News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ipnon on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:10PM (#25395030)
What was the point in waiting? What was under the consideration for so long that the FDA needed to wait weeks or months after all of the data has been released?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ummonk on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:18PM (#25395089)
They only released the data 3 days ago. Or are you talking about the marketing release of data, which needed to be properly analyzed?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ardit33 on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:33PM (#25395228)
The application and data was submitted 3 weeks ago... it took 3 weeks for the FDA to drag their feet and just say the obvious...

It is like the titanic is burning and these guys are playing violin...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by roseway4 on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:49PM (#25395336)
The FDA reran, in a matter of weeks, the entire analysis undertaken by Pfizer’s pharmacologists and statisticians over a series of months.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:18PM (#25395479)
To be fair, this was an extremely basic analysis on a relatively minuscule amount of data, where the form and format of data and the method of analysis has been prescribed months ago.

There was no decision that shouldn’t have been made ahead of time. Either it met the predefined criteria or it didn’t.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by Retric on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:27PM (#25395548)
Regulators need to independently verify more than just raw calculations. The incentives to hide or falsify data can be enormous.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:32PM (#25395575)
The only thing that couldn’t be verified until the last minute was the unblinded results.

Everything else should have been a continuous process of pre-verification up to the point the 128 positive confirmed COVID cases were unblinded.

Assume the unblinded results will be good enough, and verify everything else you would normally verify ahead of time. The only thing that remains is to verify the unblinded cases the day they are announced.

And not just that but your approval thresholds should already be preset and preregistered, the doses already distributed to point-of-care, and nurses start administering shots the very next day.

Yes it’s a big waste of money if it turns out not to work. That’s the whole point.

Turns out the vaccine is highly effective 10 days after the first dose. We could have been doing at least a million doses a day since November 19th. Realistically even long before then.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:16AM (#25396057)
I’m not in the drug industry, but in mine you can never turn the full decision process into a push button. Its trivial to turn the tests on your main metrics (is it effective) into push button, but you also have to look to make sure nothing else concerning is present, and it’s muuuch harder to formalize “nothing else here to make you worry” independent of the data.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by refurb on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:39AM (#25395883)
Ahhh... the old HN post of “I work in tech so I know more about how to approve an experimental vaccine than the FDA which is comprised of thousands of scientists and has been approving drugs for over 70 years.”
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:00AM (#25395977)
Remember when the CDC was considered the world’s absolutely top infectious disease center? Remember when they couldn’t even ship COVID test kits with uncontaminated distilled water?

Remember when the FDA wouldn’t let public or private labs run their own COVID tests and everything was being shipped to CDC headquarters to PCR?

The CDC and the FDA essentially guaranteed through extraordinary ineptitude that the US would not fend off COVID back in January/February. They deserve zero benefit of the doubt.

The FDA’s 70 years of process likely worked against them here. What I can say for certain is that there was a t-minus one, the day before the results were unblinded, and there was a t-zero, the day results were unblinded. On that day t-zero they uncovered which of the patient IDs got the vaccine versus which got placebo.

No expense should have been spared in preloading the analysis, verification, whatever could have been done, it should have been done up until t-minus-1. On day t-zero you get 15,000 patient IDs in column A and 15,000 in column B, that’s the only new thing you learn that day. There should be nothing new to talk about or discuss, the approval criteria should already be set in stone. Check the IDs and launch.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by brian_cloutier on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:20AM (#25397263)
I'm sorry you're being downvoted. The testing disaster killed far more than this vaccine approval delay has killed and it's infuriating that nobody seems to care.

They shut down testing back when we needed it most, allowing us to pretend there was no spread in the US for far too long: https://www.statnews.com/2020/05/27/coronavirus-testing-seat...

They spent far too long before approving any kind of at-home testing and to this day have not approved most rapid testing.

Three weeks ago the EUA was submitted, so three weeks ago there was an entire team of people at pfizer who had reviewed all the data and were confident FDA would approve the application, but somehow nobody at FDA was part of that set of people. In any reasonable process that application would have contained no new information, if it contained any new information they were not communicating closely enough.

I understand spending a few days doing some final checks on the data before approving. Three weeks, however, is suspiciously long. It's possible they were in fact doing important work which could not possibly have been done before the application was submitted, but nobody seems able to articulate what that important work actually was.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by refurb on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:24AM (#25398093)
A shitty test with 60% accuracy can make things worse than they already are.. People are making decisions based on results that are right barely half the time. I don’t blame the FDA for saying “no”.

I love HN who is normally vehemently anti-business (with good reason) suddenly flips and says “well Pfizer said the vaccine was ok, isn’t that good enough?”

No. It’s not good enough. The reason we spend billions per year on the FDA is because we want an independent, critical and evidence based body making decisions on drugs given to hundreds of millions of Americans.

I mean, hell, Trump was bullying the FDA (which was stupid) and HN seems to be arguing for that exact thing.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by brian_cloutier on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:37AM (#25440627)
There probably exist universes where a shitty test would make things worse. How are you so sure we're in that universe? And how are you so sure that the unapproved tests are so shitty that you're not at all curious whether the FDA made the right choice?

Nowhere in my comment did I say the FDA should just take Pfizer's word for anything.

I'm also not sure why you're trying to use Trump's actions as evidence here. "Trump did a thing and therefore doing that thing was the correct action" is an argument which requires some justification.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:30AM (#25396756)
Don't forget who is the Chief in command responsible for this outcome.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by wbl on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:28AM (#25395840)
Only the FDA does things this way.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ummonk on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:48AM (#25395922)
Perhaps e.g. the FAA should have done things the same way with the Boeing 737 Max certification.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by cyberlurker on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:38AM (#25396182)
Excellent comparison. These agencies shouldn’t blindly accept what the private sector puts out.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by aphextron on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:47PM (#25395650)
>The incentives to hide or falsify data can be enormous.

Highly doubtful. Pushing out an unsafe vaccine would be disastrous to Pfizer. They have every incentive in the world to be as absolutely certain as possible that the data is solid.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:31AM (#25396762)
That is a scientifically weak argument, and medically dangerous one.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by aphextron on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:15AM (#25398327)
> That is a scientifically weak argument, and medically dangerous one.

And so is the argument that Pfizer would have any incentive to fudge the data.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:51AM (#25398550)
Please refrain from using strawman argument.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by winston_smith on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:24PM (#25400283)
This Johns Hopkins doc claims they took off four days for Thanksgiving: https://thedispatch.com/p/fda-career-staff-are-delaying-the
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:03AM (#25395989)
What kind of computation do you think it is they are doing on this data? Seriously, it takes at MOST a week to do an extremely deep code review of this. It's not like this is some brand new testing methodology developed ad hoc for this.

How is it you think the UK was able to approve it already???

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/12/ho...

EDIT: Multiple downvotes already. Anyone care to refute what's presented in my post? Did you read any of the sources cited in the linked blogpost?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:47AM (#25396823)
The link provides some arguments and maybe FDA should've/could've rolled with the process. Long times do not provide safety, only double blind tests and verifications do.

Are Gov jobs granted overtime work by ruling party, and how was this important work prioritized and coordinated by top leader?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ineedasername on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:02PM (#25395397)
It's probably the fastest a new vaccine has ever been developed, using a technique never before used for this purpose, for something that will quickly be given to millions upon millions of people. Maybe it shouldn't have taken 3 weeks, but there was certainly a non-zero period of time during which the FDA should seriously scrutinize and not just take Pfizer's word on things.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ardit33 on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:31PM (#25395203)
I was wondering as well... the data was submitted about 3 weeks ago...

I understand that it is extensive data (for about 44,000 patients), but taking 3 weeks to compile/analyze seems excessive. They should have put in an army of analyzers into it...

There are about 3,000 people dying every day.... it is like 9/11 every day, or 9 jumbo jets falling....

The FDA should be treating this as a war effort, and not drag their feet into pointless bureaucratic 'safety' theater.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by breck on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:14PM (#25395461)
> There are about 3,000 people dying every day.... it is like 9/11 every day, or 9 jumbo jets falling

This is wrong. Median expected remaining healthy lifespan of a 9/11 deceased was ~35 years, whereas for a COVID decease it's ~3.5 years. So 9/11 is still 10x worse.

Don't get me wrong, COVID is still terrible, but it is not a "9/11 every day".

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by rrss on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:14AM (#25395789)
> it's ~3.5 years

https://www.pnas.org/content/117/36/22035

> We calculate, using these same cohort life tables, that the average person dying of COVID-19 had 11.7 y of remaining life expectancy

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by breck on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:15AM (#25396050)
My figure is correct, the 11.7yr is wrong. It's a pretty good paper, but 2 major flaws that I think should be corrected.

From the paper:

> Both of the above calculations may overstate the loss of remaining life in that they assign the remaining life expectancy based only on age, without taking into account that COVID-19 deaths are disproportionately occurring among those with compromised health status.

So their 11.7 average years remaining ignores the critical bit of information that we know this person died of COVID. It is extremely unlikely that if you took 2 80 year olds, one who died of COVID and one who did not, that if neither got COVID they would live to be the same age. I wouldn't be surprised if it was a 10x difference. While they do mention this and add some caveats (a good thing), I think because it completely changes the conclusions of the paper, they should have gone with a range and not a 11.7 number, which seems very improbable.

> Avoiding 1.75 million deaths or 20.5 trillion person years of life lost would be valued at $10.2 to $17.5 trillion

Then they take the 11.7 figure from above and multiply it by the estimated average value of a year of life. Again, there is at least an order of magnitude difference between a year of life at age 90 and a year of life at age 30, for most people.

Finally, although my ~3.5 number is much closer to the truth than 11.7, there is a difference between life expectancy and "healthy lifespan", aka "healthspan" (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6136295/). Healthspan is a newer concept but I expect will be the primary term in a decade or two.

Thank you for providing the link, a good read.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by rrss on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:32AM (#25396141)
> I wouldn't be surprised if it was a 10x difference

The next sentence:

> Hanlon et al. (10) estimate that those dying from COVID-19 have only about 1 y less of remaining life on average than those at the same age in the general population, which would mean that the overstatement is not very large, around 8%.

Your own link states that healthspan is not quantifiable, so your claim that it is 3.5y doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by breck on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:39AM (#25398869)
I saw Hanlon, and again a pretty good paper (http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/215598/1/215598.pdf), but far off. First, it came out in April, when CFR in the USA was 6.2%, not 1.9%. So that alone would be enough to drive YLL of fatalities down close to my number.

> "used to construct a plausible scenario for the prevalence of combinations of LTCs among people who died from COVID-19 for the modelling presented here."

Second, the dataset used at the time to generate their synthetic data was weak. You can see it immediately in their bar charts, where they have mostly healthy 50-69 y.o. dying in their synthetic data, skewing their YLL to the right.

> Your own link states that healthspan is not quantifiable, so your claim that it is 3.5y doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

I provided a link to a "conservative" description of healthspan, but in the field people are more optimistic about it.

Very good questions you brought up though, thanks!

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by IncRnd on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:06AM (#25395997)
That is taken out of context. The prior sentence pointed out, "we calculate that the 2020 American population of 330 million people has on average..."

The calculation you reference was done using all people in the US. Just two sentences later they wrote, "... would on average lose about 0.2 y of remaining life ..." You need to compare to the groups of affected people, which is generally not 100% of people in the US.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by rrss on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:36AM (#25396167)
The calculation I reference is the average remaining lifespan for people who die of COVID-19. The additional context doesn't make any difference, it just provides two additional (different) calculations:

average remaining lifespan across the entire population:

> we calculate that the 2020 American population of 330 million people has on average 45.8 y of remaining life expectancy, totaling 14.9 billion person years.

reduction in remaining lifespan in the 70-89 age group:

> Older individuals ages 70 to 89 y, taking those who die and those who survive together, would on average lose about 0.2 y of remaining life, and younger individuals would lose far less.

I did not include these calculations because they are not comparable to the number to which I was responding.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by pixl97 on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:30PM (#25395566)
That depends... did covid last over 10 days?

Ok, math is off, but covid is going to last for at least 2 more months with death rates like this and that accrues.

Also, do you know what they call it when I kill your grandmother 2 days before she was supposed to die of old age?

Murder.

Just because someone doesn't have much life left makes it no less of a tragedy when they die early.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by amscanne on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:17AM (#25395798)
> Just because someone doesn't have much life left makes it no less of a tragedy when they die early.

At the risk of being cold hearted, isn’t this exactly what it does?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by remote_phone on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:25AM (#25396105)
In fact, if someone is falling off a building and you shoot them dead midair, that’s also murder.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by krimpenrik on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:19AM (#25396385)
What a weird comparison, every day, 800 children die caus of dirty water.

https://www.worldvision.com.au/global-water-crisis-facts#:~:....

No one gives a shit.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by refurb on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:39PM (#25395262)
"They should have put in an army of analyzers into it."

You can't make a baby in 1 month with 9 women.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by baskire on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:34PM (#25395234)
sadly those extra days gained would do little to even put a dent in that figure.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:42PM (#25395287)
Alas, UK managed to approve the same vaccine a week ago. A week of delay means extra 15-20 thousands of lives lost.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by bigyikes on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:56PM (#25395368)
Also the sooner a vaccine is released, the sooner you can dampen the exponential growth, potentially compounding the lives saved. Not sure how significant of an effect this might be, though.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by addicted on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:19PM (#25395487)
We still don’t know if the vaccine prevents transmission. So that may not even be true.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by garmaine on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:16AM (#25396371)
We don’t have gold-standard proof that it prevents transmission, because studying that has not been a priory. There’s no reason to think that it doesn’t prevent transmission when you look at the mechanism involved. It would be very surprising.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by bigyikes on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:56AM (#25395956)
I didn’t know that, thanks! I guess I need to learn more about how vaccines work. I thought that vaccine implied immunity which implied that transmission is prevented.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:16PM (#25395471)
You get to the same number vaccinated by Jan 15th or whatever no matter what because we're production limited.

If you managed to give 5 million doses a week earlier, you save about 200 lives (about 40 deaths per million per week).

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:55PM (#25395690)
We already had millions of doses in April/May.

> If you managed to give 5 million doses a week earlier, you save about 200 lives (about 40 deaths per million per week).

No, that’s wrong.

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/12/th...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:03AM (#25395724)
> We already had millions of doses in April/May.

No we didn't. :P The US has 6.4 million doses of the Pfizer vaccine now. Projections of up to 50M delivered worldwide by the end of the year. We're on a crazy ramp.

If you want to complain about a misallocation, a key complaint would be that they're holding slightly more than half the doses back to ensure everyone dosed can get a second dose... but with rolling production such a large holdback isn't necessary.

> What could matter is if delay increases the speed at which you can ramp up.

All the jurisdictions I know will blow through the entire supply of existing doses allocated to them very quickly. It doesn't go on a slow distribution ramp gated by approval like your ridiculous source suggests. What governs the ramp is production rates, which have been running flat-out irrespective of this decision.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:28AM (#25395838)
> All the jurisdictions I know will blow through the entire supply of existing doses allocated to them very quickly. It doesn't go on a slow distribution ramp gated by approval like your ridiculous source suggests.

You misunderstand. "Blowing through entire supply" and being left with nothing is exactly the "slow distribution" Alex Tabarrok, a professor at GMU, talks about in the link I gave. He contrasts it with vaccinating entire population on day 1. Read it carefully.

> What governs the ramp is production rates, which have been running flat-out irrespective of this decision.

I consider the vaccine production regulation people to be just as incapable at cost-benefit analysis as vaccine approval people, so I assume that most production constraints are just as artificial as the approval constraints.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:42AM (#25395895)
Nope.

>You misunderstand. "Blowing through entire supply" and being left with nothing is exactly the "slow distribution" Alex Tabarrok, a professor at GMU, talks about in the link I gave. He contrasts it with vaccinating entire population on day 1. Read it carefully.

Vs.

"Now assume that the vaccine can’t roll out to everyone immediately. For the sake of this simple model let’s assume that on day one you can only vaccinate half the population. By doing so you save 1000 lives on day 1 and 2000 lives every day thereafter for the length of the pandemic. That’s the fourth panel. Now suppose we delay the vaccine rollout by one day. 2000 people die on Day 1 but you save 1000 on Day 2 and 2000 on Day 3 and every day thereafter for the length of the pandemic. How many people were killed by the delay? Compare the 4th and 5th panels. 2000 exactly as before! "

This compares vaccinating 50% on day 1, and the remaining 50% on day 2, to vaccinating 50% on day 2 and the remaining 50% on day 3.

But in blowing through the supply, we're comparing vaccinating 1% on day 1 and another 1% on day 7 and another 1% on day 15 to vaccinating 1% on day 7 and 1% on day 8 and 1% on day 15. Not at all the same scenario.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:59PM (#25395382)
That's only true in a scenario where you specifically vaccinate exactly the people that were infected that week and later died.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:54PM (#25395684)
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by chub500 on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:07PM (#25395425)
By that same logic why wait for any studies on the vaccine at all? Why not just start administering it as soon as it's developed (en masse)?

The rigor is to give the public confidence that we're better off getting the vaccine than not.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by garmaine on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:42AM (#25397071)
There are many people (like me) who argued for exactly that. We should have had general distribution and ramp up of production as soon as the Phase I studies were done. This could have prevented the second wave we are in, and saved hundreds of thousands of lives.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by henrikschroder on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:26PM (#25395534)
It's also the case that if you were to screw up on the first approval, if the first vaccine actually wasn't as safe as it needs to be, then most people will be scared of vaccine #2 or #3, regardless of their safety, regardless of how they were produced. And that would cause a huge setback and prolong all the stupidity for years, potentially.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:20PM (#25395490)
After the Phase 1 data was back, arguably it wouldn’t have been a bad call to give doses for free and gamble on the efficacy even if it turned out to be below 50%.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:29AM (#25399317)
From an ethical viewpoint, this is incredibly wrong, as vaccines given to healthy people which cause problems later are very very dangerous.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by pashamur on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:37PM (#25400884)
> From an ethical viewpoint, this is incredibly wrong, as vaccines given to healthy people which cause problems later are very very dangerous.

The first two phases are the safety tests, the third one is efficacy (so we knew the vaccine was "safe" after phase 2, we just didn't know the efficacy - that's what the poster above is alluding to).

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:51PM (#25395668)
I hope that extra public confidence is worth hundreds of thousands of deaths resulting from delaying the vaccine by months.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by lupire on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:07AM (#25398014)
With many millions of people intentionally disregarding simple low-cost precautions and unecessarily exposing themselves now, the population doesn't seem a good case for rolling out an experimental vaccine en masse.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:09AM (#25396016)
"extensive data" is 44K patients!? Wait until I tell you about the extremely extensive data that tech companies at scale deal with every day. I run a large data science organization at a major tech company. If someone told me that it was going to take 3wks to analyze an experiment of this type, I would probably have to start firing people.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:29AM (#25396127)
If someone wanted to take three weeks to analyze an experiment with these kinds of stakes, you’d fire them?! I have to assume you’re being hyperbolic.

And are you suggesting that it’s easier because the data isn’t as extensive as what the rest of us deal with? That only makes it harder.

Sure if it’s some random A/B test with data from your own systems from an experiment you designed, but this is a vaccine the whole fucking world has been waiting for for most of the year. God forbid people treat it a little more carefully.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:43AM (#25396201)
> If someone wanted to take three weeks to analyze an experiment with these kinds of stakes, you’d fire them?!

I would absolutely need to start a performance improvement process. They are definitionally 1/3 as productive as they should be. Also in terms of stakes, please show me even a modicum of work that suggests the downside risk of approval is greater than the delayed vaccinations. What reason have I to believe there is great risk in approval? Again, the UK approved this over a week ago.

> And are you suggesting that it’s easier because the data isn’t as extensive as what the rest of us deal with? That only makes it harder.

No, I'm mocking the idea of it being extensive data. It's not.

> but this is a vaccine the whole fucking world has been waiting for for most of the year.

And that's reason to go slower!? There's no need for this delay!!! https://thedispatch.com/p/fda-career-staff-are-delaying-the

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:09AM (#25396347)
> Also in terms of stakes, please show me even a modicum of work that suggests the downside risk of approval is greater than the delayed vaccinations. What reason have I to believe there is great risk in approval?

As I understand it, medical ethics isn’t about utilitarianism, or else we’d skip the rats and monkeys and just go straight to testing on the poor for money. They don’t seem to prioritize minimizing the opportunity cost of avoiding bad outcomes. Their guiding principle seems to be avoiding giving harmful treatment.

Meanwhile some healthcare workers at my partner’s facility are skeptical about whether the vaccine was rushed (I think they’re crazy, for the record). But there’s real risk if enough of the public doesn’t trust the vaccine. I’d bet that kind of angle is part of why they focus on “do no harm” instead of “minimize cumulative regret.”

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:57AM (#25397142)
But like even all of that being the case, that’s still no justification for taking 3wks to validate the data. The actual testing process is no different, the only difference is in how quickly approval comes. The same evidence is considered regardless. So what is the ethical justification for taking longer to consider the exact same evidence? Now if your point were that they should consider more evidence, then that’s fine and I can understand that but that’s not what’s at question here. The question is the speed at which the evidence is considered. What is the medical ethics justification that the UK was able to use to get this out over a week ago that is invalid in the US?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:35AM (#25399376)
I bring up the ethics question because a strict utilitarian analysis would be primarily answer the question of whether the drug is effective, looking for any red flags secondarily. A do no harm analysis (in the ethics sense, not the experimental design sense) has to look for any harms as a primary goal, maybe even equally to the question of efficacy.

Answering the question of whether the experiment harmed anything important is always much harder, as I’m sure you know. You see some metric is way down, but after a multiple comparisons correction it might just as well be noise, so then you have to start digging, doing a bespoke analysis for the fact that these non iid metrics point in these particular directions. You can’t pre-automate it because with N metrics that are practically significantly up/flat/down, that’s at least 3^N possible investigations to convince yourself whether it’s enough to stop rollout.

That’s the part that takes time, in any analysis I’ve ever done. Maybe literally zero time to check efficacy because that part is automated, then sometimes days to check whether there’s anything else worrisome in the probably-just-noise on other metrics, spending time proportional to the cost of getting the harm part wrong. Some of the hard questions aren’t statistical. You see some KPIs definitely up and some KPIs definitely down and deciding whether to roll out becomes a bitter fight between competing interests. Maybe you don’t roll it out yet for client segment X (like this trial and kids and pregnant women, as I understand it).

Re US vs UK, no idea. I’m not saying 3 weeks is necessarily the right amount of time here. I’m just so taken aback at the idea that 3 weeks is necessarily too long to the point you “would probably have to start firing people” and would “absolutely” have to start putting them on PIPs.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by raverbashing on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:19AM (#25396381)
I don't remember the last time I saw such a completely clueless comment like this one

I'm glad we have actual specialists checking the data and not people thinking it's only putting stuff on excel and writing a function

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:42AM (#25397076)
So where am I wrong? Where is this MD, MPH from Johns Hopkins wrong? https://thedispatch.com/p/fda-career-staff-are-delaying-the

Why is the UK able to approve it over a week ago but the FDA needs longer?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by raverbashing on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:04AM (#25397481)
> So where am I wrong?

Where you think processing the data just means loading up an excel table (or running a CSV through R) and that's the only data relating to the studies. Patient data is not the only thing being analyzed and it includes things like manufacturing, transport, etc

> Where is this MD, MPH from Johns Hopkins wrong?

He's not wrong but his worries as a clinical trial expert are a subset of the worries of an agency like the FDA. And I'm sure his workflow as clinical study expert is more fine tuned for that.

Or as in a developer analogy: making a code change is a 5 minute job. Actually making the change, testing, deploying, etc may take a whole day.

> Why is the UK able to approve it over a week ago but the FDA needs longer?

Pfizer sent the last info to the FDA on 22th of November. The MHRA had started a rolling review and received the last batch of info they needed on the 23rd of November.

I am certainly frustrated with the speed as well, but I don't think it's too much of a difference. Yes, maybe it could be faster.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:26AM (#25397590)
> Where you think processing the data just means loading up an excel table (or running a CSV through R)

Is it possible you could construct an even more ridiculous straw man?

> I am certainly frustrated with the speed as well... Yes, maybe it could be faster.

Oh, so you agree with what I'm saying and your problem is the straw man argument you created.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by riccia on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:19AM (#25398070)
So I work in public health, with public health colleagues. I came up with analyses pieced together from the publicly reported information and think that piece is a little disturbing.

Sure, you can come up with some standard numbers in an hour. But it wouldn't be the most thoughtful analysis, and the decision isn't really about a single efficacy estimate anyway.

I guess I figure if you're going to go down this route of pissing matches over how fast you can do an analysis on how big of a dataset, why the hell even have an FDA anyway? Just require the company post all their information and get rid of the regulation entirely. I actually think this isn't an unreasonable argument, even if I don't necessarily agree or disagree with it. It certainly seems more reasonable to me than "we should have a regulator that just rubber stamps things."

I'm fine with the FDA taking their time. The problem with risk in decisions is people forget in high stakes high risk decision making, it's about the process. This whole discussion about the FDA taking too long will look a lot different if a year from now the vaccine turns out to have some horrible long term effects (which it could, even though I think it's unlikely, just, you know, 'cause).

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:38AM (#25398159)
> Sure, you can come up with some standard numbers in an hour. But it wouldn't be the most thoughtful analysis, and the decision isn't really about a single efficacy estimate anyway.

No one is saying don't be thorough. What I'm saying and Makary is saying and the UK is saying is that the required thoroughness shouldn't take this long and when it does, real human lives are lost and sustained invasive measures in the freedoms of individuals are required.

> I guess I figure if you're going to go down this route of pissing matches over how fast you can do an analysis on how big of a dataset, why the hell even have an FDA anyway?

What a ridiculous leap. That's so many logical steps away from "the FDA moves way too slow" it's an absurdity. Who is arguing against the FDA's existence other than I guess you now sort of???

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by _Microft on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:22AM (#25396706)
They did not 'wait'. The FDA needed the time to do their job.

Contrary to what some people would like to believe government agencies are not rubber-stamping factories.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by nottrobin on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:54AM (#25396853)
I know nothing about what goes into approving a vaccine, but I am genuinely curious how come the US FDA was a whole 10 days behind the UK in approving this, and were also beaten by Bahrain and Canada.

Is it because they're genuinely more careful? Or is it just bureaucracy?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by makomk on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:30AM (#25397012)
The UK was unusually aggressive in getting everything in place to roll out this vaccine early - not just the approval process, but other logistics as well. The FDA, on the other hand, was under pressure to delay approval for partisan election-related reasons; the press created the perception that approving the vaccine early would be an evil plot by Trump to win the election. If the trials had reached enough cases to return results earlier, the difference could've been really dramatic because those delaying tactics essentially imposed a minimum length of time the trial had to run for in a slightly stupid way.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by addicted on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:17PM (#25395476)
I’d question what was the point of rushing this out?

The vaccines are gonna be supply constrained for a while. The same number of people will be vaccinated on Jan 31 (or the day before the next batch of vaccines become available) whether we start today or a few weeks from now.

At this point the more important consideration should be not doing anything that might even slightly reduce public faith in the vaccine.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by nsgi on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:22AM (#25396707)
> The same number of people will be vaccinated on Jan 31

That could still mean a big difference in the number of deaths. Some of those people may die/become seriously ill before Jan 31 before the vaccine gets to them

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by lupire on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:12AM (#25398043)
Not a big difference. A few thousand. A drop in the bucket compared to the 250K and any more ahead killed because many Americans are making a religion of intentionally refusing to limit their spreading of the virus.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by maxerickson on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:56PM (#25395692)
The first batch of Pfizer vaccine is enough to vaccinate a substantial portion of the vulnerable elderly (after vaccinating healthcare workers). Given that they are the ones that are dying at the highest rates, getting it deployed as fast as possible is likely to extend quite a few lives.

It's not like they've executed well on your last point in the meantime.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by starpilot on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:28PM (#25395191)
They needed to wait months to see if the people who received vaccine did not get the virus, and that they also were not harmed by the vaccine. This isn't some binary instantaneous outcome.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by koolba on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:40PM (#25395269)
They’re arguing about analyzing the data more quickly rather than spending three weeks analyzing it. There’s no additional data gleamed in that time period.
[dead]
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by aaomidi on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:26PM (#25395164)
With more platforms taking an anti misinformation stance I wonder if HN is planning to do the same? Even though we have a smaller reach.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by rantwasp on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:17PM (#25395080)
i enjoy a conspiracy theory as much as the average joe, but this stuff is getting out if hand
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by Karupan on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:19PM (#25395097)
I used to enjoy harmless ones like aliens or flat earthers, but the ones in 2020 are just outright dangerous.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by rantwasp on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:25PM (#25395154)
flat earthers were funny until we needed their help to flatten the curve
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:13AM (#25396038)
I highly doubt it's related to the election, but there is a "conspiracy theory" that is entirely plausible to me which is that the paternalistic leaders of the FDA/CDC believe that by taking longer to "validate" the data they are going to be better at convincing anti-vaxxers of the safety of the vaccine. The data analysis here is comically straightforward! This doesn't take 3wks! There's a reason the UK has already approved it!

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/12/ho...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by DonHopkins on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:18PM (#25395093)
That's what people who don't believe in science and disdain listening to scientists claim.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tehjoker on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:27PM (#25395176)
Trump threatened to fire the FDA administrator unless he authorized it today. That's not the hallmark of a careful analysis.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/12/11/trump-steph...

From a personal perspective, I want a safe and effective vaccine as soon as anyone would. I do not want to be propagandized into taking something potentially dangerous just because it lets the business community make money. What I want is a careful, rigorous, and non-politicized decision making process before I can trust the output of an experimental process. This has clearly not happened.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by davidf560 on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:13PM (#25395454)
The FDA announced early this morning that they were definitively going to authorize it[1], but they didn't actually issue the authorization at that point, with people telling the press that authorization would come "in the next few days".

If someone called up the FDA after that and said "hey, you've already told everyone you're going to approve this, so just sign the papers and make it official today rather than going home for the weekend and finishing it up on Monday", I have no problem with that. That's not pressure to prematurely authorize it (since they already confirmed they would), that's just cutting through the red tape/BS and making it official faster (IMO).

Put it into a tech perspective - if your company's cloud product went down and you were losing $millions every hour, and the devs found the bug and fixed it, but the product manager said "hey great, we'll fill out the release paperwork in the next few days and maybe approve pushing the change to prod on Monday", would anyone go for that? No way - they'd say we're not going home until this is fixed and released. Replace $millions with actual human lives and that's basically what we have here, isn't it?

[1] https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-stat...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by lupire on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:16AM (#25398060)
Remember when the Challenger shuttle was ready to launch so they skipped the final checks of the frozen O-ring data analysis?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tehjoker on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:35PM (#25395595)
This makes more sense to me. Thank you.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tzs on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:52PM (#25395670)
No need to worry in this case. They were going to hold their meeting to give final approval on Saturday. All Trump's blustering did was move that to late Friday.

It did not change any deliberations or analysis, nor did it change when the vaccine will actually go into use.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ummonk on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:36PM (#25395249)
I hate Trump's bullying tactics as much as the next person, but let's be clear - the FDA had completed its data analysis and released it a few days ago, and then the advisory panel yesterday supported its endorsement. At this point it was clear the vaccine was safe and effective, and an EUA should be rapidly announced by the FDA, whether the Trump would pressure them or not.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tehjoker on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:40PM (#25395270)
I don't understand then, why would the FDA need to be threatened? Wouldn't they try to move as fast as possible within the bounds of reason?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:23PM (#25395512)
I mean obviously this was not the case, since they announced they would definitely approve it but not for a few more days. We are talking about government bureaucrats here after all.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tssva on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:46PM (#25395646)
Actually prior to the threat they stated that they would approve it as fast as possible and were targeting Saturday morning. Trumps bullying sped things up by about 12 hours.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:38AM (#25395876)
Note that the approval date has absolutely nothing to do with the production schedule, which is the real limiting factor here. Having a few hundred people get their shots on Saturday instead of Tuesday or whatever isn't realistically going to move the needle. Every dose we can get is going into a patient somewhere.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by lbeltrame on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:00AM (#25397162)
Scale-up work and production started at the end of the summer.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:39AM (#25398468)
Yes, and every dose produced so far is ready to go into a patient immediately, they don't have a stockpile for the whole society, not remotely. Two days or whatever isn't going to matter that much. The timing of the first few thousand doses will change, the timing of the first ten million doses has to do with production and shipping, not approval.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by WalterBright on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:05AM (#25396329)
I saw on the news today that the vaccine was sitting waiting for the approval to ship. So yeah, getting approval sooner will get the vaccine shipping sooner.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by macksd on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:03PM (#25395403)
Trump threatening someone does not imply they needed to be threatened.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by tehjoker on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:14PM (#25395465)
It is possible he was just pissed at any delay at all. I am just feeling extremely skeptical about believing any of these people as their goal is to get us to forget about the pandemic and get back to work at maximum productivity regardless of whether this thing works.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by scoopertrooper on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:40AM (#25395889)
What's the point in rushing? Production is already going at full speed and they're not yet ready to begin the vaccination programme. Rolling this thing out is going to be a massive operation given the delicate conditions it must be stored under and the coordination across thousands of health systems required. All the preparation work is well under way and the timing of this approval doesn't impact it in the slightest.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:10AM (#25396018)
Yeah who cares about the lives being lost in the meantime?
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by scoopertrooper on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:18AM (#25396066)
My point was that none of the work required to prepare to begin the vaccinations was held up by the work of reviewing the studies and granting approval.

Furthermore, how many lives would be lost if society didn't have confidence in the approval process and declined vaccination? Russia is suffering this exact problem at the moment.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/rusisia-vaccine-...