I have always used it in what's now called "classic layout" - message list above, current message below, sidebar with accounts/mailboxes.
In the message list, I could choose what columns were shown, how wide they were and in what order.
I could just click on the top of a column to sort one way, click again to sort another.
This would let me find all the mail today or last week in order. or group by subject. Or find everything with an attachment. or back to sorting by date with today at the bottom.
What I was waiting for was smarter mail rules. maybe nested rules. Maybe smarter ways to interact (without resorting to applescript)
But they dumbed it down and there's a dropdown to pick what to sort (drop twice if the order they chose was not what you expected). You cannot choose your columns. You cannot choose the order. rules have not gotten smarter and with a name like "classic layout", I figure it is one update away from gone.
But my coworker likes the classic layout, and another coworker likes the default layout but with expanded preview text to more lines. I wouldn’t go as far to say one preference is worse than the other.
[0] https://mjtsai.com/blog/2019/10/11/mail-data-loss-in-macos-1...
It sucks that Apple has let it get so bad, but I personally wouldn't consider Mail part of the OS. It's just a built in App like garage band or something.
https://mjtsai.com/blog/2019/10/11/mail-data-loss-in-macos-1...
I'm typing this on a new 13" MacBook Air, and the screen is pretty small! don't know if BigSur is optimized for a 27" iMac display, but on a small laptop, I certainly feel like the decreased UI density feels like a hindrance.
I just don't use full screen mode much. On my 25" displays the only application that gets kept full screen is my IDE. I don't need a dedicated button that slowly animates the window to fullscreen if I accidentally click it.
Speculating here, but given that most people using a mac are looking at a 13" screen, it seems like this change was made to benefit them. And that's fair enough, but why can't there be a toggle in the system preferences to change it?
macOS has some preferences like this, but they all seem to be things grandfathered in from the old days. Future updates that change things like the green button or Mission Control don't get any preferences to tweak behaviour and it's so frustrating.
I personally really enjoy full screen mode when using my laptop undocked
I would recommend BetterTouchTool (https://folivora.ai/) to get back the ability to maximize windows with a click. Also you can drag windows to the right or left of the screen, and it resizes to half the screen. Wonderful to put two applications side by side.
They really just need to get back to ironing out the every day things. Case in point - not being able to reply to a Message directly from the notification is a huge regression. Fix stuff like that first.
Why would this be the case? Apple's a massive, well-resourced company and it seems like they should be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.
> Not every new interface will work equally well on old hardware, but that doesn't mean that the interface has deteriorated.
Apple is well-known for long support periods on mobile, and 5 years is not, in my eyes, an old computer that ought to be replaced. And so if the interface doesn't work as well on the authors supported hardware, then I think we can agree the interface has objectively deteriorated.
is a 5 year old computer old?
So, yes, a 5 year old computer is near retirement age.
† https://c3.nasa.gov/dashlink/static/media/other/ObservedFail...
(Effectively) Irreplacable batteries already limit the lifespan of many consumer devices to 3-4 years, so why limit the capabilities of the hardware to get a few years that won't be usable anyways… is how I imagine those conversations going.
Viable personal computing since 1981. GUI personal computing for the masses since 1993 or so.
That's 40 years with a conservative estimate. 5 years is 12.5% of the history of personal computing. So kinda yes.
So in OS-years, yes, the computer is old. ;-)
But reading through the piece the only tangible evidence he provides is more spacing between elements that he is pulling up on 5 year old hardware?
Screen density and pixels have improved dramatically in that time frame, we have larger screens, more resolution, and retina display, it's like switching from Analog to HD. Not every new interface will work equally well on old hardware, but that doesn't mean that the interface has deteriorated.
Making something infinitely backwards compatible will ultimately destroy the user experience, as you can't take advantage of the present and the improvements it offers.
The OS is getting a bit iOS-ified - that I agree with, but it isn't forced upon you to the level Windows does, so it is easily avoided.
I would prefer to have a seen a more detailed breakout of the real degradation in user experience, otherwise it's just a complete opinion piece with no real facts or proof points to offer.