News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by tlb on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:14AM (#26046039)
It's interesting that, under the given assumptions, you can put such tight bounds on the frequency of origination of grabby aliens.

The assumption that seems most unlikely is that civilizations will simply stop expanding when they encounter another one. Even if most civilizations would stop, a single aggressive one would quickly dominate. Especially under the assumption that they can expand at a large fraction of the speed of light, a defender would have little ability to organize a defense before being overrun.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by throwaway316943 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:41AM (#26046420)
What does a war between two interstellar civilizations look like? If they can accelerate mass to a high fraction of the speed of light doesn’t that mean their first strike weapons are all planet killers? If we assume they still primarily use planets as the sites of their industrial and population centres then doesn’t that mean any systems within striking distance are immediately obliterated by large, dark, unstoppable projectiles travelling at 0.7c? Any point defence you can think of fails when you can easily throw millions of these at a planet. There’s no way to win that game for either side.

If we change our assumptions about whether they live on or even care about planets it becomes a very different story. Who knows if they even need the free energy that stars emit. Most of the interstellar medium is ionized so it may be that it’s much easier to just scoop up gas and dust with magnetic fields than it is to attempt to extract large quantities of matter from planets that are few and far between not to mention gravitationally bound.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by avereveard on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:21AM (#26046648)
while one can postulate that this level of civilization doesn't need planets as habitats, planets with biomass would likely be an important asset as they ease the supply logistics and act as a trampoline for further, faster expansion.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by CountSessine on Saturday February 06, 2021 @12:35PM (#26048178)
But once your civilization isn’t threatened with complete and sudden obliteration by planet killers, you’re no longer stuck in the prisoner’s dilemma and you’re not necessarily compelled to strike first. It’s a big difference.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by jessehattabaugh on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:16PM (#26048525)
You shouldn't assume that an intelligent civilization wouldn't find a weapon of mass destruction that's effective against a non-planet based civilization.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by CountSessine on Saturday February 06, 2021 @03:23PM (#26049611)
So the utility cost of the betrayal scenario goes from negative infinity to a question mark.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by PaulHoule on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:56AM (#26046890)
Outer solar systems bodies have water and other volatiles as major constituents. If you want raw material for human bodies, cattle, trees, plastics, that is where most of it is.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by throwaway316943 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @03:05PM (#26049450)
And so would interstellar bodies. I’m willing to bet that a large fraction of the mass of a developing solar system gets ejected during the early years of its formation. If you can freely roam among the stars you would probably find everything you need in interstellar space.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by avereveard on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:12PM (#26048498)
miller experiment shows that there's some convergence on certain molecules, it's safe to assume that while every specific biology will differ, the building blocks will look not that far apart, and transforming existing biomass into usable biomass is going to be more energy efficient than transforming raws into usable molecules.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by jimktrains2 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:48AM (#26047708)
You just described the cold war :) I don't have any larger point, but found it interesting.

What does a war between two nuclear-capable nations look like? If they can nuclear bombs, doesn’t that mean their first strike weapons are all nation killers? If we assume they still primarily use cities as the sites of their industrial and population centres then doesn’t that mean any city within striking distance are immediately obliterated by large, dark, unstoppable projectiles? Any point defence you can think of fails when you can easily throw thousands of these at a nation. There’s no way to win that game for either side.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by smichel17 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:58AM (#26046503)
Perhaps the winning move, like with today's nuclear weaponry, simply not to play.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by goatlover on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:22AM (#26046656)
Or to hide in the Dark Forest instead of announcing yourself to the cosmos.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by generalizations on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:05PM (#26048427)
This does seem to be the logical conclusion of a game theory analysis. Since planet killers can show up without any warning, the only solution is make it impossible to aim your unstoppable weapons, which means you have to be impossible to detect or locate.

So as you said, maybe the solution to the Fermi Paradox is that every surviving civilization is hiding in cloaked habitats within the vastness of intergalactic space.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by jerf on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:25PM (#26048604)
By the time you can launch a planet-killer, you are no longer tied to your own planet anymore. It requires marshaling an amount of energy far beyond what you could afford to do in a biosphere, and a biosphere is all a planet really has to offer. Two of these civilizations might certainly take a swing at each other's planets, but it wouldn't end the war by any means; at this point the planet may not even account for single-digit percentages of what is going on in the system.

I think if you look ahead at feasible technology, you get self-sustaining pure-space civilizations long before you get civilizations that can launch relativistic planet killers.

(The other problem with the "planet killer" hypothesis, as we've discussed in other HN conversations, is that there's no reason to wait until there's a civilization on the other end to launch one, given how fast they can pop up. As soon as you see life, you should launch one. But Earth has been broadcasting fairly conclusive proof that a civilization with just a bit more tech than we have now is alive ever since the Great Oxygen Catastrophe, yet nobody has killed Earth.)

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by bcgraham on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:35PM (#26048691)
When some civilization becomes apparent, wouldn’t game theorizing say there’s a free rider problem? Wait for someone else to poke their heads out to handle it, save us the trouble, and maybe learn how we rank in a battle royale?
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by CountSessine on Saturday February 06, 2021 @12:39PM (#26048216)
With nuclear weapons we had MAD - and even if the other side didn’t retaliate, the planet would be ruined by a nuclear war so no one could win.

This is more dangerous. If weapons are absolutely but selectively destructive - I can wipe your planet out quickly before you have time to respond and my planet is just fine - it incentivizes me to attack first and hunt down other potential threats and destroy them before you or they destroy me.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by throwaway316943 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @03:17PM (#26049559)
Yes but it also changes your choice of habitat lest someone do the same to you. Remember with clever aiming these weapons have limitless range so there is no such thing as a border conflict and someone could nuke all of your systems. My point is that this strongly discourages solar system based empires and favours mobile space based civilizations. My hunch is that our galaxy is filled with nomadic hard to detect habitats and that that is the natural progression. There’s probably only a brief period of time where technological civilizations remain bound to their original planet and solar system. That’s my answer to the Fermi paradox.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by CountSessine on Saturday February 06, 2021 @03:21PM (#26049600)
This is basically what I’m saying. With an alternative to unmovable planets, the Dark Forest scenario becomes a bit less likely because the betrayal scenario in the prisoner’s dilemma becomes a lot less extreme.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by est31 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:09PM (#26048472)
Why do you say "had"... MAD is still around. There might be less fear about it in the media, but the danger is still present. As defense technology matures, it might make nuclear war winnable for the side that controls a sufficient nuclear defense. Or it might not.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by zamfi on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:03AM (#26046530)
> Even if most civilizations would stop, a single aggressive one would quickly dominate.

Would this affect their model, though? If either of the two civilizations dominates, rather than both being obliterated through mutual destruction, you would expect to see the same thing: that volume of space time is now occupied by a civilization. I’m not sure it matters which one (to their model, of course it would presumably matter to the inhabitants) — and either would be visible and have the effect described in the paper.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by codeflo on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:30AM (#26046708)
That was my read as well, it doesn’t make a difference in terms of the total volume occupied by these “grabby” civs.

Also, one civilization dominating wouldn’t mean that the other one would magically disappear. As a simple assumption, I can imagine the stronger civ expanding into the territory of the weaker one relatively unhindered (in terms of expansion speed). But the weaker civ would still expand outwards as well. If it’s expansion speed isn’t slower, it would continue to grow in absolute size.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by MattRix on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:42AM (#26047237)
Yep, this was my understanding too. It doesn’t change the fact that the area in space and time is now occupied by grabby aliens. The model and diagrams could easily be modified to use some heuristic like allowing older civilizations to take over younger ones when they collide, but it wouldn’t really matter for the purposes of the argument.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by ta202102 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:52AM (#26046193)
The wording 'stop expanding' is confusing. Figure 1 makes it more clear: When two civilizations meet, expansion stops in this direction. In the free directions the civilizations still expand.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by sandworm101 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:53AM (#26046874)
As likely is that two grabby expanding civilizations make be so different that thier volumes intercept without conflict. If one only likes warm rocky planets, and the other doesnt bother with solar systems, they might not even see each other as they pass. The "grabbed" volumes would then overlap, mooting this model. Contact would then not be a function or time and speed rather a matter of curiosity and willingness to explore non-desireable parts of one's grabbed space.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by barry-cotter on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:17AM (#26047061)
> As likely is that two grabby expanding civilizations make be so different that thier volumes intercept without conflict.

Every volume contains only a certain amount of potential free energy that can be used before the end. That’s what you fight over. Dyson Spheres, fusion, antimatter, these are all details. Everybody wants negentropy and it’s a zero sum game.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by PaulHoule on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:45AM (#26046806)
How could they stop?

If a civilization is spread out in a 10000 light year area and encounters another in one place it seems impossible they could make a collective decision given the amount of communication that it would take.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by bryanrasmussen on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:01AM (#26046945)
If that's the case they wouldn't be able to collectively decide to keep expanding either, the decision would have to be made by the parts of the civilization that came in contact with the other civilization.

This implies a lot of things though - let us say we expand to Mars and manage to terraform it somehow - after a few hundred years though Mars has enough of a population that they end up needing new resources (obviously we need some story as to how they expand this quickly, I blame genetic engineering and Hoxar Matos the dictator-general of Mars who commands a billion test tube babies be born and raised by robots in the underground Martian nursery creches).

The model for grabby aliens is that Mars must find somewhere else to expand as they are part of the human civilization - but given human civilization it seems more like splitting the civilization and infighting to get more resources would be the most likely outcome.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by throwanem on Saturday February 06, 2021 @01:26PM (#26048619)
> It's interesting that, under the given assumptions, you can put such tight bounds on...

Is it, though? Grant me whatever assumptions I like and I can put tight bounds on anything - as long as it's unfalsifiable, at least.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by smoyer on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:47AM (#26046166)
Your assumption sounds like it favors Star Wars over Star Trek (TOS).
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by philip142au on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:25AM (#26046089)
There's going to be a lot of space wars
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by DaiPlusPlus on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:34AM (#26046117)
Indeed, a very inefficient use of limited resources and energy in the known universe. How irrational.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by nvet4 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:55AM (#26046204)
Calling war irrational is irrational.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by Geezus_42 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:19AM (#26046305)
War is irrational...
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by pc86 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:25AM (#26046338)
If you have limited resourced (no money), but you do have military power, you can invade a neighbor with resources. If a neighbor invades you, you defend yourself.

Neither of those positions is irrational, except maybe the first (maybe), but there's certainly scenarios where it would be your only choice.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by throwaway316943 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:44AM (#26046436)
It becomes irrational when you develop the capacity for mutually assured destruction.
Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by omginternets on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:53AM (#26046875)
MAD is grounded in game theory. It is designed to make the only winning move “don’t play”.

It’s hyper-rational.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by DaiPlusPlus on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:41PM (#26052158)
MAD happened because of a (real, or perceived, I’m unsure myself...) risk of the Soviet Union invading Western Europe - and NATO ended up calculating that maintaining a nuclear deterrence was more affordable and more feasible than resisting a Warsaw Pact invasion using conventional forces. This assumes any kind of Soviet expansionism must be an absolute evil because the position is logically equivalent to “death is a preferable alternative to communism” (to steal a phrase from a video game...) which is patently absurd: it’s rational to prefer reduced standards of living over death, but credible deterrence requires drawing and maintaining a hard-line, even if that line is arbitrarily placed.

...given all of that is due to the risk of aggression from the Soviets, and I believe NATO may have disarmed themselves unilaterally if they didn’t see the SU/WP as a military threat (regardless of ideological threats) - what was making the SU so concerned about NATO military threats? Did the SU still have expansionist designs... or did they actually believe NATO still wanted to liberate/claim Poland long after the 1960s?

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by omginternets on Sunday February 07, 2021 @12:31PM (#26056476)
I respectfully insist: you are mistaken.

MAD is a formal (i.e. mathematical) model. It is 100%, unequivocally rational. The problem is that this rational process leads to outcomes you and I dislike.

These "bad outcomes" are value judgements. That is, MAD's outocmes don't align with our values. Therefore, the problem with mad (on which we agree!) is based in something extra-rational: values.

Again: you and I agree there is a problem with MAD. Where you are wrong is that the problem is not "MAD is irrational". The problem is "MAD's logical conclusions run afoul of our values".

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by squeaky-clean on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:45AM (#26047256)
Mutually assured destruction on a planetary scale does come about rather early in a civilization's history (if we're assuming galactic, or beyond-galactic scales of civilization). But that doesn't really mean it is easy to come about on a galactic or universal scale. Is an enemy destroying a planet or solar system you control really such a big deal when you're battling to control a third of the universe? Even having an entire galaxy destroyed would be like an enemy destroying someone's living room on an earth-scale.

Of course, this is all just making guesses about technology way beyond our current comprehension. Maybe universe-destroying bombs come up rather early in technology on this scale. Who knows.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by dukeofdoom on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:15AM (#26046612)
I read somewhere there's been something like 3000 wars in recorded human history. Seems like a pretty frequent thing. Thru out human history, raiding weaker neighbouring villages for resources, or access to females would be pretty rational behaviour for your villages growth and continuing success of your close genetic relatives.

So much so that parts of Human Male's anatomy seems to be purposely driven for combat and survival. Things like larger muscles, thickness of skull, thickness of neck. Also, societies seem to come together and cooperate, hunker down, in war and conflict. Also seems to me to have some genetic component to that social behaviour.

Only about 50% of men have reproduced through out human history. Raiding a neighbouring village, killing the man, and taking the best women for wives would be a rational though unethical behaviour. Its exactly what the Vikings did.

In fact, there's a growing concern that large and growing percentage of men, currently unattractive to females (internet incels) will lead to radicalization and possibly conflict in the west. As those man try to better their odds of reproduction. Currently they are genetic rejects.

Re:A Simple Model of Grabby Aliens by protoman3000 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:25AM (#26046334)
I disagree. Countries and states exist.