News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by spyke112 on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:51AM (#25495395)
Ideally Facebook should just allow users to buy a subscription. I think a lot of people, at least in the western world, wouldn't mind paying say $1-2 dollars a month maybe even more, if Facebook were honest about how they use your data, and how much money they make of of your data. I mean, we're all happily paying $8.99 for Netflix and friends, is it really so outrageous that consumers would pay for a social network?
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by neodymiumphish on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:06AM (#25495536)
The problem is that data collection still wouldn't stop just cause you're paying.

The trackers they build into sites would still exist to track non-paying customers, and they'd have to track the paying customers enough to differentiate from non-paying.

And if you're saying that all of Facebook becomes a subscription, you still end up with the problem that Facebook has pointed out: small sites that earn income from Facebook by implementing their tracking widget would lose that source of income.

I think we should be more vocal about the extensions and products that help block FB (and other) web trackers, to force their model to change, but I think we're a long way away from anything truly effective.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by maxwellito on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:25AM (#25495743)
> The problem is that data collection still wouldn't stop just cause you're paying.

Completely agree! There's cannot be any grey area here. It must be all ad-based or all-subscription. But the move seems impossible

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by mtnygard on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:47PM (#25497294)
The way FB tracks non-users is one of the parts that bothers me the most. One old article I read talked about a "shadow profile" that would track you across sites, ready and waiting for the day you signed up. That way they would have profile data on you from before you ever consented.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by loxs on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:36AM (#25495839)
I don't empathise at all with "small sites" that track me or benefit from someone else tracking me.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by neodymiumphish on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:31PM (#25502227)
Nor do I, but it's worth noting that these sites would go out of business or have their revenue severely impacted or force their customer base to offset the financial losses in order to stay afloat.

If you don't browse sites that do this tracking, then you shouldn't care either way about this whole FB/Apple controversy/dispute.

If you do browse these sites, get ready for the potential of a major shift in those sites' business model.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by loxs on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:18AM (#25507799)
The major shift is exactly the right development
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by randomsearch on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:34AM (#25496446)
What? Just track the customers that don’t pay. Don’t do anything with paying customers. Where is the problem? This sounds like a false defence.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by bee_rider on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:52AM (#25496685)
"Pay up or we'll spy on you" seems like it would have bad optics.

Also, they can't sell privacy, just that they won't track using their network. If your information is being taken by multiple parties and they are all pouring it into the same data soup, the value of paying any particular spy off seems pretty limited. Apple can try to sell privacy, because they are in the position to fight all the spies simultaneously (we'll see how effective it is, seems like a really hard task but it is a good sign that they've got Facebook worried).

AlsoAlso it is possible that the value of tracking is non-linearly related to the number of people you are tracking (if three people are somehow similar I might be able to apply some insight gleaned from one to the other two). So, they might fundamentally want quite a bit more than any reasonable person would be willing to pay for their service, to stop tracking.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by chillwaves on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:20PM (#25497009)
> Also it is possible that the value of tracking is non-linearly related to the number of people you are tracking (if three people are somehow similar I might be able to apply some insight gleaned from one to the other two). So, they might fundamentally want quite a bit more than any reasonable person would be willing to pay for their service, to stop tracking.

Not my problem. Price it in and be transparent about how they are using data.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by bee_rider on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:44PM (#25497267)
"Not my problem" is a funny expression, because there's an implied "to solve" at the end there. Yes, it is your problem to solve. But you do have a problem if you want a transparent and reasonably priced social media service: nobody in the market is willing to sell that, because doing it the shady way instead is more profitable. You've just got an unsolvable problem.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by chillwaves on Monday December 21, 2020 @01:57PM (#25498104)
Sounds like Apple is offering a solution.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by neodymiumphish on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:27PM (#25502203)
Which means you have to track the people enough to determine that they pay...
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by joseph_grobbles on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:24AM (#25495730)
Pay $1500 for a laptop and it will often have crapware installed. Buy a $1000 Samsung TV and it will track your viewing, sell the data, and show you ads. Buy a high end dishwasher and seemingly 50% of the logic on the device is to encourage you to use Jet Dry (because they get a kickback per unit from the Finish people, not because it's more than marginally beneficial).

Simply paying alone often isn't enough -- this sort of sleezy behavior is endemic.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by cultus on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:17AM (#25496236)
I avoid buying anything "smart." Very few things need to be connected to the internet or have an OS. There's no reason I've seen for a TV or fridge to be smart except for nefarious purposes.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by bee_rider on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:00PM (#25496781)
There are various home automation tasks that might be neat (hit the remote and the lights dim and the room goes into movie mode) but

* Nobody seems to implement these

* The risk of smart devices actively working against us is too high

* I have 0% faith in Samsung's ability to keep a fridge OS updated over the, whatever, 20 year lifespan of a fridge.

Unfortunately so many things are "smart" nowadays that it can be hard to avoid, but at least I can keep the wifi password away from the devices. For now. Until the manufacturers start including cell modems in the things.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by JKCalhoun on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:03PM (#25496813)
Yes.

"Connect to WiFi?"

[Skip]

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by saagarjha on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:16AM (#25503498)
Soon:

"Please connect to Wi-Fi."

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by victor106 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:24AM (#25495731)
I deleted my fb account 5 years ago and I hate fb. But so many of my friends are semi active on fb. Most of them hate fb but still use it cause it provides them some relevant info. For e.g; I know a mom who finds answers on her local moms group that makes her life super easy.

Also read this

https://notboring.substack.com/p/everybody-hates-facebook

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by maxwellito on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:53AM (#25495409)
It sounds great, sadly I think Facebook can generate much more by showing you advertising.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by wavesounds on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:53AM (#25495972)
Yeah currently $164 a year for a US user and growing [1]. What percentage of users would be willing to pay $13.67 a month? Probably not very many unfortunately. It's an order of magnitude more than what OP said he would to pay

1. https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average...

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by Nextgrid on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:02AM (#25496086)
$13.67/month for a tool that includes chat, voice/video calling (accessible from any platform), social networking, the ability to maintain a page for yourself or business (equivalent of a blog/web hosting), near-unlimited cloud storage for photos and videos both on Facebook and Instagram (and probably a lot more features that I'm forgetting) is an absolute bargain.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by randomsearch on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:36AM (#25496478)
True, but couldn’t Facebook make money other ways?

Eg build new products that work with Facebook and sell them.

An ethical Facebook may find it could enter new markets.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by amelius on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:03AM (#25496105)
But isn't the user paying that indirectly, anyway? (I mean somebody is paying that $164)
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by was_boring on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:04AM (#25495512)
A very small percentage would actually buy one and it would be very good PR. It would almost be a marketing expense at that point.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by bun_at_work on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:03AM (#25495492)
It's definitely more than 1-2 dollars, but not so high that subscriptions would be too expensive for users.

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/03/facebooks-average-revenue-pe...

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by anchpop on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:06AM (#25495534)
Although the average revenue per user who would be willing to spend $7/quarter is probably much higher (these users are disproportionately likely to have disposable income which probably makes them more attractive to advertisers)
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by virgilp on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:45AM (#25495908)
I think nobody would mind advertisers being able to target to "subscribers". What people don't want is the ability of advertisers to target "white male who works at ACME, lives in north Fairview and bought a car last week" (which might narrow it down to just you).

That said, I definitely believe that collecting subscription money would not stop them from trying to collect data about you, for advertising purposes. They'd view subscription as just a new revenue stream (yay!).

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by grumple on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:48PM (#25497301)
It's like cable tv has come full circle... you pay for tv without ads, then they start having ads.

Facebook will never stop collecting data on its users as long as it exists.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by ghaff on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:59AM (#25496040)
If Facebook were to charge just $1/month, I'd be willing to bet they'd still lose 80% of their users, at which point, the value would be decreased enough for the remaining 20% most of them would leave too.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by spyke112 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:03AM (#25495494)
Sure, but then they should at least give me the choice of matching the "lost" ad money as a subscription. At Facebook scale we are talking about millions of users, who would probably choose that path instead.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by maxwellito on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:21AM (#25495707)
Also, can you imagine the money saved by removing all the teams and infra dedicated to ads and data collection.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by im3w1l on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:34AM (#25495822)
Let's say 20% of users outright refuse to pay. I don't think this is unrealistic. Now there will be people with a lot of friends who left, and they ask themselves, "if my friends aren't on here, why am I paying??", so they leave too. It keeps rippling through the social graph like this until there only a hardcore facebook fanbase remains.

If they were forced to find an alternative income source, they'd be better off going with freemium.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by Chris2048 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:54AM (#25495979)
> It keeps rippling through the social graph like this until

this is a very hand-wavy slippery-slope argument. You think the entire social network crumbles because of 20% of users? The lack of right not to be part of a network (shadow profiles) is one of the problems with FB, so if SNs can't exist without payment, maybe they just shouldn't exist. I personally think society values SNs to the extent that this *won't8 happen, but let it be an exercise in seeing how much SNs are truly valued.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by im3w1l on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:07AM (#25496141)
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by Chris2048 on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:37PM (#25497201)
I'm not sure if it is. That effect requires the majority to make no distinction (wrt desirability) between halal/kosher and regular.

I don't think people are as indifferent to "being the product", or are becoming less so.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by glomph on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:06AM (#25495537)
But everyone hates facebook at this point. Seems very unlikely they would pay for it rather than jumping ship.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by dylan604 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:37AM (#25495842)
If only this were true. "But every techie hates facebook at this point." might be more accurate. Or, "But techies and tweenies who think FB if for old people hate facebook." might be even more accurate. However, there are millions upon millions of people that do love it. They don't know/don't care about the actual price of FB's 'free and always will be' service. To them it is free because it doesn't cost them money, and that's as far as they want to think about it. Any further discussion makes you one of the conspiracy people.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by onion2k on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:33AM (#25496442)
I think a lot of people, at least in the western world, wouldn't mind paying say $1-2 dollars a month maybe even more..

The problem is that Facebook only represents good value (paid in ad views, personal data, or money as you suggest) if lots of your friends stay on it. It needs the "network" aspect of social networking to operate. Consequently, even if you're willing to pay $1/month if your friends aren't to pay then that $1 represents terrible value and you'll leave because there's no value in paying.

This is the inherent problem in charging for any 'network' product - it has to represent good value for everyone not just a few people.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by jakelazaroff on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:52PM (#25497354)
So why are they not doing it now? There are three possible explanations:

1. They haven't thought of it.

2. They underestimate how profitable it would be.

3. It would be less profitable than what they're doing now.

Option 1 seems ridiculous. Option 2 is possible if Facebook is blinded by corporate inertia, or if enough people working directly on the ads feel threatened. But there are a lot of smart people working there, who stand to make a lot of money by increasing profits.

So I'm going with option 3. They don't do it because spying on everyone is more profitable.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by vmception on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:12AM (#25495609)
I pay for linked in

That’s social media except only founders and ceos post because disagreement doesn't affect their ability to exchange time for food and shelter, unlike all the employees and candidates

Some people would pay for Facebook

But Facebook’s cash cow is every small business or even idea will pay to target ads. Any corporate-led disruption to how many people that would target will be a massive deterrent to use Facebook’s platforms.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by MikeKusold on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:34AM (#25495819)
LinkedIn is a terrible example of a premium social network. The main reason that people pay for LinkedIn is for recruiting. So LinkedIn is selling their (free) users to recruiters and by doing so it completely destroys the experience. I always have tons of InMail and Friend Requests whenever I open LinkedIn, however they are rarely from ex-coworkers or friends. It is just a steady stream of low-effort "You'd be a perfect fit" messages.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by Nextgrid on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:05AM (#25496122)
I had the LinkedIn Premium trial. I expected the ads and dark patterns (such as the constant nags to add a picture, follow bullshit people or hashtags and resetting the feed to algorithmic instead of chronological) to cease but no. Needless to say I'm not paying a single penny to this terrible company.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by vmception on Monday December 21, 2020 @02:24PM (#25498390)
Its a perfect example that people would find value in multiple ways

I need inmail, I’m not a recruiter or candidate

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by jiux on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:29AM (#25496394)
Can envision this turning into “let us track you for free access” or pay some sort of monthly subscription for denied tracking + access. If socially engineered in just the right way, would not be surprised if majority of people would allow this.

Now I wonder if this goes against an App Store policy somewhere or if this is one way Apple will combat such an attempt.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by cmdshiftf4 on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:48AM (#25496634)
>Can envision this turning into “let us track you for free access”

That's exactly what it already is and we're past the point where ignorance is an acceptable excuse.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by kergonath on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:46PM (#25500605)
One of the huge problems at the moments is that it tracks you even if you don’t use it. We’ve never been at “let us track you for free access”, we jumped directly to “we track you and you can’t do a thing to avoid it”.

As despicable as Facebook’s behaviour is as far as its users are concerned, at least one could claim that there is an implicit contract (I am sure everything is explained clearly in 2pt white font on a white background on a page that’s not linked to and not indexed by Google). There is no such excuse for non-users who are tracked all the same.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by cmdshiftf4 on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @01:30PM (#25520514)
Fair and true points. Hopefully, at some point in the near future, we'll see some accountability for this abhorrent behaviour.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by annadane on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:23PM (#25497049)
Here's the issue, Whatsapp had a system like that but then Facebook bought it up and it's hard to think of a reason beyond 'we want to crush our competition'
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by sixothree on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:53AM (#25495412)
How much exactly does facebook make from its users per month?
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by fbelzile on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:58AM (#25495454)
About $26 a quarter for US/Canada users, so just under $9/mo.

https://whotargets.me/en/much-facebook-makes-per-user-per-mi...

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by maest on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:08AM (#25495560)
I probabl would be down to paying that for Facebook, especially considering the product would be massively better than their current offering. No ads + optimising for platform utility instead of eyeball time would do wonders for Facebook.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by dylan604 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:43AM (#25495888)
Why do you think there would be no ads? There's just no way that 100% of FB users would be willing to pay for it like you are. As an example, Hulu membership costs money AND you still have ads. Newspapers cost money AND have ads (the ads subsidized the cost but didn't make it free).
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by throwaway2048 on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:04PM (#25496823)
Just like how paying for cable TV means no ads right?
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by maest on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:05PM (#25496831)
Just like how paying for Netflix means no ads.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by throwaway2048 on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:06PM (#25496848)
I see plenty of ads on netflix, ads for other netflix shows, but unskippable and at the end of shows, and ads all the same.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by mthoms on Monday December 21, 2020 @01:00PM (#25497468)
How can something be both "at the end", and "unskippable"? Where would you skip to?
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by sixothree on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:37PM (#25512215)
Is this sarcasm?
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by spyke112 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:00AM (#25495471)
Facinating, so basically the same as you'd pay for Netflix in the US on a monthly basis.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by oxymoran on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:09AM (#25495568)
The shareholders would never let them leave money on the table.
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by JKCalhoun on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:05PM (#25496838)
Tracking users though — that's bad PR, bad for business.

Smart shareholders/CEO's think about brand as well, think long term as well.

Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by jonathathan on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:37AM (#25496489)
There's no pressure from the board or shareholders on the CEO, he holds the majority voting rights
Re:Facebook's attempt to vilify Apple looks like sour grapes by r00fus on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:42AM (#25495878)
You realize how much stock Zuck has, right?