They are hardly alone. There are so many issues to worry about you can really only afford to pay attention to a few. Water pollution, food pollution, being able to to be housed and fed 20 years ago...the list goes on and on. And computer security is obscure and way down the list.
And specifically addressing your case, the same is true of Windows and, TBH, all Linux distros. You've checked everything on your machine for back doors?
I would be quite surprised if American citizens were not able to come to a reasonable (at least partial fix) consensus on most of these issues in fairly short order if there was a platform designed specifically for making such decisions. Of course, getting any substantial value out of this knowledge would require a means to pass legislation, but "democracy" is at least as compromised and beyond control of the citizens as our software is.
Nonetheless, I think it would still be valuable to have a grassroots way for the public to actually voice their opinions on matters, at least then we could all have a good laugh in higher resolution at how we allowed control over our destiny to slip out of our hands, without putting up even the slightest fight.
Alternatively, they know what's going on and approve of it.
Consider that this blog post frames the issue as one of surveillance, instead of an anti-malware effort. If you are inclined to be anti-Apple-at-any-cost, then you will agree with the blog post. If you are a happy Apple user, you are inclined to go for the latter explanation.
> It's the strongest example of consumer cultism. Absolute in their exceptionalism and ignorance.
Now you're being ridiculous, snobby, and insinuating that you are of course immune to such motivations. Sucks to see this on HN.
It does address the idea of this system being intended to combat malware in the fourth and fifth paragraphs. The point it makes is that there's nothing stopping it from being used against legitimate software too, other than the benevolence of the "warlord" who controls it, so you're still just trusting them to protect you and hoping they don't take advantage of it.
That is exactly what Apple’s customers are doing.
It actually a pretty normal feature of modern society to trust institutions or businesses not to take advantage of particular powers they have.
It’s really bizarre to call a business a ‘warlord’.
The converse, where we can’t trust any institution or business and we must all be fully equipped to individually defend our own interests on our own is a lot more like a warlord situation.
That said, I agree that the centralized model is bad and we need to develop technology that is both secure and decentralized.
But currently no such technology exists.
Everyone has to trust someone.
The problem here is that Apple disallows user override, as the article explains. It's like asking that you trust your government but also allow yourself to be physically constrained from rising up and rebelling against it. And you're not only trusting Apple you're trusting whatever goverment Apple is accountable to where you live.
I'm ok with trusting Apple or Google for vetting most of the apps I have on my phone but I'm absolutely not ok with them restraining me from overriding their decisions when necessary.
We should therefore care about increased surveillance even though we personally can avoid some specific measures.
We wouldn't question someones concern about climate change just because they live in some Russian perma frost region either.
Both are global issues.
It’s a dark world fantasy extrapolation parallel to ‘the handmaids tale’ or even ‘qanon’.
There are hints at the realities being described, but we really aren’t anywhere near them being accurate.
The problem is that they can become a reality at the flick of a switch.
It would take a lot more than a flick of a switch.
They are already under a lot of scrutiny from governments without having flicked such a switch (whatever you imagine that switch to do).
It's not more bizarre than calling someone else's servers "the cloud". I'd call GAFAM warlords because they are monopolistic, force their unwanted preferences upon users and buy up competition so there is none to migrate to.
These companies have gained power by selling things people are choosing to buy.
not necessary if they gain it after the power vacuum
The behaviors these companies engage in are anti competitive. MS even saved Apple at one point so that in antitrust suit they could point out that other operating systems existed. GAFAM are not on the side of the people. For decades I never asked for a Windows license when buying PC, and yet I had no choice, most of the computers weren't available without giving MS a cut, that's a mob methods, take it leave it.
I have owned countless computers since the mid 80’s, and I have never been forced to purchase a windows license or used windows on a computer I bought for myself.
There have always been options.
Can't do it on a linux or mac, I guess I'll ask mum to buy me Windows 95
Do you have to go to a ‘Warlord’ to buy a My Little Pony too?
You don't need to turn over any data if you transmit which programs people start in the clear, unencrypted, easily observable, to one of your servers.
And they do turn it over. They tried to make icloud end to end encrypted but then didn't do it at the behest of the US government. They employ the same tactics as zoom by claiming that icloud is encrypted, trying to make people believe that it's end to end encrypted. The encryption key still sits with them though.
Yes, there are some high profile cases where they very publicly refused the feds. Got a lot of publicity. That was their main goal, to paint an image of them not turning over user data.
Maybe apple indeed collects less user data than Google. But they still collect many things, and it's way harder to escape apple's collection than to escape Google's collection as their OSs are so locked down.
Qubes/Whonix/Tails or any hardened linux distros is a practical and widely accepted alternative in the security field.
To my knowledge I don't think I recall anybody using a comprehensive "pen test" framework on a Mac.
> has refused to turn over user data even after legal challenges from the federal government
While this is true, it never stopped the agencies from getting their data through other means.
There is a company in Israel that specializes in unlocking iPhone data. It recently lead to the arrest of a child sex cult ring in South Korea.
> doesn’t generate revenues from advertising and selling user data.
neither does Microsoft if you consider the metrics are used internally and using it to optimize their product to maximize revenues.
I will agree that it is less pervasive than Google or Facebook.
Apple turned over the user data of over 30,000 customers without a warrant to the US government in 2019, per their own transparency report (see under FISA).
Apple also does not end to end encrypt device backups specifically to aid the FBI.
You have subscribed to a false narrative.
Or, you know, we're as informed (or more) than you, but have different priorities and opinions.
Other people that are not merely mindless sheep, where you and those agreeing with you are the only smart people? What a wild concept!
I've used anything, from 4 major unices of yore, to FreeBSD, a dozen of Linux varieties, Windows, and modern Linux.
I still enjoy macOS more and I agree with lots of the decisions taken in that ecosystem (not every one, but more than not).
You are free to buy something else.
>The lowest common denominator of consumer cultism is surveillance and it's no surprise that both Apple and Tesla do exceptionally well in authoritarian countries like China.
A non sequitur if I ever saw one...
> we have different priorities
That's a different way of saying "we don't care". You aren't really contradicting the other person's point.
And yet, I am. The weasel phrasing "we don't care" implies:
(a) we should care
(b) everybody should care
(c) we're doing the wrong thing by not caring
In other words, it takes the parent's prioritization as some absolute correct one everybody should agree on (this is also evident from the rest of the comment).
As opposed to merely "we have different priorities, and we don't believe yours are important".
If the parent changed the "they don't care" accusation to a neutral "they don't care about the things I care", I'd undersign it.
I would enjoy macOS if it subscribed to open source ideals, but then it wouldn't be Apple right
> You are free to buy something else.
That's exactly the advice I give to everyone who asks me about appel
Yes, and what's more troubling, I think it also wouldn't be macOS.
macOS can be more open, but it can't "subscribe to open source ideals" (and even less so the "bazaar model") without stopping being macOS.
It offers something else, and some of it could be replicated in FOSS (e.g. Gnome has copied tons of those, as have certain distros), but part of it stems from it being walled, and curated.
And it's not cut and dry which parts are the latter ones.
E.g. I think that "deprecating things" the way Apple does and no FOSS would dare do (due to inertia and community-driven nature) makes macOS able to adopt new stuff faster, and adopt it more wholly (e.g. with no leftover apps with 10 layers of old GUIs like in Windows).
Similarly the "my way or the highway" from Apple helps keep the platform focused (as opposed to all the FOSS hoopla, X vs Wayland, KDE vs Gnome vs XFCE etc, systemd vs init, and tons of other minituae and duplication of effort). We'd still be discussing Metal in FOSS land (well, we have 10 years of moving from X to Wayland and it's still going on). In macOS it's a done deal.
(That's irrelevant of whether that new stuff is better or worse, btw. It can be either - but it can be either faster, and more uniformly. That's a quality FOSS lacks, and which I appreciate over customizability).
I'm very much not ok with the iOS model where Apple and my government have veto-proof power over what software I can run on my hardware.
Sure, what the hell. It's a deal, email me and I'll run:
find ~/Downloads -type f -executable
On video for you.I am Apple user and I care a lot for my self and my privacy. Thats why I will not support this company with my money. Some people are aware, but unfortunately we run a business in which Mac OS as software platform is superior. Little Snitch is installed in all my Apple computers. In last 5 years after every os update, telemetry from mothership is exponentially more. I don't like this direction and have taken active measures to change my business operation and remove everything Apple related excluding some graphic software and audio. Windows is not an option.
Apple is a company that openly dislikes professional users and focusing marketing efforts to semi pro audience by using powerful tribe psychology, trends and sentiments to create public perception of a Good Shepard and Guardian.
In reality they know that future is data based and Google has advantage in this market. So they correct direction to recondition public over the idea of personal computing and transform Mac OS to iOS UX with already established consumer habit of no control and minimum transparency.
From business perspective the idea that someone will have a log file with my office activity is non acceptable. Period. Apple knows this and recently stopped standalone updates. This pushes businesses to avoid sandboxing of Apple computers in corporate network.
The message is clear. You rent Mac Os as a service, the price is your data. It is Beautified Google:)
Out of curiosity, what business is that? Music? Video editing?
From what I see in discussions: they do care. But it seems they have simply accepted Apple as a benevolent dictator.
I think if people bothered to read beyond blind hatred, they'd see Apple users _do_ tend to care - and are often very critical of Apple, which is what you'd want. Hell, read any of Sneak's comments on here - they might be the perfect example.
Ultimately, until another ecosystem can match what Apple provides (Windows & Linux do not), I don't see a particular point in attempting to switch. I'd rather be critical of Apple, disable the things I don't like or trust, and then do actual things with my life.
The article linked here is pretending that didn't happen. And you are pretending, against all evidence, that Apple users don't care. But it's apple users who complained and sounded the alarm in the first place. Your statement is so obviously and trivially false it's crazy to see any one up voting it.
Windows & Linux probably aren't the answer to the trillion-dollar juggernaut that is Apple.
OSS has drawn the talent, and there's a lot of talent building enterprise applications, most of which are the bricks in the wall of mega-tech as they re-write our rights.
Macs are great if you want access to the financial funnel that is the app stores now. That probably defines the echo chamber of silence that exists on this subject.
Windows, that indie project from the mom & pop software store :-))
Microsoft is another trillion dollar corporation, not that far behind Apple.
They simply do not care at all what's being done to them.
This is an ignorant view to take. I'm a pretty dedicated apple user but only because the other options don't have the tools I need and the UX I desire.Likely many of the flaws apple products have are piling up to a "straw that broke the camels back" situation for users in a few years or decades.
When you assume other's intentions and feelings, bad things happen.
This is totally fine. But there's where the friction between the two viewpoints is.
There are some refugees from Apple periodically though.
I'm not really an Apple fan, per se, but I do own a macbook and the reason is this: It's not worth my time to switch to Linux. I have a core i7 Thinkpad that I also run Debian+KDE on, and the user experience is much worse, to say nothing of track pad quality and battery life.
I'm a parent and I'm not a software developer in my professional life, which means every minute spent figuring out why Linux won't do $thing properly is a minute not spent on more important things.
The opportunity cost of using free software is just too high for my use case.
It's the strongest example of consumer cultism. Absolute in their exceptionalism and ignorance. Similar problems discussed in the article are found in Tesla.
The lowest common denominator of consumer cultism is surveillance and it's no surprise that both Apple and Tesla do exceptionally well in authoritarian countries like China.
When our data is worth more than a barrel of oil, strange things are happening.