News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by baybal2 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:49AM (#25398526)
> (apple, google, qualcomm, netflix, etc).

And out them, only Apple, and Qcom are hardware makers, and both have dropped the ball on AV1.

Qcom removed AV1 from latest snapdragon, and Apple haven't put it into M1 despite being one of first in the AV1 crowd.

The momentum is lost, and thus is the war. H265 is already a new de-facto standard by the virtue of it getting first to the hardware, while AV1 crowd was apparently arguing over whose logo design would AV1 bear, and exact legalese wording.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by hajile on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:24AM (#25398773)
> Qcom removed AV1 from latest snapdragon

From what I can tell, they haven't had AV1 support in any chip yet. They said it didn't make the cut this time which probably means they just haven't finished and verified yet. Likewise, I'd guess Apples engineering efforts are more focused on upcoming, larger designs so they can finish moving off x86. Once those ship, they can refocus (plus it's another reason to upgrade your machine).

Rollout for most codecs is slow. I remember people saying no vp8/9 hardware decoders was deliberate too.

In truth, streaming companies want to save billions in data and licensing costs. Modern mobile SoCs can decode in software reasonably well, but with worse battery life. Netflix isn't paying for that, so they aren't incentivized to care past the most atrocious battery hogging behavior (it's not like you'll be streaming their exclusives from elsewhere). This leaves Qualcomm to implement it or get worse performance reviews.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by baskire on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:55AM (#25399563)
Disagree. Most large app devs directly care about battery life these days.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by ksec on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:09PM (#25400619)
>In truth, streaming companies want to save billions in data and licensing costs.

They dont, the cost of transferring those bit are minimal. They are much more likely to be in the very low end of millions.

Internet Content Distribution Licensing are Zero from all known HEVC licenses.

Implantation of hardware codec takes time especially for VP8/9 and AV1 which tends to have changes after their so called finalised version 1. Not something I remember happening with H.26x

There are specific power budget requirement for hardware decoding in Mobile SoC. Unlike Desktop / Laptop GPU and iGPU where you can afford to have 2W to decode a video.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by fomine3 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:09PM (#25426910)
Qualcomm is still the last important company who doesn't join AOmedia.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by loufe on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:01AM (#25398601)
Both the new AMD and NVidia graphics cards and the intel CPUs support hardware decoding of AV1. I wouldn't count it out just yet. x265 has been released for many, many years and yet it's not fully adopted by a long shot. Transitioning to new technologies takes time and a step back doesn't proclude a step forward again, in the case of Qcom.

Especially considering AV1 is free, more efficient than x265, and pushed forward by powerful actors.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by selectodude on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:15AM (#25398691)
Hardware decoding is nothing more than a nice to have on desktops. On mobile, it’s mandatory. HEVC is the only format you can be assured will work there.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by izacus on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:28PM (#25399880)
And AVC. And VP9.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by grishka on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:33PM (#25401925)
VP9 (and VP8) are only hardware accelerated on Android. On iOS, you only have AVC and HEVC.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by izacus on Sunday December 13, 2020 @06:09AM (#25405743)
And Windows, macOS and Linux.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by grishka on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:14PM (#25409789)
No, definitely not on macOS. It uses the same VideoToolbox framework iOS does. You could probably write a kernel extension to add VPx support yourself tho.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by izacus on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:47AM (#25415560)
macOS Big Sur supports VP9 hardware decoding through VideoToolbox.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by grishka on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:22AM (#25418536)
TIL
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by vlovich123 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:13AM (#25399146)
Nope. AV1 has demand due to the companies behind it. I’m 95% confident it’ll start happening within the next couple of years.

There’s so much engineering knowledge that has to be built up behind how to make these things fast in hardware since the overlap with other mpeg codes is smaller. There’s also a market timing issue. AV1 will be more battery intensive so the consumer demand for AV1 has to make sense (right now the content ecosystem isn’t there). That means Google and Netflix have to transcode their entire libraries. That doesn’t happen often and I wouldn’t be surprised if there was some investigation into how to do that more cheaply as the current encoders are unusably slow at the moment (ie they may need to put video encoder hardware in their clouds which I don’t think I’ve heard of these companies ever doing, making the undertaking even more expensive)

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by cogman10 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:59AM (#25399013)
H265 is an older standard than AV1. It's closest relative is VP9.

The reason H265 has momentum now is because it's been around for longer. AV1 already has a higher efficiency than H265.

The standard that is competing with AV1 is VVC or H.266. As it stands, AV1 has much more momentum than H.266.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by dindresto on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:43AM (#25399462)
I find it funny how people try to declare H265 a winner when it will most likely never land in Chrome or Firefox. Safari has its user base, especially on mobile, sure. But it will never gain any momentum on the web until Chrome supports it. Which will never happen, as Google fully stands behind AV1.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by CharlesW on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:20PM (#25399801)
> …it will never gain any momentum on the web until Chrome supports it. Which will never happen…

That's what everyone said about Chrome and H.264, too. As it stands, Chrome has supported H.264 for over a decade.

https://caniuse.com/mpeg4

Happily, Google's ability to simply declare new standards only goes so far.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by Caspy7 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:57AM (#25399000)
> Apple haven't put it into M1 despite being one of first in the AV1 crowd.

Except they weren't. They just paid more money to be considered a "founding" members - assuming that's where you got the idea.

You seem to muse as though AV1 were on the same development track as H265 but delayed. This also doesn't reflect reality. It started well after and had a relatively quick turnaround (as far as codec development goes).

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by ummonk on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:33PM (#25401924)
Right I remember for a long time early in the development efforts for AV1 Apple was conspicuously absent.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by Caspy7 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:20AM (#25398736)
Qualcomm is no supporter of AV1 so they shouldn't have been included in that list. That being said, there's plenty of other hardware makers and licensors in the Alliance.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by ezoe on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:01PM (#25401122)
Only the brave and rich companies can use H.265 now, because of the patent. There are two major patent holders and there are some companies not belonging to either of them. Using H.265 to anything other than experiment and research in my country(as the patent law stated these for the exception of patent use) has a risk we cannot take.

I guess rest of us, honest patent-abiding citizen and low profit buziness have to wait until the middle of 2030s to use H.265 safely.

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by oblio on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:15AM (#25398690)
> And out them, only Apple, and Qcom are hardware makers, and both have dropped the ball on AV1.

Dropped the ball implies that they made a mistake. Are you sure it wasn't premeditated?

Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by colejohnson66 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:50PM (#25402068)
“Drop the ball” also just means an announcement. In colloquial usage, it has a negative connotation, so it’s usage here to mean “announce removal” makes sense.
Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable by oblio on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:57PM (#25402593)
I'm a bit confused.

My point was that "drop the ball" means that they made a mistake. I don't think they did, it was intentional and I'd say even malicious.

Why do you think that this was not the case?