News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by crazygringo on Saturday February 20, 2021 @10:07AM (#26204603)
I mean, bugs are most likely to be found in rarely used scenarios (like wiping) and also in the version of software that actually gets shipped with hardware, because it's got a non-negotiable tight release deadline. (Which is why many devices force an OS update from the internet before you can even use it for the first time.)

Of all the places for a crazy bug like this to be found, this seems like one of the least bonkers. :) And the excellent thing about Apple is that if you did brick it, Apple would just exchange it for you for free since it's their own defect.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by _underfl0w_ on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:05AM (#26205119)
I bought a non-M1 Macbook a decade ago and there were absolutely zero issues wiping it from stock. That was one of the first things I did, and everything performed as expected each time. How did things progress so far backwards in stability?
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by shawnz on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:24AM (#26205302)
> I bought a non-M1 Macbook a decade ago and there were absolutely zero issues ... How did things progress so far backwards in stability?

We are talking about a system which just underwent a huge architectural change as well as a new major release of the operating system. I think it is unreasonable to expect the same level of stability as a decades-old architecture only a couple months after release.

You can see in this case the issue is apparently already patched. It seems only with the very first software to have ever shipped on the device would you experience a bug such as this.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by titzer on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:42AM (#26205469)
On the contrary, given the huge risks being taken here, you would think that the recovery/reimage solution would be the thing that they would test the most!
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by xxpor on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:24PM (#26206462)
On the other hand, downloading 3 gb to wipe doesn't really sound that bad concidering the way to do that used to be to download the entire OS and format the disk
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by titzer on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:40PM (#26207110)
Why would you download anything? It seems possible to have a DVD/BluRay or USB disk with the golden copy on it, or the OS itself should be able to restore itself to factory settings.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by TameAntelope on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:49PM (#26207189)
There was a bug. It was designed and now does work, presumably forever, as you’ve described.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by xxpor on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:44PM (#26210049)
You had to have created that DVD at some point. Either you downloaded it or bought it.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by gogopuppygogo on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:13PM (#26205816)
Apple leaks talked about how they maintained a “Marklar” x86/x64 release branch for MacOS for years leading up to the official launch. I was hearing about them during the G4 desktop era.

The M1 benefits from its relation to the silicon in iPhone and iOS being based on MacOS but there are major differences. It’s a revolutionary mobile computing platform. So far the biggest problems have been a few software glitches that can quickly be patched over the internet. This is a trivial set of issues to trade for the power / performance gains.

I’m looking forward to the newer 16” models coming out. I still need Windows on my computer for my workflows though so if the virtualization isn’t even beta quality I’ll need to be an Intel holdout for a while longer.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by alsetmusic on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:00PM (#26210679)
> I still need Windows on my computer for my workflows though so if the virtualization isn’t even beta quality I’ll need to be an Intel holdout for a while longer.

I’m running the beta of Parallels on M1. Windows works fine, though Parallels itself is still a work in progress. The issue is only licensing with MS, who currently don’t license Win for ARM independently. Then it’s just a question of whether you’re willing to enter a licensing grey area, similar to when you want to pay for content but it isn’t available in a legal format (thus, a person turns to a torrent). This is not an endorsement, just an observation.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by shawnz on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:03PM (#26215067)
There are some issues, like ARM32 Windows store apps not working.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by Kwpolska on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:16PM (#26208994)
Apple mentioned the secret x86 build of OS X during the keynote when they announced that transition [1], I think they alluded to it in one of last year’s keynotes too. That said, you would expect them to have booting, installation, and wiping as one of the first things built in the macOS-on-ARM porting process.

[1]: https://youtu.be/ghdTqnYnFyg?t=265

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by jhoechtl on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:55PM (#26208342)
Why not AMD? Value for money seems to be good and I mean better value for less money...
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by mathgeek on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:55PM (#26208805)
Apple doesn’t make any models with AMD chipsets. They went from PowerPC to Intel and now their own chips.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by tshanmu on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:19PM (#26209019)
So, is it any cheaper given that I am effectivity beta testing hardware?
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by the_local_host on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:47PM (#26206674)
> How did things progress so far backwards in stability?

Because they just changed the foundation that the entire system is built on top of.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by spacedcowboy on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:27AM (#26205319)
Apple employees are human, deadlines are inflexible, revolutionary changes are risky.

It seems straightforward.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by sebasvisser on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:33PM (#26206021)
Humans set deadlines...
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by spacedcowboy on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:53PM (#26206205)
Ah, but once a deadline is set, it is very hard to un-set. Apple does not exist in a vacuum, it communicates its schedules to others and huge efforts are made by many people and companies to meet that deadline; it is not a trivial thing to change.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by titzer on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:43AM (#26205489)
It's a matter of priorities. Apparently recovery and reimaging scenarios are not considered priorities. Personally, I want those to be absolutely rock solid.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by spacedcowboy on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:31PM (#26205995)
That’s a conclusion that does not follow from your premises. I’m sure it was tested. A lot. But here’s the thing: when you ship anything of sufficient complexity where the quantities involved are measured in millions, there’s no such thing as a “small problem” or “edge case”.

Apple will test and fix bugs they find, as much as humanly possible, within the constraints of execution. You don’t just decide to launch on a whim, it’s baked in 3 years previously, with tens of thousands of people working towards that one goal; with supply ramps for multiple other companies arranged and enabled; with well-known public launch dates that can realistically only give you a few days wiggle room. The fact that they do this at all is a breathtaking success and a testament to the business - this applies to any such at-scale business, not just Apple.

So they’ve covered 99.9% of all boot issues before launch. As the CEO, do you go ahead ? Or do you miss the launch date, possibly invite legal action from your supply chain or worse, a critical manufacturer folds because of cash flow, and do you risk the reputation and stock price hit of a company as large as Apple “swinging and missing” in the press ?

I think it’s pretty clear what the correct choice is, and even though 0.1% of those millions of devices still adds up to a sizable number of complaints, you’re still way ahead of the game. And you get to keep that well-oiled machine moving forwards rather than stalling.

Apple has priorities. They may not be your priorities. If they differ sufficiently, you should go elsewhere, and if sufficient people agree with you and do the same, Apple will realign its priorities. I wouldn’t hold your breath though.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by titzer on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:41PM (#26207118)
So you're telling me they were never expecting someone to return a laptop and it needing to be wiped?
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by EricE on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:13PM (#26208037)
Obviously not. And it was corrected within two weeks with a software update long ago released.

Talk about making mountains out of molehills...

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by philjackson on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:01PM (#26206264)
> How did things progress so far backwards in stability?

Not a software engineer then?

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by grishka on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:08AM (#26212881)
I am a software engineer and I don't understand it either.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by BurningFrog on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:10PM (#26206348)
That's a lot extrapolation from one single bug.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by EricE on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:14PM (#26208052)
It was a problem with the initial release of macOS shipped on the machines and was fixed within a couple of weeks. It's LONG past old news.

Need I point out Best Buy was the start of this kerfuffle?

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by zxcvbn4038 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:25PM (#26209077)
Good point, why is Best Buy even open during a pandemic?
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by phs318u on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:44PM (#26207779)
> How did things progress so far backwards in stability?

Because they progressed so far forward in security. Design is an exercise in priorities and trade-offs. The ability to wipe your Mac is now second fiddle to the ability to secure your Mac.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by tw04 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:27PM (#26206490)
A decade ago your MacBook didn’t have drive level encryption with a soldered in place drive.

You were trading security for “stability”.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by imwillofficial on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:02PM (#26208391)
I think “flexibility” is a more apt word choice.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by salawat on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:01PM (#26206278)
I disagree. The most important part of a car is the brakes. Likewise, the most important part of a complex programmable device is the capability to slick and reinstall to restore a known good working state.

Shipping something that cannot uninstall/reinstall cleanly is shipping a not even half functional base device. Ubiquity of Internet access is not a crutch that can be counted on at all times. The fact that modern hardware vendors are starting to assume that is disturbing, and likely another symptom of companies slowly trying to acclimate users to not really "owning" what it is they bought.

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by lukeschlather on Saturday February 20, 2021 @10:55AM (#26205039)
It sounds like the M1 literally cannot be re-imaged from external media though, because the internal copy of the OS is so locked-down. Which fundamentally seems like a very Apple sort of disregard for providing tools for people to deal with failure modes. It also ensures the people actually solving the problem and the people who have the problem are never in the same room and never talk about what's going on.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by easton on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:12PM (#26205807)
It can[0], it's just that the partition holding 1TR and the second-stage bootloader (which is almost but not quite macOS) isn't overwritten. Just like how PCs that store UEFI variables on the SSD don't overwrite those when wiping the OS (as OS installers are now smart enough not to wipe those).

1: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211983 (specifically, "Or use a bootable installer")

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by floatboth on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:51PM (#26209729)
> PCs that store UEFI variables on the SSD

Which PCs do that? Where do they store, on the ESP?

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by easton on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:17PM (#26209892)
I was mistaken, they are stored in NVRAM and just mounted in Linux. (when I read the doc the first time I knew that I must be misunderstanding)
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by ThePowerOfFuet on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:01AM (#26205087)
This is incorrect; you can do so with another Mac and Apple Configurator, just like it was an iOS device.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by cbsmith on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:24PM (#26206455)
Again, a very Apple thing to do. ;-) You just need another device from their ecosystem.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by gumby on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:11PM (#26208021)
As opposed to "you need a special piece of hardware" it's "you need a readily available piece of hardware with the right affordances".

Doesn't sound particularly bad, especially when compared to the situation in other industries (e.g. cars and all the special proprietary OBD stuff they do).

Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by tbodt on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:24PM (#26209064)
idevicerestore will eventually support doing this from Linux.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by 1over137 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:13PM (#26205812)
These days a Mac basically is an iOS device.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by oneplane on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:01PM (#26206275)
I suppose the T1, T2 and Touch Bar are, and with the M1 those parts are integrated on the SoC. But the runtime OS is still macOS and like on x86 that is not very iOS. The best description would be 'both', as the embedded platform is added instead of displacing the existing 'computer' platform. On M1 it is closer, and much more integrated, but still very distinct.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by saagarjha on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:42PM (#26208681)
The boot and recovery process is very similar to that of iOS.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by oneplane on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:30PM (#26252801)
I don't think iOS has any similarity to booting an x86 CPU by faking an SPI Flash chip, compiling the IBB, ME and BUP code on-the-fly as needed and validating it externally before feeding it to the ROM inside the CPU for loading and microcode installation. But the T1, T2 itself is similar to iOS, as is the initial M1 boot stage.
Re:M1 Macs have another hidden boot mode by LocalH on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:01PM (#26217146)
>I mean, bugs are most likely to be found in rarely used scenarios (like wiping)

Some would posit that such scenarios should be some of the most important, because when you need to do such recovery, such scenarios can become immensely vital.