News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ardit33 on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:33PM (#25395228)
The application and data was submitted 3 weeks ago... it took 3 weeks for the FDA to drag their feet and just say the obvious...

It is like the titanic is burning and these guys are playing violin...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by roseway4 on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:49PM (#25395336)
The FDA reran, in a matter of weeks, the entire analysis undertaken by Pfizer’s pharmacologists and statisticians over a series of months.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:18PM (#25395479)
To be fair, this was an extremely basic analysis on a relatively minuscule amount of data, where the form and format of data and the method of analysis has been prescribed months ago.

There was no decision that shouldn’t have been made ahead of time. Either it met the predefined criteria or it didn’t.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by Retric on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:27PM (#25395548)
Regulators need to independently verify more than just raw calculations. The incentives to hide or falsify data can be enormous.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:32PM (#25395575)
The only thing that couldn’t be verified until the last minute was the unblinded results.

Everything else should have been a continuous process of pre-verification up to the point the 128 positive confirmed COVID cases were unblinded.

Assume the unblinded results will be good enough, and verify everything else you would normally verify ahead of time. The only thing that remains is to verify the unblinded cases the day they are announced.

And not just that but your approval thresholds should already be preset and preregistered, the doses already distributed to point-of-care, and nurses start administering shots the very next day.

Yes it’s a big waste of money if it turns out not to work. That’s the whole point.

Turns out the vaccine is highly effective 10 days after the first dose. We could have been doing at least a million doses a day since November 19th. Realistically even long before then.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:16AM (#25396057)
I’m not in the drug industry, but in mine you can never turn the full decision process into a push button. Its trivial to turn the tests on your main metrics (is it effective) into push button, but you also have to look to make sure nothing else concerning is present, and it’s muuuch harder to formalize “nothing else here to make you worry” independent of the data.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by refurb on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:39AM (#25395883)
Ahhh... the old HN post of “I work in tech so I know more about how to approve an experimental vaccine than the FDA which is comprised of thousands of scientists and has been approving drugs for over 70 years.”
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:00AM (#25395977)
Remember when the CDC was considered the world’s absolutely top infectious disease center? Remember when they couldn’t even ship COVID test kits with uncontaminated distilled water?

Remember when the FDA wouldn’t let public or private labs run their own COVID tests and everything was being shipped to CDC headquarters to PCR?

The CDC and the FDA essentially guaranteed through extraordinary ineptitude that the US would not fend off COVID back in January/February. They deserve zero benefit of the doubt.

The FDA’s 70 years of process likely worked against them here. What I can say for certain is that there was a t-minus one, the day before the results were unblinded, and there was a t-zero, the day results were unblinded. On that day t-zero they uncovered which of the patient IDs got the vaccine versus which got placebo.

No expense should have been spared in preloading the analysis, verification, whatever could have been done, it should have been done up until t-minus-1. On day t-zero you get 15,000 patient IDs in column A and 15,000 in column B, that’s the only new thing you learn that day. There should be nothing new to talk about or discuss, the approval criteria should already be set in stone. Check the IDs and launch.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by brian_cloutier on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:20AM (#25397263)
I'm sorry you're being downvoted. The testing disaster killed far more than this vaccine approval delay has killed and it's infuriating that nobody seems to care.

They shut down testing back when we needed it most, allowing us to pretend there was no spread in the US for far too long: https://www.statnews.com/2020/05/27/coronavirus-testing-seat...

They spent far too long before approving any kind of at-home testing and to this day have not approved most rapid testing.

Three weeks ago the EUA was submitted, so three weeks ago there was an entire team of people at pfizer who had reviewed all the data and were confident FDA would approve the application, but somehow nobody at FDA was part of that set of people. In any reasonable process that application would have contained no new information, if it contained any new information they were not communicating closely enough.

I understand spending a few days doing some final checks on the data before approving. Three weeks, however, is suspiciously long. It's possible they were in fact doing important work which could not possibly have been done before the application was submitted, but nobody seems able to articulate what that important work actually was.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by refurb on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:24AM (#25398093)
A shitty test with 60% accuracy can make things worse than they already are.. People are making decisions based on results that are right barely half the time. I don’t blame the FDA for saying “no”.

I love HN who is normally vehemently anti-business (with good reason) suddenly flips and says “well Pfizer said the vaccine was ok, isn’t that good enough?”

No. It’s not good enough. The reason we spend billions per year on the FDA is because we want an independent, critical and evidence based body making decisions on drugs given to hundreds of millions of Americans.

I mean, hell, Trump was bullying the FDA (which was stupid) and HN seems to be arguing for that exact thing.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by brian_cloutier on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:37AM (#25440627)
There probably exist universes where a shitty test would make things worse. How are you so sure we're in that universe? And how are you so sure that the unapproved tests are so shitty that you're not at all curious whether the FDA made the right choice?

Nowhere in my comment did I say the FDA should just take Pfizer's word for anything.

I'm also not sure why you're trying to use Trump's actions as evidence here. "Trump did a thing and therefore doing that thing was the correct action" is an argument which requires some justification.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:30AM (#25396756)
Don't forget who is the Chief in command responsible for this outcome.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by wbl on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:28AM (#25395840)
Only the FDA does things this way.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ummonk on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:48AM (#25395922)
Perhaps e.g. the FAA should have done things the same way with the Boeing 737 Max certification.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by cyberlurker on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:38AM (#25396182)
Excellent comparison. These agencies shouldn’t blindly accept what the private sector puts out.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by aphextron on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:47PM (#25395650)
>The incentives to hide or falsify data can be enormous.

Highly doubtful. Pushing out an unsafe vaccine would be disastrous to Pfizer. They have every incentive in the world to be as absolutely certain as possible that the data is solid.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:31AM (#25396762)
That is a scientifically weak argument, and medically dangerous one.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by aphextron on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:15AM (#25398327)
> That is a scientifically weak argument, and medically dangerous one.

And so is the argument that Pfizer would have any incentive to fudge the data.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:51AM (#25398550)
Please refrain from using strawman argument.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by winston_smith on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:24PM (#25400283)
This Johns Hopkins doc claims they took off four days for Thanksgiving: https://thedispatch.com/p/fda-career-staff-are-delaying-the
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by creddit on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:03AM (#25395989)
What kind of computation do you think it is they are doing on this data? Seriously, it takes at MOST a week to do an extremely deep code review of this. It's not like this is some brand new testing methodology developed ad hoc for this.

How is it you think the UK was able to approve it already???

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/12/ho...

EDIT: Multiple downvotes already. Anyone care to refute what's presented in my post? Did you read any of the sources cited in the linked blogpost?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by loopz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:47AM (#25396823)
The link provides some arguments and maybe FDA should've/could've rolled with the process. Long times do not provide safety, only double blind tests and verifications do.

Are Gov jobs granted overtime work by ruling party, and how was this important work prioritized and coordinated by top leader?

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by ineedasername on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:02PM (#25395397)
It's probably the fastest a new vaccine has ever been developed, using a technique never before used for this purpose, for something that will quickly be given to millions upon millions of people. Maybe it shouldn't have taken 3 weeks, but there was certainly a non-zero period of time during which the FDA should seriously scrutinize and not just take Pfizer's word on things.