News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ksec on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:43AM (#26291193)
As much as I want this to happen. And I have been advocating for it [1] for many years. The more I read into the whole TV, display panel and electronic industry the grimmer it is for such Apple TV set to exist.

An Apple branded TV, even if it is without the TV part or just a monitor would have to be at least 2-3x the price of today's similar TV sets. And if anything OP were only willing to paid an extra $100 is probably why Apple didn't make one.

Some of the TV in the industry isn't just on Low Margin. They are entering negative margin territory if you are discounting Data Selling and software / partner sponsorship.

Unless the cost electronic part continue to raise to the point where Apple has an advantage with their SoC.

I think one of their original purpose or intention for ProXDR was the use the Dual Layer LCD technology to create something like a true Reference Display Monitor. But the technology and cost never got to that point. At least I hope they could continue their investment in that area even if they do not intend it to be in consumer usage.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10710734

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by TylerE on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:28AM (#26291398)
The thing is, Apple could charge 2-3x, because the prices have gotten so cheap.

People would absolutely pay $1000-1200 for a 55" Apple TV with nice software, and maybe a nice brushed aluminum frame that looks nice on the wall.

(For comparison, the cheapest 55" I could quickly find from a major retail is around $300, with a "name brand" starting around $400).

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by adtac on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:52AM (#26292089)
The $300 TV that you found probably has poor audio, viewing angle, contrast ratio, support, etc. From the limited research I did before buying my TV, a 55" TV with good reviews for panel and sound quality that you can rely on for 5-10 years costs C$1,200 today.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ghaff on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:52AM (#26293409)
Good sound probably requires a sound bar. I'm not sure the physics of flat panel TVs allows for great sound quality. Getting a sound bar went from me mostly using my wall mounted TV as a digital picture frame (which was my primary thinking when I bought it) to actually being the TV I use for streaming most of the time.

5-10 years? I know I'm not on the latest technology step. But 4K isn't worth me upgrading perfectly functional TVs. Maybe if we get to reasonably priced OLED panels but I'm not in a big hurry to upgrade TVs that are working.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by Fezzik on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:31PM (#26299422)
You can get a 55” TCL QLED 4K TV for around $500 - Amazon currently has them for $534, I paid $460 a few months back. All the specs are amazing, as is the software - minimal, intuitive, and effective. And the sound is actually rather impressive out of the box, but if you want any low frequencies you need bigger external speakers that cannot physically fit in a flatscreen TV.

I actually took home quite a few (3-4) more expensive TVs from Costco before buying the TCL, and it was far and away the best set while also being 1/2 to 1/3 the price.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by mayankkaizen on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:55PM (#26318138)
I'd say 1500 dollar TV is a viable purchase given that a TV has a life of 15+ years as against to 1000 dollar iphone or any other mobile which actually has a life of may be 4-5 years.

It would be the best of Apple product to show off.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by 411111111111111 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:42AM (#26291476)
they were talking about OLEDs, so 3000-5000 would be a more realistic estimate with that markup.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by fossuser on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:29AM (#26294017)
Agreed - Apple could easily charge 3-5k. The LG TVs I mentioned cost that much.

They could offer three sizes. Mini, Normal, Max.

They could use it as a jumping off point to own the “living room” if they wanted.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ksec on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:07PM (#26294801)
All OLED TV, including non LG OLED currently ships about 5M unit per year. The volume of those high price range OLED are tiny in total shipping volume.

And if that specific LG model charges 3 to 5K, Apple will have to sell it at 6 to 10K.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by fossuser on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:07PM (#26295452)
I don’t think so - Apple has a better supply chain, more committed users, more scale, etc.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ksec on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:11PM (#26295501)
There is only one OLED TV display panel maker. That is LG.

Edit: I think I need to spell things out a little more clearly. If Apple were to use OLED and aim at a top tier market, then it would be competing directly with LG TV, which also happens to be gaining momentum in terms of both OLED display panel ( LG Display ) and TV set ( LG Electronics ). LG Display will also need to built new Fab for Apple. The recent expansion at Guangzhou doubling their capacity, AFAIK has already been booked and has no relation to Apple. i.e LG has little interest to do it with Apple given they are already fully booked on capacity. And Apple doesn't seems to be interested in pushing LG to partner.

The answer to if Apple could do something will always going to be yes given they have hundreds of billions of cash and has little idea what to do with it other than buying back stocks.

The answer to if Apple will do it is always going to complex. And nothing in the supply chain and BOM cost analysis suggest it is a good strategy worth going for.

I do wish Apple prove wrong though.

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by onion2k on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:03AM (#26291559)
Why would it be 2 or 3 times more? Apple phones are between 10 and 15 times the price of the cheapest Android alternatives (iPhone 12 $999 from Apple, Samsung Galaxy A01 $55 from Amazon). Apple could, and probably would, sell a $4000 television.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by dijit on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:06AM (#26291576)
Which puts it in spitting distance of some of the highest end Samsung TVs (or short throw projectors) anyway.

(Samsung LSP7 is $3,500)

Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ksec on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:42AM (#26291719)
2x to 3x at a comparable model on Hardware level.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:45PM (#26297390)
What? Just no, that's like how a Vespa moped an alternative to a Porsche car?
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by cm2187 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:51AM (#26291520)
...and that would only play Apple content.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by leadingthenet on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:41AM (#26292035)
The Apple TV plays content from other providers just fine.
Re:In Defense of Dumb TVs by iso1210 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#26294191)
I've got a 3rd generation apple TV, which is EOL and apps are being slowly discontinued (no disney, youtube is going soon)

However I can still watch Disney on it using airplay from my OG iphone SE (2016). As far as consumer electronics go, apple is well ahead of the pack.