Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by simonebrunozzi on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:38AM
(#25712854)
> ...a regulation to replace the lottery-based allocation system for the controversial H-1B visa with a wage-based process
So, it seems that the deal is to switch from a "random" assignment, to one based on proposed wage, favoring - I presume - higher wages.
This might actually be an interesting idea. Let me explain.
I'm not up to date, but a few years ago the issue with H1-B was that the big Indian consulting firms (Wipro, Tata (TCS), HCL, Infosys, Tech Mahindra) [0] were used to submit a VERY large amount of H1-B applications, knowing that about 1/3rd to 1/4th of these would "win" the lottery and be accepted. As a result, most of the H1-B granted are theirs (top 3 in this list [1]).
At least, if it's wage-based instead of random, they would be forced to review the wages offered to Indians moving to the US to work for them.
I am not sure if there are other implications (did I miss something important in my little analysis?), but I think it would be something worth exploring more.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Danieru on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:44AM
(#25712440)
This is a good change which prevents body shops from privatizing the financial surplus of the visa. Right now body shops can flood the lottery and underpay their employees relative to direct hire h1b.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by leereeves on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:56AM
(#25712534)
I agree. The H-1B lottery favors exploiting foreign workers for relatively low paying tech jobs with poor working conditions. I hope this article is wrong about Biden reversing this.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by niq999 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:05AM
(#25712608)
For the record, I make $300/month as a hired software engineer here in Russia. I would prefer slightly better conditions, than no such opportunity at all.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by cpursley on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:55AM
(#25712972)
Nonsense. You can make this working as a cashier at Magnit (grocery chain). Average salary for non-skilled labor outside of Moscow is $500 per month. Probably higher when you consider the gray/black market (tax avoidance is huge here).
A competent software developer in Russia working remotely for western countries is making at least $20 per hour, and in many cases much more. Even a developer working for local companies is going to make several grand per month.
10 000 - 30 000 RUB which is $134 - $400. And that's not even Junior position, as it's required to have 1-3 years of experience to apply and plenty of checkboxes to tick.
I agree that good developer can find much better wages, especially if he's not hesitating to move to Moscow/SPb. But not every developer is good and not everyone is fine with relocating.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by 0xy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:09AM
(#25712634)
Is this common in Russia? It seems low even for a junior and even in Russia. When I look on Upwork and Freelancer, decent mid and senior level developers in Russia/Ukraine etc seem to charge $30/hour on the low end.
Can't you freelance for more money if that's true?
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Muromec on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:23AM
(#25712747)
It's probably just Russia. Software developer salaries in Ukraine[0] are usually in 2k-5k per month range with virtually no tax overhead. Median for the city of Kyiv was 2800 USD per month in 2020.
You probably can get as low as 300 working in public sector, but I'm not sure about that now.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Muromec on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:56AM
(#25714253)
Yes, all contracts in last 10 and something years I had were denominated in USD.
Now what you get -- that depends. It's either USD or EUR wired from abroad directly or equivalent sum in UAH if you have contract with Ukrainian entity (we simply can't have transactions inside the country in currencies other then hryvnia). You can't get your hands on hard cash in USD or EUR either way, but in the first scenario you can at least keep it and choose when to sell.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by kamidesu on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:26AM
(#25712763)
Not sure how common it is but it's not that difficult to get more.
A bit difficult for me to say what the exact numbers are at the moment but most of my friends make around 4 to 5 thousands USD after all taxes (nvidia, jetbrains, some remote work).
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by cosmodisk on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:55AM
(#25712968)
If he's in Russia, he gets paid in rubles. It's easier to just put out USD values everyone can understand considering how international HN is. Also,not sure if that's still the case but US dollars used to be tightly woven into day to day lives of Russians because of ruble's instability.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Muromec on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:59AM
(#25712991)
Well of course they get RUB, the question is -- whether the sum in RUB fluctuates along with exchange rate or stays fixed and they eat the cost of denomination.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Barrin92 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:01AM
(#25712569)
There's no evidence that this is true. H-1B workers are generally paid above market wages compared to workers of similar skill level[1].
This argument is often brought up when people compare median wages, but they seem to forget that half of the American workforce isn't paid the median wage.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by true_religion on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:03PM
(#25719015)
H1-B visas were intended to be used to exceptional workers in cases where there was genuine immediate need for them. Currently they are just being used for matters of convenience. That’s people true gripe with them.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by pg_bot on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:16AM
(#25712692)
The US should steal Australia's point based system of immigration. Put a value on the attributes we are looking for and if you reach that number of points you can immigrate. It is far too difficult to become a naturalized US citizen.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by christiansakai on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:35AM
(#25713227)
I personally know someone who managed to exploit H1B to work a relatively low skilled job who can be done by Americans instead. The person even managed to get a permanent residence an bringing his family with him. It was a motel manager job.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by carlsborg on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:04AM
(#25712598)
The UK did this really well with the erstwhile Tier1 visa program: no work restrictions (including starting your own company), but show us annual earnings of more than, for example 2x of the general populations average salary when you apply to renew every 2 years.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by setr on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:18AM
(#25712707)
Is that a problem? Isn’t the usual complaint that foreigners are happy to accept less pay, and h1bs are used to fuel that?
You want foreigners to cost more, to incentivize usage of the local population first — and the whole point of the h1b was supposed to be to “improve the average”, by only hiring for those skills/expertise that can be met by local population.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by smdz on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:20AM
(#25712717)
Why would a business pay 2x to someone when they can get the same output from a local at 1x pay? Unless they(business) are doing some financial trickery
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by Muromec on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:31AM
(#25712797)
>Why would a business pay 2x to someone when they can get the same output from a local at 1x pay?
In the Netherlands it's 2x of median salary across all job market, not 2x of the same position that could be filled by local. The idea of this policy is to prevent foreigners (which EU citizens are not) from outbidding locals and lowering the living standard in the country.
So if knowledge workers are a scarce resource which you can't find at home, you are naturally paying more.
Re:Trump administration goes ahead with rule to scrap visa l...
by kc10 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:32AM
(#25712806)
People who are already on H1B do not fall into this quota. Their visas can be extended up to 3+3 years or their employer should apply for a green card so they can stay beyond the 6 year limit.
So, it seems that the deal is to switch from a "random" assignment, to one based on proposed wage, favoring - I presume - higher wages.
This might actually be an interesting idea. Let me explain.
I'm not up to date, but a few years ago the issue with H1-B was that the big Indian consulting firms (Wipro, Tata (TCS), HCL, Infosys, Tech Mahindra) [0] were used to submit a VERY large amount of H1-B applications, knowing that about 1/3rd to 1/4th of these would "win" the lottery and be accepted. As a result, most of the H1-B granted are theirs (top 3 in this list [1]).
At least, if it's wage-based instead of random, they would be forced to review the wages offered to Indians moving to the US to work for them.
I am not sure if there are other implications (did I miss something important in my little analysis?), but I think it would be something worth exploring more.
[0]: https://www.deccanherald.com/business/economy-business/india...
[1]: https://www.myvisajobs.com/Reports/2020-H1B-Visa-Sponsor.asp...
A competent software developer in Russia working remotely for western countries is making at least $20 per hour, and in many cases much more. Even a developer working for local companies is going to make several grand per month.
10 000 - 30 000 RUB which is $134 - $400. And that's not even Junior position, as it's required to have 1-3 years of experience to apply and plenty of checkboxes to tick.
I agree that good developer can find much better wages, especially if he's not hesitating to move to Moscow/SPb. But not every developer is good and not everyone is fine with relocating.
English translation of this ad: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=ru&tl=en&u=https:/...
Can't you freelance for more money if that's true?
You probably can get as low as 300 working in public sector, but I'm not sure about that now.
[0] https://dou.ua/lenta/articles/salary-report-devs-june-2020/
Now what you get -- that depends. It's either USD or EUR wired from abroad directly or equivalent sum in UAH if you have contract with Ukrainian entity (we simply can't have transactions inside the country in currencies other then hryvnia). You can't get your hands on hard cash in USD or EUR either way, but in the first scenario you can at least keep it and choose when to sell.
This argument is often brought up when people compare median wages, but they seem to forget that half of the American workforce isn't paid the median wage.
[1]https://www.cato.org/blog/100-h-1b-employers-offer-average-m...
This certainly isn't true for someone like me.
You want foreigners to cost more, to incentivize usage of the local population first — and the whole point of the h1b was supposed to be to “improve the average”, by only hiring for those skills/expertise that can be met by local population.
In the Netherlands it's 2x of median salary across all job market, not 2x of the same position that could be filled by local. The idea of this policy is to prevent foreigners (which EU citizens are not) from outbidding locals and lowering the living standard in the country.
So if knowledge workers are a scarce resource which you can't find at home, you are naturally paying more.