News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by simias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:06PM (#25750768)
"Brainwashed" is not a very honest way to frame this discussion. You can be convinced of something without being brainwashed.

I genuinely believe that free speech should have limits in order to maintain the cohesion of our societies and protect people from mobs. I don't think I've been brainwashed into it, I've just seen what unbridled and unchecked hate speech can lead to.

Of course there's the problem of where the line should be drawn and who should draw it, but in order to have this discussion we need to move away from these strawmen (strawpersons?) and accept that maybe people just have convictions they haven't been brainwashed into.

After all, I'm sure you wouldn't be very happy if I erected billboards along the highway featuring hardcore pedopornography with your faced photoshopped in. One way or an other we all have limits to what we consider acceptable expression, it's all about figuring out how this should be codified and enforced.

And I want to add that having taboo topics and forms of expression is probably a good thing overall. For our lives to have meaning we need "sacred" things to protect, things to fight against, things to think about. We need to be able to shock, we need to be able to be transgressive, to make revolutions and counter-revolutions, to express frustration.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:23PM (#25752984)
The belief that free speech must have limits is necessarily equivalent with the belief that a large part of the people are stupid and they must be protected by the smart people by preventing them to hear anything that might influence their feeble minds and make them act in a wrong way.

Maybe this belief about most people being stupid is correct, therefore free speech must indeed be limited, but I do not see any of the advocates of limiting free speech having the courage to tell what they really think in the face of those whom they want to protect.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mlyle on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:39PM (#25753256)
I think it just comes down to Popper, who puts it elegantly enough:

> ... In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols. We should therefore claim, in the name of tolerance, the right not to tolerate the intolerant.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adnzzzzZ on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:49PM (#25753397)
>The hobbit is simply embarrassed into compliance by his elven betters. The ideas he believes become a dangerous mental disease. This diagnosis is written into history. The sooner he gives up this nonsense, the better. To help convince him, we'll make this idea quasi-illegal. The sooner he gives it up, the less his life will suffer. Eventually he can be fired for staying an idiot. Everyone will agree that he deserved it.

>This is Popper’s paradox of tolerance. Popper discovers that every real regime must have the apparatus of the Inquisition in its back pocket. If it hesitates to deploy its intellectual rack and thumbscrew, it will be replaced by a regime with no such qualms.

>Popper, read logically, advises the Nazis to repress the Communists, the Communists to repress the Nazis, the liberals to repress both and both to repress the liberals. From his “open society” he comes all the way around to Hobbes, Schmitt and Machiavelli. Next he will tell us, in Esperanto, that “the earth is nothing but a vast bloody altar.”

I think Moldbug reads Popper much more elegantly. https://graymirror.substack.com/p/vae-victis

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mlyle on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:31PM (#25754046)
Poorly, you mean, because Popper asserts (as I quoted before):

...as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise...

It's only when the other side has abandoned discourse and is interested in meeting you with force that tolerance is to be abandoned.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ogogmad on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:16PM (#25753811)
Popper's point is that if someone wants to curtail your right to free speech, you have the right to curtail theirs. On the other hand, if a political opponent respects your right to speak freely, you should do the same for them. It's not really a paradox; it's about symmetry.

By analogy, imagine if someone commits murder. Would putting them to death as punishment also be murder? No. You have the right to life as long as you respect other people's right to the same.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by Knufen on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:52PM (#25754389)
The problems always begins with grey and ends in black. Who defines when, where and how someone is curtailing their right to free speech? There is always asymmetry in power.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by offby37years on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:30PM (#25753097)
This is correct. You can't have democracy without free speech. If you don't trust your fellow citizens to be able to deduce the truth, you shouldn't trust them to cast their own vote.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:18PM (#25753848)
Yes, you are right.

This is the most unfortunate consequence of the idea that free speech must be limited.

If it is accepted that a part of the people cannot be trusted to not do wrong things when others tell them to do so, then an unavoidable consequence is that to that part of the people the right to vote must also be denied, because if they may be convinced by lies to do very wrong things, like violence, then it is even more certain that they will be easily convinced by lies to do a minor mistake, like casting a wrong vote.

Any proposal to deny the right of voting to stupid people, or to give different weight to the votes, depending on the "intelligence" of the voters, would rightly generate huge protests.

However, any proposal to restrict the free speech without also restricting the right to vote is logically inconsistent, even if many seem to not notice this.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by modriano on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:41PM (#25753285)
> If you don't trust your fellow citizens to be able to deduce the truth...

Do you trust people who live in an echo chamber overrun with disinformation to deduce the truth about the outcome of the US election? If so, can you speak to the mechanism by which such people can determine the truth? And could you speak to the empirical failure of this population to discover the truth?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by offby37years on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:58PM (#25753548)
With almost every technological advance, destructive power arrives long before the protective powers. It's much easier to destroy something with a nuclear weapon than it is to build a nuclear power plant. Likewise, we arrived at muskets before the combustion engine. Disinformation is much cheaper (and profitable for media companies surviving on outrage driven clicks) than delivering self-verifiable empirical information. This will change in time.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by dagw on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:37PM (#25753223)
You can't have democracy without free speech.

So are countries that have more limits on free speech than what the US has, less democratic than the US?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:27PM (#25753988)
There are no single criteria that can be used to judge how democratic a country is.

Many European countries have more restrictions on free speech than USA, so yes, they are less democratic by this criterion.

By other criteria, e.g. by evaluating how many abusive laws they have that favor a few rich individuals that own some large companies against the majority of the citizens, most European countries are more democratic than USA.

The same conclusion comes from other criteria, like how easy is for most citizens to access education or health services.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mlyle on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:37PM (#25753213)
You need free speech, but you don't need free coordination of violence by those rejecting discourse.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by offby37years on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:40PM (#25753268)
In attempt to curtail the latter you forgo the former.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by chopin24 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:55PM (#25753494)
>The belief that free speech must have limits is necessarily equivalent with the belief that a large part of the people are stupid and they must be protected by the smart people by preventing them to hear anything that might influence their feeble minds and make them act in a wrong way.

You're leaving out some very well-established restrictions on free speech, including slander, libel, copyright infringement, obscenity, privacy violation... in short, absolutism hasn't been a prevailing philosophy for centuries. This sudden resurgence of it feels like a refusal to engage with the very real, very difficult debate on what speech deserves censorship.

It doesn't have anything at all to do with intelligence, but the observed consequences of certain kinds of speech. Lies, for example, that manipulate peoples' emotions. This is not unique to "stupid people."

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:42PM (#25754230)
Some other poster already mentioned that what you list are actions that are punishable by various laws, at least in most countries.

There is a huge difference between punishing someone for something already done, e.g. slander or libel, and denying him access to publication media because you believe that in the future that person might say something that might have who knows what effect on other people, who might do some crimes.

I completely agree that whoever abuses the free speech right to do something punishable by law must be judged and punished if found guilty.

On the other hand, I do not agree with any of these "deplatforming" actions based on vague beliefs about the future actions of some people.

If Trump or anyone else is expected to do a speech crime, then watch him and, as soon as he does that, fine him or arrest him.

If he already did such a crime, then also fine him or arrest him.

Otherwise, "deplatforming" him has no basis in facts.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by rileymat2 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:11PM (#25754643)
> denying him access to publication media because you believe that in the future that person might say something that might have who knows what effect on other people, who might do some crimes.

Is this the case here?

The statements in question are already made. Typically, the deplatforming happens after a violation has already been made. Which seems to be the case here, unless I am misunderstanding.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @06:05PM (#25755252)
In the case of banishing someone like Trump from Twitter, where that is justified by many previous misleading messages, I agree that this is right.

However, this discussion thread started about the actions done against Parler.

I had not previously heard about Parler, but I understand that the efforts to stop its activity are based on claims that it does not perform adequate censorship of the content published there, unlike Facebook or Twitter.

If there are people that have published there things that are punishable by law, they should be punished. If Parler itself has done something illegal, then they should be punished.

However, if some private companies sabotage Parler based on the fact that Parler does not have the same censorship rules as themselves, then that is clearly wrong.

From what I have heard here, it might be good if Parler disappears, but I cannot accept that the end justifies the means.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:38PM (#25753235)
And of course, those advocating limiting speech are sure that they are not among the stupid. They're always advocating limiting someone else's speech, not their own, because they're smart people who are not fooled by the wrong things, and who listen to and believe the right things.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by leetcrew on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:29PM (#25753078)
> Maybe this belief about most people being stupid is correct, therefore free speech must indeed be limited, but I do not see any of the advocates of limiting free speech having the courage to tell what they really think in the face of those whom they want to protect.

I don't know about this part. the narrative seems to be more about protecting the vulnerable from the stupid, not so much protecting the stupid from themselves.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:03PM (#25754548)
Nobody can be so vulnerable to the words of other people that they will do obviously bad things, unless they are stupid.

Normal people are vulnerable to lies only in the sense that when presented with deliberately false information that they cannot verify immediately, they may trust the liar and make a wrong decision to do something that they cannot know yet whether it is right or wrong, e.g. buying something cheap for a high price or being the victim for another kind of fraud.

Only someone stupid will beat someone or burn a house because of some false accusations.

All the arguments for these deplatforming actions were that the people, who would have heard the propaganda of those to whom the access is denied now, would have been easily convinced to do stupid things.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by phs318u on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:54PM (#25755154)
> but I do not see any of the advocates of limiting free speech having the courage to tell what they really think in the face of those whom they want to protect.

It's not them I want to protect (though I don't have any explicit desire for them to _not_ be protected). It's me I want to protect. Your right to swing your fists ends at the tip of my nose, and your right to yell "Fire!" or "Stop the steal" or "Storm the Bastille!" are likewise constrained when they infringe on my rights.

The practical implementation and realisation of rights is always a trade-off of rights vs rights. What is under discussion is where the balance of those trade-offs lay.

Having said that, there is a very strong case to be made that we need to address people's propensity to listen to, invest in, and act on, obvious bullshit (e.g. flat-earthers, reptilians etc). More than education is required. My brother-in-law - a highly functioning, tertiary educated small business owner and nice guy - is a dyed-in-the-wool conspiracist, believing the most outrageous things. Having a rational discussion with him has not budged him from his beliefs one iota. I believe it's a psychological condition as common as depression or anxiety.

There are no easy answers nor quick fixes for this problem.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by claudiawerner on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:07PM (#25753679)
>The belief that free speech must have limits is necessarily equivalent with the belief that a large part of the people are stupid and they must be protected by the smart people by preventing them to hear anything that might influence their feeble minds and make them act in a wrong way.

I don't see why this is true; intelligent people can be harmed by speech just as much as stupid people can. Everyone can certainly be harmed by the immediate follow-on effects of speech. Some words can harm in a way it is unreasonable to expect guard against, or those for which it is impossible to guard against.

The scholarly literature on speech, harm, and legality has dozens of such examples.

>but I do not see any of the advocates of limiting free speech having the courage to tell

I can courageously say now that I'm not in favor of restrictions on speech for reasons of "stupidity" but rather the demonstrable harm speech can cause.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by FuckButtons on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:40PM (#25753264)
I don’t agree, perfectly rational otherwise smart people can be duped by lies, to suggest otherwise is to deny the evidence of the entire advertising industries existence. We need to protect everyone from predatory actors, propaganda and lies irrespective of their intellect because we are all susceptible.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by nec4b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:03PM (#25754555)
And who will do the protecting if we are all susceptible? You?
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by glogla on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:33PM (#25753157)
I'm not sure you have actually shown the equivalency.

But if you did, how is that different from worker protections or consumer protections or environmental protections or mandatory seatbelt or million other laws?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by JeremyNT on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:56PM (#25754459)
> Maybe this belief about most people being stupid is correct, therefore free speech must indeed be limited, but I do not see any of the advocates of limiting free speech having the courage to tell what they really think in the face of those whom they want to protect.

Maybe people don't actually espouse that stated position because it's a strawman.

Intelligent people can be fooled and manipulated without being stupid - they have been for ages. What's different now is the speed and concentration of misinformation.

Platforms of mass misinformation and manipulation are curious beasts, and susceptibility to radicalization != stupidity. Something somewhat novel appears to be happening due the new ways we communicate, and it's not unreasonable to suggest that "something" should be done about it.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jokethrowaway on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:50PM (#25751520)
Free speech doesn't need limits.

Inciting violence, endangering someone with false speech, committing fraud: they're already a crime and they're not covered by free speech.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by hctaw on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:01PM (#25751677)
Those are examples of limiting of free speech

edit: it seems people have misunderstood my comment to take a position. I' m taking issue with the idea that "free speech doesn't need limits" followed by a listing of limits applied to free speech. If we can't agree that there even exists such limits and that perhaps they're necessary any discussion below is fruitless.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by coryfklein on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:32PM (#25752192)
I think parent was pointing out that the question of "where should the line be drawn and who should draw it" has already been settled. Those things are already illegal, so we don't need to impose further restrictions on speech in order to prevent those things.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ardy42 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:35PM (#25752237)
> I think parent was pointing out that the question of "where should the line be drawn and who should draw it" has already been settled. Those things are already illegal, so we don't need to impose further restrictions on speech in order to prevent those things.

I'm skeptical that such a line can ever be truly "settled." Sure, it can be settled in a particular social and technological context, but when those latter things change, the line may need to be adjusted.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by coryfklein on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:49PM (#25752444)
See Trope 9: "This speech may be protected for now, but the law is always changing."

TLDR: yeah, the law can change, but it's highly unlikely because "the United States Supreme Court has been more consistently protective of free speech than of any other right, especially in the face of media sensibilities about "harmful" words"

[1] https://www.popehat.com/2015/05/19/how-to-spot-and-critique-...

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ardy42 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:35PM (#25754118)
> See Trope 9: "This speech may be protected for now, but the law is always changing."

It's worth noting that no legally forbidden censorship has been happening with regards to the recent insurrection against congress.

> TLDR: yeah, the law can change, but it's highly unlikely because "the United States Supreme Court has been more consistently protective of free speech than of any other right, especially in the face of media sensibilities about "harmful" words"

But that's not a fixed fact of nature, it's a reaction to a particular social and technological context.

For instance, if someone discovers an idea instantly turns 10% those who hear it into murderous zealots (sort of like the poem in "The Tyranny of Heaven" by Stephen Baxter), that idea is going to censored hard and the Supreme Court will be like "yup, ban it."

Likewise, if some social change or technology renders the legal regime that the Supreme Court has created a cause of serious dysfunction, then Supreme Court is going to have to change that regime to accommodate. Idealism's great, but not when it doesn't work.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by coryfklein on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:45PM (#25754287)
> no legally forbidden censorship has been happening with regards to the recent insurrection against congress.

Yes, this is true as far as I am aware as well. But I find myself in a conundrum; had this "inciting" speech taken place in the town square or a public park, much of it likely could not have been censored because it would have been protected by the 1st amendment and the last 100 years of case law. Where, then, is the town square and public park of 2021?

Despite the fact that the legal protections of public speech haven't changed much in decades, the practical protections of public speech (as I discuss in greater detail in [1]) have indeed been eroded, because social media platforms and, apparently, web hosting and device makers are now the arbiters of the vast majority of speech. Free speech that only applies where virtually noone can hear you is a very limited free speech indeed.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25662466

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by allturtles on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:43PM (#25755025)
The town squares and public parks are still there.

The existence of Twitter, Facebook, etc. have accustomed people to the ability to air their opinions globally free of charge, however that is a very novel phenomenon. It's hard for me, having come of age in the 1980s/1990s, to see this as an inalienable right.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by coryfklein on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @07:13PM (#25756030)
Of course they are still there! But the conversations increasingly aren't taking place there. If free speech is essential to a liberal democracy, we're moving to a place where the majority of speech takes place in non-free-speech areas, and that does not bode well for the health of our democracy.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ardy42 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @02:06PM (#25766567)
> Of course they are still there! But the conversations increasingly aren't taking place there. If free speech is essential to a liberal democracy, we're moving to a place where the majority of speech takes place in non-free-speech areas, and that does not bode well for the health of our democracy.

You have a right to speak, but not a right to reach.

The majority of speech always took place in areas with some kind of limits. For instance: in some guy's tavern or in the pages of a local newspaper.

Furthermore, what's happening to Parler could also be conceived as a kind of self-defense exception: the factions it embraced have recently attempted to literally attack (in the name of a selfish demagogue) the heart of the liberal order that enables free speech, and they cannot be tolerated if toleration is to survive.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:31PM (#25768230)
> If free speech is essential to a liberal democracy, we're moving to a place where the majority of speech takes place in non-free-speech areas, and that does not bode well for the health of our democracy.

The majority of conversation in democracies has always taken place in private venues that were free to control who had access and did absolutely do so based on political viewpoint.

That these private spaces are now virtual rather than physical doesn't change the essence of that fact.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by claudiawerner on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:11PM (#25753739)
>the question of "where should the line be drawn and who should draw it" has already been settled

I think it should at least be a line open to challenge without being accused of being brainwashed. If that line cannot be questioned, we're skating on dogmatism. There are very few good reasons for a special guarantee of free speech (versus, say, a special guarantee to be able to eat fries) which stand up to closer scrutiny.

The only convincing reason for a constitutional guarantee to freedom of speech is mistrust in the government, but again, that depends where you draw the line. Food regulation is arguably just as important in our lives, but few mistrust the FDA as to call for its abolition, or propose a constitutional amendment banning all regulation of foods.

This isn't a matter of what the law is, it's a matter of what the law should be - whether it's a constitutional law or not.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by option on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:18PM (#25751963)
no it is not. Saying “covid is a hoax” should be protected by free speech because it is an expression of (stupidly false) opinion. Saying “we storm Capiton at 8:00am on Jan 6” is a call to violent action, not an idea, thought, or opinion and obviously must be taken down ASAP
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ardy42 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:37PM (#25752269)
> no it is not. Saying “covid is a hoax” should be protected by free speech because it is an expression of (stupidly false) opinion.

But I shouldn't be obligated to let someone put a sign saying that on my lawn, nor should I be obligated to remain friends with someone who is pushing that lie.

Most of the people who are complaining about free speech being limited are really arguing for things like the above.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ericd on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:35PM (#25753186)
You preventing signs on your lawn are fine, you preventing specific messages on systemically important communications infrastructure you happen to own is not. It’s the same reason that AT&T was heavily regulated back when it carried 90% of telecom traffic and before it was ultimately broken up via antitrust.

You running a corner store the way you want is fine, you running the only store in the country the way you want is not.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ardy42 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:46PM (#25754295)
> You preventing signs on your lawn are fine, you preventing specific messages on systemically important communications infrastructure you happen to own is not. It’s the same reason that AT&T was heavily regulated back when it carried 90% of telecom traffic and before it was ultimately broken up via antitrust.

You know, you don't need AWS to run a website, right? Similarly, newspapers have often been local monopolies, but as far as I know, they've always been able to decline to publish a letter to the editor.

Whoever wants to stick a sign on my lawn is going to come up with some rationale to force me to do it, but that doesn't mean it holds any water.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by foolinaround on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:14PM (#25752844)
yes, but then you don't get covered under section 230, because you are actively making judgement calls, and therefore, should be liable for those.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by chc on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:54PM (#25753492)
Whatever news source you heard talking about section 230, you should stop trusting it, because they are actively misinforming you.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by tstrimple on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:29PM (#25753091)
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by foolinaround on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:24PM (#25753934)
this link clarified some things for me,thanks
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by majormajor on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:41PM (#25752317)
We got to the latter because of years and years of the former.

"You're allowed to talk people into believing that they need to violently rebel, but you're not allowed to actually do the rebelling" is not a particularly reasonable position.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by avgDev on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:58PM (#25752574)
I'm working on a blog, where users will post about their experience with a particular drug and its side effects. Since, I am paying for hosting and I created the blog, I will NOT allow any pseudo science. Am I limiting free speech? No.

There is a good reason twitter, facebook, youtube does remove certain content. They have the right to remove whatever they want.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by option on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:48PM (#25755077)
do you think your water and energy utilities should be free to decide whether to serve your house or not?
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by hctaw on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:30PM (#25753113)
All speech is free speech. Avoid hyperbole here because it doesn't help. Your examples both kinds of speech that people think should be limited, trying to discard one as not speech rather than focusing at hand on what speech should be limited does nothing but rile up those that disagree with your examples.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by kolinko on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:22PM (#25752035)
+1.

If someone publishes fake news about vaccines, it takes a lot of effort then for people to keep explaining to other people how this is not true. It is harmful to society, and unfair - it takes less time to invent a new hoax than to fact-check it.

Just like loitering on the ground is considered an offence, so should be publishing fake news. It doesn't hurt one person, but it hurts society.

There also are objective criteria for determining if something is fake or not - so it is possible to create laws that forbid it and don't limit a freedom of opinion.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by silexia on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:34PM (#25752221)
Why is everyone debating on whether they should be limits on free speech when that is irrelevant? Free speech is something provided by the government, not by private companies. Any private company, such as a restaurant, can throw you out for any reason outside of discriminating against a protected class.

What seems to be under attack here is the right of individual companies and people to decide who they wish to work with. Everyone who is criticizing big tech for choosing not to work with certain people is forgetting that that same principle can be applied to them. Do you want to be forced to work with companies you abhor?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by wutbrodo on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:11PM (#25752776)
> What seems to be under attack here is the right of individual companies and people to decide who they wish to work with. Everyone who is criticizing big tech for choosing not to work with certain people is forgetting that that same principle can be applied to them. Do you want to be forced to work with companies you abhor?

You mention protected classes in your first paragraph, but then act like it's self-evident that it's bad to "force people to work with (and serve) people they abhor". What else is the concept of a protected class if not this?

It's clear that we already don't have full freedom of association, and the question is where the line should be drawn. When people talk about big tech regulation, it's undergirded by many of these platforms' unique amount of market power. This isn't a novel concept; utility companies are an example of a natural monopoly: benefiting from scale, considered critical infrastructure, and legally prohibited from cutting off power to its customers, even if they don't like their politics. The topic under discussion here is whether the "new public square" (or things like payment infrastructure!) are considered critical enough to society that we want to protect access to them.

I'm constitutionally (not "Constitutionally") disinclined against ill-considered regulation, and most of the conversation by government about tech regulation is pants-on-head stupid. But the dissonance between the two paras in your comment are a good indication that this discussion isn't nearly as simple as you're framing it.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mkolodny on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:04PM (#25753624)
> The topic under discussion here is whether the "new public square" (or things like payment infrastructure!) are considered critical enough to society that we want to protect access to them.

That's one core question. Another is whether it should be up to these companies to police their own platforms. Inciting violence is illegal. They're banning people and platforms inciting violence.

"Repeal section 230" seems to be about making these companies responsible for policing their own platforms. When people incited violence/genocide on Facebook in Myanmar, some people held Facebook partially responsible. Now, there are people are inciting violence on Facebook in the US, and it's still an open question whether Facebook should be held liable.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:29PM (#25754032)
When people incited violence/genocide on <radio> in Myanmar, some people held <radio> partially responsible. Now, there are people are inciting violence on <radio> in the US, and it's still an open question whether <radio> should be held liable.

There are important differences, but the parallels between the Rwandan genocide and the growth of talk radio in the US in the 90's have always struck me as interesting.

That being said, I think that the new public square argument is strong, and if we're going to have internet monopolies, then they probably need to be regulated similarly to the utilities.

Alternatively, they can be broken up. I don't think the current state is sustainable over the longer term.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:36PM (#25752248)
> Why is everyone debating on whether they should be limits on free speech when that is irrelevant?

It's not irrelevant.

> What seems to be under attack here is the right of individual companies and people to decide who they wish to work with.

To the extent that that is based on expressive preference, that is an aspect of free speech, and the closely-related right of free association.

Limiting that right is limiting free speech.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by zaroth on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:04PM (#25752672)
I agree that this is a limit on corporations’ free speech. Monopolistic corporations do have a well founded legal limit to their free speech rights.

For example, it’s a form of free speech for Microsoft to decide how they write their own software. One of those decisions was to bundle a free web browser in with their OS and tie the OS function tightly together with that browser. Microsoft Corporation was almost broken up by the government because they did that.

The issue that Greenwald is raising is similarly rooted in anti-trust;

> If one were looking for evidence to demonstrate that these tech behemoths are, in fact, monopolies that engage in anti-competitive behavior in violation of antitrust laws, and will obliterate any attempt to compete with them in the marketplace, it would be difficult to imagine anything more compelling than how they just used their unconstrained power to utterly destroy a rising competitor.

Freedom of speech is not absolute. Just like individuals’ free speech rights have limits such as incitement to violence, corporations also have limits to their “free speech” rights based in anti-trust law and anti-racketeering laws in how they can attack potential competitors.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by edmundsauto on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:00PM (#25752608)
On the other hand, forcing a platform to allow expression they disagree with is limiting their free speech to not amplify something.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:18PM (#25753843)
That's not the other hand, that’s what I was saying in GP.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by bee_rider on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:57PM (#25752557)
It isn't really free speech, you are right. It is more of an anti-trust issue, that a couple companies could get together to completely ban another one. We should consider if too much power has been concentrated in the hands of a few tech companies, if essentially their content moderation policies can so easily be misinterpreted as free speech issues.

That the outcome here is banning a community that was apparently mostly used for hate speech (never actually checked it out) is... maybe a red herring? I mean, they obviously didn't build these massive companies with the primary goal of banning niche hateful websites.

If we were to, say, break up social media and internet infrastructure giants, then this sort of website would probably be able to persist by hopping from host to host until they found one without any morals. But could consider if losing the ability to perform this kind of deplatforming would be worth it, in exchange for a much more competitive marketplace.

I think it is actually a really tricky situation.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by silexia on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:12PM (#25752806)
Keep in mind that sites like parler are not actually banned. They could simply hook up their own computer to the internet and run their site if they wished. No one has some natural right to be able to use a convenient service like AWS. And if AWS refuses to do business with you, there are hundreds of other hosting companies that you can choose from.

Ultimately, if not one of the hundreds of hosting companies out there wants to work with you, that should be a very strong indication that the community is not something we want. But if you really really want this community anyways, just hook up your computer to an internet connection and host the site yourself.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by brlewis on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:11PM (#25752783)
> Free speech is something provided by the government, not by private companies

It is not provided by the government. Congress is prohibited from passing laws that abridge freedom of speech; Congress is not the fountain that free speech springs from.

It is perfectly relevant to discuss freedom of speech in contexts where someone else might be doing the abridging besides the U.S. Congress.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by throwawayboise on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:14PM (#25752831)
So when a politician or pundit cherry-picks one sentence out of a larger statement and spins that to imply something other than what the speaker meant, perhaps even the complete opposite of what he meant, is that "fake news" or is that "opinion?" And who decides?
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:10PM (#25754634)
I completely agree.

However, I want to repeat what I have already replied to another similar post.

All these speech crimes should be punished according to the law, as soon as they are committed.

Restricting the speech of someone, by denying access to publication media, just because it is believed that they might commit some speech crime in the future, that is clearly an arbitrary and baseless restriction of the free speech right.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by colinmhayes on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:41PM (#25752328)
The problem is people are idiots who will believe someone who calls themself Q and claims the deep state is trying to take down the president. Once you convince people of that you don't need to use illegal speech to inspire violence, they're already inspired.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:09PM (#25752754)
How do you suggest prosecuting those crimes?

If I threaten to kill you, or commit fraud, in person, you call the police, give them what information you have about me, and ideally I get a knock on the door. If I do it online, well, you don't have much recourse.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:23PM (#25754783)
If the author of such an online message cannot be identified, then the recourse is what is already common practice, to delete the offending message or possibly to replace the deceiving information with correct information.

If the author can be identified, which is frequently true, then it should be the same for online as for in person.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @06:10PM (#25755315)
I suspect we are in agreement, then.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25752536

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by simias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:15PM (#25751924)
If you want to frame it that way then fine by me: "there are no limits to free speech, but there are limits to what can be described as free speech". I'd argue that it's effectively exactly the same problematic seen from a slightly different angle.

Saying things like "I support Nazis" could be considered a valid political opinion protected by free speech in some countries and illegal hate speech in others.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by etangent on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:35PM (#25751316)
> I genuinely believe that free speech should have limits in order to maintain the cohesion of our societies and protect people from mob

Imagine saying this in June 2020

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by simias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:10PM (#25751837)
I'm not American and I don't have a strong opinion on the events you refer to (I actually had to read the replies to understand what you were getting at), so I definitely would've told you exactly the same thing in June of 2020. Feel free to ask me again whenever you see fit.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by _vertigo on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:42PM (#25751408)
Could you explain what you mean by this?
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by j_walter on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:59PM (#25751647)
Protesting anything is fine. It's how far you take that protest that is the problem. When does a protest become a riot?

When you block traffic? When you enter a secured space? When you break into a federal building? When you set fire to a federal building? When you set fire to cop cars? When you break windows of local businesses? When you loot local businesses? When you spray paint hate speech? When you threaten cops families with death? When you throw fireworks at people? When you throw Molotov cocktails at people?

These all occurred in large numbers during between the death of George Floyd and the Capitol Riot. How many times did big tech step and and stop the coordinating efforts for those protests/riots?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by whimsicalism on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:05PM (#25751751)
Hm. I think a lot of people reasonably draw the line on speech somewhere after the protests & property damage that happened during 2020, but before action coordinated to take control of the seat of government/potentially kidnap or kill elected representatives.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by neuland on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:27PM (#25752125)
Or, people are just inconsistent and not thinking about things beyond their politics.

People will praise the Arab Spring organizing on Twitter without considering the implications for the events at the Capital on Jan 6th.

People are fine with Parler getting banned by all their vendors for not moderating violence and threats. But people would loose their minds if the same thing happened to Facebook for their failure to moderate violence around the Rohingyan genocide.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by garden_hermit on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:08PM (#25752728)
> People will praise the Arab Spring organizing on Twitter without considering the implications for the events at the Capital on Jan 6th.

The reason why someone might hold these competing beliefs is simple: they strongly value democratic institutions. Violence, in the name of promoting democratic institutions, and ideally expanding human rights, is justifiable. Violence in the name of authoritarian insurrection is not.

Now, of course this gets really tricky, because many people on Parler, and in the capitol riots, fully believed that they were protecting democracy from massive voter-fraud. No clear answer to address that issue, but it is something that democratic societies will need to reckon with. How does one preserve democratic ideals (including promoting free speech, to whatever extent possible), while still maintaining a healthy society that doesn't tear itself apart?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by caseysoftware on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:50PM (#25752461)
> People will praise the Arab Spring organizing on Twitter without considering the implications for the events at the Capital on Jan 6th.

This is a great point. It's also key to consider that some of the groups that praised the Arab Spring were the Obama State Department which was led by Hillary Clinton at the time.

It appears the threshold is "support violent insurrection in other countries but stamp out the discussion of it here".

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:27PM (#25753049)
Or, perhaps, "support violent insurrection after peaceful protests against authoritarianism, human rights violations, political corruption have failed, when there is no further peaceful opportunity for opposition."

(The United States had an election, right? One with no more than the usual, minor, issues, right? One where legal actions were taken and weighed appropriately, right? One where one specific loser seems only to be complaining about losing, right? One where all of the other contemporaneous votes were not objected to, right? One that will be revisited in 2 to 4 years, right?)

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by caseysoftware on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:38PM (#25754949)
Serious question: Which of the lawsuits went into discovery and were heard to weigh those claims? I'd love to read the details as that could dispel rumors and bs.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @05:01PM (#25768524)
Pearson v. Kemp, No. 1:20-cv-4809 (N.D. Ga.), No. 20-14480 (11th Cir.), No. 20-816 (S. Ct.) (https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/court-cases/voting-ri...) has a fun one:

"In this case, the district court issued an emergency temporary restraining order at the plaintiffs’ request, worked at a breakneck pace to provide them an opportunity for broader relief, and was ready to enter an appealable order on the merits of their claims immediately after its expedited hearing on December 4, 2020. But the plaintiffs would not take the district court’s “yes” for an answer. They appealed instead. And, because they appealed , the evidentiary hearing has been stayed and the case considerably delayed. For our part, the law requires that we dismiss the appeal and return the case to the district court for further proceedings."

https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.gand.284055...

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:25PM (#25768166)
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_interest/election_... seems to be a big list of the lawsuits, including state courts, but doesn't have links to the filings (argh!).

https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/court-cases/voting-ri... does have links, but not always to the court filings. (There's a crap-ton of lawsuits in Georgia.)

And then there's https://healthyelections-case-tracker.stanford.edu/cases.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @05:46PM (#25769045)
Georgia's a pain in the butt. Apparently, their official court documents site wants $.50 / page for the PDFs of filings. That's not happening.

Many of the court records can apparently be found on democracydocket.com, but my browser is complaining about the site. Sorry.

Trump v. Kemp, 1:20-cv-5310 (N.D. Ga.) (https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.gand.285271...) (from https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/court-cases/voting-ri...) is interesting, though. The plaintiff's first claim is that the election was not conducted in accord with election laws established by the GA legislature. The court decides "Therefore, Plaintiffs Electors Clause claim belongs, if it belongs to anyone, only to the Georgia General Assembly" and since none of the plaintiffs are members of the assembly, they don't have standing. (That's rather fine logic chopping, but....)

The rest of the ruling seems to be that the governor and secretary of state of the state are not the ones legally responsible for verification of ballots, so the second claim cannot apply to them.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @09:53PM (#25771246)
This one is fun: Trump v. Raffensperger, No. 2020 CV 343255 (Ga. Super. Ct., Fulton Cnty.) (https://healthyelections-case-tracker.stanford.edu/detail?id...).

It sounds like a good example, massive allegations of fraud and what-not. But it was voluntarily dismissed. After a Trump/Raffensperger phone conference. Yes, that conference (https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/jan/04/trumps-phone...). The Trump team accepted the terms of the settlement from R., that Georgia share information about the election outside the court process in return for Trump, et al, dismissing the suits. (https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/45/...).

I can hear the smug smiles.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @03:00PM (#25767207)
Ok, now I've been sucked in. I started from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-election_lawsuits_related..., which lists a number of the cases, mostly in federal court, and mostly (I think) appeals, which don't deal with matters of fact. I'm having to dig through those to the original cases, in state courts.

For example, Bowyer et al. v. Ducey et al., which has a currently unresolved (https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USCOURTS-azd-2_20-cv-023... is the latest federal dismissal) but the dismissal refers to Ward, CV 2020-015285 (Ariz. 2020); (Doc. 81-1) (and has a short explanation of the ruling that goes into the evidence).

So, that brings me to Ward v. Jackson et al (CV2020-015285) (https://www.clerkofcourt.maricopa.gov/records/election-2020/...). https://www.clerkofcourt.maricopa.gov/Home/ShowDocument?id=1... is the minutes of the first evidentiary hearing and https://www.clerkofcourt.maricopa.gov/Home/ShowDocument?id=1... is the minutes of the second evidentiary hearing and ruling. (The minutes don't include the evidence, just who gave testimony and what the evidence is.) The ruling is 1) Background, 2) The Burden Of Proof In An Election Contest ("The Plaintiff in an election contest has a high burden of proof and the actions of election officials are presumed to be free from fraud and misconduct."), 3) The Evidence Does Not Show Fraud Or Misconduct (see below), 4) The Evidence Does Not Show Illegal Votes, 5) The Evidence Does Not Show An Erroneous Vote Count, and 6) Orders.

P: "A.R.S. § 16-672(A)(1) permits an election contest “[f]or misconduct on the part of election boards or any members thereof in any of the counties of the state, or on the part of any officer making or participating in a canvass for a state election.” Plaintiff alleges misconduct in three respects. First is that insufficient opportunity was given to observe the actions of election officials."

C: "The observation procedures for the November general election were materially the same as for the August primary election, and any objection to them should have been brought at a time when any legal deficiencies could have been cured."

P: "Second, Plaintiff alleges that election officials overcounted mail-in ballots by not being sufficiently skeptical in their comparison of signatures on the mail-in envelope/affidavits with signatures on file."

C: "Maricopa County election officials followed [the Secretary of State’s Election Procedures Manual, with multiple verification steps] process faithfully in 2020. Approximately 1.9 million mail-in ballots were cast and, of these, approximately 20,000 were identified that required contacting the voter. Of those, only 587 ultimately could not be validated.[...] The Court ordered that counsel and their forensic document examiners could review 100 randomly selected envelope/affidavits to do a signature comparison. [...] Of the 100 envelope/affidavits reviewed, Plaintiff’s forensic document examiner found 6 signatures to be “inconclusive,” meaning she could not testify that the signature on the envelope/affidavit matched the signature on file. She found no sign of forgery or simulation as to any of these ballots. Defendants’ expert testified that 11 of the 100 envelopes were inconclusive, mostly because there were insufficient specimens to which to compare them. He too found no sign of forgery or simulation, and found no basis for rejecting any of the signatures. [...] None of them shows an abuse of discretion on the part of the reviewer. Every one of them listed a phone number that matched a phone number already on file, either through voter registration records or from a prior ballot. The evidence does not show that these affidavits are fraudulent, or that someone other than the voter signed them. There is no evidence that the manner in which signatures were reviewed was designed to benefit one candidate or another, or that there was any misconduct, impropriety, or violation of Arizona law with respect to the review of mail-in ballots."

P: "Third, Plaintiff alleges errors in the duplication of ballots. Arizona law requires election officials to duplicate a ballot under a number of circumstances. One is where the voter is overseas and submits a ballot under UOCAVA, the Uniformed And Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act. Another is where the ballot is damaged or otherwise cannot be machine-tabulated."

C: "The Court ordered that counsel could review 100 duplicate ballots. Maricopa County voluntarily made another 1,526 duplicate ballots available for review. [...] Of the 1,626 ballots reviewed, 9 had an error in the duplication of the vote for president. Plaintiff called a number of witnesses who observed the duplication process as credentialed election observers. There was credible testimony that they saw errors in which the duplicated ballot did not accurately reflect the voter’s apparent intent as reflected on the original ballot. This testimony is corroborated by the review of the 1,626 duplicate ballots in this case, and it confirms both that there were mistakes in the duplication process, and that the mistakes were few. When mistakes were brought to the attention of election workers, they were fixed. The duplication process prescribed by the Legislature necessarily requires manual action and human judgment, which entail a risk of human error. Despite that, the duplication process for the presidential election was 99.45% accurate. And there is no evidence that the inaccuracies were intentional or part of a fraudulent scheme. They were mistakes. And given both the small number of duplicate ballots and the low error rate, the evidence does not show any impact on the outcome."

The Arizona Supreme Court decision (https://www.clerkofcourt.maricopa.gov/Home/ShowDocument?id=1...) makes for good reading. It's pretty clear, with a summary of the evidence (for the parts that were appealed). Weirdly, it takes the three claims in reverse order. I particularly liked the statements that the Secretary [of State, of Arizona] represented an error of 0.37%, while the appellants say it represented an error of 0.55%; the trial court accepted the appellants' number but it and the Supreme Court note that extrapolated to the total number of duplicated ballots, that doesn't come close to what would be required for a recount. The appellant offered no evidence that 1626 ballot sample was inadequate. The court accepts that there were irregularities, but that they did not even render the result uncertain.

So, there's one. I'll go fishing for more.

From what I know about law (NOT A LAWYER!), they're probably all in state courts---elections are state procedures---and thus not reported like the federal cases (which seem to fall into two classes: appeals, which deal with laws and procedures, not evidence, and them as were dismissed due to lack of standing since state procedures are a matter for state laws.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:55PM (#25772218)
I know you're going to feel like I'm picking on you, but I'm not. I'm just using this as a location to record the interesting cases I've seen. :-D

Nevada! Law v. Whitmer, No. 20 OC 00163 1B (Dist. Ct., Carson City, Nevada), No. 82178 (Nev. Sup. Ct.) (https://healthyelections-case-tracker.stanford.edu/detail?id...) Complaint: https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/45/..., Order granting dismissal: https://www.8newsnow.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/59/2020/12....

Let's talk AI. In this case, Clark county used a machine to sort mail-in ballots and to do a first pass validation of signatures. For 453,248 ballots. For reasons, including that the signature exemplars from the DMV were less than 200DPI, 70% of the ballots were viewed as sketchy, while 30% were found machine-okey-dokey and passed on without further review. The complaint wants those 130,000 votes invalidated.

The interesting thing is that the 70% that required manual review, 1-1.5% were initially rejected due to signature mismatch. Most were "cured" by voters (presumably by officials actually contacting the voters), leaving 0.3% to be completely rejected. The court notes that Washoe county (not using the magic machine) had a pre-cure reject rate of 1.53%. [So, if I have my sums right, the complaint wants 130,000 (30% of mail-in votes) plus some unknown number (greater than 1%) of the remainder invalidated, full stop, because between 1,400 and 6,900 were invalid. Or something.]

The complaint also includes Nevada's electronic voting machines ("not less than 1000 illegal and improper votes" counted and "not less than 1000 legal and proper votes" not counted). And no less than 15,000 illegal and improper mail-in votes from out-of-state. And the USPS, which was "directed" to deliver mail-in ballots where the addressee was deceased, moved, or had no known affiliation with the address. No less than 500 votes from dead people. There are also allegations of fraud in vote counting and observation. (It's a laundry list.)

According to the court, the Agilis sorting machines were determined to be ok in a previous case, Klaus v. Cegavske (which I have yet to look up).

As far as evidence, the court ordered the contestants to disclose all witnesses and evidence they intended to use by 5:00 pm Nov. 25. The contestants did not issue their first deposition notices until Nov. 27. Therefore the contestants' evidence consists of non-deposition witness declarations, with no cross-examination. The court considered these hearsay.

Michael Baselice offered expert evidence on the incidence of illegal voting based on a phone survey. He was unable to identify the source of his data and conducted no quality control. Similar questions faced Jesse Kamzol's analysis of various databases of voters. Scott Gessler's report lacked citations of facts and evidence and did not include any exhibits in support of his conclusions; his conclusions are based on a handful of affidavits. The complainants' experts were found to be of little or no value, but were not excluded from consideration, although given little weight.

The defendants provided a stack of testimony that court judged credible (including Dr. Michael Herron and the president of the company manufacturing Agilis).

Based on Herron's testimony, the court finds no evidence of a higher rate of voter fraud associated with mail-in voting. He also found that an illegal vote rate of 0.00054 percent between 2012 and prior to the 2020 general election. Herron testified that the contestant's implied double voting rate was 89 times larger than a conservative academic estimate. He finally testified that the contestants provided no persuasive evidence that fraudulent votes affected the presidential margin of 33,596 votes. (Gessler also testified that he had no personal knowledge of any voter fraud.)

The court found that the record does not support allegations of problems with provisional ballots.

The court found that the Agilis machine did not accept any signatures that should have been rejected and that the record did not support a finding that ballots with improper signatures were counted.

And on, and on. The court finds that the record does not support the allegations of the complainants, hearsay declarations included, under "any standards of evidence". The contestants failed to meet their burden and the case was dismissed.

I'm going to bed.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by mcguire on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @09:00PM (#25770852)
On a different computer now; I can get to democracydocket.

Here's one from Michigan based on affidavits from eye-witnesses, trying for an injunction forcing an independent audit of the election: https://www.democracydocket.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/45/... (Love the URL. But no cut-n-paste.)

J claims that election workers coached voters and was instructed not to ask for photo ID from voters. However J does not name the location, provide the number of incidents, or name the employees. J never told a supervisor of the incidents nor took steps to address them. (J only came forward after reports of Biden winning.) J also claims, at the TCF center, she was directed not to compare signatures and to "pre-date" absentee ballots received at TCF on Dec. 4. The State Elections Director, CT, answers that signatures were previously verified at the Detroit Election Headquarters and that the "pre-dating" involved completing a data field inadvertently left blank during that earlier process. (I wonder if Michigan use the envelope/affidavit and anonymous ballot approach like Arizona, which ideally would have stripped off the signature part before vote counting for privacy. Michigan may need to do some work, if vote counters can match signatures with ballots.)

State Senator RJ wasn't there and makes claims based on other affidavits.

AS was a Republican challenger that didn't attend the training. AS claims out-of-state license plates brought "tens of thousands" of ballots in at 4:30 am, and that every ballot after that was for Biden. CT responds that rental trucks with out-of-state plates were used, all ballots were brought in the same way, the number of ballots he claims is speculation, and that 220,000 more votes were made for Biden.

DG claims large numbers of ballots were delivered in unsealed containers. Plaintiffs never supplied any legal requirement that sealed containers were required.

PC claims that computers were connected to the internet, based on an icon on one of the computers, but provides no other evidence. CT asserts that only the computers that needed to be connected were. (The Court notes that CT, in a Facebook post prior to the election, claims that Democrats were using COVID to commit election fraud (They see you when you're sleeping, they know when you're awake. (I'm getting punchy here.)) and that the predilection to see fraud undermines his claims.

MC was an IT consultant from Dominion Voting Services at TCF. MC claims witnessing "nothing but fraudulent events take place" including tabulating machines that jammed a lot (?) and a cover-up of the loss of vast amounts of data. No one else corroborates MC's claims, and by no one the court says the other complaintants.

Ex-Assistant Attorney General ZL claims that he was mistreated, that ballots were processed without confirmation of eligibility, that he was unable to observe because he was required to stand 6 feet away, and that he was excluded from the room after leaving to get something to eat because he was a Republican. However, two Democratic observers were also excluded, with the reason being the maximum occupancy of the room. Further, as mentioned above, voting eligibility was determined elsewhere. A large monitor was provided to allow observation at a safe distance. ZL also did not file any complaints at the time.

There's a bit about injunctive relief, irreparable harm, and legal remedy. (Michigan law provides for the Secretary of State and county clerks to audit races, but that doesn't seem satisfactory for the plaintiffs.)

The court finds that the plaintiffs have legal remedies and suffer no harm without an injunction, but that the defendants would be harmed by an injunction, as well as the public interest. The plaintiff's affidavits are contradicted by the State Election Director, whose account is corroborated by five other affidavits. An injunction and independent audit is denied.

This one is kind of interesting, even though the "independent audit" thing seems only like some kind of delaying tactic, rather than trying to get the election discarded.

On one hand, there's the assumption that election procedures and officials are legal and fair, and the further consideration that a ruling for the plaintiffs would be a big deal. (Judges apparently don't like to be backed into a corner and forced to make rulings that result in big deals, particularly on short notice. The phrase "judicial activism" shows up, for example.) On the other, these are serious accusations that are being considered seriously.

In this case, the court decided that the plaintiffs had other options they could use, and that the affidavits were not credible enough to override other considerations.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by Apocryphon on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:06PM (#25752702)
It's been a decade, I think people's opinions of the Arab Spring have been revised since then. The Arab Spring worked out best for the actual country it originated in, Tunisia.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ekianjo on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:39PM (#25752294)
But you know that people only think about the narrative. If its BLM everything goes. If its the other side, its evil, has to be stopped. And the best thing is that they are completely oblivious to their double standards.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by edmundsauto on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:03PM (#25752660)
That is one perspective, although it’s very limited in its nuance. A lot of people supported BLMs pre-violence protests because they wanted police held accountable. And a reasonable person can discuss whether the violence would have escalated if the police hadn’t been so aggressive.

Compare that to the Capitol insurrection, where the goal was to overturn the results of an election. To overturn the government. Where the people inciting the violence were in the same tent.

There was never good intent on the side of the insurrection it’s, and they escalated to violence on their own.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by ekianjo on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:31PM (#25770597)
> where the goal was to overturn the results of an election

If that was really the goal you'd think they would have gunned up a little more than they did. Instead, very few people were actually armed, so that seems rather disorganized for an actual coup.

> A lot of people supported BLMs pre-violence protests because they wanted police held accountable.

So protesting for police violence makes it OK to loot stores and burn cars that have nothing to do with it? How is that EVER ok? If you condemn violence you need to condemn violence no matter who instigates it, not only when it's very convenient for one to do so. because this is exactly what was happening 6 months ago, people cheer-leading the violence on Twitter if it was BLM related.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by adrian_b on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:34PM (#25754917)
I do not think that it is very hard to determine when a protest becomes a riot, but I think that it is extremely difficult to determine who is guilty for transforming a protest into a riot.

I have no idea about what has really happened last year in USA, because the truth cannot be discovered just from video transmissions at TV or on the Internet.

Nevertheless, I have seen much more closely a large number of peaceful protests in other countries, which eventually became riots.

However it became clear later, that in most or in all cases, the transformation of the protests into riots was done by undercover police agents or secret service agents, who had infiltrated the protests and who had done this in order to discredit the protests so that their demands could be ignored and their organizers punished.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by watwut on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:12PM (#25751884)
> These all occurred in large numbers during between the death of George Floyd and the Capitol Riot. How many times did big tech step and and stop the coordinating efforts for those protests/riots?

They did closed accounts that called for violence. I have literally seen that. Both twitter and facebook. Not perfectly, but they did not refused to delete tweets or whole accounts.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by j_walter on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:13PM (#25752818)
There are dozens of accounts for groups in Portland that aren't specifically calling for violence because they use code words. Despite violence happening constantly for 5+ months at the events being organized...

I haven't actually seen any proof that the Capitol riot was anything other than a protest that got out of hand (like what was described every time there was violence and riots after BLM protests across the country). It only takes a few dozen agitators to get a mob mentality going.

Facebook suspended #WalkAway, a group of 500K people that joined to support leaving the Democrats because they were being alienated by their policies (their words, not mine). No threats, no violence. Straight up deleted the group with no recourse by the organizers. All Facebook said was that the page allegedly ran afoul of “hateful, threatening, or obscene” content, but no proof was actually given.

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2021/jan/8/brandon-stra...

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by kofejnik on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:28PM (#25752138)
https://twitter.com/adbusters/status/1288193793267625984 is still up

"On September 17, 2020 we will lay siege to The @WhiteHouse for exactly fifty days.

We need your wisdom and expertise to pull off a radically democratic toneshift in our politics.

Are you ready for #revolution?

This is the #WhiteHouseSiege"

1k retweets

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by johnmaguire2013 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:55PM (#25752534)
https://twitter.com/Adbusters/status/1289363787879915522

Doesn't seem they were advocating for violence.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by weaksauce on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:09PM (#25752750)
because they didn't call for a violent overthrow of the government but a peaceful jazz fest like they had 9 years prior. they are calling for an occupy wallstreet 2.0

https://www.adbusters.org/campaigns/whitehousesiege-tactical...

the stuff that parler was leaving up was outright sedition and calls for violence.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by lwheelock on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:05PM (#25752686)
> Fifty days — September 17th to November 3rd. > > Let us once again summon the sweet, revolutionary nonviolence that was our calling card in Zuccotti Park.

If your stated intent explicitly calls for ‘non-violence’, I expect this doesn’t violate ToS despite potential inferences from the sensational branding.

I never heard of this before so I don’t even know what happened on Sept. 17. Was it violent?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jokethrowaway on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:59PM (#25751649)
Parent was obviously referring to the 34 deaths, theft, forcing people to comply with the requests (raise your first or face the mob) and millions of damage in private property, due to the BLM rioting.

Still, it's not relevant because they weren't exercising freedom of speech, just incitement of violence. Same as the people at the Capitol.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jacobolus on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:31PM (#25752184)
Your numbers are not reliable, and you should discount whatever source you got them from. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/aug/07/facebook-p...

The large Black Lives Matter protests all over the country were overwhelmingly lawful and peaceful. The main exceptions were the scenes in many places of cops beating the shit out of people, etc. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/02/style/police-protests-vid...

In various cities a small number of people acted violently. These were opportunists without apparent link to the Black Lives Matter organizers who took advantage of the situation to smash things up. Some were likely sympathetic to the BLM message, but others have been identified as far-right agitators. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/22/who-cause... https://www.justsecurity.org/70497/far-right-infiltrators-an...

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jokethrowaway on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:45PM (#25753338)
The only number I brought up is number of deaths which I thought it was 34 from memory.

I don't mind the people protesting peacefully, I'm talking about the violent ones.

Your fact checker doesn't report a number, some people counted 36. Wikipedia reports 19+ deaths: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_and_controversies_dur...

It's irrelevant.

There was looting from stores, burning of buildings and killings, surrounding people in restaurants and forcing them to comply.

You can call it a peaceful protest as much as you want and you can link biased sources all day, but you won't change facts.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jacobolus on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:10PM (#25753728)
Did you read your Wikipedia list? We have a whole bunch of people shot by cops, a few looters shot by store owners, people shot in unrelated murders that happened near protests, people run over by cars that drove into crowds, some people shot when groups of armed racists started gunfights with groups of armed antiracists, etc.

This list does not at all support the thesis that organized BLM protests were intentionally violent.

* * *

Yeah, there was a time that a group of white BLM sympathizers heckled another white BLM sympathizer who was eating at a restaurant table on the sidewalk, and the heckling was caught on video. The people involved are obnoxious jerks (organizers and most others in the BLM movement also agree they are jerks).

Similar heckling by all sorts of groups of jerks happens all over the country on a regular basis. For example a bunch of MAGA folks were following and heckling Lindsay Graham at an airport a few days ago.

But you really think heckling at a restaurant should be compared to an armed mob breaking into the Capitol building, chanting for the Vice President's execution and for the overthrow of the US government, beating cops to death, ransacking offices, stealing sensitive national security materials, and literally shitting all over?

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by optical on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @05:46PM (#25755061)
> This list does not at all support the thesis that organized BLM protests were intentionally violent.

Are you really claiming there was never any incitement?

This popped up with one search: https://nypost.com/2020/06/25/blm-leader-if-change-doesnt-ha...

“If this country doesn’t give us what we want, then we will burn down this system and replace it. All right? And I could be speaking figuratively. I could be speaking literally. It’s a matter of interpretation,”

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by jacobolus on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @06:23PM (#25755473)
The NY Post is a disingenuous propaganda rag owned by Rupert Murdoch. Find better sources.

https://blacklivesmatter.com/for-immediate-release-statement...

> Hawk Newsome has no relation to the Black Lives Matter Global Network (“BLM”) founded by Patrisse Cullors, Alicia Garza, and Opal Tometi — and is not the “president” of BLM or any of its chapters. Only BLM chapters who adhere to BLM’s principles and code of ethics are permitted to use the BLM name. The reason for this is simple: unaffiliated uses of BLM’s name are confusing to people who may wrongly associate the unsanctioned group and its views and actions with BLM. As BLM has told Mr. Newsome in the past, and as is still true today, Mr. Newsome’s group is not a chapter of BLM and has not entered into any agreement with BLM agreeing to adhere to BLM’s core principles.

If you look hard enough you can find unaffiliated yahoos of every ideological persuasion and self-proclaimed identity (libertarians, stoics, Christians, vegans, Canadians, chess players, computer programmers, stamp collectors, minivan owners, ...) spouting militant nonsense. Such statements should be condemned (and have been by those nonviolently protesting police brutality), but cannot be taken as sweeping evidence that everyone with similar self-proclaimed ideology or identity is a supporter of hateful violence.

If you intend to apply this kind of standard, then surely every organization that calls itself "conservative" should be similarly held responsible for the actions of the MAGA insurrectionists, right?

[dead]
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by watwut on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:16PM (#25751936)
Conservative groups still exist outside Parler. And they can and do coordinate there.

The same platforms were closing accounts calling for violence and preparing it during BLM protests. The difference is that while people on Parler claim that violent subgroups don't represent all Trump supporters, platforms that don't allow calls for violence are not good for them.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by rsync on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:34PM (#25753158)
"Of course there's the problem of where the line should be drawn and who should draw it"

That's not "a problem", that's the only problem.

Of course hatred and bigotry and false scientific claims and calls to violence, etc., are negative and of course we wish they would vanish.

But a Ministry of Truth would be worse.

I am willing to build and maintain mental, emotional and psychological armor against very negative, harmful speech if it helps avoid erecting a Ministry of Truth.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by gyudin on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:40PM (#25752305)
Not American per se, but free speech has limits. People breaking the law should be prosecuted in courts.
[dead]
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:01PM (#25751694)
> Democratically maybe?

But...we did that. And the answer arrived out through representative democracy thus far is:

(1) For matters where no legal liability, or only civil liability (except for sex trafficking, and copyright law which has its own special rules) would be involved, mostly leave it up to the free discretion of each online provider to determine and address unwelcome content.

(2) a whole bunch of crime-specific rules in criminal law, including (relevant to recent events) an absolute prohibition against knowingly providing any good or service (with narrow medical and religious exceptions) that will be used in “terrorism” offenses.

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by pkulak on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:43PM (#25752356)
> mental gymnastics required to adopt authoritarian and undemocratic ideals to "combat fascism".

It is a paradox, after all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler by simondw on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:36PM (#25752255)
> Why should Silicon Valley play the roll of unelected police-state.

Since when is a corporation deciding not to do business with someone equivalent to throwing them in prison?