News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Chyzwar on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:15PM (#25584285)
Once self-driving is better we need to do is to create moral rules for AI.

There is a car controlled by computer. Pedestrian (child) abruptly enter into road from behind cover. The Computer knows that with current speed it is impossible to stop. Its other choices is to drive into the sidewalk killing an old lady, drive into the opposite lane risking the life of a car owner and people in another car.

A Human driver can decide on instinct, usually protecting themselves. The Computer needs to have an algorithm that decide who will live and who dies.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by glandium on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:19PM (#25588870)
Why is it always about running to the sidewalk or the other lane? There's also the option to reduce speed as much as possible, aka break hard, that a computer can do a) earlier than a human would b) much harder than a human would. Yes, the people in the car might take a lot of negative Gs. But that's also an option. The car might still hit the kid, but the difference could be some broken bones, or with chance, bruises, vs. death.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by jjav on Thursday December 31, 2020 @04:22AM (#25591041)
> There's also the option to reduce speed as much as possible, aka break hard, that a computer can do a) earlier than a human would b) much harder than a human would.

a) A computer can initiate braking a small fraction of a second faster than a human, which is great but not such a huge difference in braking distance.

b) A computer cannot brake any harder than a human, certainly not "much harder". The max deceleration rate is traction-limited, which any remotely modern car (last ~25 years) can easily sustain with an untrained driver thanks to modern ABS.

(As a side hobby I instruct in car control and accident avoidance clinics. Blindly braking hard is not often the best answer.)

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by glandium on Thursday December 31, 2020 @04:44AM (#25591171)
Most people don't actually hit the brakes as hard as they could or should.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:19PM (#25584338)
> The Computer knows that with current speed it is impossible to stop.

Then the car was going too fast. Full stop. The rest of your scenario is irrelevant.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:15PM (#25587976)
>Then the car was going too fast. Full stop. The rest of your scenario is irrelevant.

How can you possibly say that with a straight face?

There will be situations where a car is going a perfectly fine speed for the situation and then the situation changes in a way the car cannot have seen, known about, or anticipated resulting in a crash. This happens all the time with human drivers. It will happen with AI drivers too.

Furthermore, we don't subject anything else that moves to this burden, why would we do so for cars (AI or otherwise)?

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:41PM (#25589004)
> There will be situations where a car is going a perfectly fine speed for the situation and then the situation changes in a way the car cannot have seen, known about, or anticipated resulting in a crash.

The parent's situation was not one of those. This was a situation where "Pedestrian (child) abruptly enter into road from behind cover." and there's an old lady on the sidewalk. In other words, there's a situation with limited visibility, limited room to maneuver (since the only other option is to go up on the sidewalk) and pedestrians present (the child may not be known but the old lady was). If you're in that situation and you're going too fast that you can't stop on a dime, you were not going a "perfectly fine speed for the situation".

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Chyzwar on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:41PM (#25625027)
In European cities you will often see pedestrians walking 1m from cars driving 50-70 km/h. Human drivers can take this risk, AI to be useful needs to handle it well.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:52PM (#25589067)
If 95% of human drivers do something, then you can't just call it "irrelevant" because you think it's wrong to do.

And humans don't go past parked cars on a street at 5mph.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @12:31AM (#25589894)
20mph is slow enough to essentially ensure collisions aren't fatal.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @01:33AM (#25590154)
But they still get hit. And the first paper in google suggests that 5% are still going to die. That's pretty far from sure.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:12AM (#25592811)
My reference shows 1% at 30km/h. But even 1% is too high. But luckily you also usually get a chance to scrub off some speed through braking. Braking follows a square law, so driving a little bit slower gains a massive difference in stopping distances.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by closeparen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:22PM (#25588891)
When you already believe that cars should not exist, it’s not much of a stretch to say that cars which do exist should be limited to less than a walking pace anywhere pedestrians might be present.

There’s a thing about the car companies having essentially stolen public space from the everyone else when they made it incumbent on pedestrians to watch out for cars, and a desire to reverse this.

Of course this would pretty much invalidate them as a transportation mechanism, but that’s the point.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:56PM (#25589095)
I think you could simultaneously have a better improvement for pedestrians and less impact on traffic by turning those parking spaces into sidewalks and greenery.
Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:30PM (#25588944)
> Furthermore, we don't subject anything else that moves to this burden, why would we do so for cars (AI or otherwise)?

Yes we do. There are many jurisdictions where in a pedestrian-car collision, the car is presumed to be at fault unless the driver can prove otherwise.

Re:Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety... by a_t48 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:44PM (#25587729)
Have you as a human ever come into this situation?