I have a 2018 15 MBP with an i9-8950HK that has the same power range - this thing is unusable at full load for anything but burst - and the way it taxes the thermals makes it a terrible laptop (people in the office start turning their heads).
I'm not convinced any portable laptop can handle that TDP efficiently - so maybe this is interesting for gaming laptops - but to me this looks like Intel is still making shitty power-hungry chips for laptops
They are boasting performance comparisons to AMD Navi 2, Navi 3 also brings a ~20% IPC improvement which they claim to have over it. I'd speculate that Ryzen 7 5800U should outperform this chip in most relevant use cases (eg. sustained load like running a simulator while developing/running build watchers or running VM/docker and IDE/compiler) while being in 25W range which can be handled reasonably at this device size.
Unfortunately laptop manufacturers are so slow at adopting AMD in premium line laptops (I preorder a surface pro with an AMD 5xxx CPU). I don't see myself buying an Intel based laptop until they improve the thermals.
Everyone's got different uses for their machines, so just test the heatsink at maximum load/TDP for several hours at least, make sure it doesn't overheat. Is that too much to ask?
And if you design your laptops to be thin and light, don't shove a 6 core 45W processor in it... just don't. It will perform slower than a 4 core 35W chip, so what's the point? Having it on the spec sheet is not worth the negative feedback from buyers.
Apple went the other way with the M1, it doesn't overheat because it just uses much less power, while having the same performance. Really impressive.
You can fix the overheating problem by buying some good thermal paste and applying it yourself and/or by using software like Throttlestop to limit the maximum TDP (and even undervolt it to claw back some of that performance) and NotebookFanControl for the fans. Not sure if there are alternatives for the MacBook, though.
I've thought about opening it up and reapplying paste but I don't want to risk bricking my work device - I don't have the time to deal with it. I will have a few weeks off soon so might consider it if the expected gains are significant but from what I saw back when I looked into it (this[1] mostly) it's not worth it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/macbookpro/comments/96wwyf/so_i_rep...
My M1 Macbook on the other hand, is dead quiet on top of absolutely destroying the XPS in CPU performance while having vastly superior battery life. I don't have to run anything out of spec to keep it from cooking itself.
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Dell-Dynamic-Power-Policy-A-lo...
The result is hilarious: Dell's own machines with a lower end processor have equal or higher performance compared to the same models with higher end CPUs.
This is actually part Intel's fault, as with TurboBoost their processors with the same core count have nearly the same performance, so it makes little sense to pay $100-200 more for a "higher end" CPU unless it has more cores.
What a 15 MBP can and can't cool is therefore not very interesting. Thermally it's terrible. 45W is still going to be a challenge for other designs, but it can (and has) been done without being deafeningly loud like a MBP or monstrously thick. Simply having intake & exhaust vents beyond just the keyboard & hinge alone massively improves things here. But yes you will hear it under sustained load. But you're also doing whatever you're doing a lot faster as a result - it's a tradeoff here. You could always disable half the cores if you don't like the 45W, Intel will sell you quad cores all day long quite happily.
Is there a bar missing there? Just one bar, maybe just two letters?
Perhaps even running in x86 emulation?
Hardcore borders on false advertising.
2. Keep in mind fastest Single Threaded benchmark is still somewhat true considering Intel can turbo up to 5Ghz.
3. TDP comparison between AMD and Intel are meaningless these days. They have different definition of TDP.
4. So if you put 2 and 3 together, that is like saying they have the fastest Laptop processor by overlocking it to 5Ghz with a higher energy usage within limited time frame.
Final Note: Generally speaking one should avoid wccftech unless you know precisely how to read into their rumours and findings. ( Unless their source are official like in this case ) Anandtech is a much better source.
Intel purposefully misidentifies AMD chips with the CPUID check so always runs the generic version of a function on AMD. It does this even if the host AMD chip supports 100% of the features as some Intel CPU that runs the optimized version.
So for any benchmark compiled with ICC any results for AMD chips are meaningless. You can only compare Intel to Intel or AMD to AMD. Compiling that same code without FMV so each CPU runs the exact same instructions will see the difference between them narrow or reverse.
Intel is free to optimize the shit out of their compiler but it's bullshit that they also actively sabotage AMD chips at the same time. It's very much a vendor lock-in tactic.
I would argue they actively make sure their compiler optimisation works only on Intel CPU. Which is actually a fair deal. Those optimisation work isn't free.
It is BS tactics? Yes. Do I Like it ? No. It is wrong to do it? That is up to debate.
The point is using an Intel Compiler on Non Intel CPU comparison makes the benchmarks pretty much useless. Something like GCC / LLVM should have been used to be vendor neutral.
Where I find fault is bullshit marketing saying their CPUs are x% faster than AMD and then point to code compiled with their compiler. I'd be fine if they wanted to say ICC produced faster results than GCC or LLVM. There's no problem selling your CPU with your compiler to get the best performance possible.
Instead they're saying our chips are faster than AMD. Full stop. Once you wade into the bullshit you see they're using ICC with FMV enabled. This means even if you know what compiler flags they used you still can't be sure what code is running on each CPU. It's bullshit marketing and I think it needs to be called out whenever it happens.
Intel say they have the fastest single threaded performance of any laptop processor.
They show a graph of a benchmark of something called SPECRATE * 2017_int_base compiled with the Intel compiler.
Does the Intel compiler still hamstring AMD?
Also is this benchmark useful in real world usage?