You're still giving photos to someone else with a pinky swear they won't do share them further.
I think my biggest fear is that that this idea takes off, but some competitor makes a free offering by selling data and including ad targeting and most users don't know the difference.
Plus the market is enormous. Probably room for a handful of good sized competitors.
Google gives you a lot of things for "free". I trust someone who I pay $9/mo to if they promise to not share my photos. If they share my photos, they'll stop getting my $9/mo.
Legally, the host can include protections for your data including not reselling or sharing your data even in cases of acquisition. If it's in the contract with the host, it's binding both ways.
Third, by allowing audits. There's a cost here and auditors are still human, but they provide outside assurance - especially when their findings are published independently.
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/11/21559930/google-train-ai...
Google doesn't give you a pinky-swear that they won't do anything further with the images.
If their service's privacy policy isn't materially different, then I wouldn't trust it. If their service's privacy policy materially restricts how they can use the data in ways that Google's would otherwise allow, then I would put more trust in it.
We use Tinybeans for this
> Haven is about sharing privately with friends and family. There is no option to make your blog public to the world. You get to create an account for anyone you want to have access.
Is more compelling than one where grandparents have to register, find my blog, I have to approve them, and for every post I have to set permissions levels.
As much as I've loved working on Scuttlebutt, I can't recommend using it for this use-case.
It's pricy at $40 per year, but seems to hit all the marks.
It's also federated, so people not using your instance can still interact from where they are
MyFamily.com was essentially this in the pre Facebook era. IIRC there was a modest annual fee for a private site/feed that let you share posts, photos, and recipes with family members.
What's different about what you envision then that?
The downside is that everything's ephemeral. I've long thought there was room for a private network where you can pub/sub to people you care about. Sort of a simple and private Livejournal / Blogger.
FWIW I think the self-hosting bit isn't where the opportunity is. It's in hosted private sharing. One thing I'd do is create landing pages for people who want to share privately and have $$. Parents are the first group that comes to mind.
I wish you success - the world needs what you're doing!