News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by porknubbins on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:26AM (#25583008)
Somehow the idea of a computer error killing me seems way worse than at least having a chance to save myself, since I’m a very cautious driver (though unlikely safer than average by 5x) . Self driving cars need to get to airline level safety where crashes are a rare thing and most people don’t think twice about giving up control to the pilots/auto pilot. If that takes expensive Lidar thats what we should use. I can’t imagine ever feeling good about trusting my life to a computer vision algorithm.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by colechristensen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:49AM (#25583235)
A computer error is going to be scarier by far.

When a human kills someone with a car it is almost always in a way we can empathize. When you’re around cars you have pretty good mental models for the humans that drive them and how the car will behave.

When you’re around human piloted cars you can look at the driver and get a pretty good idea of intent. You can tell if the driver sees you, you can tell what their mental state is, if they’re paying attention, what they intend to do. You can sum up a person with a glance, this is the power of evolution, we’re really good at figuring things out about other living things.

Crossing the street in front of a car is a leap of faith, not troubling at all when there’s a human there, but a robot? There’s no body posture, no gestures, no facial expressions, nothing to go on. There’s a computer in control of a powerful heavy machine that you’re just expected to trust.

Robot cars don’t make human mistakes, they make alien mistakes like running down kids on the sidewalk in broad daylight, things which don’t make any sense at all that make people feel like they aren’t anywhere safe.

It won’t take but a couple of cute kids killed in a surprising matter to shut down the whole autonomous experiment.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by twoWhlsGud on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:38PM (#25587669)
From experience I can say that's it's pretty disturbing when a human driver breaks your model, too. And this happens more often than I'd like - I was second in a set of pedestrians about to cross the street (two lane arterial with a 25mph limit - heavily used by both cars and peds - at a cross walk I use several times a week) - the guy in front of me and I both judged that the driver was looking in our direction (it was dark admittedly but street is well-lit) and the car slowed in a fashion that led us to think it was going to stop.

The fellow in front of me steps in front of the car which suddenly accelerates and hits him knocking him down. Immediately before impact it decelerates and comes to a stop.

The fellow ended more shaken up than anything else, but it was a very near thing and a reminder that it's precisely that assumption of the predictability of human drivers that fails in many crash situations.

In other words, your judgement that you understand what other drivers are going to do is more fragile than you imagine.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by itchyouch on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:19PM (#25589230)
It seems that most of the radar systems today in cars (in the US) are pretty adept at detecting pedestrians reliably and engaging the automatic emergency braking system to at least minimize the potential for harm.

On my 2018 Lexus, AEB won't come to a complete stop, but it will definitely slow from say 40mph to 20mph, so hitting a pedestrian at 20 hopefully has a much better outcome than hitting them at 40+.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by dado3212 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:59AM (#25583336)
> Crossing the street in front of a car is a leap of faith, not troubling at all when there’s a human there, but a robot? There’s no body posture, no gestures, no facial expressions, nothing to go on. There’s a computer in control of a powerful heavy machine that you’re just expected to trust.

This is something that's very solvable though. Robot cars should and almost definitely will have a way to communicate to pedestrians. I agree with the general point though around a greater possibility of very out of the norm mistakes.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by wool_gather on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:38PM (#25583757)
There's an opportunity for them to communicate better with pedestrians than the average human driver. Drivers tend to assume that their intent to stop or not to stop is obvious and don't bother with a clear signal like flashing their lights or waving visibly.

From the pedestrian's perspective, it can be hard to see the driver at all (small movements of the hand can be invisible in sun glare; direction of gaze likewise), and also hard to tell what they're doing. Just because they're slowing somewhat as they approach doesn't mean they see you or intend to stop.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway201103 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:28PM (#25588077)
One could imagine a standardized set of signals on the front of the car. Red = stopped/stopping. Yellow = about to start moving; Green = moving and continuing. Something like that.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by jfim on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:15PM (#25585558)
Drive AI (now acquired by Apple I believe) used to have LED matrix displays that communicated that way with other road users. I recall seeing them say things like "waiting for you to cross" or "driving autonomously" with an icon.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Fricken on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:19PM (#25588006)
They really just needed a pair of animated eyes.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:56PM (#25588708)
White parka crossing a snow covered road. Will the AI make the right decision?
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by beat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:16PM (#25583520)
When a human kills someone with a car because they're drunk, or texting, I don't have much empathy for them.

I read a statistic long ago - don't know how true it is, but it feels truthy - that half of all traffic fatalities happen between 9pm and 3am on friday and saturday nights. The fact that autonomous systems will never be intoxicated, distracted, or emotional makes me feel much safer.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:29PM (#25585057)
A brick tied to the gas pedal will also never be intoxicated. It takes more than inability for intoxication to make a system that can drive a car safely.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by staunch on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:27PM (#25583640)
That stat seems to be very untruthy. Fatal crashes seem to be distributed much more evenly than I would've guessed.

https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/overview/crashes-b...

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by beat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:42PM (#25583809)
Maybe not 50%, but there's certainly a strong bias in that data toward friday/saturday nights. Since the data resets at midnight rather than on bar hours, look at the difference in midnight-4am data on saturday and sunday mornings, vs the rest of the week.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:07PM (#25587933)
Those are also the only nights when people are out at all. People who have to be at work on weekday mornings aren't driving home from visiting their parents late on a Tuesday night, they're doing it late on a Saturday night. Yeah, it probably is alcohol but there's a lot of confounding factors.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway201103 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:34PM (#25588117)
Indeed. A drunk driver alone on the road isn't really a danger to anyone but himself.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ealexhudson on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:29PM (#25583653)
It only makes me feel safer if those systems are substantially safer than humans.

If the systems are broadly as safe as humans _including_ a significant set who are drunk / high / distracted, that feels subjectively much less safe even though the statistical number of accidents is the same.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by beat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:37PM (#25583753)
Oh, I concur. I want it measured against skilled, sober, attentive drivers, not "bad" drivers.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ageofwant on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:11PM (#25588400)
Everybody drives better than the average, until they get distracted or tired. A AV driver that passes the standardised driving test 1M times in a row is good for me.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by hypertele-Xii on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:58PM (#25587851)
Well, now we've transferred the responsibility: Now the programmers of the car's AI must never be intoxicated, distracted, or emotional while creating it. Also, the business people managing the programmers must not be greedy, callous, or incompetent, which is a tough sell.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ageofwant on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:52PM (#25588265)
So we need AI driver certification then. Just like we have with people. If the AI can past the, perhaps 5x human capability test, its licensed to drive, just like the 16 year old teenager driving his new truck on the highway behind you with his four buddies scolling coors.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by beat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:47PM (#25583878)
The one time I was hit by a car as a pedestrian was a driver who wasn't paying attention. He was making a perfectly legal left turn at a green light, except for the pedestrians in the way (me and my girlfriend).

The danger with an autonomous vehicle is it not seeing you. The danger with a driver is not noticing you.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by itchyouch on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:24PM (#25589254)
I'd think that with the radar systems in place today, vehicles would have far greater reliability in "seeing" you.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by kaba0 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:16AM (#25591964)
But that doesn’t require self-driving, but a commonly implemented emergency brake in a ‘normal’ car.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ridgeguy on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:41PM (#25588184)
> Robot cars don’t make human mistakes, they make alien mistakes like running down kids on the sidewalk in broad daylight, things which don’t make any sense at all that make people feel like they aren’t anywhere safe.

This expresses well the perceived difference between catastrophic human and machine errors.

I have two cars, a ’99 4Runner and a Tesla Model S.

When driving my S, I’m at an involuntary elevated state of alertness compared to my 4Runner. I think it’s discomfort at driving a car that might suddenly kill me through failure modes that I can’t possibly anticipate.

While I think my S’s technology is much more likely to result in my safe travel than my dumb iron 4Runner, my subconscious maintains a different assessment.

I expect this dichotomy in perceived risk is generational and will disappear after a decade or two of lower accident rates in autonomous vehicles compared to human drivers.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by itchyouch on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:28PM (#25589279)
I outfitted my car with Comma's openpilot and I can concur with that my experience is similar with the additional effect that overall, my driving quality of life is significantly improved.

I can tell that I already have an inordinate amount of trust in the system several weeks in on boring highway driving.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by mcot2 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:05PM (#25583395)
We can eventually make AI do any of that better than a human by a long shot.

We tend to overestimate the power of the human brain. There is a lot we don’t know yet, but we shouldn’t treat it as magic and unsolvable by AI.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by panta on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:06PM (#25584154)
There is no evidence that AI can reach the level of skill and safety of a human driver. I’m not saying that it’s not possible, only there is no reason to be sure of the contrary. IMHO we are extremely far.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by mcot2 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:04PM (#25584811)
And IMHO we are extremely close. There is lots of evidence that AI can be much _better_ than a human driver, although currently on things like well mapped highway driving with clear conditions. Whats going on now is just making that general purpose for all different types of enviornments.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by mcguire on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:02PM (#25587331)
Out of curiosity, do you have a specific source for,

"There is lots of evidence that AI can be much _better_ than a human driver, although currently on things like well mapped highway driving with clear conditions."

The only thing I know about is claims from Tesla, comparing Autopilot (in "well mapped highway driving with clear conditions") versus general human drivers (and which, as I recall, had some further sketchiness).

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by kaba0 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:18AM (#25591981)
They can easily surpass humans in really specified problems like looking at millions of cells and identifying which is likely cancerous. Today’s AIs are pretty bad at complex problems where each subproblem would require a specific AI and then some logical thinking on top measuring each results’ to each other. And driving in non-trivial circumstances is definitely in the latter category
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by rtx on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:49PM (#25589387)
Without special infra, we are atleast 50 years away.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by glandium on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:08PM (#25588787)
> well mapped highway driving with clear conditions

and perfectly visible unambiguous markings. The bar is rather low.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by asiachick on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:11PM (#25583466)
Honda did an experiment where they added LCD's to the headlights to give the car expressive eyes to communicate to people outside the car.

Also while it is scary to us and it will take a while there are already self driven vehicles we just take for granted like elevators and driverless trams/trains. Sure they are much easier to make but they weren't trusted at first.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ntsplnkv2 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:52PM (#25588679)
This comparison is just not a good one.

Trains are on a track, the scenario never really changes. The variables are low. Just like in an elevator, which is largely a mechanical device anyway. There is no real decision making.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bwat49 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:07PM (#25584168)
and here I was about to make a joke about adding emoticons to the front of self driving cars
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway201103 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:36PM (#25588136)
No need for anything so corny. Just need some standardized signaling. We already have it for brake lights and turn indicators.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by dkobran on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:49PM (#25584655)
> When a human kills someone with a car it is almost always in a way we can empathize

Nonsense. You can empathize with someone texting and killing someone?

This whole post reads like an attempt to appeal to people’s emotional attachment to human drivers coupled with fearmongering about robots.

You are placing far too much emphasis one our ability to “read” other drivers intent and the impact this has on automobile accident fatalities. Many accidents occur without any chance to see the offending driver e.g. accidents at night, someone switching lanes when you are in their blind spot, a drunk driver suddenly doing something erratic, etc. Moreover, this so-called advantage of human drivers is statistically meaningless unless you believe that the number of deaths due to automobile accidents is at an acceptable level and that it cannot be improved with technology, in this case, AV. I certainly don’t believe that. In the not too distant future, I believe this position will be laughable. Through adoption of autonomous vehicles, many predict we will drastically cut the number of fatalities. Will there be issues along the road? Most certainly. But as long as the overall number is falling by a significant amount, we simply cannot justify our love affair with humans “being in control”. We’ve proven to be perennially distracted, we have terrible reaction times, we have extremely narrow vision, we panic in situations instead of remaining calm, etc. and yes, these faults do lead to the deaths of children. These are not theoretical deaths like the robot scare tactic examples, these are actual deaths from human drivers.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ksk on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:43PM (#25585183)
>Through adoption of autonomous vehicles, many predict we will drastically cut the number of fatalities.

Who are these many people, and why should we believe their predictions?

> We’ve proven to be perennially distracted, we have terrible reaction times, we have extremely narrow vision, we panic in situations instead of remaining calm, etc. and yes, these faults do lead to the deaths of children.

We've also proven that all software has bugs, and developers keep introducing new bugs in every single release. There is no reason to think that self-driving car software will be any different. Whats worse is that when software is updated, these bugs will now be pushed out to tens of thousands of cars - instantly.

Bit much to call someones position nonsense when they're just skeptical of obvious stuff :)

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by dkobran on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:23PM (#25585638)
I was referring the absurdity of empathizing with drivers who kill people while texting, drunk, etc. (hence the quotation). What part of that statement do you agree with?

But I’ll go further and double down and say the entire post is nonsense. Why? Because the author’s skepticism doesn’t extend to the human factor. The position is not an accurate representation of the facts i.e what causes accidents (humans) and the known data around AVs today. If AV risk is so obvious as you claim then why does the enormous amount of data show that AVs are involved in the less accidents and lead to less fatalities than cars operated by humans on a mile per mile basis? And how is the negligent human driver not obvious as a source of automobile fatalities? The notion that we are safe because we can read humans is not substantiated by anything. Maybe you believe this number of fatalities is acceptable or the best we can do but I certainly don’t. There will be flaws in autonomous vehicles, no doubt. But will there be a net reduction in automobile related fatalities as a result? Like anyone else, I can’t predict the future. But to paint a rosy picture about how our ability to read other drivers is somehow safer relative to AVs is nonsense. It just is. The data doesn’t support this argument. And separately, if we’re talking about will happen in the future, the notion that humans will ultimately prevail over AVs because for safety reasons seems preposterous. We can debate the “when” in terms of AVs but debating the “if” seems pretty out of touch with the way society has progressed with respect to our willingness to depend on technology.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ksk on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @05:53PM (#25587251)
>Because the author’s skepticism doesn’t extend to the human factor.

And your over-enthusiasm for AV doesn't extend to the human factor. We all have our own blinders ;)

>The notion that we are safe because we can read humans is not substantiated by anything.

That is your own misinterpretation. I did not read the comment that way.

>If AV risk is so obvious as you claim then why does the enormous amount of data show that AVs are involved in the less accidents and lead to less fatalities than cars operated by humans on a mile per mile basis?

What you mean when you say AV, is actually "AV + Human". We're running controlled experiments, limiting the unknowns, and we're mandating a human be present - because the current AV technology sucks.

> We can debate the “when” in terms of AVs but debating the “if” seems pretty out of touch with the way society has progressed with respect to our willingness to depend on technology.

People used to say that about flying cars 40 years ago.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by wnkrshm on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:29PM (#25588519)
A future where AVs exist that can replace human drivers is a future where so many requirements and drivers for personal mobility have changed as well: due to the possibility of replacing a human performing a highly complex task in situ.

That future may not even want or need cars.

The other, more realistic future is one where human-level AVs are always just out of reach. Where causes of accidents are just as intransparent as with human drivers, we're all a little bit safer but a patch can cause catastrophic divergent behavior due to the innate non-linearity of the problem.

That future may not want or need cars either but it may not even be considered.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:38PM (#25588989)
> The other, more realistic future is one where human-level AVs are always just out of reach.

That sounds pretty unlikely to me. "just out of reach" is a very narrow band, and to be stuck there despite decades of improvements would be pretty strange. I think there are only two likely outcomes for the next 50 to 100 years: either we don't even get particularly close, or we'll slowly but surely surpass the median human driver.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ksk on Thursday December 31, 2020 @01:13PM (#25595284)
>That future may not even want or need cars.

Agreed, 100%. Instead of AV, we could focus on remote presence and other tech to make cars and/or daily commute unnecessary.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by henrikschroder on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:12PM (#25589501)
> Robot cars don’t make human mistakes, they make alien mistakes like running down kids on the sidewalk in broad daylight, things which don’t make any sense at all that make people feel like they aren’t anywhere safe.

This.

It doesn't matter if autonomous cars are objectively safer, 5x, 10x, 100x, doesn't matter. They have to be subjectively safer, which is part PR problem, UI problem, and part human stubbornness problem.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tuatoru on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:33PM (#25584478)
> When you’re around human piloted cars you can look at the driver and get a pretty good idea of intent. You can tell if the driver sees you ...

This is a key area of driving that has been completely overlooked in AVs so far - giving feedback to other non-car road users.

Not hard on the face of it (excuse the pun).

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:19PM (#25584327)
> It won’t take but a couple of cute kids killed in a surprising matter to shut down the whole autonomous experiment.

That is sacrificing the counterfactual children that wouldn't have been killed if the bad human driver had been replaced by an average autonomous car.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ntsplnkv2 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:53PM (#25588687)
Society isn't without emotion.

As much as we engineers want to look at numbers and say "see, safer!" That does little to help people who have had deaths, or the visceral impact that death can have.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:34PM (#25624415)
You also end up reducing the number of people who are impacted by death or who have to feel those emotions. Yes, in the process of touching the system you also end up shuffling around who gets affected but in the end it's just part of the process of affecting fewer people.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Chyzwar on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:15PM (#25584285)
Once self-driving is better we need to do is to create moral rules for AI.

There is a car controlled by computer. Pedestrian (child) abruptly enter into road from behind cover. The Computer knows that with current speed it is impossible to stop. Its other choices is to drive into the sidewalk killing an old lady, drive into the opposite lane risking the life of a car owner and people in another car.

A Human driver can decide on instinct, usually protecting themselves. The Computer needs to have an algorithm that decide who will live and who dies.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by glandium on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:19PM (#25588870)
Why is it always about running to the sidewalk or the other lane? There's also the option to reduce speed as much as possible, aka break hard, that a computer can do a) earlier than a human would b) much harder than a human would. Yes, the people in the car might take a lot of negative Gs. But that's also an option. The car might still hit the kid, but the difference could be some broken bones, or with chance, bruises, vs. death.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by jjav on Thursday December 31, 2020 @04:22AM (#25591041)
> There's also the option to reduce speed as much as possible, aka break hard, that a computer can do a) earlier than a human would b) much harder than a human would.

a) A computer can initiate braking a small fraction of a second faster than a human, which is great but not such a huge difference in braking distance.

b) A computer cannot brake any harder than a human, certainly not "much harder". The max deceleration rate is traction-limited, which any remotely modern car (last ~25 years) can easily sustain with an untrained driver thanks to modern ABS.

(As a side hobby I instruct in car control and accident avoidance clinics. Blindly braking hard is not often the best answer.)

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by glandium on Thursday December 31, 2020 @04:44AM (#25591171)
Most people don't actually hit the brakes as hard as they could or should.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:19PM (#25584338)
> The Computer knows that with current speed it is impossible to stop.

Then the car was going too fast. Full stop. The rest of your scenario is irrelevant.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:15PM (#25587976)
>Then the car was going too fast. Full stop. The rest of your scenario is irrelevant.

How can you possibly say that with a straight face?

There will be situations where a car is going a perfectly fine speed for the situation and then the situation changes in a way the car cannot have seen, known about, or anticipated resulting in a crash. This happens all the time with human drivers. It will happen with AI drivers too.

Furthermore, we don't subject anything else that moves to this burden, why would we do so for cars (AI or otherwise)?

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:41PM (#25589004)
> There will be situations where a car is going a perfectly fine speed for the situation and then the situation changes in a way the car cannot have seen, known about, or anticipated resulting in a crash.

The parent's situation was not one of those. This was a situation where "Pedestrian (child) abruptly enter into road from behind cover." and there's an old lady on the sidewalk. In other words, there's a situation with limited visibility, limited room to maneuver (since the only other option is to go up on the sidewalk) and pedestrians present (the child may not be known but the old lady was). If you're in that situation and you're going too fast that you can't stop on a dime, you were not going a "perfectly fine speed for the situation".

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Chyzwar on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:41PM (#25625027)
In European cities you will often see pedestrians walking 1m from cars driving 50-70 km/h. Human drivers can take this risk, AI to be useful needs to handle it well.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:52PM (#25589067)
If 95% of human drivers do something, then you can't just call it "irrelevant" because you think it's wrong to do.

And humans don't go past parked cars on a street at 5mph.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @12:31AM (#25589894)
20mph is slow enough to essentially ensure collisions aren't fatal.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @01:33AM (#25590154)
But they still get hit. And the first paper in google suggests that 5% are still going to die. That's pretty far from sure.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:12AM (#25592811)
My reference shows 1% at 30km/h. But even 1% is too high. But luckily you also usually get a chance to scrub off some speed through braking. Braking follows a square law, so driving a little bit slower gains a massive difference in stopping distances.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by closeparen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:22PM (#25588891)
When you already believe that cars should not exist, it’s not much of a stretch to say that cars which do exist should be limited to less than a walking pace anywhere pedestrians might be present.

There’s a thing about the car companies having essentially stolen public space from the everyone else when they made it incumbent on pedestrians to watch out for cars, and a desire to reverse this.

Of course this would pretty much invalidate them as a transportation mechanism, but that’s the point.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:56PM (#25589095)
I think you could simultaneously have a better improvement for pedestrians and less impact on traffic by turning those parking spaces into sidewalks and greenery.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:30PM (#25588944)
> Furthermore, we don't subject anything else that moves to this burden, why would we do so for cars (AI or otherwise)?

Yes we do. There are many jurisdictions where in a pedestrian-car collision, the car is presumed to be at fault unless the driver can prove otherwise.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by a_t48 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:44PM (#25587729)
Have you as a human ever come into this situation?
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by mankyd on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:42AM (#25583168)
While I don't disagree, I will note that most people don't think twice about giving up control to bus and taxi drivers.*

I think we trust humans to make a reasonable decision in a trolley-problem scenario (rightly or wrongly). Or rather, we trust the human we're in a vehicle with to value their own life, and thus our own, more than those outside of the vehicle in most scenarios.

I expect there is research to investigate this, though I wouldn't know where to begin looking.

*I've definitely had a few bad drivers, of course.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by xiphias2 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:59AM (#25583337)
I always sit in the back of the taxi (just like what Waymo does), and that already significantly decreases my chances of dieing. And with bus it's again easily more than 5x safer than a car.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by nelgaard on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:26PM (#25583620)
Busses are generally much safer because they are bigger and heavier. Except in mountains. But I only encounter that on holidays and on holidays we take a lot more risks.

And I do think twice about taxis.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by wnkrshm on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:43PM (#25588622)
Bus vs. AV: AV rider dead, lots of injuries in the bus. That's conservation of energy and momentum.

Assuming some utilitaristic equation for minimizing total injury, an AV bus probably won't swerve, and probably won't brake significantly except if colliding with a heavy or fast vehicle.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by sliken on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:40AM (#25583142)
Problem is, 95% [1] of drivers think they are better than average.

[1] citation needed.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by senko on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:53AM (#25583279)
Happy to oblige: https://www.smithlawco.com/blog/2017/december/do-most-driver...

In summary: in a study done in 1980, 93% of Americans thought themselves better than an average driver.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tjoff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:02PM (#25583368)
And they are all correct.

Except for when they haven't slept, or aren't paying attention etc.

That is not a good baseline to compare self-driving cars against. That would be horrific.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:21PM (#25584359)
The average baseline involves a driver that is not paying attention or hasn't slept X% of the time. You cannot magically wave away all the bad days and pretend only the good humans are on the streets. The bad days happen, people die. The autonomous vehicle only has to do better than that. That's the whole point.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tjoff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:47PM (#25584635)
Statistically no. But you need to convince people - that is the point.

We are not rational. We do not respond well to a car running straight into a barrier or stand-still vehicle at 100 km/h without even attempting to brake (such as the failure modes that Tesla has demonstrated) even if it does well most of the time and has better statistics than an average human.

And further, as noted in the thread, a good part of driving is assessing other vehicles and vehicles behaving oddly (even if it is objectively better in isolation) is really bad and will increase the risk of collisions.

I think google have experienced this, that people do not respond well do the driving technique of their car since it doesn't behave as a human - not that it does anything wrong.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:51PM (#25584671)
Individuals may not act rationally but regulators and insurance companies with their birds-eye view will see the hard numbers and hopefully provide incentives aligned with the rational choice.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:08AM (#25593312)
Regulators at some point defer to voters. It’s going to matter much more what voters are led to believe than what the numbers say.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tjoff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:55PM (#25584714)
I hope not. I expect them to produce cars that are much better than the average human before setting them free on the road.

That is the rational choice given the human psyche.

We can barely even convince people that vaccines are good.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:57PM (#25584739)
Just as with vaccines waiting for better cars means letting more people die in the meantime. That is a grim hope.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tjoff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:29PM (#25585058)
If companies rush this (as Tesla and Uber already has!) too much the backlash will likely set back self-driving unnecessarily.

I believe a more careful approach will get broader adoption and likely save more lives.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by the8472 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:53PM (#25585302)
I didn't suggest that the technology should be rushed and I agree that a careful approach can save more lives. But what constitutes "careful" matters here. For example if a city chooses to offer robotaxi discounts to people with bad driving records (before some cutoff date to avoid perverse incentives) then even an average taxi fleet could be a net-benefit even though the taxis do not perform better than the general population. And that's just in terms of lives saved, not counting the other benefits of having cheap transportation.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by nelgaard on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:09PM (#25583451)
Which says:

== Obviously, not everyone can be above average. Exactly half of all drivers have to be in the bottom half when it comes to driving skills and safety. ==

Maybe, but the bottom half is not necessary drivers worse than average.

I do not know how you would calculate "average". But there are people on the road that could pull down the average a lot. So that more than 50 percent are better than average.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by adwn on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:47PM (#25583880)
In colloquial speech, most people don't differentiate between "mean" and "median". My guess is that, in that kind of survey, the participants read or say "average" and implicitly mean "median" – and exactly 50 percent of drivers are better than the median, by definition.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:02PM (#25589128)
The problem with not differentiating clearly between mean and median, is that you look out at other drivers and calculate a mean, then you assume that the median is the same. With a sufficiently skewed distribution this will hugely inflate your numbers, even if you have a realistic perspective of your actual skill.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Ajedi32 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:04PM (#25583387)
Which could be true, assuming the median skill level of drivers is sufficiently higher than the average.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by gifnamething on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:22PM (#25583584)
Mean is an average, not the average. Mode is an average. Median is an average.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:03PM (#25589134)
> Mode is an average.

They sure do claim that to elementary school children. But using mode sounds absolutely insane to me. Does any field actually do that?

Maybe you could carefully bucket/smooth your data and then use the peak, but that's a far cry from taking raw numbers and looking at the most common.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by matt-attack on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:42AM (#25583161)
I feel the opposite. The one sensor that is guaranteed to have sufficient information to drive in all conditions is vision. That's obviously because humans drive exclusively with vision (and a single vantage point to boot - modulo mirrors).
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by ghaff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:17PM (#25583528)
>The one sensor that is guaranteed to have sufficient information to drive in all conditions is vision.

Minor nit but humans can't drive--certainly not safely--in all conditions. You can certainly get to a point in fog, blizzards, and even very heavy rain where you really would like to get off the road if possible. (Not always possible of course and in snow particularly, pulling off to the side of a highway isn't a great option.)

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by wool_gather on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:48PM (#25583895)
Not a nit at all; the parent comment has the cart completely in front of the horse. Humans use vision (primarily) to drive because it's the only sense we have that's even close to being sufficient.

There are certainly other senses (lidar, ultrasound, radio signals) that robots could avail themselves of that would be helpful even in conditions where vision also worked.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by jschwartzi on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:57AM (#25583319)
Kind of. The difference between human vision and computer vision is that human vision is stereoscopic. We perceive depth in addition to color and shape. And that gives us the ability to perceive the 3-dimensional shape of an object, which lets us anticipate how it might move. A lot of CV algorithms operate on single images from a single camera, which makes it impossible to judge depth. In that case you'd have to use the size of an object as a proxy for its distance and speed, so you'd tend to misjudge how far things are from you and where they're going.

The nice thing about LIDAR is that you can gather that depth/shape information and with sufficient calibration map the shapes in the camera image to the depths in the LIDAR image. You can do the same thing with two cameras so I'm not sure why LIDAR would be preferred here.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by tjoff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:09PM (#25583440)
We don't need two eyes to drive. And we don't need two eyes to gauge depth. Neither does a machine, but adding stereoscopic cameras is not hard.

The stereoscopic effect is very poor on driving distances, doesn't help us that much. Primarily we use clues form the environment to gauge distances. We also have to focus our eyes to the correct distance - that also tells us how far an object is.

Primarily we have had an insane amount of training to understand our world. An understanding that a self-driving car will never achieve unless singularity happens. It might not need that, but it will need other ways to compensate for it.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by sliken on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:28PM (#25584420)
Tesla as an example has 3 forward looking cameras, additionally a single moving camera can sense depth since differences between frames relates to the distance from the camera.

LIDAR has its advantages, like precise 3D positions under ideal conditions. However there are downsides as well. Cost is a big one, but that's becoming less of a issue over time. Another is sensitivity to rain, fog, blowing sand, etc.

A complicating factor is human driven cars will assume cars to act like they have human limitations. So higher speeds when humans can see well, and low speeds when humans can't.

Not sure Tesla's current sensors will do it, but seems like camera based systems are likely to be quite competitive with LIDAR. Maybe instead of 3 forward cameras, 6 or 8 so there's overlapping views (for stereoscopic vision), handling failures better, and allowing a narrower field of view at a higher zoom.

More range will be a huge help, that way an autonomous car can slow more gently when uncertain and drive more like a human. After all superhuman reflexes aren't much use if you get rear ended all the time.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by vagrantJin on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:20PM (#25584982)
> You can do the same thing with two cameras so I'm not sure why LIDAR would be preferred here.

I almost spilled my beer about to comment that a camera or two are equally if not more powerful than lidar. To me personally, Lidar feels like an incomplete solution to 3D mapping when high res images from a smartphone camera can provide so many more data points from different angles.

My thinking was vehicles should have an idea where other vehicles are without the need for comp viz. Like beacons saying "hey Im here." And we can try to calculate relative direction and distance. The vision bit should ideally come in to validate and confirm other things like road signs etc. Ideally we should add that data to mapping software andnthe car should know these things without "seeing it".

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by yarcob on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:07PM (#25584165)
You can get 3D data from a single moving camera. The technique is called structure from motion and has been demonstrated to work well more than a decade ago.

The biggest problem with relying on visual data is that you get very noisy data. Poor lighting and reflective or glossy surfaces cause problems (I'm not sure what current state of the art is, it's been a few years since I looked at the research).

As far as I understand the big advantage of LIDAR is that you get nice and clean depth data and it's not so computationally expensive.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by beat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:51PM (#25583941)
That's why one place I really want a driving assist is automatically backing out of spaces in parking lots. Visibility is terrible for the driver. You need to be paying close attention in multiple directions at once, you often don't have visibility at all when you need to start moving (like a larger vehicle parked next to you), and both pedestrians and other vehicles can appear out of nowhere, often moving in unexpected directions. It feels very unsafe.

Computer vision could be making those go-stop decisions for you, much more effectively than human drivers.

Heck, imagine a "smart" parking lot that tracks its available spaces and communicates with your car. You enter the parking lot and hand over control, and the car and lot work together to park you safely in the best available space.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by curryst on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:22PM (#25588039)
Some cars already have those. I've got a car from 2017 that has some kind of sensors wrapping all the way around the bumper. When I'm parked between two cars, it can detect a car roughly 15-20 feet away as soon as I get an inch or two of my bumper clear of the other cars.

It does lack any spatial indicators to the driver, though. It just plays a beep, but it doesn't seem to play the beep from the side of the car the danger is in, nor does it beep louder when they're closer. Still, it works remarkably well. Reliably detects pedestrians and vehicles (even while I'm moving, which is impressive, because it doesn't go off for parked cars when I start moving).

I think it's the Dodge ParkSense, but I bought the car used so there's a possibility it's something aftermarket.

It's saved my ass a number of times. I'm in jacked-up pickup truck country, so it is often impossible for me to see pedestrians about to walk behind me because of the lifted truck, and likewise the pedestrians can't see me until they're behind me.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by robocat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:15PM (#25587977)
Wherever practical, I back into car parking spaces. That avoids many many scenarios, while marginally adding a few new issues.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by sokoloff on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:08PM (#25588789)
This practice is recommended by several safety programs. https://safestart.com/news/4-reasons-backing-parking-spaces-...
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bombcar on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:31PM (#25588101)
A similar calculus was what lead me to get a private pilot’s license instead of a motorbike - general aviation fatalities are something like 90% pilot error but 60% of motorbike fatalities are NOT the fault of the rider.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by toper-centage on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @05:23PM (#25586915)
Good point. But it doesn't matter how carefully you drive if the road is full of idiots and intoxicated drivers.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by thesuitonym on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:00PM (#25584766)
As cautious as you are, you still get distracted, focus on the wrong thing sometimes, and have blind spots. Computers don't.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by lemonspat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:52PM (#25585964)
Computers might not get distracted, but have many other problems. And I assure you a computer can still focus on the wrong thing and have blind spots.

https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sen...

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by kaba0 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:31AM (#25592052)
And I would choose a fly over today’s state of the art computer vision systems because they are still better than the latter.