News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by baskire on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:34PM (#25395234)
sadly those extra days gained would do little to even put a dent in that figure.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:42PM (#25395287)
Alas, UK managed to approve the same vaccine a week ago. A week of delay means extra 15-20 thousands of lives lost.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by bigyikes on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:56PM (#25395368)
Also the sooner a vaccine is released, the sooner you can dampen the exponential growth, potentially compounding the lives saved. Not sure how significant of an effect this might be, though.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by addicted on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:19PM (#25395487)
We still don’t know if the vaccine prevents transmission. So that may not even be true.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by garmaine on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:16AM (#25396371)
We don’t have gold-standard proof that it prevents transmission, because studying that has not been a priory. There’s no reason to think that it doesn’t prevent transmission when you look at the mechanism involved. It would be very surprising.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by bigyikes on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:56AM (#25395956)
I didn’t know that, thanks! I guess I need to learn more about how vaccines work. I thought that vaccine implied immunity which implied that transmission is prevented.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:16PM (#25395471)
You get to the same number vaccinated by Jan 15th or whatever no matter what because we're production limited.

If you managed to give 5 million doses a week earlier, you save about 200 lives (about 40 deaths per million per week).

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:55PM (#25395690)
We already had millions of doses in April/May.

> If you managed to give 5 million doses a week earlier, you save about 200 lives (about 40 deaths per million per week).

No, that’s wrong.

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/12/th...

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:03AM (#25395724)
> We already had millions of doses in April/May.

No we didn't. :P The US has 6.4 million doses of the Pfizer vaccine now. Projections of up to 50M delivered worldwide by the end of the year. We're on a crazy ramp.

If you want to complain about a misallocation, a key complaint would be that they're holding slightly more than half the doses back to ensure everyone dosed can get a second dose... but with rolling production such a large holdback isn't necessary.

> What could matter is if delay increases the speed at which you can ramp up.

All the jurisdictions I know will blow through the entire supply of existing doses allocated to them very quickly. It doesn't go on a slow distribution ramp gated by approval like your ridiculous source suggests. What governs the ramp is production rates, which have been running flat-out irrespective of this decision.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:28AM (#25395838)
> All the jurisdictions I know will blow through the entire supply of existing doses allocated to them very quickly. It doesn't go on a slow distribution ramp gated by approval like your ridiculous source suggests.

You misunderstand. "Blowing through entire supply" and being left with nothing is exactly the "slow distribution" Alex Tabarrok, a professor at GMU, talks about in the link I gave. He contrasts it with vaccinating entire population on day 1. Read it carefully.

> What governs the ramp is production rates, which have been running flat-out irrespective of this decision.

I consider the vaccine production regulation people to be just as incapable at cost-benefit analysis as vaccine approval people, so I assume that most production constraints are just as artificial as the approval constraints.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by mlyle on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:42AM (#25395895)
Nope.

>You misunderstand. "Blowing through entire supply" and being left with nothing is exactly the "slow distribution" Alex Tabarrok, a professor at GMU, talks about in the link I gave. He contrasts it with vaccinating entire population on day 1. Read it carefully.

Vs.

"Now assume that the vaccine can’t roll out to everyone immediately. For the sake of this simple model let’s assume that on day one you can only vaccinate half the population. By doing so you save 1000 lives on day 1 and 2000 lives every day thereafter for the length of the pandemic. That’s the fourth panel. Now suppose we delay the vaccine rollout by one day. 2000 people die on Day 1 but you save 1000 on Day 2 and 2000 on Day 3 and every day thereafter for the length of the pandemic. How many people were killed by the delay? Compare the 4th and 5th panels. 2000 exactly as before! "

This compares vaccinating 50% on day 1, and the remaining 50% on day 2, to vaccinating 50% on day 2 and the remaining 50% on day 3.

But in blowing through the supply, we're comparing vaccinating 1% on day 1 and another 1% on day 7 and another 1% on day 15 to vaccinating 1% on day 7 and 1% on day 8 and 1% on day 15. Not at all the same scenario.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Friday December 11, 2020 @10:59PM (#25395382)
That's only true in a scenario where you specifically vaccinate exactly the people that were infected that week and later died.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:54PM (#25395684)
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by chub500 on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:07PM (#25395425)
By that same logic why wait for any studies on the vaccine at all? Why not just start administering it as soon as it's developed (en masse)?

The rigor is to give the public confidence that we're better off getting the vaccine than not.

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by garmaine on Saturday December 12, 2020 @04:42AM (#25397071)
There are many people (like me) who argued for exactly that. We should have had general distribution and ramp up of production as soon as the Phase I studies were done. This could have prevented the second wave we are in, and saved hundreds of thousands of lives.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by henrikschroder on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:26PM (#25395534)
It's also the case that if you were to screw up on the first approval, if the first vaccine actually wasn't as safe as it needs to be, then most people will be scared of vaccine #2 or #3, regardless of their safety, regardless of how they were produced. And that would cause a huge setback and prolong all the stupidity for years, potentially.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by zaroth on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:20PM (#25395490)
After the Phase 1 data was back, arguably it wouldn’t have been a bad call to give doses for free and gamble on the efficacy even if it turned out to be below 50%.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:29AM (#25399317)
From an ethical viewpoint, this is incredibly wrong, as vaccines given to healthy people which cause problems later are very very dangerous.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by pashamur on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:37PM (#25400884)
> From an ethical viewpoint, this is incredibly wrong, as vaccines given to healthy people which cause problems later are very very dangerous.

The first two phases are the safety tests, the third one is efficacy (so we knew the vaccine was "safe" after phase 2, we just didn't know the efficacy - that's what the poster above is alluding to).

Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by xyzzyz on Friday December 11, 2020 @11:51PM (#25395668)
I hope that extra public confidence is worth hundreds of thousands of deaths resulting from delaying the vaccine by months.
Re:FDA Issuing Emergency Use Authorization for First Covid-1... by lupire on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:07AM (#25398014)
With many millions of people intentionally disregarding simple low-cost precautions and unecessarily exposing themselves now, the population doesn't seem a good case for rolling out an experimental vaccine en masse.