Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by reader_mode on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:42AM
(#25747485)
Does it really matter in a 45W power range ?
I have a 2018 15 MBP with an i9-8950HK that has the same power range - this thing is unusable at full load for anything but burst - and the way it taxes the thermals makes it a terrible laptop (people in the office start turning their heads).
I'm not convinced any portable laptop can handle that TDP efficiently - so maybe this is interesting for gaming laptops - but to me this looks like Intel is still making shitty power-hungry chips for laptops
They are boasting performance comparisons to AMD Navi 2, Navi 3 also brings a ~20% IPC improvement which they claim to have over it. I'd speculate that Ryzen 7 5800U should outperform this chip in most relevant use cases (eg. sustained load like running a simulator while developing/running build watchers or running VM/docker and IDE/compiler) while being in 25W range which can be handled reasonably at this device size.
Unfortunately laptop manufacturers are so slow at adopting AMD in premium line laptops (I preorder a surface pro with an AMD 5xxx CPU). I don't see myself buying an Intel based laptop until they improve the thermals.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by AmVess on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:56AM
(#25747676)
Apple's M1 has shown us how antiquated and far behind Intel has become. My Macbook is not only much faster than my XPS unit, but it doesn't get hot, nor does it use up the battery in 4 hours.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by bserge on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:48AM
(#25748423)
It's the heatsink. And Apple isn't the only offender. All major manufacturers use terrible cooling systems, even on thick workstation class laptops. Their testing is seriously flawed, they design the heatsink for "normal workload" which means jack shit.
Everyone's got different uses for their machines, so just test the heatsink at maximum load/TDP for several hours at least, make sure it doesn't overheat. Is that too much to ask?
And if you design your laptops to be thin and light, don't shove a 6 core 45W processor in it... just don't. It will perform slower than a 4 core 35W chip, so what's the point? Having it on the spec sheet is not worth the negative feedback from buyers.
Apple went the other way with the M1, it doesn't overheat because it just uses much less power, while having the same performance. Really impressive.
You can fix the overheating problem by buying some good thermal paste and applying it yourself and/or by using software like Throttlestop to limit the maximum TDP (and even undervolt it to claw back some of that performance) and NotebookFanControl for the fans. Not sure if there are alternatives for the MacBook, though.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by reader_mode on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:57AM
(#25748550)
You can't under-volt on latest machines (mine included). I need to limit TDP to get the machine usable.
I've thought about opening it up and reapplying paste but I don't want to risk bricking my work device - I don't have the time to deal with it. I will have a few weeks off soon so might consider it if the expected gains are significant but from what I saw back when I looked into it (this[1] mostly) it's not worth it.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by AmVess on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:46AM
(#25749425)
It may drop the temp a few C or delay throttling, but small heatsinks and tiny fans can only dump so much heat out of the chassis. I did all kinds of things to my XPS, but the largest gain came from undervolting and it still sounded like a leafblower when it was being worked moderately hard.
My M1 Macbook on the other hand, is dead quiet on top of absolutely destroying the XPS in CPU performance while having vastly superior battery life. I don't have to run anything out of spec to keep it from cooking itself.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by reader_mode on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:14PM
(#25749905)
Yeah no doubt M1s are amazing, I'm kind of sad Apple is the only one with it because Apple isn't big on providing options. My ideal form factor is a Yoga or Surface Pro style - and iOS is not a real option.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by bserge on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:04PM
(#25750733)
That's unfortunate. Is it because of Plundervolt? Intel's answer to that was basically "lol, just disable manual voltage control", even older machines got BIOS updates disabling it, which made a tiny number of people angry.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by fomine3 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:13PM
(#25757114)
VAIO argue that they design great cooling system (with TruePerformance brand) so their laptop with lower TDP CPU performs better than other manufacturer's higher TDP laptop with crap cooling. It looks interesting because it's also portable, but it's expensive due to VAIO's selling scale.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by bserge on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:49AM
(#25760062)
That looks like Dell's Dynamic Tuning, which also dynamically adjusts performance. Except Dell still sells models with higher end processors that their cooling simply can't handle.
The result is hilarious: Dell's own machines with a lower end processor have equal or higher performance compared to the same models with higher end CPUs.
This is actually part Intel's fault, as with TurboBoost their processors with the same core count have nearly the same performance, so it makes little sense to pay $100-200 more for a "higher end" CPU unless it has more cores.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by kllrnohj on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @07:55PM
(#25756461)
The 15 MBP has worst-in-class thermal design. MacBooks have always had worst-in-class thermal designs, as Apple prioritized looks over function on that. Hence why there's no visible vents.
What a 15 MBP can and can't cool is therefore not very interesting. Thermally it's terrible. 45W is still going to be a challenge for other designs, but it can (and has) been done without being deafeningly loud like a MBP or monstrously thick. Simply having intake & exhaust vents beyond just the keyboard & hinge alone massively improves things here. But yes you will hear it under sustained load. But you're also doing whatever you're doing a lot faster as a result - it's a tradeoff here. You could always disable half the cores if you don't like the 45W, Intel will sell you quad cores all day long quite happily.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by jeffbee on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:04PM
(#25751745)
The 45W rating is hardly relevant. Excluding Apple, Intel 11th Gen Core CPUs are the fastest on most single-threaded benchmarks, whether they are configured at 15W, 27W, or 45W. In fact there is barely any difference in peak performance between the 15W and the 27W config.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by reader_mode on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:10PM
(#25753726)
That's the single core improvement you have between Zen 2 and Zen 3, but Zen 3 also has sightly better power usage than Zen 2 and Zen 2 was already superior (allegedly - I haven't actually used a Zen 2 mobile device since nothing really premium was built with it) - Zen 3 mobile isn't out yet but I suspect it's going to be a much better experience for mobile just like Zen 2 was compared to 10th gen intel.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by ksec on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:14AM
(#25747898)
1. Hamstring might not be fair to "Intel Compiler", as it was designed for Intel in the first place. Unfair Comparison would be a more valid description. i.e The problem is not with "Intel's compiler", the problem is with the benchmarks and marketing.
2. Keep in mind fastest Single Threaded benchmark is still somewhat true considering Intel can turbo up to 5Ghz.
3. TDP comparison between AMD and Intel are meaningless these days. They have different definition of TDP.
4. So if you put 2 and 3 together, that is like saying they have the fastest Laptop processor by overlocking it to 5Ghz with a higher energy usage within limited time frame.
Final Note: Generally speaking one should avoid wccftech unless you know precisely how to read into their rumours and findings. ( Unless their source are official like in this case ) Anandtech is a much better source.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by giantrobot on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:02PM
(#25749731)
The Intel compiler has been doing function multi-versioning for many years now. If you annotate a function for multi-versioning the compiler will build several optimized versions of it, including a generic version, running the most optimal one for the host CPU based on a CPUID check.
Intel purposefully misidentifies AMD chips with the CPUID check so always runs the generic version of a function on AMD. It does this even if the host AMD chip supports 100% of the features as some Intel CPU that runs the optimized version.
So for any benchmark compiled with ICC any results for AMD chips are meaningless. You can only compare Intel to Intel or AMD to AMD. Compiling that same code without FMV so each CPU runs the exact same instructions will see the difference between them narrow or reverse.
Intel is free to optimize the shit out of their compiler but it's bullshit that they also actively sabotage AMD chips at the same time. It's very much a vendor lock-in tactic.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by ksec on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:48PM
(#25750476)
>Intel is free to optimize the shit out of their compiler but it's bullshit that they also actively sabotage AMD chips at the same time. It's very much a vendor lock-in tactic.
I would argue they actively make sure their compiler optimisation works only on Intel CPU. Which is actually a fair deal. Those optimisation work isn't free.
It is BS tactics? Yes.
Do I Like it ? No.
It is wrong to do it? That is up to debate.
The point is using an Intel Compiler on Non Intel CPU comparison makes the benchmarks pretty much useless. Something like GCC / LLVM should have been used to be vendor neutral.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by giantrobot on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:09PM
(#25751817)
I don't find fault in Intel using insider knowledge to make their compilers work better on their own CPUs. If they make optimizations they know work on their CPUs but can't guarantee AMD CPUs will work exactly the same, I also don't find fault in them only supporting their CPUs with those optimizations.
Where I find fault is bullshit marketing saying their CPUs are x% faster than AMD and then point to code compiled with their compiler. I'd be fine if they wanted to say ICC produced faster results than GCC or LLVM. There's no problem selling your CPU with your compiler to get the best performance possible.
Instead they're saying our chips are faster than AMD. Full stop. Once you wade into the bullshit you see they're using ICC with FMV enabled. This means even if you know what compiler flags they used you still can't be sure what code is running on each CPU. It's bullshit marketing and I think it needs to be called out whenever it happens.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by mwcampbell on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:22AM
(#25748001)
45W hardly strikes me as "mobile". That's in the realm of laptops with fans and big batteries, right? I figured a "mobile" processor would need a maximum TDP of 15W or less.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by pja on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:41AM
(#25749323)
The M1 peaks at about 27W at max compute load. Apple TDPs are like Intel TDPs - they’re a benchmarking number pulled out of the air for marketing reasons that have at best a tenuous relationship with reality.
(This is not to undermine the fact that the M1 is a /great/ chip, but the 10W figure is a marketing number.)
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by GeekyBear on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:14PM
(#25752843)
There were a few caveats attached to those numbers.
>It’s especially important to keep in mind that the figure of what we usually recall as TDP in processors is actually only a subset of the figures presented here, as beyond just the SoC we’re also measuring DRAM and voltage regulation overhead, something which is not included in TDP figures nor your typical package power readout on a laptop.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by ogrisel on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:50AM
(#25749508)
A MacBook Air with M1 does not have a fan and I find it faster than my Dell XPS 13 from 2015 when running the scikit-learn test suite which is quite CPU intensive.
Running those tests on the XPS 13 would typically cause the fan to turn on after a minute or two if I remember correctly.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by pja on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:04PM
(#25749749)
One would hope that a CPU from 2020 would be faster than one shipped in 2015!
As I said, the M1 is a /great/ CPU. But the numbers are marketing numbers & should be treated as such. The same goes for the CPU in your XPS. It was sold with an advertised TDP, was probably configured by the manufacturer to a /different/ TDP target subject to the thermal constraints of the laptop & as an end-user you can shift the set-points of thermals vs power consumption yourself if you want to. None of this is new & Apple is no exception. If Intel hadn’t completely failed to deliver their last 2 fab shrinks, you’d be sat here raving about how amazing your passively cooled Intel Mac was I imagine.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by Macha on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:56AM
(#25746904)
The thoughts of reviewers based on their claims is that likely you will get something that is competitive with current gen ryzen mobile (4900h on the high end) on power usage/perf and competitive with m1 on perf, but not power usage. However, I don't see them drawing even with Apple on power efficiency, and AMD have their Zen 3 mobile chips in the near future, so it's more a holding on in technical quality. Likely they will outsell both though, given the M1's Mac exclusivity and the limited range of AMD laptops (and limited stock of TSMC 7nm everything currently) - try buy a 4900H system vs a 108xxH, it's much harder.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by agloeregrets on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:35AM
(#25748177)
Their perfromance claims will result in M1 multicore level probably with more cores but nowhere close in single core regardless of their shockingly false single core claims.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by Traster on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:53AM
(#25746856)
This specific announcement is an incredibly run of the mill "Intel produced a new larger variant of a chip they already make". It's still produced at 10nm, this is not any kind of big step forward to catching up with Apple.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by abacadaba on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:01AM
(#25746969)
So if I was gonna try to interpret tea leaves, did yields finally increase to where 8 cores on a die was viable or was it just limited to 4 cores before to maximize capacity?
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by zamadatix on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:35AM
(#25747391)
I would put it more as "Intel didn't do poorly this round" if all holds true to the information we have so far. AMD still hasn't overtaken them in low core count performance in the laptop space and this should hold them off from doing that until at least Zen 4 (late Fall-ish or so) or open Intel up more time to continue changing its momentum if Zen 4 falters any. In this space the M1 is still miles ahead both (i.e. AMD/Intel can generally match the performance or the power budget with their latest designs but the M1 can do both at the same time). On the desktop side the Rocket Lake S should just eek out Zen 3 on single core performance albeit ~6 months (or about half a product cycle) later. Certainly good news for Intel as it keeps them from being steamrolled in a single year but that means AMD still has higher momentum, a time advantage on the next release, a guarantee that TSMCs new 5nm process they want to use works (as used in the M1), and a significantly better many core position.
AMD has their presentation shortly but I wouldn't expect more than news on Zen 3 mobiles (which may dampen Intel's presentation a bit but probably won't outdo them) and Zen 3 Epyc (server, likely to wipe the floor) this early into it on the CPU side.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by Macha on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:52AM
(#25747629)
Currently (and for laptop CPUs specifically)
1. AMD Ryzen 4900H
2. Apple M1, though the Intel 10875H is pretty much the same perf (though at 3x the power usage)
3. Only Intel uses this, so whatever Intel's fastest chip on this process is.
That said, it varies by use cases, and M1 leans heavily on accelerators so has big wins in some and big losses in others when compared the 4900H or 10875H, which are closer to each other in single threaded benchmarks.
So per that the M1 is 8% faster in single-core than the 28W i7-1185G7 (side note: Intel fix your naming yeesh). It would not at all be surprising if Intel claws that back, that's well within "typical" generational IPC gains.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by ksec on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:18AM
(#25747950)
I assume some could actually answer your question with respect to designm but you would be asking the wrong question. Intel's main competitor is not ARM or AMD. It is TSMC's ecosystem. Which is ex-CEO Morris Chang calls it the Grand Alliance.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by yowlingcat on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:33AM
(#25747361)
Any thoughts on how Intel's going to address the out of control thermal envelopes? This whole recent episode in Intel history over the last few years just reminds me of the Prescott Pentium 4.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by m_st on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:48AM
(#25747576)
Quote form their slide: "Optimizing 11th gen power and performance in the best enthusiast platform for gaming & content creation"
Why should I be an enthusiast? Indeed I wait for a much faster laptop to replace my venerable Dell XPS15 9550 for software development. But my mom also deserves a fast laptop for web browsing and emailing.
It's funny how they try to segment the market because they can't deliver the same power to everyone. Yet we all deserve it.
Why should I even bother selecting a CPU option? Give me the best of the moment.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:53AM
(#25747644)
> It's funny how they try to segment the market because they can't deliver the same power to everyone. Yet we all deserve it.
You may feel that you deserve the sun and the moon, but getting Intel to agree with you on that will be harder than getting blood out of a stone. If you pay for it, you can have the best processor. Otherwise, you'll be getting something less.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by R0b0t1 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:40AM
(#25748276)
I find the word enthusiast problematic for different reasons. Enthusiast means non-professional tricked into spending way too much money. I intentionally avoid most things labelled enthusiast, it's a money pit because Intel wants your money.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by AmVess on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:49AM
(#25749487)
One of Intel's biggest scams is having top end mobile CPU's that actually perform worse than cheaper parts because they hit maximum TDP quickly and then throttle themselves into a giant state of anemia.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by ENOTTY on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:17AM
(#25747162)
Intel's 10nm SuperFin process at 5 GHz is quite impressive. Clocks like that, combined with the core improvements, should allow Intel to compete on performance and core count.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by kllrnohj on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:18PM
(#25749961)
Bold claim to make when you don't know the starting specs nor upgrade prices. Remember the $999 MBA is only 8GB RAM & 256GB SSD. It's not exactly a good configuration, and Apple's upgrade pricing means it quickly becomes a $1400-$1600 MBA when you give it modern specs on those two aspects.
The X1 Titanium Yoga then offers a touch screen, a better aspect ratio, convertible usage, and significantly faster multi-core performance, at least in bursts. That can easily be worth another $400 depending on the use case & personal preferences. It's also fully possible the X1 Titanium Yoga will be overpriced, of course.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by breakfastduck on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:35AM
(#25747388)
Yeah I've never understood the attitude of wanting someone like Intel to fail.
If they start pushing back with strong performing CPUs it will only increase competition and help push Apple and AMD even further.
Not sure why people think an AMD monopoly would be any better than the intel we've seen over the past 5 years.
If they lose their main competitor they'd take their foot off the gas on performance / process improvements & start to focus more and more on the bottom line alone, it's just natural.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by anovikov on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:16PM
(#25752863)
For me it's easier: what was the last time they built a CPU that was worth looking to buy a device that had it? Not in the last 15 years (ok first Core Duo was that thing, but it was so many years ago). I really gave up hoping to see them pleasantly surprise ever again.
Re:Intel’s 8-Core Mobile Tiger Lake-H, at 45 W, to Ship in Q1
by dijit on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:41AM
(#25748292)
> Yeah I've never understood the attitude of wanting someone like Intel to fail.
I can give a pretty clear reason: they deserve to.
They committed two cardinal sins and one that pisses me off personally:
1) Using their monopoly position to crush competition, over and over and over. Using shady business practices and their enormous wealth to kludge any person who could even attempt to compete.
Examples include: Cyrix, the 80386 branding (IE, trademarking "Pentium" so that they could force processor companies to be unable to claim "Pentium-compatible" after failing to trademark their CPU model numbers), crippling their compiler on AMD platforms (checking CPU version strings to enable CPU acceleration for things like AVX instead of checking CPUID like it should) and even going so far as to set embargos on their new CPUs until the day of large competitor product announcemnets to drown out the news or make the new products seem potentially uncompetitive and that consumers should wait for intel (more info here; https://www.overclock.net/threads/intel%E2%80%99s-behavior-i... )
Hell, they even changed the way they market TDP to be the "average" not the max load.
2) Resting on their laurals.
CPUs have stagnated in the desktop/laptop market for 10 years, meanwhile phones have caught up and even in some cases exceeded the performance of desktop/laptop CPUs, to the point where people are looking at Apples M1 as a revolution.
3) Aggressively segmenting the market, steering it towards bad ideas.
16 PCI lanes and lack of ECC memory are just a few things that are terrible about intel CPUs in the consumer market.
Those are not enthusiast requirements, those benefit everyone.
Intel say they have the fastest single threaded performance of any laptop processor.
They show a graph of a benchmark of something called SPECRATE * 2017_int_base compiled with the Intel compiler.
Does the Intel compiler still hamstring AMD?
Also is this benchmark useful in real world usage?
I have a 2018 15 MBP with an i9-8950HK that has the same power range - this thing is unusable at full load for anything but burst - and the way it taxes the thermals makes it a terrible laptop (people in the office start turning their heads).
I'm not convinced any portable laptop can handle that TDP efficiently - so maybe this is interesting for gaming laptops - but to me this looks like Intel is still making shitty power-hungry chips for laptops
They are boasting performance comparisons to AMD Navi 2, Navi 3 also brings a ~20% IPC improvement which they claim to have over it. I'd speculate that Ryzen 7 5800U should outperform this chip in most relevant use cases (eg. sustained load like running a simulator while developing/running build watchers or running VM/docker and IDE/compiler) while being in 25W range which can be handled reasonably at this device size.
Unfortunately laptop manufacturers are so slow at adopting AMD in premium line laptops (I preorder a surface pro with an AMD 5xxx CPU). I don't see myself buying an Intel based laptop until they improve the thermals.
Everyone's got different uses for their machines, so just test the heatsink at maximum load/TDP for several hours at least, make sure it doesn't overheat. Is that too much to ask?
And if you design your laptops to be thin and light, don't shove a 6 core 45W processor in it... just don't. It will perform slower than a 4 core 35W chip, so what's the point? Having it on the spec sheet is not worth the negative feedback from buyers.
Apple went the other way with the M1, it doesn't overheat because it just uses much less power, while having the same performance. Really impressive.
You can fix the overheating problem by buying some good thermal paste and applying it yourself and/or by using software like Throttlestop to limit the maximum TDP (and even undervolt it to claw back some of that performance) and NotebookFanControl for the fans. Not sure if there are alternatives for the MacBook, though.
I've thought about opening it up and reapplying paste but I don't want to risk bricking my work device - I don't have the time to deal with it. I will have a few weeks off soon so might consider it if the expected gains are significant but from what I saw back when I looked into it (this[1] mostly) it's not worth it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/96wwyf/so_i_rep...
My M1 Macbook on the other hand, is dead quiet on top of absolutely destroying the XPS in CPU performance while having vastly superior battery life. I don't have to run anything out of spec to keep it from cooking itself.
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Dell-Dynamic-Power-Policy-A-lo...
The result is hilarious: Dell's own machines with a lower end processor have equal or higher performance compared to the same models with higher end CPUs.
This is actually part Intel's fault, as with TurboBoost their processors with the same core count have nearly the same performance, so it makes little sense to pay $100-200 more for a "higher end" CPU unless it has more cores.
What a 15 MBP can and can't cool is therefore not very interesting. Thermally it's terrible. 45W is still going to be a challenge for other designs, but it can (and has) been done without being deafeningly loud like a MBP or monstrously thick. Simply having intake & exhaust vents beyond just the keyboard & hinge alone massively improves things here. But yes you will hear it under sustained load. But you're also doing whatever you're doing a lot faster as a result - it's a tradeoff here. You could always disable half the cores if you don't like the 45W, Intel will sell you quad cores all day long quite happily.
Is there a bar missing there? Just one bar, maybe just two letters?
Perhaps even running in x86 emulation?
Hardcore borders on false advertising.
2. Keep in mind fastest Single Threaded benchmark is still somewhat true considering Intel can turbo up to 5Ghz.
3. TDP comparison between AMD and Intel are meaningless these days. They have different definition of TDP.
4. So if you put 2 and 3 together, that is like saying they have the fastest Laptop processor by overlocking it to 5Ghz with a higher energy usage within limited time frame.
Final Note: Generally speaking one should avoid wccftech unless you know precisely how to read into their rumours and findings. ( Unless their source are official like in this case ) Anandtech is a much better source.
Intel purposefully misidentifies AMD chips with the CPUID check so always runs the generic version of a function on AMD. It does this even if the host AMD chip supports 100% of the features as some Intel CPU that runs the optimized version.
So for any benchmark compiled with ICC any results for AMD chips are meaningless. You can only compare Intel to Intel or AMD to AMD. Compiling that same code without FMV so each CPU runs the exact same instructions will see the difference between them narrow or reverse.
Intel is free to optimize the shit out of their compiler but it's bullshit that they also actively sabotage AMD chips at the same time. It's very much a vendor lock-in tactic.
I would argue they actively make sure their compiler optimisation works only on Intel CPU. Which is actually a fair deal. Those optimisation work isn't free.
It is BS tactics? Yes. Do I Like it ? No. It is wrong to do it? That is up to debate.
The point is using an Intel Compiler on Non Intel CPU comparison makes the benchmarks pretty much useless. Something like GCC / LLVM should have been used to be vendor neutral.
Where I find fault is bullshit marketing saying their CPUs are x% faster than AMD and then point to code compiled with their compiler. I'd be fine if they wanted to say ICC produced faster results than GCC or LLVM. There's no problem selling your CPU with your compiler to get the best performance possible.
Instead they're saying our chips are faster than AMD. Full stop. Once you wade into the bullshit you see they're using ICC with FMV enabled. This means even if you know what compiler flags they used you still can't be sure what code is running on each CPU. It's bullshit marketing and I think it needs to be called out whenever it happens.
(This is not to undermine the fact that the M1 is a /great/ chip, but the 10W figure is a marketing number.)
>It’s especially important to keep in mind that the figure of what we usually recall as TDP in processors is actually only a subset of the figures presented here, as beyond just the SoC we’re also measuring DRAM and voltage regulation overhead, something which is not included in TDP figures nor your typical package power readout on a laptop.
https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...
Running those tests on the XPS 13 would typically cause the fan to turn on after a minute or two if I remember correctly.
As I said, the M1 is a /great/ CPU. But the numbers are marketing numbers & should be treated as such. The same goes for the CPU in your XPS. It was sold with an advertised TDP, was probably configured by the manufacturer to a /different/ TDP target subject to the thermal constraints of the laptop & as an end-user you can shift the set-points of thermals vs power consumption yourself if you want to. None of this is new & Apple is no exception. If Intel hadn’t completely failed to deliver their last 2 fab shrinks, you’d be sat here raving about how amazing your passively cooled Intel Mac was I imagine.
these new chip is based on 10nm. this article say "Intel's current 10 nm yields are nowhere near viable for “full production”"
that's from 4 weeks ago. did Intel fix their yields problem in 4 weeks?
It seems that this year Apple has only secured 80% of TSMC 5nm production: https://wccftech.com/apple-secured-80-tsmc-5nm-production-ca...
AMD has their presentation shortly but I wouldn't expect more than news on Zen 3 mobiles (which may dampen Intel's presentation a bit but probably won't outdo them) and Zen 3 Epyc (server, likely to wipe the floor) this early into it on the CPU side.
That last part of the title would seem to imply that it's not the fastest overall.
Wonder what are:
1. the fastest overall
2. the fastest overall single thread
3. the fastest overall on the 10nm SuperFin process
1. AMD Ryzen 4900H
2. Apple M1, though the Intel 10875H is pretty much the same perf (though at 3x the power usage)
3. Only Intel uses this, so whatever Intel's fastest chip on this process is.
That said, it varies by use cases, and M1 leans heavily on accelerators so has big wins in some and big losses in others when compared the 4900H or 10875H, which are closer to each other in single threaded benchmarks.
In single core? At least by Geekbench (clearly not the best test) it is shown to be more than 25% slower than M1.
So per that the M1 is 8% faster in single-core than the 28W i7-1185G7 (side note: Intel fix your naming yeesh). It would not at all be surprising if Intel claws that back, that's well within "typical" generational IPC gains.
Is geekbech single core test a single thread test or two threads pinned to one core (if the cpu supports HT)?
Why should I be an enthusiast? Indeed I wait for a much faster laptop to replace my venerable Dell XPS15 9550 for software development. But my mom also deserves a fast laptop for web browsing and emailing.
It's funny how they try to segment the market because they can't deliver the same power to everyone. Yet we all deserve it.
Why should I even bother selecting a CPU option? Give me the best of the moment.
You may feel that you deserve the sun and the moon, but getting Intel to agree with you on that will be harder than getting blood out of a stone. If you pay for it, you can have the best processor. Otherwise, you'll be getting something less.
Yes since years, no.
If someone is not tied to Windows, it's hard to justify this over a $999 MBA.
The X1 Titanium Yoga then offers a touch screen, a better aspect ratio, convertible usage, and significantly faster multi-core performance, at least in bursts. That can easily be worth another $400 depending on the use case & personal preferences. It's also fully possible the X1 Titanium Yoga will be overpriced, of course.
Everyone should want Intel to perform at a high level.
If they start pushing back with strong performing CPUs it will only increase competition and help push Apple and AMD even further.
Not sure why people think an AMD monopoly would be any better than the intel we've seen over the past 5 years.
If they lose their main competitor they'd take their foot off the gas on performance / process improvements & start to focus more and more on the bottom line alone, it's just natural.
I can give a pretty clear reason: they deserve to.
They committed two cardinal sins and one that pisses me off personally:
1) Using their monopoly position to crush competition, over and over and over. Using shady business practices and their enormous wealth to kludge any person who could even attempt to compete.
Examples include: Cyrix, the 80386 branding (IE, trademarking "Pentium" so that they could force processor companies to be unable to claim "Pentium-compatible" after failing to trademark their CPU model numbers), crippling their compiler on AMD platforms (checking CPU version strings to enable CPU acceleration for things like AVX instead of checking CPUID like it should) and even going so far as to set embargos on their new CPUs until the day of large competitor product announcemnets to drown out the news or make the new products seem potentially uncompetitive and that consumers should wait for intel (more info here; https://www.overclock.net/threads/intel%E2%80%99s-behavior-i... )
Hell, they even changed the way they market TDP to be the "average" not the max load.
2) Resting on their laurals.
CPUs have stagnated in the desktop/laptop market for 10 years, meanwhile phones have caught up and even in some cases exceeded the performance of desktop/laptop CPUs, to the point where people are looking at Apples M1 as a revolution.
3) Aggressively segmenting the market, steering it towards bad ideas.
16 PCI lanes and lack of ECC memory are just a few things that are terrible about intel CPUs in the consumer market.
Those are not enthusiast requirements, those benefit everyone.
They do deserve to fail, but I don't want them to. I want them to throw resource at developing cutting edge CPU tech.