not intend it to be in consumer usage.
People would absolutely pay $1000-1200 for a 55" Apple TV with nice software, and maybe a nice brushed aluminum frame that looks nice on the wall.
(For comparison, the cheapest 55" I could quickly find from a major retail is around $300, with a "name brand" starting around $400).
5-10 years? I know I'm not on the latest technology step. But 4K isn't worth me upgrading perfectly functional TVs. Maybe if we get to reasonably priced OLED panels but I'm not in a big hurry to upgrade TVs that are working.
I actually took home quite a few (3-4) more expensive TVs from Costco before buying the TCL, and it was far and away the best set while also being 1/2 to 1/3 the price.
It would be the best of Apple product to show off.
They could offer three sizes. Mini, Normal, Max.
They could use it as a jumping off point to own the “living room” if they wanted.
And if that specific LG model charges 3 to 5K, Apple will have to sell it at 6 to 10K.
Edit: I think I need to spell things out a little more clearly. If Apple were to use OLED and aim at a top tier market, then it would be competing directly with LG TV, which also happens to be gaining momentum in terms of both OLED display panel ( LG Display ) and TV set ( LG Electronics ). LG Display will also need to built new Fab for Apple. The recent expansion at Guangzhou doubling their capacity, AFAIK has already been booked and has no relation to Apple. i.e LG has little interest to do it with Apple given they are already fully booked on capacity. And Apple doesn't seems to be interested in pushing LG to partner.
The answer to if Apple could do something will always going to be yes given they have hundreds of billions of cash and has little idea what to do with it other than buying back stocks.
The answer to if Apple will do it is always going to complex. And nothing in the supply chain and BOM cost analysis suggest it is a good strategy worth going for.
I do wish Apple prove wrong though.
(Samsung LSP7 is $3,500)
However I can still watch Disney on it using airplay from my OG iphone SE (2016). As far as consumer electronics go, apple is well ahead of the pack.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/02/the-best-feature-of-...
Presumably will still boot slowly and only the topmost UI layer loads differently, and until they confirm otherwise I’m guessing that even with a simplified UI it still includes all the creepy tracking of everything you watch.
https://www.consumerreports.org/privacy/how-to-turn-off-smar...
Android TV might not build it in, but much like android phones, you get extra “features” from pretty much every OEM.
Evidence is a high bar. But I can tell you my f...ing smart tv asks me on behalf of tv stations to accept cookies when I switch to some german tv stations. Yes, I'd say they are tracking what I am watching. That is with TV over satellite in Germany.
Sharp offers (most of) their range as dumb TVs[1]. They still take a few seconds to turn on, but not notably longer than a typical computer monitor.
1. https://sg.sharp/products/tv?filters%5B33%3A36%5D=33%3A36
https://www.wsj.com/articles/sharp-to-americans-you-dont-wan...
At any rate, according to Google it seems to be over[1] and Sharp took back control in 2019.
1. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-sharp-hisense-idUSKCN1SE1...
Hopefully that means there are better options this year?
I love that a sibling comment to yours calls out the remote as dealbreaker terrible, but I agree with the sentiment that I would love a remote that was really well-designed.
- it’s impossible/difficult to do with current tech (not true)
- the classic Apple forum response of “why would you want to do that?”
This turned into a bit of a rant but I’ll conclude the thought by saying that there’s certainly some sort of happy medium between a gajillion buttons on the remote and lack of absolutely critical functionality. In fact if you invest a bit of extra money into the Sideclick add-on to Apple TV remote you achieve exactly that.
Who would’ve thought it’s necessary to be able to grab the remote when it’s dark and know what orientation it is in.
People on HN complain about this a lot, but I’ve used it for years and had parents use it without issue. I think it’s a made up problem.
The other buttons I’d have on it would be power, and input switch.
I’d have an Apple HomePod sound bar which connects to the tv so you don’t have to configure any of that.
Then you’d use the Apple TV remote like normal for everything else. The regular dial remote is just always sitting on the coffee table.
Alternatively they could extend the existing Apple TV remote a bit to add a mute and volume knob or reconfigure to be the one remote for the dumb tv and the Apple TV.
While this option is certainly not available to all, it is the only thing that will really fit your needs. I completely gave up on finding anything decent in that market.
What usability / long-term reliability perk does your own software running on a RPI have over an Apple TV plugged into a dumb TV / monitor?
My own solution has the pros:
- I control precisely what I need and what not, both in terms of features and in terms of usability
- I control when it gets changed/updated
- I control which data flows in and out of the system
- Your device is not a brick when the manufacturer decides to end the support or shuts down the wrong server
The obvious downside is that it means work and requires a certain set of skills. Whether it is worth it or not depends on how important that thing is for you and how much all the TVs suck at doing what you want in the way you want it done.
I would say not "hn user" level folks, more like "i have a gaming pc".
Everyone's idea of 'simple' is rather asinine, unimaginative.
The latest Pis come practically preinstalled with everything, just have to load Kodi.
But someone who has found 'their' solution i.e. some crap by Apple e.g. assumes this is how everything should be... And we all get stuck with crappy 'smart' TVs (or don't own one - I have survived 10+ years without a TV - absolutely nothing about TVs today makes me want one. So much hot garbage)
[0]: https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/build-the-ultimate-4k-home-...
But that would be a TV which you can't use to watch adult content. And Netflix and HBO would be 30% more expensive.
Heck, the stand for the mac pro monitor is $999.
Look at the price of Mac mini.
I'd prefer the remote as an app on my phone. My desk is covered with remotes. Remotes are so 1980s :-/
Die apps, die. I want dedicated remotes for lights, stereo, curtains, garage door, and TV.
Apps won’t be around – forget 20 years, 5 years if you’re lucky. A company can disappear along with its stupid fucking app.
About the only advantage an app has is a keyboard.
We heard you like remotes, so how about a remote with dedicated, non-reprogrammable buttons to open apps you never use that don't even exist anymore?
Sincerely, Roku
^
< OK! >
vAbsolutely true, which makes a good argument also for going back to websites and pages (HTML5 helps a lot) instead of the apps business model that basically brought us back to the pre-www era. Also regarding the phone (mis)use as remote, why nobody mentions latency? Every smartphone I tried had an absolutely atrocious UI latency even compared to my 30 years old Amiga 500, why should I want to use it instead of a dedicated device that does the job immediately and I can substitute with 5€, and sometimes even repair?
They can also disappear and when you lose your remote, too bad. (That's why remotes go for $$ on ebay.)
I've been meaning to hack an old phone to be an instant-on remote with some custom software, but there are always dozens of higher priority projects. If anyone wants to hire/partner with me to build such a thing though...
Me OK Google mute
Me> OK...Google....mute
Me> OKGOOGLE mute
G> Sorry, I don't understand
Me> mute...
Me> MUTE MUTE MUTE MUTE MUTE
Me> OKGOOGLE MUTE
G> What would you like to mute?
Me> The TV
Me> Mute the fucking TV Google
Me> OKGOOGLE MUTE THE FUCKING TV
G> Sorry, I don't understand
Me> Fuck it. I should have just looked for the controller to begin with.
I end up with some vulgarities and ask my children to do it the old fashioned way (that is to tap the name on their phones, not to use smoke signals)
And we usually end up insulting Alexa as well.
C: bla bla bla, if you want to speak to a representative say "representative".
Me: representative
C: sorry i couldn't understand, please chose an option or say representative to speak with one
Me: re-pre-sen-ta-tive
C: (same answer as before)
Me: REPRESENTATIVE
C: (same answer as before)
Me: GO FUCK YOURSELF
C: Ok, I'll call a representative
I want to believe that their system either sensed the tension in my voice or saw the expletive and decided to call for adult supervision.
I'm not an native English speaker so I have an accent (which isn't too heavy, but still). Using any form of speech recognition is an instant fuck-show.
Using any form of technology? Without dropping one side or the other into an irreparable state that requires power cycling one or both ends at least once and then hoping for the best?
It’d be cool if it worked, by my expectation is that it’ll be implemented by the guy in charge of that YouTube “cast” app that has only theoretically worked one time in a lab in Palo Alto.
What we need might actually be a single remote for everything.
Re: a single remote for everything, the term for that is "universal remote", and not once have I been satisfied with one due to the difficulty and fragility of programming it. Maybe in this day and age we can finally make that programming dead simple and robust; Logitech came close with its universal remote from years ago, but even that still wasn't quite easy enough to setup and use to fully replace all my remotes. That HDMI-CEC or whatever it's called also comes close, but it's restricted to HDMI, obviously leaving non-HDMI devices in the dust.
Make it OLED, dumb TV, instant on, Apple TV box plugs in. Separate box with front facing ports that connects to screen with one cable. A remote designed by someone who thought about it for ten seconds (why do modern TVs have dozens of buttons no one ever uses?).
This entire market is in desperate need of someone to make something decent.
The best available option today is LG and it’s still laden with ads and takes a few seconds to boot up.