News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by ericmay on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:43AM (#25683670)
If only Apple didn't have a monopoly on the App Store on the iPhone. Then we wouldn't have to know this information because we could get it from a different App Store where Facebook doesn't have to share this info!
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by vincnetas on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:07AM (#25683801)
App distribution can be totally different from API access to my device. No matter where i get the app from, when accessing certain APIs i would get notified about that, or would have to explicitly enable that functionality in OS settings.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by Razengan on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:35AM (#25684017)
For Apple to know about API access the app would still have to submitted to them in some manner.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nicky0 on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:41AM (#25684051)
The idea was that the phone OS could detect the usage of those APIs and prompt the user wthout Apple having to be directly involved in the process.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nautical on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:02AM (#25684221)
"that the phone OS could detect the usage of those APIs"

This must be handled correctly as it can this also lead to privacy violation.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nicky0 on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:17AM (#25685479)
There is no reason it can't all be done on-device. That is indeed how the current "Enable camera access?" etc. system works.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nautical on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:41AM (#25685740)
This is not a question at all that this can be done or not ( There is no reason it can't all be done on-device. )

Question is will this be ethical .. I will not be comfortable using a device that logs every API an app on it is calling.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nicky0 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:53PM (#25689455)
Why would anything have to be logged? Apple phones already do this and have done for years. With no phoning home.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by mamon on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:41AM (#25686477)
Access control is not the same as logging - the first time an application tries to access the API the OS checks permissions, asks user to approve/deny, and then stores the user's choice. No need to log the actual API calls at all, no permanent records needs to be created.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by darkwater on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:16AM (#25684358)
Just like on device image recognition which Apple is already doing.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by IntelMiner on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:56AM (#25683732)
That's a pretty intentionally obtuse take on a completely unrelated problem
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by evgen on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:03AM (#25683785)
It is actually too obtuse, to be honest.

It would be better to be explicit: if it were not for the Apple 800 lb gorilla holding the Facebook 800 lb gorilla's feet to the fire here due to its self-appointed role as gatekeeper of the iOS App Store then this information would remain hidden from general consumers.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by Daho0n on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:22AM (#25684420)
And while they force this to be disclosed about Facebook Apple hide its own data harvesting since they can collect via sources Facebook cannot. This is pure PR and abuse of market share to better Apple's own ad service.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by evgen on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:23AM (#25686254)
You have repeatedly made this claim and have yet to provide even the thinnest shred of evidence. Please supply some or stop making these unfounded assertions.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by AlexandrB on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:34AM (#25685084)
I've seen multiple people allude to Apple secretly collecting data before. I would really like a source because it's very plausible but I haven't seen any independent research showing that this is actually happening or what's being collected.

Google searches turn up stuff like this: https://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-data-collection-stored-r...

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by k4rli on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:53AM (#25683710)
If only Apple had a monopoly on all phones and computers so everyone would know it, right?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by nine_k on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:01AM (#25683764)
Why, the idea of an universal benevolent overlord is neither obscure nor new. It's basically the idea of God.

Do you know what's the problem with God?

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by dwighttk on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:40AM (#25684046)
What’s the problem with God?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by wizzwizz4 on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:56AM (#25684177)
Well, for one, God isn't Apple Inc..[citation needed]
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by absolutelyrad on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:10AM (#25683821)
I'd argue that if apple didn't have a monopoly, we'd have stores that catered to privacy conscious people far earlier.

If apple didn't restrict the OS so much, you'd have people making their own Facebook clients, wouldn't have mattered if Facebook liked it or not. The monopolization of Facebook's control on personal connections is partially because of closed OS's. And Apple's iOS is one of the most responsible OS's that gave rise to Facebook's data monopoly.

Had it been like Windows, there wouldn't be a way that Facebook could've maintained their monopoly.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by tchalla on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:24AM (#25683934)
There are other OS with a larger percentage of devices installed with other app stores possible. How many privacy focused stores do we see with privacy focused Facebook clients? How many of the users exercise those privacy options and give informed consent to share their data?

Hypotheticals can be argued either way but it’s just one possible option, not the only one.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by absolutelyrad on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:50AM (#25684127)
The answer is chrome web store/firefox store and adblock/tracker block. They offer a hint into a more free future.

Imagine if adblock wasn't allowed on those stores. Today the equivalent is alternative clients to Facebook not being allowed on iOS and the App Store.

Look at YC startups like motion being built on top of the web. They are building on top of the network effects of gmail/google/facebook/slack etc. We aren't allowed any of that on mobile. Had they been allowed more access to the mobile OS's, they could be a very successful company. We haven't even touched the tip of cross OS productivity integrations.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by realusername on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:15AM (#25684351)
> There are other OS with a larger percentage of devices installed with other app stores possible.

Like which ones? There's the AppStore, the PlayStore and that's it, nothing else is even worth being mentioned in terms of market share.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by ascagnel_ on Friday January 08, 2021 @12:28PM (#25687146)
> If apple didn't restrict the OS so much, you'd have people making their own Facebook clients, wouldn't have mattered if Facebook liked it or not.

You're totally wrong on this. In fact, the first alternative FB clients I remember using sprang up on the iPad, before FB bothered to put a native app out for it.

What killed alternative FB clients was FB itself -- they've slowly closed off the APIs you'd need to access to make an alternative client optional. FB has also closed off their own alternative clients as well (FB Paper), and have been forcing users into their official web or native clients for a while.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by qwytw on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:50AM (#25684125)
I'm not sure that it really workout that way, you wouldn't have Facebook clients on these privacy conscious stores because FB wouldn't provide an open API which they could use. Otherwise are there any reasons why these client can't be published on the App Store besides that there no way to make one?

Instead it's probably more likely that FB would host Messenger and Whatsapp clients on their own app store with all the details hidden somewhere in the user agreement.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by dwighttk on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:42AM (#25684057)
What’s the well-known privacy-conscious Android store that’s been running for a long time?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by papaf on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:47AM (#25684104)
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by fsflover on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:14AM (#25683865)
F-Droid proves your point.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by qwytw on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:58AM (#25684187)
Are there any "unofficial" Messenger apps on F-Droid?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by papaf on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:05AM (#25684249)
F-Droid has a search box you could use to answer such questions for yourself:

https://search.f-droid.org/?q=facebook&lang=en

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by qwytw on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:03AM (#25684799)
That was a rhetorical question. AFAIK the closest thing you can get is wrapper around messenger web app which (which by default doesn't work on mobile browser because FB wants to force everyone to use their native apps).
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by davidy123 on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:40AM (#25685737)
While it wraps their web app, I use Frost for Facebook, which is an open source app that lets me access Facebook messages on mobile without using any of Facebook's apps.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by BlueTemplar on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:18AM (#25686175)
I thought that Facebook didn't allow for any unofficial clients, be it for Facebook itself or Facebook Messenger ?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by Nabati on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:19AM (#25683897)
How does using Facebook via another client prevent or diminish Facebooks data monopoly?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by absolutelyrad on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:38AM (#25684033)
If you're serious about this question.

The the answer is: a competitor could build their services on top of Facebook. They wouldn't have to start from scratch. Independent client's mean if the one user trusts you with their data, you can provide them a bigger value.

Today you cannot innovate on top of Facebook. Their network effects mean if your service is superior, you need to beat the network effects first.

And Facebook cannot reasonably offer independent access because: Cambridge Analytica.

Independent client's do what they want without Facebook taking a hit on their reputation. No one blames apple for the crimes committed using their phones/computers do they?

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by the_french on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:23AM (#25684432)
I think that building a competitor on top of facebook is against their terms of service. You wouldn't be able to build an 'alternative facebook client', legally at least.
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by Razengan on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:37AM (#25684026)
> I'd argue that if apple didn't have a monopoly, we'd have stores that catered to privacy conscious people far earlier.

That didn’t happen before the App Store and isn’t happening anywhere else after the App Store either.

Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by teekert on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:31AM (#25684514)
We do one thing right! So we don't need competition because you can safely assume all other things are right and the way they should be!
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by dwighttk on Friday January 08, 2021 @07:40AM (#25684043)
Yeah Epic sure showed Google Play, didn’t they?
Re:Apple's privacy labels show WhatsApp and Facebook Messeng... by tmpUserA on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:57AM (#25684747)
Is there a single time in tech history where a monopoly was not totally abused ? You are asking Apple to take over the world because you buy their privacy propaganda but ICloud is not even end2end encrypted, employee are listening to Siri conversation, Apple knows all apps you run and when instead of just providing a blacklist you compare against locally... There's a scandal every month about Apple privacy.

How long before they ban ProtonMail because "You know what, we think our emails are "better for you". How long before they ban Signal because "You know what, IMessage has a better security than signal so it's "better for you".

Monopoly / tech dictatorship are the easy and tempting solution but nothing good ever came out of giving some dude total power over you. And even if you like those dude because you buy their propaganda, many other people might not share your view.