News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by terramex on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:28PM (#26209102)
Almost identical incident happened 3 years ago - the same type (B777-200), the same engine (PW4077), the same operator (United Airlines), the same side (right engine), the same failure (unconfined engine failure).

https://avherald.com/h?article=4b4e8ca7&opt=0

I would not be surprised if the whole fleet of this type/engine gets grounded for some time.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by nradov on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:16PM (#26209481)
Korean Air had an incident in 2016 where a PW4000 on a Boeing 777 disintegrated during takeoff.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Air_Flight_2708?wprov=s...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by pdonis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:22PM (#26215731)
From the report on the previous incident (Feb 2018), it looks like NTSB determined that the root cause was a cracked fan blade in the engine that should have been spotted on a previous inspection but wasn't. That doesn't just implicate this type/engine; it implicates the inspection procedures in general.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by hazeii on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:32PM (#26209146)
I thought it was 'confined' if the containment ring did its job? If it had failed (like not supposed to) it would have been a whole lot worse.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by colechristensen on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:24AM (#26211050)
The plane landed and didn’t blast enormous holes with ejected compressor blades. That’s a successful failure.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by hazeii on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:31AM (#26213009)
Plenty of youtube videos of a blade-off test - here's a short one [0] of an A380 Rolls Royce engine testing. That's about £9,000,000 of engine being destroyed in this (successful) test.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-8_Gnbp2JA

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by dtgriscom on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:25AM (#26213630)
At the beginning of the video the blades seem to be spinning at about 2RPS, but after the explosion they're spinning much faster. I presume the former was an artifact of the camera's frame rate.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by hazeii on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:12PM (#26215648)
They normally have high-speed cameras running; that short video is a mish-mash of super-slow-mo and regular speed footage. There are much longer versions on YT, e.g. this one [0] which covers it in more detail (watch the people in the room jump when it blows - despite being a fair distance away).

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j973645y5AA

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by underseacables on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:55AM (#26211179)
Is that what happenes when The fan blades fly off and hit the airplane?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by colechristensen on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:41AM (#26211904)
Pieces on the inside of jet engines are spinning between 2,000 and 12,000 rpm. They should all be properly contained in an airliner, but before that was the case of one fan blade broke and hit the plane it could look like a bomb blew an enormous hole in the side of the plane. These small pieces have a huge kinetic energy because they’re spinning so fast.

Nothing bad happening, everyone uninjured and a plane making an orderly airport emergency landing is many layers of safety systems all working properly.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by dredmorbius on Monday February 22, 2021 @07:16AM (#26223627)
Hull penetration at altitude can lead to explosive decompression, and, depending on the specifics of the penetration, complete hull loss.

Airplanes are big fragile inflated sausages, and it takes relatively little by way of explosive to down one. An early model (the de Havilland Comet, operated by BOAC and South African Airways in the 1950s) was downed due to a design flaw leading to metal fatigue around the windows, with three aircraft lost in 12 months due to in-flight break-ups, 99 souls lost.

Even at lower altitudes, an uncontained fan or turbine failure can be rough on the cargo or passengers, either from direct shrapnel, decompression, or (partial or full) egress.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-43803340

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by hazeii on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:16AM (#26211783)
As ever, more detail and clear explanations on pprune[0].

As one commenter put it, to an ER doctor this is a shallow wound with lots of blood.

[0] https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/638797-united-b777-uncon...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by lm28469 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:53AM (#26212801)
Most of the "skin" of a plane is only a few mm thick [0] it doesn't take much to puncture, I mean, it does, but thin turbine blades made to resist birds impact at 10k rpm would cut through it like butter.

[0] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/45566/how-thick...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by kyshoc on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:48AM (#26211413)
That’s almost exactly what happened on Southwest 1380[0] a few years ago.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by benhurmarcel on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:00AM (#26213462)
To add to the topic, aircraft structure and systems are made to withstand the projection of those debris hitting with "infitite" energy. That means for every trajectory possible, it's considered that a part flies through everything in its path. The aircraft still has to land.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by o-__-o on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:18PM (#26215226)
The wing is an exceptionally strong component of the aircraft. It’s usually the freak accidents where you hear of a fuel tank being ruptured or control or hydraulic lines being cut. In all of these accidents I bet there is wing damage but the plane is able to continue as usual

WW2 fighter planes anyone?

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by touisteur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:26AM (#26212102)
Ugh look up QF-72 for an A380 Rolls-Royce engine containment failure...
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by mcdevilkiller on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:00AM (#26212236)
Are you sure? That was an A330, and a failure on one ADIRU.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by touisteur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:32AM (#26213013)
Aaaaaah always mixing this and QF-32 :-( sorry. The book by Richard de Crespigny is a must read if you can find it. Great.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by martyvis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:45AM (#26212445)
QF-32. (BTW the pilot Richard Champion de Crespigny wrote a fantastic book on the incident. The intensity of going though procedures on an iPad and manuals as alarms were going off, while remembering to just fly the plane, was the thing that most sticks in my mind.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by touisteur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:39AM (#26213047)
Sorry, right, always mixing up those two. Best lessons from the book for me are:

1- meet the designers, understand the "why"s and not only the descriptive posthoc documentation

2- when you don't trust your instruments, keep following the procedures, checklists, (for this you need an excellent, trained, cold-headed team), and eventually try to reconstruct 'what aircraft you have'

3- trust the automated checklists but not too much! Crosscheck what's asked of you, with what you know of the aircraft. Since you know the 'why's you know the automated checklist system's designers probably never expected an aircraft with that much damage to keep flying...

4- there are no hall-passes for heroes. At the end De Crespigny fails his evaluation (the flight was an evaluation flight, with an instructor on board).

All around a great, great book for systems people.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by implements on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:29AM (#26211835)
That’s my understanding - “confined” meaning nothing flying tangentially away from the engine and hitting the fuselage or wing.

Saying that, resultant vibration causing the inlet and nacelle cowling to separate isn’t supposed to happen either - because of the serious risk to the tail.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by djmips on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:49AM (#26212468)
2020: (JAL 777 same engine) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-_IAKCBTxc&t=10s

2018: United 777 same PW engine (seems very similar but without fire) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-_IAKCBTxc&t=10s

2016: KAL 777 same PW engines (aborted takeoff after engine failure) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bHrW_34kAk

All planes had zero casualties.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by frogpelt on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:19AM (#26214045)
You posted the same link twice.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by tim333 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:05AM (#26214446)
I guess the 2020 JAL one could be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k2ZJjYQj2bY

There's some good video off the current one on the BBC site https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-56141673

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by Kye on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:01AM (#26213158)
If I were an airline's insurer, I wouldn't want to gamble on the good luck lasting.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:55AM (#26213855)
Not luck. Design. These failures are anticipated. That they can be handled so well is testimony to the energy and regulation put into engine safety over decades. Whereas once such failures could down an airline, killing all on board, they can now be handled safely.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by pdonis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:25PM (#26215753)
> These failures are anticipated

Sort of. The possibility of some types of failure is anticipated in the design of other parts of the engine. But there are also inspection procedures in place to ensure that engine parts that might fail are replaced before they fail. A report on a previous incident in Feb 2018 (referred to upthread) says that the root cause was a cracked engine fan blade that should have been detected on a previous inspection but wasn't. Failures that are supposed to be prevented by inspection and replacement of parts are not necessarily also allowed for in other parts of the design. So it's quite possible that luck is involved here as well and that a future failure of this type could have much worse consequences.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:29PM (#26216856)
fan blade failures are expected. Engines are designed to contain failed blades. There is a huge test that is done whereby a blade is "failed" at full throttle. Engine dies but damage is to be contained.

https://youtu.be/j973645y5AA

(A380 "blade off" test, rare footage of giant engine failing)

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by pdonis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:44PM (#26220206)
> fan blade failures are expected.

No, they're not. Fan blade cracks are expected; and fan blades are inspected for cracks so that the blades can be replaced before they fail.

Yes, it's also true that, as a second line of defense, engine housings are designed to contain failed blades. But the overall risk of the system is calculated on the assumption that that is a second line of defense, not the only line of defense. In other words, it's calculated on the assumption that a fan blade failure in flight will not be due to a crack that could have been detected at the last inspection but wasn't. It's calculated on the assumption that a fan blade failure in flight will be due to some other root cause that nobody has ever seen before. In other words, we have second lines of defense because we don't presume that we know about all possible root causes for a given failure. We don't expect fan blades to fail, but just in case one does due to some root cause we didn't know about, we design an extra layer of protection.

But what happened here is that an inspection regime designed to catch a root cause we do know about, failed to catch it. That's not within the design parameters of the system.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Monday February 22, 2021 @08:12AM (#26224099)
The requirement came after several blades left their engines, severing vital systems on a couple flights. So the requirement is that new engines be able to contain blade failures regardless of the cause. Inspections can save a blade failure from happening, but they cannot be relied upon to prevent failures, necessitating the reliance on containment of eventual non-prevented failures.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by pdonis on Monday February 22, 2021 @11:26AM (#26226330)
> Inspections can save a blade failure from happening, but they cannot be relied upon to prevent failures

You still are not addressing my point.

Of course inspections cannot be relied upon to prevent failures due to root causes that are not known prior to the incident.

But inspections are relied upon to prevent failures due to root causes that are known. And that's what failed to happen in this case.

Put it this way: by your argument, the NTSB's final report on this should be something along the lines of "this was an expected failure and the containment worked, so no corrective action needs to be taken". Do you really think that's what will happen?

Whereas by my argument, the NTSB's final report on this will be something along the lines of "the inspection process failed to properly catch a cracked fan blade, and corrective actions A, B, and C need to be taken to fix the process".

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by netsharc on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:31PM (#26218454)
4:37 for the content and to skip all the typical over-dramatization of these kinds of documentaries...
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by BrianOnHN on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:08AM (#26213963)
How do you safely handle the debris falling to the ground?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:12AM (#26214001)
You dont. A few pounds of engine parts is infinitely better than the previous option, many tons of airliner falling on a house.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by wavefunction on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:20AM (#26214060)
@sandworm How about a third option where neither the plane nor the debris falls?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:02AM (#26214419)
The risk of falling debris actually killing someone pales in comparison to the risks of it perhaps doing more damage onboard the aircraft. A loose part near/inside an engine is no longer doing its job and could cause more damage where it is. And the ground is a big place. Drop a random pin in google maps. Then zoom in to see if it is actually on someone's head. This is lottery odds territory.

Objects drop from aircraft all the time, daily. It isn't generally newsworthy unless part of a larger story. And even then, only if the object is found and recognized as being from an aircraft. Small rocks also fall daily from space, probably more by weight than aircraft-related objects, yet virtually nobody ever gets hit by space rocks.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:22AM (#26214625)
To add to that, 100 tons of spacerocks hit eath every day. I dont think 100 tons of parts fall of airliners daily.

That being said, there was a russian spacecraft that disintegrated and hit someone house, in the middle of siberia bo less. So it does happen, but its freak ecen3ts territory.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:36AM (#26214784)
Oh, if you are going to include manmade space-related objects there have been many deaths. Dig into how many Chinese rocket stages have landed on villages. If we include such things as "aviation" I would retract my above statements re debris. Rockets do sometimes fall on people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelsat_708

https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/11/china-keeps-dropping...

"It has happened many times before, including most infamously in 1996 when a Long March 3B rocket veered off course shortly after a launch and crashed into a village. Chinese officials reported six dead from the accident, although Western sources have speculated that hundreds of Chinese citizens may have died in the accident."

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by o-__-o on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:14PM (#26215201)
Why compare two sovereign nations with vastly different safety regulations?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:15PM (#26216728)
I didnt. I only said that rockets sometime crash on people and gave an example. Nobody is comparing countries in this thread. Aviation is about as international as any industry can be.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by airhead969 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:50AM (#26214929)
False equivalency. 100 T of diffuse material reaching Earth, likely burning up, isn't the same as or even remotely comparable to parts falling off aircraft due to man-made negligence. Jettisoning honeycomb cowling sections because a particular model of engine is relatively unreliable, through design, manufacturing, or maintenance, isn't an excuse for not fixing it or not using a better engine if it cannot be fixed economically.

Could you proofread and type correctly so we understand what you're saying? I can't read all of what you're saying.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by galangalalgol on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:37AM (#26214189)
I'm sure people PW is working on that, but the failure rates on commercial aircraft parts are already ridiculously low. Bad things will always happen.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by airhead969 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:04PM (#26215082)
"Bad things will always happen" is a despicable shrug mentality. Bad things happen when people don't have their acts together in design, engineering, manufacturing, maintenance, and operation. The failure rates should be striving for zero, unlike the stunts Boeing has pulled on 737NG, MAX, and the 787.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by galangalalgol on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:28PM (#26215299)
Totally agree with you on the recent laxness in design and the regulatory capture that allowed it. But treating zero as a feasible goal is unrealistic. I've done code inspections for safety of flight code and making sure you have 100% coverage and branch coverage not just in the high level code but in assembler still doesn't get everything. You try to make sure that redundancy saves you (seriously boeing!) But common mode errors and just human fallibility to see all the possibilities mean we miss stuff. And all this is so much easier in software than in mechanical designs where redundancy sometimes just isn't doable. We shouldn't give up best practices, but we shouldn't have unreasonable expectations of them either. And not every engineering failure implies a failure in engineering process.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by galangalalgol on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:43PM (#26215406)
I wanted to clarify my last statement. Even when best practices are followed bad stuff happens, and that doesn't necessarily mean best practices need to change.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by airhead969 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:08PM (#26215617)
Of course not. Make improvements rather than knowingly shove-in bad Ducommun parts on the line or crappy MCAS. Also, hold manufacturers responsible when they take cost-shortcuts, sacrifice safety, and kill people. Boeing routinely gets a slap for doing so since it's also considered a strategic defense contractor, part of the MIC that greases palms in DC.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by airhead969 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:00PM (#26215549)
I never said it was feasible, you did. It must be strived for, because that's the difference between excellence and crap.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by leesalminen on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:29PM (#26209119)
And I’m supposed to fly on a 777-200 to Denver operated by United in just a few days. Yay!
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by valuearb on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:49PM (#26209282)
The 777 has been flying for 25 years with almost no fatal accidents. Unless your flight will be flying over Russian anti-aircraft missile batteries or through a wormhole above Malaysia, you should be perfectly safe.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by codingdave on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:12PM (#26209460)
Another way of looking at it is that after flying and accumulating 25 years of wear and tear without major incident, we now have seen a repeatable flaw that these aircraft may encounter due to their age.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by throwawayboise on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:16PM (#26210749)
Aircraft undergo regular preventative maintenance checks, with letter codes A - D. The D check being the most comprehensive, it occurs every 6-10 years and basically the entire aircraft is taken apart and inspected, looking for among other things anything like stress fractures, corrosion, unusual wear, etc.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_maintenance_checks#D_...

A commercial aircraft does not just accumulate wear and tear for 25 years until something breaks. They can basically fly indefinitely, but in reality after two or three D checks they are usually retired because the cost of the D check is more than the value of the aircraft.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ghotli on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:25PM (#26210785)
Great context. I gained a lot of respect for aviation's use of checklists and procedures from the book 'The Checklist Manifesto'

In this case, something obviously went awry and it's both engineering, planning, and a miracle no one died or was crushed from debris from above. Regardless, comments like yours leave me feeling far more confident in this sort of thing.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by eru on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:05AM (#26211737)
> In this case, something obviously went awry and it's both engineering, planning, and a miracle no one died or was crushed from debris from above. [...]

Yes, though even something going wrong doesn't necessarily mean that we'd need to change any procedures.

Sensible procedures bring risks down to acceptable levels at an acceptable price. That level of risk is generally still more than 0%.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by touisteur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:31AM (#26212123)
Beware of the dangers of preventative maintenance, where sometimes while replacing or inspecting or re-mounting inspected parts, the maintenance crew breaks something that was OK and probably going to be working fine for years.

But yeah, a D check is so expensive I've heard there's a habit of dumping the aircraft on less observing flying companies some thousand miles before it comes up...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by Leherenn on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:17AM (#26212604)
A minor point, it's not based on miles, but cycles (takeoffs/landings) for structural parts or hours for engines.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by touisteur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:31AM (#26213003)
You're right, thanks for the correction.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by pdonis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:29PM (#26215789)
> Aircraft undergo regular preventative maintenance checks

And in a similar incident in February 2018 on a 777 (referred to upthread), one of those checks was found to have failed: the NTSB determined that the root cause was a cracked engine fan blade that should have been detected on a previous inspection (and that would have resulted in the blade being replaced), but wasn't. If this incident turns out to have a similar root cause, that means there are issues with the preventive inspection and maintenance process.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by dzhiurgis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:02AM (#26212249)
> basically the entire aircraft is taken apart

How is that safe unless you've got a production line doing it? Seems impossible to re-assemble it in the same way as it was done in factory...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by donarb on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:22PM (#26215732)
It's not taken totally apart, but it is stripped of the interior down to the bare metal, all wiring is checked/replaced as needed. All mechanical parts like the flaps and landing gear are removed and checked for wear. The skin is checked for cracks. This is done every 5 years for planes, taking about 5-6 weeks to complete.

Here's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLil1MZmchI

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ajarmst on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:45PM (#26209687)
As well as two demonstrations that the aircraft meets the design specification that even a catastrophic failure in the worst stage of flight is easily recoverable. I'd expect an increased inspection rate, possibly some new mandated ND testing for fractures and discontinuities (the last one was an LP shaft failure, IIRC).

One thing that does bug me, though is that we now have two events where the shroud was lost. Were these uncontained failures (problematic because of potential for wing damage) or contained faiLures followed by aerodynamic shedding of the damaged shroud (system functioning as designed). I'm also somewhat concerned about the fire remaining in the burner stage. Might have just been lubricants, but I'd want to make sure the fire handle had been pulled and investigate whether it worked correctly.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by dognotdog on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:12PM (#26210729)
It looks it’s the “cowling” that was lost, not the protective shroud / containment around the fan (and the rest of the engine) that keeps the fan/compressor/turbine blades from becoming high speed radial projectiles when they break off at full speed.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ajarmst on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:02PM (#26215561)
Agreed. The last one was pretty clearly a failure of a shaft or turbine, and the damage was much more obvious. This might be something completely different.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by interestica on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:14PM (#26210223)
> As well as two demonstrations that the aircraft meets the design specification that even a catastrophic failure in the worst stage of flight is easily recoverable.

But in that type of failure, you can't control where the pieces go.

https://abc7ny.com/philadelphia-emergency-landing-southwest-...

It resulted in depressurization and partial ejection/death.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by kortilla on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:21PM (#26210768)
That’s a different type of failure. Uncontained vs contained.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by interestica on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:19AM (#26211022)
Kinda. While the 2018 incident was "contained", it still resulted in damage to the fuselage.

"Two small punctures were found in the right side fuselage just below the window belt with material transfer consistent with impact from pieces of an engine fan blade"

(From the link in parent to this thread https://avherald.com/h?article=4b4e8ca7&opt=0)

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ajarmst on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:53PM (#26215478)
Not 'kinda'. Debris exiting the engine housing with sufficient energy and in a direction that leads to damage of other systems is the literal definition of an unconfined engine failure (i.e. it can spit as many parts as it wants to out the exhaust). There is a band of armour around the plane of the fans that should prevent any blades leaving the engine perpendicularly. If there was fuselage or wing damage from debris, that was an unconfined failure and would require investigation as a major fault.

However, loss of the shroud doesn't necessarily imply there was a confinement failure. Damage to the shroud during the event can easily lead to the cowling shedding aerodynamically, which is also part of the design: the last thing you need is more drag on the dead engine side. We can't tell which that was in this case, but it's important that we do---the design criteria specifying that the aircraft can be safely recovered from a catastrophic single engine failure during any stage of flight would assume the failure is confined to the engine.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ashtonkem on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:48PM (#26209704)
Engine age isn’t the same as airframe age, and components don’t age linearly with calendar time; they age with flight hours or pressurization cycles. Without access to a log book, it’s impossible to know how old an engine is or when it was last overhauled.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ralph84 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:25PM (#26210276)
Indeed, for a 25-year-old airframe with the utilization it would have at a major carrier like United there's basically no way the engines hanging on it now could be the same engines it was delivered with.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by bluGill on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:21PM (#26210255)
That isn't completely true. We don't know exactly, but the documented time between overhaul and the life of the airframe place upper bounds on those.

Some cheap airlines might ignore those rules, but none in the US. (Only the poorest, most corrup, countires in the world will ignore those limits)

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by ekianjo on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:57AM (#26211185)
> these aircraft may encounter due to their age

Unlike some codebases, aircrafts actually have mandated maintenance. Which is why most accidents are due to human error and not massive technical failures.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by eru on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:09AM (#26211754)
And often pretty silly and stupid human errors.

(That's a feature, not a bug! The pervasive checklists and general professionalism mean that most 'normal' human errors are recovered from without enough consequences to make it into the news.

So only the really unlucky and incompetent are what we usually hear about.)

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by hazeii on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:20PM (#26215714)
Engines are separate from the airframe; on big commercial aircraft the engines get swapped/moved around all the time (the engines may well be on lease, separate to the lease on the airframe). Thus, in this sort of situation it's the engine's history that'll be important, rather than the airframes.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by danaliv on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:46AM (#26211676)
Until the NTSB investigates, there's no way to know whether age has anything to do with it. It might. It might not. There could be a common cause, or there isn't.

We don't know yet.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by sandworm101 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:43AM (#26214874)
>> a repeatable flaw that these aircraft may encounter due to their age.

There are hundreds of flaws. Aircraft are not perfect. Any large airframe sees lots of little things break every year. That's what inspections and maintenance are for. But the system is designed so that such things never add up into something really bad. Be worried about the aircraft without flaws. To me, that means it either never gets used or isn't being inspected properly.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by StopHammoTime on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:22AM (#26211305)
Or also if your pilots have just finished their type rating and used to fly A320s. Hopefully they remember that you actually need to manage your throttle on a Boeing!
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by nirguzam on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:45AM (#26211397)
Are you suggesting that there's a germane difference between the fly-by-wire FADECs on these two aircraft types?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by jey on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:33AM (#26211348)
Which incident are you referencing here?
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by leetrout on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:08PM (#26209424)
And you have nothing to worry about. Statistically you really have nothing to worry about given this incident happening today.

Enjoy your flight and enjoy Denver. Get a donut from Voodoo for me.

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by jfk13 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:38PM (#26209192)
At least it's unlikely to be that 777-200.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by viraptor on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:17PM (#26209490)
That specific plane will go through a lot of rebuilding, checks, thorough investigation, etc. Given a choice, I'd take that plane over another one.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by AdamJacobMuller on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:22AM (#26211040)
Yeah but not if they rush the rebuilding and complete it in a few days. I suspect that's gonna require too much duct tape and bubble gum.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by Reason077 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:29AM (#26211836)
Assuming there’s no damage to the airframe itself, it could be back in the air pretty quickly. Changing the engine is a fairly routine procedure, which takes about a day:

https://blog.virginatlantic.com/change-aircraft-engine/

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by oh_sigh on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:13PM (#26210734)
Look on the bright side - you're probably more likely to die from catching COVID-19 from another person on the flight.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by tekromancr on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:31AM (#26211079)
Not sure which is the worse way to go. 3-8 mins of flaming, falling terror; or weeks of facing potential death in a hospital
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by alamortsubite on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:58AM (#26215021)
If you're riding in an automobile to/from the airport, you have reasonable cause for concern.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by Aperocky on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:09PM (#26209433)
Well, wouldn't be surprised if the aircraft is literally this one, and you'll now fly on a different one.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by reddotX on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:49PM (#26209280)
good luck!
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by throw0101a on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:28PM (#26209962)
Animated recreation with ATC audio of that flight (UA1175):

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-_IAKCBTxc

Animated recreation with audio of this one (UA328):

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7-zh7Sebr8

* Via: https://forums.liveatc.net/atcaviation-audio-clips/ual-328-u...

Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by guidedlight on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:53PM (#26209312)
The failure was blamed on lack of training for inspectors.
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by acvny on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:47PM (#26215978)
Also, the same destination: Honolulu. And only 1 digit difference in registration number (N773UA in 2018 vs N772UA in 2021).
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by acvny on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:52PM (#26217610)
Must be a bad batch. Please return by post with batch number visible for a refund and let us know what you didn't like about the product
Re:United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet sepa... by thgaway17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:46AM (#26212176)
It was a bird strike.