News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:45PM (#25555217)
That's nice. But honestly, what are average people supposed to do anymore? If we keep making everything more difficult and more difficult to compete with, then how can average people survive? I would like to retire and have a small farm, but this basically says it's not possible to compete.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:28PM (#25555500)
Farmers aren't 'average people'. A commercial-scale farm requires millions in investment. It runs on small margins, and is run like a factory. A modern 1000-acre farm can be operated by one or two people. That's been the trend for 200 years. America for instance has gone from 50% farmers to under 2%. Arguably the reason we were the superpower we were - so much more manpower for other things.

And to create a fancy mechanical robotic wall-farm to produce commodity products like lettuce seems folly. I'm sure they chose that because it comes to maturity in a score days, not weeks or months. And the 'floor space' per plant has to be enormous for that farm-of-the-future.

The article belabors the 'less land used' argument throughout. Perhaps because that's the only place they win (not on price; not on investment cost; not on variety or flexibility?) While that's important, the issue is not running out of farmland. The American farmer has gotten so efficient, doubling output per acre repeatedly for a century now. Iowa could feed two United States. The US could feed the world. With old-fashioned land-intensive agriculture.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by edoceo on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:34PM (#25555547)
Most of your points are solid. However, Variety could be a huge win. With the full-auto farm there is room to try out different types and experiment in small batch with tight monitoring and control which can also give predictable yield.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:17PM (#25555821)
As long as the crop is fast-maturing. Else the expensive 'pot' makes experimentation cost prohibitive?
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:33PM (#25555532)
That all depends on the crops. The labor needs or ability to use vertical farms is vastly different between tomatoes, citrus, and corn (for example).

There are still small farms, although they are continuing to die off. But even if farmers are not average, then what work do average people have?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:19PM (#25555828)
What work? Not sure what's the question. Its retail sales, service industry, delivery, stuff like that.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:28PM (#25555876)
So automated stuff? Retail has been dying off due to online sales. Delivery services are looking automate with drones. Not to mention that places like Amazon start their own service and pay their drivers less than the major places (worse jobs). Service industry is reeling from the pandemic. Many of those jobs are automatable too.

The general trend has been to eliminate onshore jobs that are low skill and outsource those tasks to lower cost countries. As it has also been towards jobs requiring higher education. So what opportunities are there? After all, we are seeing increased dependence on support programs and wage stagnation.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:39AM (#25559076)
Worse than that. China is America's number one consumer of automation equipment. They're just a decade or two behind us. Soon their working class will be out of things to do as well.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:38PM (#25555564)
It's pretty dystopian to see a page comprised of technocrats writing about these topics.

Median estimation for AGI is around 2060 so its not just "average" people.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:06PM (#25555753)
Why is it dystopian to talk about agricultural related topics?

Is that AGI of 2060 a mistake?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:11PM (#25555792)
The people who are on this forum are cogs in a machine that, over the next 40 years, will displace millions of American workers. It seems where we are headed into a bifurcated society part overeducated technocrats part gig economy task rabbits.

Seeing the former group beginning to consider the effects of their work is dystopian.

I'm not sure what you mean by "mistake."

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:34PM (#25555893)
Where did you get your number for AGI? An adjusted gross income of $2060 seems extremely low (very far below average).

It's not dystopian to consider the possible effects of one's work. If you don't consider them, then how can you make adjustments/improvements? It would be dystopian to maximize the negative impacts. We are doing the opposite - questioning what the best course of action might be.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:46PM (#25555961)
By AGI I meant Artificial General Intelligence. There is no stopping or meaningful slowing of the machine.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:52PM (#25555992)
They also estimated we would have flying cars 20 years ago. These sort of estimates are highly inaccurate. Even then, do we just ignore the average people for the next 40 (your median) years?
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:15PM (#25556096)
"They also estimated we would have flying cars 20 years ago." My number comes from a collection of AI researchers from the future of life institute so I can't imagine a better "they" to defer to. That said, we are bad at predicting the future so who knows?

I never said we should forget about the average people or normal people as Yang calls them in his book "The War on Normal People."

Even if we don't have AGI we will have narrow AI such as self driving/factory stuff/textiles which will displace millions. I'm all for UBI or some sort of equivalent social safety net (I'm not an economist so I don't want to be prescriptive here as I have heard some drawbacks to UBI).

The technocrats have already created platforms that are tearing our social fabric apart by promulgating conspiracies and radicalizing our youth while reducing long-form literacy an increasing anxiety and depression.

What we need is some sort of social revolution that in my opinion could only be obtained by an authoritarian government that protects people from themselves and the exploitive tech corporations. Ban facebook to reduce conspiracy promulgation. Ban tiktok and ever increasingly addictive video games to prevent our youth from becoming dopamine junkees. Ban drugs so the listless and ever-growing welfare class remain mostly docile.

None of these changes are feasible in a country whose identity revolves around personal freedom/choice.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:58PM (#25556283)
"obtained by an authoritarian government that protects people from themselves"

Why fight nature? Government shouldn't protect citizens from themselves. Let it take its course. The stupid people should reduce through natural attrition. It's controversial, but it's the way the natural world works.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:22PM (#25556403)
We can definitely make systemic changes that help people make better "decisions." I don't believe in free will and you clearly do so we're kinda approaching this problem from fundamentally different frameworks. Stupid people shouldn't be culled but rather shepherded. Governments are artificial constructs so asking them to act "naturally" doesn't make sense to me as they have no natural state.

Also reducing human suffering seems to be a pretty good thing to do and your natural system doesn't seem to do that.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:39PM (#25556476)
I never said they should be culled. I'm saying let the problem take care of itself.

The actions you were proposing weren't things to help people make better decisions (if they were, it would still be free will). They were to make laws to outlaw activities. If you don't believe in free will, why do you propose helping people make better decisions? Do you really think imposing someone else's will over others is more benign? The government imposes its will through force or threat thereof (causing human suffering).

Government and politics is not really artificial. They form naturally whenever there are groups of people - similar leadership and power dynamics exist in the natural world too (look at bees, ants, wolves, etc).

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @11:17PM (#25556632)
The government imposes its will all the time. It prevents you from shooting me or overthrowing the government. Surely this imposition is just? Surely this is more benign then letting you shoot me or letting you overthrow the government.

Why? Because it reduces human suffering.

Also surely with better technology we will be able to transform prisons into rehabilitation centers and thus reduce our countries prison populations and thus become a FREER country, albeit one with less rights?

I think comparing our government to a beehive or a pack of wolves is ridiculous I guess you can call governments "natural." Even if we consider this government natural, surely it doesn't have a natural state. What is the "natural state" of a government of 350 million people?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:38AM (#25558730)
You're being very presumptuous and not using linear premises in your logic. You assume that government reduces human suffering and that people would be running wild without one. There's a lot more to society than government.

For example, why would I shoot you? I have no motive to do that regardless of what the laws may be. There is nothing the government has done to make it impossible for someone to shoot you. It's just that if some one does and gets caught, they go to prison.

On the subject of dissolving the government, you are completely wrong. There is nothing stopping me from non-violently overthrowing the government. The Constitution even states that if the people want to dissolve the government, they can. So I could try to convince people to elect myself and others who would change or even dissolve it.

"Also surely with better technology we will be able to transform prisons into rehabilitation centers and thus reduce our countries prison populations and thus become a FREER country, albeit one with less rights?"

This is completely nonsensical. Technology isn't holding back prison reform - social and political powers are the main drivers. Why would the number of rights be reduced? You've laid out no premise to connect nor support that statement.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:51PM (#25555243)
We've already got sort of a dystopia in software engineering. Get into FAANG and you're good for life. Combined FAANG (say 10 biggest tech companies) is over 5 trillion dollars, more than a lot of countries' GDPs with sovereignty.

I suspect in year 2100, we will have no small businesses but giant monolith corporations that will drive everything from content censorship to citizen governance through proxies, everyone's savings are going to be in their stocks which keep increasing at an ever increasing pace. Traditional currencies have been devalued and replaced by corporate-owned coins. Neuralink will ensure utter dominance of a few. Abstract things we consider today are commodicized and traded.

Future kind of sucks to be honest. We're past golden prime years. I just want to run a small tea shop and hang out with the locals.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:16PM (#25555420)
A 5 trillion GDP is bigger than every country beside the US and China. Japan is 4.9. Germany is 3.9.

But comparing market cap (wealth) to gdp (production) doesn't really make sense.

It would make more sense to compare revenues maybe?? Top 5 tech revenues would combine to about $1T - which still makes them bigger than all but 16 countries...

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by IkmoIkmo on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:41PM (#25555582)
Comparing revenue with added value makes no sense, either. Makes more sense to look at profits.

After all, a company buying A for $100 and selling A for $100 will boost revenue, but will not see profit rise. A country in which companies buy A for $100 and sell A for $100 will not see GDP rise.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by Fricken on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:03PM (#25555331)
That's what William Gibson was saying in the early 80s about 2020.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:12PM (#25555384)
To be honest, 80’s were the prime time. Things went downhill from then. Sure there is progress in medicine and productivity and what not. Just the general state of the world today is worse off than if we were to go back to 80’s with some hindsight on how to run the next 40 years.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by TameAntelope on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:23PM (#25555467)
For white, affluent, straight Americans, the 80s were probably just fine. For a large number of people who aren't those things, the 80s were hell, though.

The "general state of the world today" is likely to be much better for billions of people than it was in the 80s, however. It's worth keeping that perspective in mind, IMO.

Edit: I've linked one slide deck I think will describe what I'm talking about a bit, but there are certainly more and better sources for this kind of information.

Maybe we can share some sources here as a way to better educate ourselves on this topic?

https://slides.ourworldindata.org/hunger-and-food-provision/...

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:30PM (#25555513)
I see what you’re saying. I’m noticing general trends towards authoritarianism, corruption of public discourse, death of journalism, polarization of politics, rise of conspiracy theories, climate is worse, etc.

If you’re an average Chinese citizen, your life has probably improved dramatically. The auto mechanic down the street is struggling though since newer cars are basically unrepairable.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by alphabettsy on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:49PM (#25555661)
There are certainly some concerning trends, but you believe things were better in general during the Cold War before the fall of the Soviet Union? When substantially more people globally lived in poverty? When the US was just coming off the civil rights movements of the 60-70s? When AIDS was rampant, but there was no treatment? When global warming was happening, but it wasn’t widely known or acknowledged?

The majority of brand new cars that the average American is buying is still an ICE-powered automobile that’s nearly as serviceable as the old ones, sometimes requiring more advanced diagnostics tools, but far safer and more reliable.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by Baeocystin on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:01PM (#25556039)
Worldwide, life is better for billions of people.

Life in the United States was better for most Americans in the 80's than it is now. That was the beginning of the decoupling of productivity from pay, and it has been ongoing ever since.

https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/

It's ok to both acknowledge the developmental progress of the rest of the world and lament the backsliding of the US.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by TameAntelope on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:29PM (#25556431)
That's not the same thing as "basic ability to survive".

When billions of people couldn't buy food and don't have clean water to drink, cries of, "But I'm not maximally benefitting from my own productivity increases!" come across as relatively unimportant.

The phrase that caught my eye was, "the general state of the world today is worse off." I don't think that meshes with observed reality over the past 40 years for the humans living on this planet, if you're not white, affluent, straight and American.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:35PM (#25556186)
I am happy for the the fact that lot of people have been lifted from poverty.

What I am not happy about is all of us, all 8 billion of us, being able to afford everything we can and hoard useless electronics and plastic doo-dads, waste a ton of resources and live an excessive life. But, "We in the west have it so they should also" is a controversial take on this.

We as Americans waste a lot of resources. That shouldn't be the role model for others.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by TameAntelope on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:33PM (#25555533)
Totally fair, I just don't want to forget how much we've raised the floor in the last 40 years -- from 44% of all humanity in "absolute poverty" to 9.6% is a huge accomplishment.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by alphabettsy on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:16PM (#25555414)
This is one of the most ridiculous things I’ve read in a couple weeks. The world is better by nearly any measure than it was 40 years ago.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:20PM (#25555448)
Suicide rates are generally higher now, signaling a general dissatisfaction and hopelessness in life.

Sure living standard is higher (but with more inequality), most fields are more advanced now, but what's the true purpose if people feel more depressed and inclined to kill themselves?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by alphabettsy on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:32PM (#25555527)
That’s an important metric for sure, but should we ignore the massive decreases in infant mortality or deaths from hunger, disease, or war?

How did you determine it was generally higher because it appears to be lower in much of Eastern Europe, Asia and Africa?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:34PM (#25555548)
This is a pretty first world-centric perspective. There are slightly higher rates of dissatisfaction and hopelessness but quality of life is drastically improving in the second and third world. More efficient production results in better and more stuff even if the stuff isn't distributed perfectly.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by andy_ppp on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:29PM (#25555504)
I just keep thinking how terrifying the pandemic would be without the Internet for information, entertainment and connection with friends. We are insanely lucky and we do not take time to appreciate it.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by pshc on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:22PM (#25555456)
#shitHNsays
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:26PM (#25555484)
Lol, glad I could entertain. Take it with a grain of salt and lighten up all.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by dnautics on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:23PM (#25555469)
Funny story, what is Fortune 1? Still not a tech company (not for long).
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by kortilla on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:00PM (#25555315)
Small businesses haven’t been wiped out by FAANG though. It’s not a zero sum game.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by systemvoltage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:05PM (#25555344)
I wonder how many small businesses and shops have been wiped out by Amazon.

Yes, on average its not a zero sum game. Ask your corner bookstore if its not a zero sum game. Local effects are real.

Just in another thread I was greeted by how much of a bargian GSuite is. For $5/month, you get world class in the cloud office/productivity tools + gazillion other services and email, SSO. No other SaaS can compete with this.

Github with free private repos, why would anyone choose another competitor? It has all the things and more.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ghgdynb1 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:15PM (#25555411)
The people who really got wiped out were Borders and Barnes & Noble. If you’re a small bookstore you actually have an niche now.

You can’t compete with Amazon’s virtually infinite selection and they can’t compete with your local presence and the physical experience and customer service you offer to your patrons. If you’re incapable of doing a good job with any of those then you’re toast, but then again maybe you shouldn’t have been running a small bookstore anyways.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by NestedLoopGoBrr on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:12PM (#25555387)
> For $5/month, you get world class in the cloud office/productivity tools + gazillion other services and email, SSO.

And if they ever decide to lock you out, you lose everything. That cheap price comes with a cost.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:17PM (#25555429)
GSuite can't just "lock you out" if you're paying, that's why there is a contractual relationship. There are all sorts of third party business relationships (e.g. banks, HR systems, counterparties, other SaaS products, etc.) that all companies depend on running smoothly, I don't see why GSuite is any different.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by WillPostForFood on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:17PM (#25555426)
I asked the guy at the corner bookstore if it was zero sum, and he said no. Then he offered to sell me an Econ 101 textbook, but I got it on Amazon for 1/2 the price.

We both wonder how many shops have been wiped out. I also wonder how many online businesses have been created. I work with many online vendors who sell on Amazon that would not have been viable if they had to open a brick and mortar retail location.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:13PM (#25555395)
I suspect the reason you're downvoted is because so many small businesses HAVE been wiped out by FAANGs, and other megacorps. I mean, just look at the effects of the pandemic. Many independent retail stores in my city have closed up shop but Amazon is booming like never before. Even local restaurants that have switched to delivery, it's like they're barely scraping by (if they haven't already closed) but DoorDash etc. are raking it in.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by WillPostForFood on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:19PM (#25555438)
Were they wiped out by the pandemic, or Amazon?
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by IncRnd on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:17PM (#25555423)
> Combined FAANG (say 10 biggest tech companies) is over 5 trillion dollars, more than a lot of countries' GDPs with sovereignty.

That's apples and oranges. More apt is the comparison of FAANG revenue to GDP.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by evanb on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:28PM (#25555498)
This is one of my biggest pet peeves---GDP is a rate! The units are often quoted as dollars [or equivalent] but they're actually dollars/year. Or, put another way, they're the rate, but integrated over a definite time period (1 year) from which you can only extract an average rate.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by billfruit on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:43PM (#25556225)
It may not necessarily be a bad thing, small firms can be very exploitative of employees and fail to provide many of the safeguards and systems that large employers provide. More large employers are subject to more intense regulatory scrutiny, so, I don't really think that small businesses will be some kind of utopia for workers.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:51PM (#25556260)
The flip side of that is that large firms have no incentive to provide better pay or benefits since they are less connected to the community. This is especially true for lower income individuals since the supply of lower skill workers is not constrained.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by rmah on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:43PM (#25556490)
Except that, generally speaking, larger companies do indeed provide better pay and benefits than smaller firms in the same line of business.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by vangelis on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:01PM (#25561399)
From experience, the small (but not sole proprietor type) firms are owned by people whose community is other small firm owners. They're almost a landed gentry of store and factory owners in rural America.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by hbrundage on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:01PM (#25555318)
Totally possible to compete on quality, especially if you are more in it for the lifestyle or the community aspect. You can sell at a farmer's market for 5x what the local grocery store charges and you get 100% of the margin!

Better yet, if you harvest at the right time your product will taste way better because it wasn't shipped across the continent!

Lots of people are still getting into farming these days, you can make a full time salary on as low as 1 acre, especially if you do microgreens. See this fellow's content for far more detail than you might ever want https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbHwAfHQA9M

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:40PM (#25555574)
> You can sell at a farmer's market for 5x what the local grocery store charges and you get 100% of the margin!

Ever tried selling 50 tons of wheat at the farmer's market? Its a minor side-income at best

> "you can make a full time salary on as low as 1 acre,"

Thats total wishfull thinking. - you can only do that in specific niches, with significant capital outlay, near a city. You are not going ti make any money off an average 1-acre field in the countryside

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by vangelis on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:11PM (#25561474)
Don't compete on commodity crops to start.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ClumsyPilot on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:44PM (#25565710)
That's 99% of farm produce, so you are basically supporting the statement above - only the largest farms are profitable, and family farm is dead outside tiny niches.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:23PM (#25555472)
Most small farmers I know have modest incomes or less. Many also need to work another job.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by randomdata on Monday December 28, 2020 @10:14AM (#25559782)
> Most small farmers I know have modest incomes or less.

I guess that depends on your perspective. As a small farmer, the per-hour income is incredible, putting my earning potential as a developer to shame. But it doesn't require many hours of my time.

> Many also need to work another job.

Since it doesn't require many hours of my time, it seems reasonable to spend that time doing something else. Sitting around watching TV all day would get old pretty fast.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by tyingq on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:00PM (#25555309)
Their selection of crops seems fairly limited.[1] I don't know that corn or soybeans, for example, would do well vertically.

[1] https://www.plenty.ag/our-produce/

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by bpodgursky on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:03PM (#25555334)
You'd be surprised how few people it currently takes to farm 720 acres.

Maybe a few for lettuce, but for cereal grains... we're talking guy on a combine (part of) 3 days a year.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by stellar678 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:50PM (#25555985)
I'd venture that you're looking at hundreds of people at harvest time for 720 acres of lettuce. I suppose the spikey nature of the labor demand is another reason why automation could be a better approach.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:56PM (#25556008)
The only question then, is what does that unskilled labor do as an alternative?

As a side note, the labor is generally migratory so they move the the next crop that needs harvesting.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by imjustsaying on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:11PM (#25555381)
If you're retiring with a small farm, why are you concerned about the market prices of what you're producing? You're just eating it yourself / giving it to neighbors, right?

If you intend to sell it, well the differences of economy of scale of a small farm versus a large farm and the resulting cost difference alone should have been obvious. You wouldn't have been competing well in that market either, right?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:14PM (#25555403)
No way. You need income just to pay the ever increasing property taxes, the equiptment costs, etc.

The idea is to produce higher margin products, such as organics, honey, ir niche products.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:29PM (#25555510)
You can grow 100% of what you need / want beside grains on less than 5 acres (really 1 acre can suffice depending on what you want to grow). Growing your own grains is quite frankly ridiculous. It will likely cost you close to 100x what you could buy them for (if you include your time), and importantly the quality in taste is minimal.

You don't need a ton of equipment to feed yourself. You might WANT some to make life easier, but even then, I'm pretty sure you don't need to pay yearly tax on a tractor in most states...

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:37PM (#25555562)
You probably aren't paying tax on the tractor, but you are paying thousands in tax on your land and house. Then you do have equipment costs of the tractor, capital expenditures, etc. So you also need to produce enough to sell to cover some costs.

Also, you can't grow more than an acre of wheat for self-use legally in the US anyways.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by imjustsaying on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:01PM (#25563744)
>Also, you can't grow more than an acre of wheat for self-use legally in the US anyways.

I find this very surprising, especially considering this should vary by state (although I know this might be the kind of thing the Commerce Clause could get up into).

I can't find any information that there's a cap on wheat production in the US. Got a source?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:02PM (#25555741)
An acre of wheat is almost 2k pounds! What could you possibly do for personal use with more than 2k pounds of wheat?!
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:20PM (#25555833)
You're really looling at about 1000 lbs of flour per acre. I think I was mistaken about 1 acre. I think its actually 1/4 acre, which is about 250 pounds, which should be enough for most families. But still, you need to produce excess yo pay for costs and provide an income.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by driverdan on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:10PM (#25556349)
> You need income just to pay the ever increasing property taxes, the equiptment costs, etc.

The whole concept of retiring is that you've factored those things into your savings. If you can't afford to pay property taxes for the rest of your life you can't retire.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:50PM (#25555235)
I guess people downvote just because they don't agree. But it's true. The number of people on assistance continues to grow and the easier jobs are outsourced to lower cost countries.

Edit: looks like some others have upvoted.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by diveanon on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:52PM (#25555249)
why does it need to be a competition in the first place?

If we have automated manufacturing and food production why does the average person really need to do anything?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by sokoloff on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:19PM (#25555440)
Because the inputs to those processes (raw materials, energy, maintenance, and a bit of labor) all cost money/are limited?
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by daniellarusso on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:55PM (#25555280)
People need purpose, not necessarily a ‘job’, but something to occupy their time.

Kinda like Pompeii back in the day?

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:58PM (#25555292)
I think many could find purpose with hobbies, charity, and children. The main issue I have is how does one pay for that and support themself? I would gladly quit my job if I had the means.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by skissane on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:09PM (#25555367)
Society is always going to be unequal – some people will have more than others.

So long as there is work, the people who have a smaller share always have the opportunity of improving their lot by working harder and smarter than others.

A society with no work is basically one in which everyone lives off their assets, in which wealth primarily comes through inheritance. A society with even more inequality than today, but with far less social mobility.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:45PM (#25555616)
If there is no way to work, there must be no way to provide value to others. Correct? If there is no way to provide value to another then there is no inequity.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by diveanon on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:31AM (#25557450)
People provide non transactional value to each other all the time.

I hope that isn't your worldview, it sounds lonely.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by diveanon on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:53AM (#25557310)
I think you are conflating livelihood with purpose.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by giantg2 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:54PM (#25555269)
Because the current paradigm requires one to work to have a decent life.

It's always a competion. That's just life. Darwin has laid that out before pretty clearly.

Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by diveanon on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:51AM (#25557304)
Our society is not darwinian, if it was we would just let the sick and disabled die.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by wildrhythms on Sunday December 27, 2020 @06:58PM (#25555297)
That is not 'just life'; that's the puritanical work ethic that you're describing. Life absent of a need for labor-intensive work to produce basic goods and services is better than the system we have now. The issue is not automation; the issue is who benefits from making manual human labor obsolete, and in our capitalist system I doubt it will be the workers it displaces.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by ConcreteGidget on Sunday December 27, 2020 @07:42PM (#25555591)
Maslow put "employment" in his hierarchy of needs. As a trust fund kid I've never had to worry about living in the streets but found that without the purpose of work I felt pretty worthless. If you live in the first world you basically have food water and shelter taken care of for you if you're resourceful. The rest seems to be climbing status hierarchies and opulence.
Re:2-Acre Vertical Farm Run by AI and Robots Out-Produces 72... by diveanon on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:30AM (#25557446)
That's not the point though. Your self worth and employment are not directly correlated.

Furthermore as our society evolves the hierarchy of needs can and should shift to demphasize employment.

What you are describing is the result of industrialized societies needing workers, soon that will not be the case.