News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by incrudible on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:15AM (#25671239)
I like to think the problem is that "the nerds" have failed the rest of the people. People used to listen to us about computer stuff. Then computers became usable without us. Then smartphones arrived. We gladly were relieved of our obligations, but also of our influence.

It's too late to go back. People are already used to the trade-offs, convenience rules above all. People may be "sort of concerned" about privacy, but they shrug it off. If privacy was high-value, any privacy-conscious competitor would've taken the market by storm.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by randomsearch on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:30AM (#25671398)
I think it’s simpler. Boycotts don’t work at an individual level. I have been boycotting nestle for decades. Can’t say they’ve become less evil. That’s because the marginal effect is negligible for them and strongly negative for the individual (assuming you’re a fan of Kit Kat’s).

Network effects amplify the marginal impact on the individual, because they lead to a monopoly with no true competition. Sure, you can leave whatsapp for signal, but you can’t talk to that community group on WhatsApp from signal. From an individual’s point of view the market power is an absolute monopoly.

The only solution to these problems is organising to the level of a mass boycott, or regulatory intervention. The former is impossible because too many people don’t care about the company’s behaviour (not because they’re ignorant, they just don’t care) and the latter is slow and a very hard and unfun pursuit for campaigners.

Nothing we say to non nerds will be of sufficient magnitude on an individual level. It’d have to be collective action.

Personally I’m far more worried about Facebook undermining democracy right now. That’s sufficient reason to shut them down.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by qwertox on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:10AM (#25671899)
I wish the EU would force messaging systems to also support interactions with XMPP or other similar open standards.

There's nothing in their way to expect such a thing, except the lobbyists.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by rapnie on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:00AM (#25672499)
Interoperability enforcement may become part of the EU Digital Markets Act.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by 1f60c on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:42PM (#25675293)
If the GDPR is any indication, WhatsApp could just choose to stop offering its services in the EU.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Retric on Thursday January 07, 2021 @02:36PM (#25676103)
That would seriously break the network effect and eventually kill them off. Skype, Yahoo Messenger, etc got popular because they where free and easy to use. However, the market is really fickle and network effects can kill stuff off really quickly.

WhatsApp is already DOA in my circle of friends, it might come back but the odds aren’t great.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by shaoonb on Thursday January 07, 2021 @03:03PM (#25676540)
The WhatsApp network effect is strongly tied to borders though. Almost no one uses it in New Zealand for example, but a lot of people use Facebook Messenger but it isn't completely dominant like WhatsApp is in some places. I wonder if it ties back to countries that have good value cell phone plans? Even the very cheapest plans here come with unlimited SMS and it's been that way since smartphones were first taking off.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by xmprt on Thursday January 07, 2021 @03:47PM (#25677229)
I think you're understating the strength of weak connections. If I have even one friend who's not on Whatsapp that I want to stay in touch with then I'm going to download another app. If there's a group chat with this person then everyone in that group is downloading a second app. And then second degree and third degree connections get affected too.

Getting out of the EU would be a massive blow to any established social media company that depends on network effects. It doesn't matter as much for smaller companies that are still growing (eg. early Facebook still managed to grow by only offering services to college students).

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by luelistan on Thursday January 07, 2021 @02:34PM (#25676076)
Which would be great IMO
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by baq on Thursday January 07, 2021 @04:03PM (#25677436)
too good to be true.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by rusk on Thursday January 07, 2021 @03:02PM (#25676524)
That’s the point.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by didsomeonesay on Thursday January 07, 2021 @04:00PM (#25677388)
problem solved
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jokethrowaway on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:23AM (#25672053)
Why would you want your government to mandate how technology works?

Sounds like a recipe for disaster and the perfect way to stifle innovation

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by kroltan on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:45AM (#25672288)
Is it not reasonable to demand interoperability for one of the main methods of communication in the entire world?

Forcing a specific standard is problematic, but it would be reasonable to ask any communication service to provide a fully documented and public API with features and access equal to the features and access of the official application.

Random nerds make integrations to whatever application/protocol is in vogue, business still gets to have complete freedom in where their take their API and thus their product.

---

I would even go as far as to say that every web-service should be machine-consumable in that fashion, but that's beyond the point.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jokethrowaway on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:15AM (#25672779)
My problem is not demanding it, as users, it's enforcing it with laws.

If users don't want that, they should be free not to have that.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by saagarjha on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:23AM (#25683288)
The problem is that the users who couldn't care less drive the decision.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by vladvasiliu on Thursday January 07, 2021 @12:16PM (#25673886)
They probably shouldn't mandate "how technology works". I certainly wouldn't vote for that.

However, I think that public services (paid for by taxes) should be open and accessible. That is, the government should mandate certain properties ("it should be open") and not certain implementations ("it should use this specific protocol / app").

Another commenter gave the example of Brazil schools sending parents important information via WhatsApp.

Now I'm not against the schools doing that if it's one of multiple options and if the parents have an actual choice. I think the government should mandate that at least one open choice be made available, without necessarily detailing said choice.

In my view this wouldn't stifle innovation. If you come up with some new communication app that's better than anything else, if it's open and many people pick it up, there's no reason for the schools not to use it instead of the older / inferior option. This would also allow schools to choose one among several open solutions according to their particular needs.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by matthew_wilson on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:55AM (#25672427)
“One System — One Policy — Universal Service”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingsbury_Commitment?wprov=sft...

"the promise of mail delivery [helped] grow the nation and economy instead of serving only existing communities."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Service_Act?wprov=sfti1

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jokethrowaway on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:10AM (#25672673)
I think it's a different problem - mail delivery requires a series of entities interacting with each others (think about a network of mailmen).

Also, private mail exists and it's definitely useful.

Digital messages are usually built on top of the internet (which would have similar problems) and every service can be used across the entire network.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Drdrdrq on Thursday January 07, 2021 @12:15PM (#25673858)
Really? So I can reach my cousin via Signal, even though he is on WhatsApp?
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by arpyzo on Thursday January 07, 2021 @03:54PM (#25677323)
Let's rewrite this to illustrate a point:

Why would you want a small, self-interested, unaccountable group of private investors to mandate how technology works?

Sounds like a recipe for disaster and the perfect way to stifle innovation

Depending on the particulars of your government, perhaps it looks more appealing now.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by zerox7felf on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:59AM (#25672468)
Because innovative != ethical! Hopefully it would stifle innovation that depends on tracking users and platform lock-in. I think there would certainly be space for innovation beyond that, possibly with even better conditions for competition as it would be easier for users to move between platforms.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jokethrowaway on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:06AM (#25672583)
What if as a user I'm happy to get a free service and be tracked?
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Smaug123 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:19AM (#25672868)
Governments exist in large part to solve problems of the form "all individuals are incentivised to take actions which, when universally taken, are detrimental to the commons".
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Leherenn on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:08PM (#25674805)
I am not sure it is a problem for most people though, if anything I believe most people would not like the alternative.

If the choice is between being tracked, which results in many things being free (as in beer) with otherwise almost no practical visible consequences for most people (different ads?), or having to pay for each and every service but no tracking, I think you would face a huge backlash if you forced the latter.

A solution could be to have free access if you accept tracking and pay otherwise, but I believe this is illegal under GDPR.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by rglullis on Thursday January 07, 2021 @04:42PM (#25677946)
Who do you think that allocates frequency spectrum? Imagine if every mobile phone company wanted to lock its users by operating on a specific frequency.

Imagine if Hollywood or TV studios had any saying over Digital TV standards. Streaming would never exist and we would be used to a "pay-per-view" model forever, with mandatory and built-in DRM.

This is not about enforcing how technology works. It just ensuring that no monopoly can occur. Common standards don't stifle innovation, closed ones do.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by ruiseal on Thursday January 07, 2021 @05:13PM (#25678355)
We would have been much worse off if governments, or governmental bodies like the UN, allocated IP addresses rather than a private anarcho-like entity.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by rglullis on Thursday January 07, 2021 @06:31PM (#25679146)
How does allocation of IP addresses related to pushing for interoperability of communication protocols?

If your analogy was something about governmental bodies was worse than private entities when pushing for a standard network standard, then you would have a point. But unless I am deeply wrong, TCP/IP, GSM, LTE, DVB, even FM radio and PAL were standards that only became dominant after governmental bodies sanctioned as standards and no one misses AppleTalk or Novell's IDP because of "government meddling".

Even still, the argument is not for killing private protocols or stopping private companies to innovate and develop new technologies. It's "just" that these innovations should be made on top of open standards instead of displacing them. Don't forget that Google Talk and even Facebook's messenger started on top of XMPP. They closed purely for business reasons, not technical ones. Had the FCC told them "do whatever you want with your network and your client, but anyone speaking XMPP should be able to communicate with your users", we wouldn't be in this mess.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Dig1t on Thursday January 07, 2021 @03:48PM (#25677250)
I generally agree with this sentiment, but sometimes I think mandating cooperation between walled gardens is the only way to help consumers. Take healthcare for example: Epic, Cerner, Athena, etc all have NO incentive to build any interoperability into their products. It greatly benefits them to create walled gardens and wall-off hospitals and healthcare institutions from other institutions that use their competitors' software.

It took Congress to mandate open standards and to spell out that healthcare institutions must offer a public APIs to patients. We are only now starting to be able to download health records from hospitals as a result of this despite it being technically possible for decades. In fact there are still many patients that are required to request stacks of DVDs containing their health records, and this is their only option.

Obviously this is more a commentary on how shitty healthcare in the US can be, but also a good example IMO of how sometimes government intervention in technical standards requirements can greatly benefit consumers.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by lmm on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:46PM (#25680891)
Market competition doesn't work for natural monopolies, and network effects mean messaging is one of those. Governments should regulate as necessary to ensure free markets for competition, which means aggressive antitrust enforcement and giving natural monopolies the choice between opening up enough to allow competition, or nationalisation.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by IanCal on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:07PM (#25680551)
Forcing interoperability means the apps need to actually compete with each other by being better - rather than just by being the biggest incumbent. Restrictions and requirements can boost innovation.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by zvr on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:13AM (#25672734)
Because deployment of technology is a policy decision. And policies are what governments are about.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by bflesch on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:44PM (#25675326)
Also if XMPP would be possible, the data privacy problems would persist. For many people it's a problem that FB reads all their messages.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by BrandoElFollito on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:55PM (#25675481)
The EU cannot force anything. It would be enough for the company that provides WhatsApp to not have any business in the EU (today that's FB, it could be a spinoff tomorrow).

The only, weak, solution would be to force the EU ISPs, on an European level, to block FB. Blocking on itself will not be easy (technically speaking) and good luck to have a consensus on that among our countries.

I completely fail to understand why many US companies, operating on US grounds care about GDPR at all. I would not and, please, sue me. Even the ones that block access from EU are overreacting.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by selestify on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:46PM (#25680887)
What do you think the differences between modern boycotts and Rosa Parks bus boycott are? Why are modern ones so ineffective in comparison?
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by zzzbra on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:50PM (#25680918)
Rosa Parks was a militant activist and part of a large activist network that was consistently staging public acts in defiance of Jim Crow segregation. This is misleadingly left out of most folks’ intro to her most successful action.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by whimsicalism on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#25685432)
My school system was always big on emphasizing that there were pre-cursors to Rosa Parks (like Claudette Colvin), but they didn't have the connections that she did to make it happen.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by ebrenes on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:35PM (#25703071)
Another factor is that the black people that were mainly affected by the segregation were the primary funders of the bus system. Their boycott was incredibly significant to the bottom line.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by randomsearch on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:30AM (#25683324)
As sibling said, organisation was there, but also I think most people would feel very strongly about that issue, where here we are a minority.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jimkleiber on Thursday January 07, 2021 @12:39PM (#25674309)
When employees want to have more say over their working conditions, they organize. If users want to have more say over the product conditions, is there an opportunity to organize as wel?
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by raziel2p on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:23AM (#25671314)
Eh, it's not like "the nerds" can build a better product in terms of UX anyway, and definitely can't market it better.

Besides, who says "the nerds" are trustworthy anyway? They keep arguing among each other about which operating system or programming language is best, and why should we take their advice when software security vulnerabilities keep being discovered?

Not disagreeing with your point - it's become too easy to just randomly click "agree" on any TOS and trade away your privacy/security for convenience - but don't make it an "us vs them" type of thing. To me, this is purely corporate interest being prioritized ahead of public needs because most politicians either have no spine or answer to lobbyists more than the common person.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by jimbokun on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:03AM (#25671823)
> Eh, it's not like "the nerds" can build a better product in terms of UX anyway, and definitely can't market it better.

Um, the original WhatsApp company was pretty much run by nerds, I thought, who made a product with UX so good they organically built a user base so large that FaceBook paid $16 billion for the company?

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by 411111111111111 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:36AM (#25672171)
The service even cost money. A chat service for which you paid money to use. That was actually the argument why a lot of people used it, because "if you're paying for it, you know that they don't have shady business practices"

The only thing that surprises me is how long this change took. I expected them to do this when they removed the subscription.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by Leherenn on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:12PM (#25674862)
Wasn't it only after the first year? That meant you could try it for free which is huge for adoption.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by j780 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:41AM (#25698972)
Then one of the whatsap co-founders initiated the Signal Foundation! See "2018–present" at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_%28software%29
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by millibar on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:41AM (#25673290)
$19 billion according to wiki :-)
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by dkarl on Thursday January 07, 2021 @12:32PM (#25674193)
"The nerds" tend to think logically and extrapolate without regard for reasonableness, precedent, or social norms. That makes us pretty bad at a lot of things (and we blow a lot of our credibility that way) but, it turns out, pretty good at predicting how corporations will abuse technology.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by rubin55 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:27AM (#25671356)
What’s wrong with ‘wall’ or ‘irssi’! ;)
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by MayeulC on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:39AM (#25671508)
I'd trust most nerds over most salesmen, but hat's what people do by clicking "I agree". Don't deal with the devil.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by raziel2p on Thursday January 07, 2021 @02:21PM (#25675887)
Kind of want to agree, but you're comparing the extremes on both sides. The truth is somewhere in-between, and consider that for mainstream products like WhatsApp or Windows or whatever, the general public never deal with actual salesmen, just word of mouth and marketing.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by chinathrow on Thursday January 07, 2021 @04:04PM (#25677448)
No, the nerds have not failed us.

The founders of WhatsApp has failed us by selling for FU money. I was happy paying them a fee in the beginning.

Then authorities have failed us by aproving the merger.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by j780 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:35AM (#25698936)
Maybe they didn't fail us... Wikipedia: On February 21, 2018, Moxie Marlinspike and WhatsApp co-founder Brian Acton announced the formation of the Signal Foundation
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by chinathrow on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:42AM (#25712888)
They failed us to sell WhatsApp to FB while the networks effects are (at least in Europe) in full effect. I simply can't abandon WhatsApp due to this now.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by fsflover on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:52AM (#25672371)
> It's too late to go back.

It's never too late. Spread the message and show people alternatives. I do.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by zepto on Thursday January 07, 2021 @08:45PM (#25680366)
Agreed - it’s also a win even if you just get someone to use signal in addition to WhatsApp, as I was able to do today.

Eventually abandoning WhatsApp will slowly get easier as alternatives propagate, and using two messengers really isn’t a problem now.

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by simplecto on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:47AM (#25671611)
Very well said.

Convenience > Privacy, which is an interesting conundrum.

This makes privacy a feature more than a USP (unique selling proposition). I predict that some "privacy" focused products and search engines will need to pivot to something more than just "we don't steal your data."

Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by imhoguy on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:04AM (#25671838)
There is no more nerds' voice which matters, it is marketing for some time.
Re:Poll: Switching from WhatsApp by eternalban on Thursday January 07, 2021 @01:57PM (#25675515)
I disagree with where and how this industry failed the rest of people. I can quote you numerous "nerds", such as the esteemed (/s) Eric Emerson Schmidt that told us on a public podium that it is unreasonable to have "an expectation of privacy "(a technical legal phrase, btw) when using the internet. So let's not blame this on the "smart phone" and usability.

In the late 80s and 90s, we had influential technologists that sold what became the Panopticon as a liberating force that would unleash creativity and usher in a new era of freedom. Most now work for one of the FANGs. The rest made a face saving effort via EFF.

> If privacy was high-value, any privacy-conscious competitor would've taken the market by storm.

Which VCs would fund them? VCs, even our gracious hosts YCombinator, are gate keepers of who & what gets funding.

Has YCombinator, with genuine educated and well informed geeks at the helm, ever supported a decentralized proposal?

Consumers can only choose from what is on the menu.

And "privacy conscious" competitors were not on the menu. Or maybe I did miss these. This is possible, so can you point out which VC funded "privacy conscious" startups failed against competing venture funded centralized systems?

To this day, non-geeks are not aware that it is possible for them to have their social apps while insuring their privacy.