News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by andrewem on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:53PM (#25688425)
You know what scares the shit out of me, to use your phrasing? The people on that site murdering me or overthrowing the government, so that they seize power and elections end or become irrelevant.

“The free Internet” has value, but it’s not the only thing that has value. When it conflicts with other values, then there has to be a nuanced resolution.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by lldbg on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:14PM (#25688820)
"We can guarantee freedom of speech, but not freedom after speech." Idi Amin.

This year I have barely spoken more than 30 minutes to someone in real life, per day. If my interactions over the internet were to be as they say curated, I would effectively be silenced.

I was a frequent reader of r/dt a few years back, as the top poster was. There was nothing in particular there, no trend, that was any more terrible than what I could find in my bookshelf. Deal with it.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:47PM (#25689361)
Your bookshelf doesn’t analyze your reading habits and recommend other books specifically to drag you deeper into the rabbit hole of extremism.

Your bookshelf doesn’t allow you to instantly connect with thousands of likeminded people to incubate terrorist plots.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by ng12 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:59PM (#25689555)
> drag you deeper into the rabbit hole of extremism

This is what banning /r/the_donald and now /r/donaldtrump did. It doesn't stop the users from believing what they believe, it just further isolates them in an echo changer while simultaneously reinforcing the belief that the liberal media is "out to get them".

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:03PM (#25689626)
But crucially, it also makes it much more difficult for unwitting people to start discovering it. The point is to slow the spread, not to reach the people who are already there.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by zamadatix on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:16PM (#25689828)
The idea that the only way to protect unwitting people from falling into some undesirable line of thinking is to limit what they see to the desirable line of thinking seems doomed to fail. Either discourse works and you expect people can be made to come to their own sensible conclusions or discourse doesn't work and every change from the norm must be subversive. I.e. tucking it away doesn't guarantee it ends up less visible to people it just guarantees it will be less visible to the system tucking it away. People are still going to share ideas that don't agree with the majority opinion but now those hearing have zero tools or experience for dealing with such claims.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:35PM (#25690097)
Memes as viruses seems apt. There's a fine balance between exposure leading to herd immunity, and pure isolation making the entire population susceptible to being swept up in a collective insanity once a novel one emerges or re-emerges from generational turnover (eg Marxism or Nazism.) Anyone pretending like one or the other is a global maximum is wrong, and pulling us closer to something non-balanced creates risk around the worst case befalling us in that regime.

The obvious question in this analogy is if there's anything akin to a vaccine. Well, when it comes to bigotry, I think having people you care about in your life that are in tribes or groups being demonized by bigots is just that. And a society of liberal norms of the free exchange of ideas and democracies acts similar to a culture of hand washing and cleanliness in a society where people are free to interact with the sick.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by triceratops on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:45PM (#25690930)
> simultaneously reinforcing the belief that the liberal media is "out to get them".

These people are brainwashed. No concrete action normies take can convince them. They have to decide to get better and ask for help. And we must help them, without judgment or scolding, when that happens. But at some point, you have to stop a policy of appeasement because it doesn't work. They'll just keep pushing and taking more and more.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rorykoehler on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:22PM (#25689913)
What would you do?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by ng12 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:31PM (#25690051)
Leave it alone. Reddit did the right thing early on by minimizing /r/td spam on the front page. Aside from that I'm convinced there were no problems posed by /r/td or /r/donaldtrump aside from those invented by the small, vocal minority of pearl-clutchers complaining that someone somewhere on Reddit was posting things they disagreed with.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:42PM (#25690178)
An interesting thought exercise is if the whole thing which happened would have been avoided if they were allowed to stay on reddit. They were driven to another site, and I can say for sure the level of extremism was unchecked in comparison by their own community at that point. On reddit, they at least were exposed to more formalized community moderation as well as regular influx of more level headed people who often tried to talk sense into some of the more extreme members. I think some good faith efforts and ground rules were in place on the new site, but a lot of this insurrection shit seems like it would have gone very differently on a more public facing reddit subforum.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rorykoehler on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:36PM (#25690115)
Would you take down posts around organising an attempted coup? Where is the line? I'm asking because I see both sides but err on your side but I also know it's a very suboptimal solution.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by bra-ket on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:00PM (#25689571)
I'd argue it further isolates users in those liberal echo-chambers from hearing a different opinion.

Given the heavy left leaning media bias it leads to free speech being free as long as it doesn't disagree with the 'party line'.

I.e. the same dynamics as in communist Soviet Union where 'enemies of the people' were ostracized and persecuted by totalitarian regime.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cygx on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:16PM (#25689829)
Given the heavy left leaning media bias

Note that Fox News remains the most-watched cable news network - though online, it ranks after CNN and NYT (and possibly others, depending on the metric).

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:41PM (#25690156)
Because Fox is the primary "mainstream" news source for conservative viewers. There are many more left-leaning news networks so their viewers are more divided. The majority of remaining news channels/networks/etc. have liberal bias.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cygx on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:47PM (#25690947)
Viewers have various options to choose from (eg CNN, MSNBC, Fox, Newsmax, ...). The divion CNN+MSNBC vs Fox (in terms of, say, viewership or ad revenue) seems to be roughly comparable to what you'd expect from voter demographics.

If, say, Newsmax rose to prominence and we'd see more fragmentation on the 'right', or CNN and MSNBC were to merge, and we'd see less fragmentation on the 'left', what would that change?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:09PM (#25702783)
Just looking at the "AllSides Media Bias Chart" there are more "major" sources that are left-leaning than right [0]. The chart includes top sources by traffic. I mean this doesn't calculate all traffic and determine if in general left sources are more viewed but it's a start.

[0] https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-chart

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cygx on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:53PM (#25721870)
The chart includes top sources by traffic

But traffic is decided by the market. There's nothing wrong with left-leaning media being more popular.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by acdha on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:27PM (#25708157)
That’s a very subjective chart and by their own admission doesn’t even try to compare for honesty or credibility. Most of the two R columns routinely run fake or highly selective coverage to a degree which only Democracy Now and certain HuffPost writers approach.

There is an enormous difference between an outlet like the New Yorker, which is definitely liberal but also fiercely committed to fact checking, and outlets like Newsmax or The American Conservative which are proudly movement conservatives first and journalists second, if at all.

This desire to present a false equivalence is understandable - it makes it easier to avoid acknowledging a major schism in the country - but the misrepresentations requires are a disservice to their readers. Just the fact that The Economist is listed as leftist to the same degree that The Post Millenial or NY Post are listed as right wing tells you how interested they are in accuracy!

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:09PM (#25719880)
> That’s a very subjective chart

Can you explain? On the site:

> The AllSides Media Bias Chart is more comprehensive in its methodology than any other media bias chart on the Web. While other media bias charts show you the subjective opinion of the one person who made it, our ratings are based based on multipartisan, scientific analysis.

> and by their own admission doesn’t even try to compare for honesty or credibility

I don't think this matters in the context of the point I was making.

> Most of the two R columns routinely run fake or highly selective coverage

Hmm, so this further reduces the number of quality right-leaning sources. Seems to further prove my point. Remember, the chart shows sites with the most traffic.

> There is an enormous difference between an outlet like the New Yorker, which is definitely liberal but also fiercely committed to fact checking, and outlets like Newsmax or The American Conservative which are proudly movement conservatives first and journalists second, if at all.

Maybe, but it doesn't matter in the context of my point. Also, if they are clear about their biases it shouldn't matter, unless presenting outright lies. Many left-leaning sources try to come off like they are objective. Also:

> A leading New Yorker writer omits crucial facts to run interference for Joe Biden against serious allegations of corruption in Ukraine, writes Joe Lauria. [0]

Many left-leaning sources were also guilty of this (twitter going so far as take down the tweet from the NY Post as "hacked information" even though there was zero evidence this was the case, and Facebook de-prioritizing shared link of the same).

This is my opinion and based around some examples I've seen, but I believe that conservative sources have a tougher time making money, because people will attack their ad-partners for supporting those companies. I'd like to see where this happens to left-leaning sources.

[0] https://consortiumnews.com/2019/10/08/the-new-yorkers-partis...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:06PM (#25689673)
Perhaps we should leave up ISIS recruitment videos, so users in liberal echo chambers can hear that differing opinion as well. /s

This is not a new or exciting phenomenon. Censorship and “cancel culture” have rich histories on all sides of the American political spectrum.

[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:59PM (#25690427)
There's a reason you're reacting to my comparison of these people to ISIS, rather than suggesting that ISIS recruitment videos be permitted. ISIS represents something "beyond the pale", so obviously bad that it's okay if we censor it because it's dangerous and seditious.

You object to the comparison because it's an attack. We all know ISIS is bad, so the only reason to comparing these people to them is to make it seem like they're bad too, even though they're trying to say a lot of reasonable things if someone would just listen with an open mind!

Obviously, not everyone on r/DonaldTrump is down to invade the capitol. I'm sure there are plenty of people who support ISIS that don't support their violence either. No group is homogenously made up of cartoon villains. But that doesn't mean we need to be fine with the recruiting grounds for their most violent sects.

To be clear, your rhetorical position is the exact same as mine. You're perfectly fine with the exact same censorship you're ostensibly criticizing. You just want the line to be drawn somewhere else.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rorykoehler on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:24PM (#25689952)
>In this case conservatives are bundled into a group of ‘fascists’, ‘racists’, ‘nazis’, literally and without sarcasm,

That's what they are though. One side of my family are full-on conservative Trump supporters and I know for a fact that's exactly who they are.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:44PM (#25690208)
Conservatives make up roughly 50% of the United States. Are you saying all conservatives are ‘fascists’, ‘racists’, ‘nazis’?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rorykoehler on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:48PM (#25690269)
It is certainly looking that way to me. At least ~80% of them. They're all going along with this bullshit apart from a few more principled ones who are in it for the money/ self enrichment only.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by _zg4q on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:04PM (#25694066)
I think it's unfortunate that you feel this way, especially if it's without any evidence. I wouldn't say that 80% of liberals are communists and socialists. I think this mentality will only further the division between sides.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by uoaei on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:42AM (#25697664)
I highly recommend you do some studying of how Weimar Germany led to the rise of Hitler.

It is no exaggeration to say that Trump is playing from a handbook which is poorly scribbled and obviously plagiarized from Hitler's.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:25AM (#25701649)
I don't believe most conservatives agree with his rhetoric, they just like his policies for the most part. They probably don't even like him much, they just dislike the direction the democratic side is going enough to vote for him.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by krapp on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:41AM (#25701828)
> I don't believe most conservatives agree with his rhetoric, they just like his policies for the most part. They probably don't even like him much, they just dislike the direction the democratic side is going enough to vote for him.

"I don't care for Hitler's rhetoric, I just voted for the Nazis because I think he has some good ideas about infrastructure and I like his jobs plan" doesn't exactly come across as sympathetic. Especially not after it becomes obvious where the trains are going.

If you're a conservative or a Republican who supports Trump for his politics alone, or because he was the R and you hate the D, the moral thing to do as of January 6 is to disavow Trump entirely, and look for another candidate who supports his views, or perhaps consider supporting a third party. Not to dig in and continue making excuses for him and his supporters.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:03PM (#25702699)
Can you be upset and disavow what someone says but still support them? The instant someone says something "bad" they should be just thrown out?

I don't agree with a lot of what Trump says, but I don't hold him accountable for others' actions unless he specifically called for violence which I don't think he did in this case. He does say some questionable things, but has always disavowed violence on both sides.

Obama has promulgated lots of anti-police rhetoric, and there are some who would blame him for certain attacks on police. I disagree with things he said, but would not blame him for any of that.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by krapp on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:32PM (#25703746)
If you truly can't see any relationship between Trump's rhetoric and the behavior of his extremist base - particularly with the conspiracy theory of the 2020 election being stolen from him - a conspiracy theory he continued to spread at every available moment and which provided the impetus behind numerous incidents of violence leading up to the events at the Capitol just days earlier - then we may be at an impasse.

As far as I can tell, Obama is considered "anti-police" simply because he supports BLM, but BLM have legitimate concerns about police violence and systemic racism in law enforcement, and voicing those concerns doesn't make one anti-police. I have yet to find an "anti-police" statement made by Obama which condemns all police and calls them all evil, that is at all equivalent to the vitriol or paranoia in Trump's rhetoric.

It seems like a false equivalence drawn between the two.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:56PM (#25704055)
There are people out there that are crazy, and will use anything to justify their actions. Unless he called for a specific action, I don't see how he is to blame. It would be setting a bad precedent to blame or punish anyone that said something provacative that is not explicitly a call for inciting harm/violence. People need to be held responsible for their own actions.

I believe Obama used carefully picked statistics to say there is widespread racism in the police. There are likely racist people/cops, but I don't believe there is evidence to suggest widespread racism.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rorykoehler on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:20AM (#25701606)
> I wouldn't say that 80% of liberals are communists and socialists.

That’s because they aren’t. Most liberals are pro globalisation which is the de facto pro business policy.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by kuzimoto on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:28AM (#25701680)
Do you have proof that concervatives are?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by flukus on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:13PM (#25691214)
You skipped over it, just to be clear, do you think ISIS recruitment videos should be allowed to stay up?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by rblatz on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:10PM (#25689740)
The media is moderate, not left leaning. But anything left of Donald trump is considered socialist by his supporters.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:15PM (#25689823)
The media is more left leaning than 1) the median of the population and 2) the media was 20 years ago.

I think 1) is what's driving the "media is left" feeling. It is left compared to the median of society. To many people (not just on the far right), that feels like the media pushing leftist views/narratives/agendas.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:08PM (#25689709)
Such further isolation and radicalization was inevitable, large companies weren't going to host the process on their servers.

As they have every right not to do.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by bosswipe on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:11PM (#25689751)
What it does do is prevent them from recruiting from redit's normie population for free.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by lldbg on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:12PM (#25689767)
Among the first few pages in many of my books are recommendations for other similar books from the same publisher, and not infrequently the author himself cites related works.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:18PM (#25689855)
Are you saying that references to other books is the equivalent to an algorithm designed to get more clicks?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by lldbg on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:34PM (#25690082)
no
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:09PM (#25689716)
Do you accept that there is a difference between r/dt and your bookshelf?

In principal, are they different technologies? Or is all information, regardless of medium equal?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:03PM (#25688625)
I agree. Why would you think that I thought the free Internet is the only thing that has value? That's a nonsensical position. My point was that if a company shuts this down with an SSL cert hack of some kind, it may be just or even backed by law enforcement, but it exposes a vector for suppression by corporations of the Internet that I had not considered before and we need to understand the high order effects from that.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:19PM (#25688899)
Just yesterday HN had a link to an article on plaintext HTTP for the modern era. I'm not condoning illegal/dubious attempts to silence dissent, but loss of an SSL cert doesn't really suppress anyone's ability to communicate.

Tell me I'm wrong.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:26PM (#25689038)
You're wrong to the degree SSL becomes a requirement burned into browsers, which seems highly likely and is partially true already for certain domains. Unless you're going to argue that being forced onto the non-web is not suppressing your ability to communicate, but if so that's a tough argument to dig into here.

edit: I should add here the thought exercise is that you are participating in speech that is legal and ethical but are overruled by SSL cert providers and are unable to get a root signed cert from anyone (or whatever other means of preventing SSL.) In that case, even if you are not hard blocked, having your speech be passed around the internet in cleartext also seems like it affects your ability to communicate in a negative way.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:59PM (#25692781)
as noted by others, you do not need an SSL cert to be on the web. You need an SSL cert to use https, which is something entirely different.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:44PM (#25689318)
1) Browsers no longer let you (easily/ 2-click) override some ssl errors, and the overwhelming trend has been to start treating a lack of https similar to an ssl error, as far as ui goes.

2) Is this practically any different than saying newsgroups, or even bbs(?), still exist, so those avenues for free speech are viable remedies for being otherwise suppressed.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by grkvlt on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:06PM (#25689671)
1. seems unlikely. I don't think there's any mainstream browser that presents http://myrandomsite.whatever/ as an SSL error, in the same way as, say https://google.com/ having an invalid certificate, nor is there ever likely to be.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by farisjarrah on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:01PM (#25689598)
To your first point: Firefox still lets you easily override a ssl error with 2 clicks. Go to the site, click "Advanced" and then click "Accept the risk and continue". Using the most up to date version of firefox on MacOS, Linux and Windows.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:20PM (#25689891)
Only for certain types of ssl errors. The advanced button has been removed from some of the error pages.

*Although it's mostly been chrome. I did at least see it on Firefox while att tried to MitM errors during a recent outage.

I believe the recent att router bit-flipping issue resulted in the same.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by tsimionescu on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:11PM (#25689760)
I'm pretty sure that even FF won't let you easily override an error on a site with HSTS that presents an invalid certificate.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by marcosdumay on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:11PM (#25688770)
That's why you create some sort of police, have them look at those places, and watch if anything leads to some real world movement.

You should also watch it for damaging lies, and have a judiciary system that makes them fix any damage those lies create.

What you don't create is a paraestatal censor authority empowered to cut any information it wants out of the internet. (You don't create an estatal one either, but that's not what we are talking about here.)

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:27PM (#25689049)
Were you scared of the women’s March murdering you after they “stormed” the capitol? https://twitter.com/EgSophie/status/1048634940169048064?s=20
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:52PM (#25689434)
This is like hearing someone at a bank saying they were scared a masked robber was going to murder them, and responding “were you scared of the customer who came in before them murdering you too?”

The terrorists who stormed the capital on Wednesday have a history of violence and connections to various far right extremist and terrorist groups. They came carrying weapons, zip ties and bombs. Don’t pretend there’s no difference between the two groups.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Damorian on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:15PM (#25689815)
And the last 6 months of race riots? I'll take a few smashed windows and pictures taken in congress over tens of millions in burned and stolen property, assaults and murders in basically every city in the country. "Only my side's political violence is acceptable." That's what I get from facebook.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:33PM (#25690066)
The BLM protests — the overwhelming majority of which were peaceful [1] — stretched over 6 months and involved thousands of events and millions of people. After all that… 19 people died [1].

The terrorist attack yesterday exceeded a quarter of that death toll in a matter of hours.

I don't know how to explain that invading our nation's capitol with the intent of capturing and murdering politicians is different than breaking into a Target.

[1] https://time.com/5886348/report-peaceful-protests/

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_and_controversies_dur...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Damorian on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:43PM (#25690192)
I appreciate you taking the time to tell me how to think. I know what I saw both locally and on TV. You can give me as many bubble-filtered thoughts as you like, but you're trying to convince me that I saw and experienced something that I didn't see and experience.

Let me know when I can't get my wife's medication again because right wing ""terrorists"" smashed up my pharmacy, or when parts of my city are completely off limits for violence, or when one the teachers in my school district gets arrested for assaulting somebody filming them burning a car. I'm not losing sleep over congress getting delayed for a couple of hours. I'll keep my perspective that all political violence is bad, and that I want little to do with politics in general, but one side of extremists in particular has caused more problems for me than another.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:53PM (#25690351)
Your argument amounts to “When we do it, it’s okay.”

It’s founded on the presumption of bad faith, which is bad faith in itself.

The fact is that the only people who died during the 1/6/21 event were part of the protestors.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:16PM (#25690622)
"Your argument amounts to, 'when a customer enters the bank, it's okay.'"

Just because two groups have opposing political aims doesn't mean they're equivalent. One attempted to take our nation's capital by force, the other attempted a sit in.

Show me literally one single source that indicates the Women's March people were out for blood. Were there any casualties? Injuries? Was there even any fighting?

Your fact is false, by the way. The terrorists murdered a Capitol Police officer. https://www.cnn.com/2021/01/08/politics/capitol-police-offic...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:45PM (#25690927)
Show me one source that proves that the trump supporters were “out for blood.”

The point of the protest was not to “take the capital by force.” That’s cartoonish and unrealistic. The point was to express disapproval of the election results. Where do you get your information from?

Sicknick died as a result of a blood clot in his brain. His death was not the direct result of any protestors actions.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:50PM (#25690987)
Show you a source that says the people who murdered someone were out for blood? You say he died due to a blood clot in his brain, but the police statement says that he died due to injuries sustained while physically engaging with protestors, and a homicide investigation is open.

Not literally everyone was there to take the capitol, obviously. But that was the point for many people. This was entirely predictable. See [1] [2] or especially [3], wherein someone back in December describes exactly what ended up happening.

Why bring guns and zip ties if you're not there for violence?

[1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/science/2021-01-08/us-capitol-st...

[2] https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/internet/extremists-made-little...

[3] https://twitter.com/ariehkovler/status/1341016471795843080?s...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:04PM (#25691122)
> Why bring guns and zip ties if you're not there for violence?

Got it, so you have no evidence they were out for blood. It’s just a bad faith assumption on your part, ignoring that people often carry weapons for good faith reasons. Ignoring that no one was attacked with said guns except for the protestors.

It has not been proven that Sicknick was murdered. He died due to a blood clot that happened while he was on duty.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:10PM (#25691185)
I provided two links full of evidence and one very accurate prediction. But anyway.

What is a good faith explanation for forcing your way into the capitol with guns and zip ties?

What is the good faith explanation for e.g. this video? https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2021/01/08/ash...

Again, show me literally one single source indicating that the Women’s March sit in was remotely like this.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:28PM (#25691358)
I never claimed the women’s March storming of the capital were out for blood.

Ashli Babbitt was killed by law enforcement. If law enforcement was not deployed it’s not clear there would have been any deaths. If law enforcement were deployed on the women’s March Storming of the capital, maybe they would have injured or killed protestors as well.

But regardless, the actions of the maga protestors did not directly cause the death of anyone. Doesn’t matter what you want to assume about their guns, you can’t deny that.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:56PM (#25691604)
Your original question was whether OP was scared of the Women’s March murdering them. The implication is that by some important metric, the sit in was indistinguishable from the terrorist attack on Wednesday. You haven’t provided any evidence for that, other than telling me that it’s bad faith to presume violent intent behind the armed people scaling walls and breaking down doors.

We haven’t even mentioned that many of the invaders came bearing Nazi symbols and/or were members of known violent groups like the Proud Boys. I suppose that it’s unfair to presume that someone wearing a 6MWE shirt isn’t coming to be peaceful?

Obviously it’s impossible to prove conclusively whether or not there would have been deaths without law enforcement. But there are multiple accounts of them assaulting journalists. What do you think they would have done had they made it to the floor of the Senate without police there?

What, exactly, do you think the zip ties were for?

I will concede that a medical examiner has not confirmed the officer’s cause of death. But signs point to him being killed by one of the terrorists, so I’ll continue to describe it as murder until evidence arises to the contrary.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:31PM (#25692104)
> Your original question was whether OP was scared of the Women’s March murdering them.

Yes the point of the question was to tease out what concrete differences there were between the two to justify fear of murder in the second case. It seems like his fear is more based on narrative and assumption of bad faith than any direct evidence of intent to “take the capital” violently. The violence was perpetrated against the protestors, not by them.

> But signs point to him being killed by one of the terrorists, so I’ll continue to describe it as murder until evidence arises to the contrary.

You should assume innocence until proof of wrongdoing. Anything else is illiberal.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:56PM (#25692737)
The evidence exists, whether or not your confirmation bias will let you see it.
[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mint2 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:36PM (#25690111)
Except what you’re saying is false. Democrats overwhelmingly condemned the riots and violence during the BLM protests. But most protests and protestors were peaceful and they supported those ones.

If everyone is going to knowingly twist facts like your post does, there is no point in even trying to debate.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by adolph on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:59PM (#25691628)
Snopes: Campaign staffers for U.S. Democratic 2020 presidential candidate Joe Biden contributed to a bailout fund for protesters arrested after the police in-custody death of George Floyd.

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/biden-staffers-bailout-fun...

Harris, a former California state attorney general, asked the public to bail out protesters

https://www.factcheck.org/2020/09/reviewing-the-facts-in-ant...

Can you talk about rioting as a tactic? What are the reasons people deploy it as a strategy?

It does a number of important things. It gets people what they need for free immediately, which means that they are capable of living and reproducing their lives without having to rely on jobs or a wage — which, during COVID times, is widely unreliable or, particularly in these communities is often not available, or it comes at great risk. That's looting's most basic tactical power as a political mode of action.

https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2020/08/27/906642178...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mint2 on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:06PM (#25694131)
> Biden has publicly stated his opposition to the cash-bail system, referring to the practice as a “modern-day debtors’ prison.” However, no evidence exists to suggest that donated funds came directly from the campaign.

You do realize posting bail isn’t excusing the punishment?

And Biden repeatedly condemned violence and the rioters. He and the other prominent dems did not spend months encouraging them.

And that NPR article is some rando, not a Congress person or anyone else important. Why did you even bring up some rando? If that’s the most relevant person you can find then you’re providing strong evidence against your case.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by adolph on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:27PM (#25695573)
>You do realize posting bail isn’t excusing the punishment?

There is no need to excuse or not excuse. People’s words are rarely as enlightening about their value system as their actions. By promoting the posting of bail for those arrested during protests in which much harm was caused those that promoted that bailout show that they are interested in continuing those actions. If Democrats such as Sen Harris held as a value the true problem of process as punishment and the unfair cash bail, there was plenty of time before and after that point in history to promote it. By choosing that point in time they actions spoke louder than words as to what they value.

I’m glad that the president elect has spoken against cash bail although it seems to be a subject out of his federal expertise.

NPR and particular parts of the organization are ostensibly nonpartisan but are in such alignment with Democratic Party positions value-wise that the assertion of nonpartisanship is a distinction is without a difference. I write and think that as a lifelong listener. By promoting “In Defence of Looting” when they did it was clear that it wasn’t a random book review but an editorial statement of what behavior was acceptable and a dramatic non-denunciation of extra-legal actions taken by people peripheral to the protests of the period.

Would you be willing to wager something about some concrete action a Biden administration could take about cash bail that would indicate a care for the topic outside of the quadrennial BLM protests? It might be a block grant to assist municipalities in decreasing cash bail or a regulatory restriction on funding that encouraged the same, or some other class of concrete action that wasn’t just words.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mint2 on Monday January 11, 2021 @11:56AM (#25731696)
Fiy, California had repeatedly tried to end cash bail. California’s senator, and the 2nd in command in Biden’s admin, has also advocated abolishing cash bail. Are you seriously telling me you think the only reason you think the Biden admin cares is political points on the left during BLM protests?
[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jakelazaroff on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:13PM (#25690600)
Proud Boys and QAnon were both out in force. What's the story on them?

What's the story on all the people wearing Nazi regalia? The people carrying guns and zip ties?

[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:49AM (#25697722)
> Why not pay attention to the hundreds of thousands of Americans who came to DC to protest but had nothing to do with the storming of the capitol?

Because they didn’t break into congress? There’s a special type of attention you deserve when you form a mob and storm national legislatures (as seen on TV!), and neither the peaceful protesters from the Trump rally or BLM did that.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by runarberg on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:55PM (#25689485)
Again, there is room for nuance.

There is a fundamental difference between storming the house with the intent of stopping a democratic process (the confirming of the next president) and marching to it to deliver a message.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by nwsm on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:55PM (#25689479)
Was I scared by people sitting on the Capitol steps [sic]?

No I was not.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by brayhite on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:57PM (#25689520)
I sincerely hope you don't mean this to be comparable. Beating police with batons? Stealing their riot shields? Spraying them with mace? Stealing property from the capitol?

You and I both know that if all the folks did yesterday was go into the Capitol and march and chant in the halls, they'd be framed as deranged lunatics who might've gone a bit too far - not domestic terrorists. Show me the video evidence from the women's march where they coordinated a group to push into the police while yelling for "fresh patriots" to come to the front line and push back.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:10PM (#25689734)
That's part of the point.

The left was basically allowed to freely enter the Senate building, in an attempt to sway the ongoing confirmation vote of a scotus justice, and met little to no police resistance, and it was celebrated by the media.

Replace "confirmation" with "certification", and "scotus justice" with "president," and what's the difference, politically?

[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:33PM (#25690074)
You make my point exactly:

the left portends to have authoritative insight over the intent of others... based only on their biased perception or desire. And that is precisely the problem.

You just did it to me.

The media does it depending on whether they want "mostly peaceful protests march" or "attempted violent coup."

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:22PM (#25695518)
Please...

There is no honest way to suggest that the events of this week are comparable to the events surrounding the protesting of appointments.

I will note however, that you're subtly changing the topic when you change your argument from the protests about the appointment of a judge to the "mostly peaceful protests".

Again, this is bad faith. You are just moving the goal posts to try and suite your argument.

Edit: I conflated the womens march with the protest about the appointment of scotus judge.

[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:22PM (#25695526)
I wont fall for this nonsense and I encourage anyone reaching this depth to recognize this as the problem we all have to learn to combat.

These people are far to accustom to being rewarded for this rhetoric and double speak.

As I said before, we must learn to call a spade a spade without being guilt tripped into pretending we can't notice the non-spades.

I say it again sir. This argument is bad faith.

As evidence, I encourage you to re-read your argument. Do you not see the difference of the events that YOU are describing?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:16PM (#25691245)
> You're right, the women's march protests were far more dangerous.

This is beyond bad faith, this is an open "fuck you" to anyone that dares participate in this discussion. To shut it down, to make any sort of dialogue impossible.

And you say the left wants to censor, what a laugh.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by ufmace on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:06PM (#25691690)
The only "bad faith" going on here is the left's pathetic attempt to shut down any mention of the political violence that they have been encouraging and celebrating for the last 4 years and the 6 months of nationwide rioting they've cheered on.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:35PM (#25693439)
You clearly don't understand what a bad faith argument is. Every word you say demonstrates it.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:12PM (#25694263)
"Yeah but what about" isn't a valid respond under any circumstances, especially not when you are trying to deny that you argue solely in bad faith.

Your state of denial and victimhood complex make any discussion impossible.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:00PM (#25695236)
The Equal Protection Clause is literally, the legal/ constitutional application of "Whataboutism."

There are many (most) cases whataboutism is merely an excuse or distraction, but here, it's the very basis of the ongoing argument.

That most of the left doesn't even realize this is a big part of the problem.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by courtf on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:36PM (#25691429)
> nobody was directly threatened

next sentence:

> one women who came a little too close to breaking into where some VIPs were was shot in the neck and died

the shot heard round the trailer park!

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:02PM (#25695921)
They don't understand what bad faith is.

As if smashing doors and climbing through them while armed guards tell you not to with congress fleeing on the other side is not "directly threatened".

The absurdity of these arguments is astounding. What's worse, they seem to be thinking that they are making sense and that there is some global conspiracy on the left to "silence them".

The rest of the world is standing in awe and shock at the US.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by blueblob on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:00PM (#25689566)
In this false equivalence you're trying to make, did the people in the women's march come with zip ties to kidnap congressmen? Did they come to interfere with the electoral process? Did they steal? Were they violent?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:06PM (#25689679)
You're right to call this false equivalence.

I think it's a mistake to argue the specifics. The parent comment here is arguing in bad faith.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:04PM (#25689643)
This comment is why having this discussion is so difficult.

To anyone not invested emotionally in this conversation, it's clear that your point isn't making a valid point. They are not equivalent actions.

You're pretending they are to try to lend cover to the truly harmful action that just took place.

We can call a spade a spade without pretending that everything else is also a spade.

To be clear, I am directly saying that you are arguing in bad faith.

I hope it is clear that this is not an attack on you as a person. I am attacking your idea directly, not you.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:07PM (#25690523)
How are they not equivalent? Both were organized protests intended on occupying the capitol for the sake of airing out their political grievances. What truly harmful action took place that was caused by the protestors? Be specific.

The only difference that in can see is that during the 1/6/21 event, the police were called in. They attacked and killed 4 protestors.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:13PM (#25691210)
Maybe you don't know that 60 Capital Police were seriously injured, 15 remain in the hospital, and one is confirmed dead from the attack.

Maybe you don't know that of the 4 rioters that died, one had a heart attack (unconfirmed), one was shot and the others were trampled (by the mob).

Maybe you didn't know that congresspeople from both sides of the isle hid in closets and under desks, terrified and afraid for their lives.

Maybe you just didn't know these things, and got them wrong. But when confronted with them, you aren't going to say "oh sorry I was mistaken." You will respond with whataboutism and other deflection, to preserve your worldview that this wasn't a mob and Trump didn't do anything wrong, etc.

Which was OP's point. This isn't a good faith discussion. You are either ignorant of the truth (and will respond poorly when confronted with it), or you know the truth and are cynically lying about reality to win a rhetorical game.

This is the nature of all bad faith political discussion, which is why I (try to) avoid it all together.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:32PM (#25691393)
You’re making a lot of assumptions about me for someone claiming I’m arguing in bad faith.

Maybe you don’t know that the police officer who died, died as a result of a blood clot. Not as a direct result of any action by the protestors.

Those police were doing crowd control. If they were not deployed there would have been no on-duty injuries. Was law enforcement deployed on the women’s March protestors?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:36PM (#25692274)
> Those police were doing crowd control. If they were not deployed there would have been no on-duty injuries.

"The Bank security guard would have never been hurt if they just let people steal the money and take hostages."

> Maybe you don’t know that the police officer who died, died as a result of a blood clot.

This is beyond bad faith, this is insulting. And i'm not going to participate anymore. I just hope people like you die out before this country is irrevocably harmed, and your children don't carry your sickness to a new generation.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:58PM (#25693873)
> "The Bank security guard would have never been hurt if they just let people steal the money and take hostages."

can you explain this analogy? What are you assuming the protestors would have done if the police weren’t deployed?

> I just hope people like you die out before this country is irrevocably harmed, and your children don't carry your sickness to a new generation.

This is a pretty radical statement. I’m actually a center left liberal and you’re wishing that I die simply because of a fact I brought up that refutes your narrative. Can you substantiate your claims that I’m causing harm to this country by citing facts? How did you get this radicalized?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:14PM (#25694321)
I regret spending even a moment interacting with you.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:17PM (#25695467)
Well I don’t know what to tell you. I’ve been cordial and rational in my reasoning and interactions with you. Why does the mention of the fact that the officer’s cause of death was a blood clot provoke such a strong negative reaction?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:15PM (#25696080)
Please.

You're pretending that your "rational" arguments are anything other than bad faith.

It's difficult to take anything you say seriously when you can't admit that the actions this week are not the same as the women's march.

This is game that the rest of us are tired of being subjected to. The results of this style of thinking has just borne fruit thanks to the continued lying and obfuscating of the President and his gaggle of sycophants. The world is not confused about the dangerous actions that just transpired.

You are purposefully and willingly beyond reach.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:52PM (#25697209)
The fact remains that 4 unarmed protestors were killed, at least 2 were directly killed by capitol police. There were no deaths directly caused by the protestors. Sicknick died from a blood clot.

So when you say that the protestors caused a truly harmful action to take place, what exactly are you referring to?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:58PM (#25697248)
...breaking and entering into congress?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:09AM (#25697362)
Yea again, by that logic, it was also a truly harmful action when the women’s March protestors stormed the capitol. https://twitter.com/EgSophie/status/1048634940169048064?s=20

Of course, if you’re fair and reasonable in your judgments you’d see that both were legitimate protests, and the only innocent victims of violence in the maga protest were the unarmed protestors themselves.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:20AM (#25697469)
> when the women’s March protestors stormed the capitol.

What the heck are you talking about?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:39PM (#25717887)
It's MAGA world, they are closing ranks around "violence is ok look what you made us do".

It's the natural last step in any fascist movement. The question remains, how many Americans remain this radicalized. If the number is low enough , the country survives.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:06AM (#25697334)
Btw even Matt Gaetz can’t defend that one, which is why you see him hallucinating under command on national television about them being antifa.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:13AM (#25697391)
Matt Gaetz is not an authority on what is true and his take on things is irrelevant in this thread.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:23AM (#25697502)
Clearly not. But it’s a clear example of where the rest of this society is drawing the line.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:26AM (#25697532)
That argument is as valid as the argument that I should jump off a cliff because the rest of society is doing it.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:30AM (#25697562)
That argument is as valid as arguing that jumping off cliffs for no reason and admitting that breaking into congress is bad are equivalent.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:43AM (#25697672)
I never compared jumping off cliffs and breaking into Congress. The point is that your argument that we ought to condemn the actions of the trump supporters because the rest of society has done so is not a rational argument.

I don’t think breaking into Congress is always bad. I support people’s right to peaceful protest. The Trump supporters by and large did not initiate violence, the violence was initiated on them by the police. If there was evidence that the trump supporters actually were initiating mass violence against people in the capitol that would be a different story, but with 4 unarmed protestors dead, they were the only ones who suffered casualties. That’s simply a fact.

You’re drawing a line that any protest which occupies the capitol is immoral. I disagree with that but if you really believe that, was it immoral when the women’s March protesters took the capitol? https://twitter.com/EgSophie/status/1048634940169048064?s=20

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:58AM (#25697790)
> your argument that we ought to condemn the actions of the trump supporters because the rest of society has done so is not a rational argument.

I’m not arguing that at all, I’m just telling you what the rest of the society is doing; that pressure you feel to change your opinion is coming entirely from within yourself.

> was it immoral when the women’s March protesters took the capitol?

I’m not sure, let me check: did they break windows and doors to gain entry into the capitol building? Did they break into representatives’ offices? Were there weapons and detaining tools found on their persons?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by CyberRabbi on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:04AM (#25697826)
> I’m not sure, let me check: did they break windows and doors to gain entry into the capitol building? Did they break into representatives’ offices? Were there weapons and detaining tools found on their persons?

So now your position is that it’s okay to occupy a capitol building as long as you don’t break windows, break into representatives offices, and/or some small percentage of them have weapons on them? Even if they directly cause no one harm. Okay. Was it immoral when BLM occupied and damaged the Ohio capitol? https://www.cleveland.com/open/2020/05/state-officials-asses...

> Damage included 28 broken windows along the west and south sides of the building, as well as damage to the wooden window frames, five pole lamps and two doors, including the West Rotunda entrance, according to the Capitol Square Review and Advisory Board, the agency responsible for keeping the Statehouse grounds. Flags planted in flower beds were burned.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:20AM (#25697920)
> So now your position is that it’s okay to occupy a capitol building as long as you don’t break windows, break into representatives offices, and/or some small percentage of them have weapons on them?

No, but it’s the bare essentials to stick to if you don’t want to be taken for an insurrectionist.

> Was it immoral when BLM occupied and damaged the Ohio capitol?

Yes! Whoever thought that was a good idea is a goddamn punk. Although, they weren’t trying to change the outcome of an election; that’s a pretty significant difference. There’s few things in a democracy worse than interfering with its election, I’m sure you agree, except maybe literally blowing it up.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pqhwan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:23AM (#25697938)
> I never compared jumping off cliffs and breaking into Congress.

You’re not a child, I think, so I can’t scare you with made up stories about what happens when you lie. But seriously, it’s not good for you, or those around you.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:49AM (#25700772)
I applaud your efforts pqhwan.

But this is the point I tried to make at the top of this thread.

These people are playing a game. They aren't interested in talking about this honestly.

Seriously, where is the legitimate debate about the events of this week?

Is anyone compelled by the idea that this seditious event was comparable to the women's march?

I don't know what tools we have to bring these people back. I wish I could point to something and say "here", this is how we can find common ground. But they are proving every day that they are more interested in this dishonest babble than engaging in serious discussion.

Again, for anyone whose made it this far. The fact that they are pretending that there is no difference between the women's march and the events this week are all you need to see to dismiss the rest of the justifications they put forth.

Don't fall for the trap. They wont argue "the point". They will deflect, lie and twist every issue to fit their narrative.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:01AM (#25700854)
"The circumstances surrounding Mr. Sicknick's death were not immediately clear, and the Capitol Police said only that he had “passed away due to injuries sustained while on duty.” At some point in the chaos "

Capitol Police said this...

Or are we only allowed to provide partial facts?

Maybe all of those gun shot victims I keep reading about are simply dying from loss of blood? My mistake...

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/08/us/brian-sicknick-police-...

https://googlethatforyou.com?q=stroke%20after%20blunt%20forc...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:15PM (#25704841)
And...

"While authorities haven’t provided details on the medical emergencies, Greeson’s son said his father died from a heart attack mid-protest. Boyland died after being crushed by the crowd, according to one report, while Philips had a stroke, fellow protesters said."

https://www.thedailybeast.com/benjamin-philips-kevin-greeson...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by forserious on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:13PM (#25704823)
Shocked to not hear back on this. /s

https://www.thedailybeast.com/benjamin-philips-kevin-greeson...

Just in case we need more...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:48PM (#25718009)
If they do respond, it will be with "Yeah but what about..." without missing a beat. No reflection, no introspection, just furthering the infinite game.

More footage: https://twitter.com/mickeydelo/status/1348312979129905155

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:04PM (#25691124)
> I am attacking your idea directly, not you.

This is why I don't talk politics, ever. You simply cannot attack a person's idea in politics, because their ideas are their identity. They will respond with the ferocity in which they would if someone were to physically attack them. While noble of you to try, it will fail. Every time.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by AlexandrB on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:05PM (#25689660)
I think part of the problem is that on many issues elections are already irrelevant. If I'm an American and I want the US to withdraw from Afghanistan, who do I vote for?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:15PM (#25689819)
The relevancy of elections comes not just from how they affect things in the present moment and the choices they bring, but in the ability to assume there is always an open path towards progress for issues you care about, no matter now narrow.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Uhhrrr on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:26PM (#25689970)
In the last election, Jo Jorgensen.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by dang on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:49AM (#25711598)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25687988.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cercatrova on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:06PM (#25688674)
This is the paradox of tolerance. We can tolerate having a free internet but if it leads to the intolerant taking over and making everything worse, we need to be intolerant of them now, not later.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by danaliv on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:11PM (#25688763)
Please, can we put this canard to rest? It is an extremely simplistic take that is bordering on cliche at this point. It adds nothing, it illuminates nothing, and it fails to address any of the very real and complex issues by turning everything into a binary of tolerant/intolerant.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gameman144 on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:10PM (#25690566)
Is the irony that this cuts both ways not obvious? Seems very clear; the left thinks the right is intolerant and must be silenced, the right thinks the left is intolerant and must be hobbled. The twist is that both sides are absolutely correct: the other side is intolerant.

The Paradox of Tolerance is a great game theory exercise, just like Mutually Assured Destruction, but I'd prefer to live in a society where we don't lean into these strategies with our foot on the gas.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:13PM (#25688800)
A witty saying proves nothing, and in this case it particularly doesn't since you seem you do not know what else was being said when it was written by its author.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by seppin on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:17PM (#25691254)
Calls to violence were not, and are not, protected speech. It is a false argument to say they should be now.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cercatrova on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:59PM (#25695880)
I'm saying calls to violence are what we should be intolerant about.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by stale2002 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:11PM (#25689758)
> then there has to be a nuanced resolution.

The nuanced resolution is our laws and court system.

If something is illegal, then our justice system can handled it. Otherwise, it should be allowed to exist on the free internet.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mint2 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:32PM (#25690058)
It’s like the libertarian view that everything will work without regulation, it just requires everyone to abide by some unrealistic “do no harm principle” that obviously can’t work.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mudil on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:25PM (#25689014)
Trump (and his supporters) has been in possession of the entire federal apparatus, from CIA/NSA to the military, and yet he's been a pretty ineffective in overthrowing anything. It's your fantasies that need to be overthrown.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by BitwiseFool on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:55PM (#25688474)
Have you ever spent time on the leftist "tankie" / "Chapo trap house" kind of subreddits? Or the Gen Zedong groups that glorify the purge of landlords during the communist revolution in China? If we are really going to go after such people wanting to violently overthrow the government we can't be ignoring the left when they do it.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by nucleardog on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:59PM (#25688562)
As soon as those people take action and start murdering all the landlords, absolutely.

Speech is speech, when that speech begets action then we have a problem.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by coldtea on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:05PM (#25688663)
So like several months of looting and burning in various cities like Portland?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by onethought on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:17PM (#25688868)
Yes. People who break the law should be prosecuted, else you weaken the law.

But, burning and looting is in a different category to the Capitol stuff, I think.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by coldtea on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:45AM (#25701873)
Is it? To me it's the same kind or even more symbolic - it just annoys people that it was the "wrong" thinking masses to do it.

If it was done for some other cause, there would be no end of celebratory articles on the same outlets that now condemn it...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by onethought on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:15PM (#25704245)
Given the seditious aspect to it off directly attacking a body of government. It seems different under US law compared with arson/vandalism that has most characterised the protests around US cities.

I think it would be condemned equally no matter who tried it. It’s the beginning of an end game scenario of democracy... so it makes sense it is viewed so harshly

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by scythe on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:45PM (#25689327)
It is wrong to say that there was "burning" for "several months", unless you're referring to the forest fires. A few buildings were burned down in isolated incidents during several months of protests across multiple cities. Looting is not well-documented but my friends in Portland didn't seem very concerned.

The vast majority of participants in the protests following the Floyd murder did not take part in any violence. It is all but certain that the fraction who did is much smaller than the fraction of 1/6/21 protestors who illegally entered the Capitol.

Comparing the one to the other is not justified.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by coldtea on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:49AM (#25701914)
>It is wrong to say that there was "burning" for "several months", unless you're referring to the forest fires. A few buildings were burned down in isolated incidents during several months of protests across multiple cities.

That's neither here nor there. I didn't say "burning for months" (e.g. the same fires keep burning for months), I said "burning and looting for months", that is incidents of burnings and lootings occuring for months. There have been dozens, if not hundreds, and have lasted (not each individual, the case of them popping has lasted) for months...

>The vast majority of participants in the protests following the Floyd murder did not take part in any violence. It is all but certain that the fraction who did is much smaller than the fraction of 1/6/21 protestors who illegally entered the Capitol.

That's not certain at all. The videos show a totally different story.

>Looting is not well-documented but my friends in Portland didn't seem very concerned.

Many of those in favor aren't, especially if they live outside of the affected radius.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by scythe on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:32PM (#25705658)
> I said "burning and looting for months", that is incidents of burnings and lootings occuring for months.

Weasel words, then. The continuous presence of fire for months was of course not implied.

>Many of those in favor aren't, especially if they live outside of the affected radius.

In favor of what, precisely?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by pie_flavor on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:12PM (#25689772)
There have been five hundred separate BLM/Antifa-related riots, and the most recent one was the night before the Capitol protest. They have, in fact, lasted several months.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by BitwiseFool on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:08PM (#25688703)
All of these efforts are happening to prevent Trump supporters from speaking. I'm certain you would not apply the same judgement to Trump supporters who are just speaking about violence, would you?
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by aaronbrethorst on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:59PM (#25688563)
Chapo hipsters buy fixies, not AR-15s. You're not going to kidnap the Speaker of the House, or murder a Senator with a gearless bicycle.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by zdragnar on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:17PM (#25688871)
Until they throw moltov cocktails and explosives, or set buildings on fire, or permanently blind you with a high powered laser.

Use of violent tactics is not particlarly novel on either side

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by cygx on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:06PM (#25689663)
But note that as far as the US is concerned, in the past couple of decades, right wing extremists have killed a significantly greater number of people than left-wing extremists (eg. the CSIS credits them with 90% of all extremist killings in the timeframe 2018/19). They also lead by number of plots - though by body count, Islamist terror still takes the lead for the obvious reasons.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by aaronbrethorst on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:44PM (#25690203)
"I am particularly concerned about white supremacist violent extremists who have been exceptionally lethal in their abhorrent, targeted attacks in recent years" said (now-former) acting DHS Secretary Chad Wolf in DHS's most recent domestic threat assessment.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/06/us/politics/homeland-secu...

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by timwaagh on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:59PM (#25689544)
Not in the USA they don't. But in Venezuela it's a different story.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by aaronbrethorst on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:06PM (#25689667)
I don't think there's a large audience for Brooklyn hipster leftist podcasts in Caracas.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jahnu on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:01PM (#25688591)
How many people are in positions of power that represent these leftist groups? I don't think it's in any way comparable to the fact that the far right literally have the US president on their side along with a sizable portion of the GOP.

Tankie leftists that support violence have the political weight as furry enthusiasts afaik.

[dead]
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by BitwiseFool on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:11PM (#25688769)
Call it whataboutism if you wish, but it's relevant to the discussion when it comes to evenly applying the rules.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by eertami on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:24PM (#25689011)
It unequivocally is in no way relevant. Sure, if these people you mention had invaded the white house with weapons and make-shift bombs then it would be a fair comparison. However that didn't happen, it is a completely false equivalence.

I simply don’t know what to say to you except to please re-examine your humanity as well as your critical thinking skills.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by BitwiseFool on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:28PM (#25689054)
>"I simply don’t know what to say to you except to please re-examine your humanity as well as your critical thinking skills. "

If you're worried about logical fallacies like Whataboutism, you've just committed an Ad Hominem. Why go there? Why question my humanity?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by qorrect on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:07PM (#25689691)
He's very angry and wants you to know it. If you don't agree with him, you are an idiot.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mcphage on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:43PM (#25690196)
> If you're worried about logical fallacies like Whataboutism, you've just committed an Ad Hominem.

That's not what an Ad Hominem fallacy is.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by thatguy0900 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:10PM (#25688737)
Noone cares anymore about the left rioting
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by lamontcg on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:54PM (#25689470)
The left wasn't being actively encouraged and incited by the sitting President.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by ufmace on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:09PM (#25689715)
Not by the sitting President, but by every single mainstream media organization and a pretty solid fraction of sitting Democrat Congresspeople and Senators, who spent months excusing and denying violent riots as they raged for months.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jansan on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:30PM (#25690026)
Here are two examples.

Chris Cuomo on CNN "And please, show me where it says that protests have to be polite, or peaceful"

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on Twitter "The whole point of protesting is to make ppl uncomfortable."

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by sirshmooey on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:32PM (#25690056)
Trump’s nature further polarized both sides. He’s a binary-minded individual, either for / against. Dangerous quality for a leader, pushes both sides toward the extremes.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by throwawaysea on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:15PM (#25689821)
Can you please provide evidence for the President inciting violence?

I would also say that there are leftist politicians who are encouraging and inciting criminal acts. See this recent tweet from AOC (https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1334184644707758080), where she excuses activists acting illegally because the "polite language policy game" (her words) didn't work for them. This is no less an act of incitement than Trump, since Trump never called for violence or encouraged acts of violence.

I also think there is a great deal of hypocrisy from the left on this point given the events of this last year. There have been numerous riots, arrests, deaths, and illegal occupation of public places recorded. All the politicians, activists, organizations involved in those criminal acts have been given a pass and have faced very little accountability and virtually no censorship from big tech.

Even before George Floyd, we have incidents from left-leaning activists where they literally invade federal buildings. Here's an example documented by the Associated Press (https://youtu.be/B_kxyacaAF4). What was the response from the far left elements? Rashida Tlaib and AOC actually joined some of their events and encouraged them (https://theintercept.com/2018/11/13/alexandria-ocasio-cortez...). And yet, these two continue to be allowed their platforms.

Let's be honest, the tech platforms are using this ridiculously inept protest at the Capitol as an enabling excuse to further censorship and erode free speech, aligning with the interests of their left-biased employee bases. The precedent it sets is dark, as it will be employed to discriminate against viewpoints that disagree with the progressive agenda.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mudil on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:47PM (#25690245)
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by ardy42 on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:45PM (#25691515)
> Exactly. Remember when this was OK? https://twitter.com/MSNBC/status/1047935416182235136?s=19

Did they break into the offices and steal things?

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by throwawaysea on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:08PM (#25695988)
They certainty broke into the offices in some of these incidents, like the one involving AOC, where they broke into Pelosi’s office. There was also an incident where they broke into McConnell’s office. I don’t know if they stole things or not but it’s somewhat irrelevant. They costed time and resources which is still theft.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by throwawaysea on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:55PM (#25691041)
I totally forgot about that one - it's almost an exact fit for what happened here.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by klyrs on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:26PM (#25689042)
That's because they're laughably ineffective and tend to shit their own kitchens. It's also last year's news, a whataboutism to deflect from the actual insurrection that occurred this week.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by throwaway0a5e on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:40PM (#25689265)
"Shitting in their own kitchen" got many/most major cities to examine how they allocate police and social service resources just like the protesters wanted.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beerandt on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:56PM (#25689498)
Negotiate with terrorists, expect more terrorism.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jasonlotito on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:09PM (#25688725)
We aren't. But one is the POTUS and is the leader of one of the two major parties in the US. So, let's calm down on the both sides arguments.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by MrZongle2 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:59PM (#25688569)
Exactly. There are dangerous extremists on both ends of the spectrum, but God forbid you want to assess the entire landscape in some forums. You're just mocked for being some kind of centrist, as if not being a slobbering partisan is a character flaw.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by mrguyorama on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:33PM (#25689170)
Because "both sides" is an invalid argument when both sides are clearly not equal
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by andybak on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:13PM (#25688791)
I'm a centrist by instinct and by UK standards.

Unfortunately that would probably put me in the "radical leftist" bracket according to current US discourse.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beaconstudios on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:21PM (#25688953)
if a centrist in the UK would be halfway between current Labour and Conservative policies, that would probably make you close to a mainstream Democrat. Labour is left of the Democrats and the Conservatives are right of them (primarily economically), but neither by a huge margin.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by nicky0 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:48PM (#25689375)
I agree with you. I would go so far as to say that the Conservatives are to the left of the Democrats, even economically. Look at the extent of public borrowing funding all the furlough schemes etc. Not to mention both Labour and Tories are fully behind free public healthcare, which Democrats are having to be dragged kicking and screaming towards. Although that is rather a special case.

Come to think of it I can't think of any policies on which the (mainstream) Democrats are to the left of the Conservatives, but maybe I'm not thinking hard enough.

Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by beaconstudios on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:04PM (#25691673)
That's a good point, especially since Thatcher the conservatives haven't even been all that economically right wing. They do have a tendency to cut public sector spending, with austerity and such policies, but the UK starting point for the welfare state is much more than the US.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jansan on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:23PM (#25689932)
And if you move one inch to the right, you will be branded a right wing fascist. It has become extremely difficult to be seen as part of the center.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by jasonlotito on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:10PM (#25688750)
Only one party made their extremist the leader of their party.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Covzire on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:46PM (#25689337)
I don't read or follow thedonald.win, but I share your general feelings of apprehension for the well being of anyone who consumes CNN, MSNBC or NYT hoping to be accurately informed.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by gfodor on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:54PM (#25689459)
One indisputable lesson of these last few years (which was probably always true, and known by some) is that people largely seem to be able to recognize propaganda from people they disagree with but by and large are very poor at using that to better see the propaganda they are accepting for themselves.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Covzire on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:58PM (#25689539)
I won't dispute that. Imagine if there was some AI that could discern "truth" in an unbiased way, I bet it would have many interesting (and enraging) things to say.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by chris11 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:20PM (#25689890)
The MSM can't be compared to QAnon and OANN related media. One has professional standards, the other starts conspiracy theories.
Re:Reddit bans subreddit group “r/DonaldTrump” by Covzire on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:24PM (#25689951)
Iraq WMDs, Russiagate, just to name a couple big ones. MSM is complete and utter trash, any one pretending they're actually informative where it matters has already been deceived. I really don't know where to get good news, the best I've found so far are random Youtube channels who parse all the news and try to cut through the constant flood of BS.