News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:21PM (#25334290)
For me, it is impossible to cook properly on anything but a well controlled flame. Humans have used fire for millennia to cook our food. Making the modern, reasonable version of this illegal is an oppressive idea. Why should the restaurant industry be allowed to continue to use gas but I can't use it at home to make my own meals? Quit trying to control everyone.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by warent on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:27PM (#25334382)
Give me a break. Humans have not used natural gas for millennia to cook. If this was truly about sticking to your roots, you'd be cooking over a woodburning stove and this wouldn't be an argument. But you're not, because this is about something else.

If it was literally "impossible" then you probably have some impairment that prevents you from caring for yourself. But "Impossible" here doesn't mean its literal definition, right? It roughly translates to something like "too different from my old routine for me to put forth any energy toward adapting in the name of public health and the environment."

This has to he the most bogus and first-world complaint for people to throw a fit over having to cook with electricity.

EDIT: fireplace->stove

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by xkqd on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:20PM (#25335164)
I’m not agreeing with or disagreeing with you, but the tone of your message is pretty shit and berates OP for having their own opinion. Be kind.

Either way, OP’s remarks are common sentiment. I’ve heard from plenty of home chefs that a gas stove is drastically easier to work on. I can sympathize with them wanting options in their life.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by matthewdgreen on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:51PM (#25335598)
I also like cooking on a gas stove. But given the serious effects we're already seeing from climate change (just watch some videos from last summer in CA) I think statements like "quit trying to control me [so I can enjoy a slightly better hobbyist cooking experience]" also seem kind of crappy.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by warent on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:50PM (#25335589)
Your criticism is a little bit ironic, but despite that and the downvotes I think you make a fair point, it could come across harsh and probably not very useful for persuasion
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by forest_dweller on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:33PM (#25334464)
It obviously not impossible and the poster was being a bit hyperbolic.

However it is more difficult to cook well on electric hobs than gas hobs as you can't directly adjust the heat as needed. Given the choice (I don't have it) I would take gas everytime.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:35PM (#25334496)
I didn't say it was impossible full stop. I said it is impossible to cook things _properly_ with just electric which is true if you know much about cooking.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by pureliquidhw on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:38PM (#25336212)
I used to think the same thing, but now I have an induction stove and it is significantly better than the gas range at my previous house. It heats the pan instead of the air/element, and so it is significantly more efficient. A side benefit is significantly reduced exhaust load and a much easier to clean cooktop.

Also, water boils so fast now! You'd be amazed.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by igetspam on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @08:28AM (#25344725)
Agreed. I've heard people make this argument for years but they always seem to ignore changes in tech. A high quality range can reach the temperatures necessary for canning (another thing I've been told you can't do without a flame) and hold a consistent temperature the entire time.

I'm very happy with my electric ranges.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by forest_dweller on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @08:59AM (#25345115)
It not that people are ignoring changes in tech. It is the fact that most people don't have this "high-quality" range or an induction stove.

I've never seen an induction hob ever. Almost everyone I know has gas or electric and electric has always been more difficult to cook on.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by sliken on Monday December 07, 2020 @05:21PM (#25338492)
It's just a different way of thinking about it. Not sure how it could be impossible to use an electric range to "properly" cooj.

I find it MUCH easier to simmer at a low temperature with electric, and I prefer the dial a temp, over dial a volume of natural gas. You don't have to tinker nearly so often. Want a nice slow boil, just set the temp, watch it run at 100% till it reaches the temp, then throttle back as the temp is reached.

Similarly when cooking any kind of reduction you don't have to keep tinkering as larger fractions of the water cooks off.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by renewiltord on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:29PM (#25334417)
Wood burning devices are already banned in new construction.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by jzoch on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:31PM (#25334437)
Which proves his point - its not as life-ending as the top level OP made it sound. I hate cooking on electric stoves but lets not pretend its akin to losing a leg.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:34PM (#25334478)
> lets not pretend its akin to losing a leg

No one compared it to that or anything like that.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by silon42 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:35PM (#25334504)
Only in cities/larger towns I hope... better put some of that fuel to use before it burns your house down.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by warent on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:43PM (#25334610)
If wood burning stoves are illegal to install on private property away from cities, that's something I would agree is a problem. As far as I know though it is legal.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:37PM (#25334520)
> Humans have not used natural gas for millennia to cook.

I didn't say that so please don't put words in my mouth. Natural gas is the most reasonable and common way to cook with fire year round. Additionally, new wood burning equipment is already outlawed in many places.

I also did not say it was impossible to cook at all with electric. I said it is impossible to cook properly with electric. If you know anything about cooking you know that is a fact.

Some people cook as a passion and care deeply about the tools they use to make the food they eat. Maybe we should outlaw whatever hobby you have! How would you like that?

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by Someone1234 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:46PM (#25334653)
> I said it is impossible to cook properly with electric. If you know anything about cooking you know that is a fact.

I do and I do not know that as a fact. Can you cite it please?

Heat is an important aspect of cooking, but the source of the heat (outside of hotspots) isn't maybe as important as cookware heat-storage-capacity/heat transfer speed.

The only thing I can immediately point to gas doing that electric/induction cannot is a traditional round-bottom wok. But I'd be lying if I said a wok was a major part of my cooking.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by watertom on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:35PM (#25334499)
Induction works better than gas.

Commercial kitchens have been switching to induction because the new units can maintain precise temperature, it also allows for much cooler kitchens, it’s easier to clean, and it gives them flexibility for staffing options, because the precise maintainable temperature control some cooking methods become almost foolproof.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by Yetanfou on Monday December 07, 2020 @06:23PM (#25339168)
It doesn't work well with a wok though, nor does it - or any other ceramic-covered stove (halogen, IR) - cope well with those who have an "active" style of cooking where the pan is moved almost as much as the utensil. I was an early adopter of induction in the 90's in the Netherlands but moved back to a wood-burning stove when I moved to Sweden. Yes, wood, in Swedish called "vedspis" (firewood-stove). It warms the house, it works when the power fails - which is does regularly out here in the countryside - and it works wonders with a wok. I still have a few induction plates but I hardly ever user them other than outside when there is fire ban in summer.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:41PM (#25334581)
It is also way more expensive to get into and requires the use of certain types of pans which increases cost more.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by Someone1234 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:51PM (#25334722)
> requires the use of certain types of pans which increases cost more.

Really, no. Walmart's "own brand" stainless steel pans that start at under $10 work fine. The pans it doesn't work with are actually rare/expensive (pure aluminum/pure copper, and certain high-end stainless steel that are now largely discontinued).

People repeat this special pan thing often (multiple times in this thread) but I don't know where this idea came from. The most common/popular pans for the last fifty years work with induction, and cheap ones are MORE likely to work.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by klyrs on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:02PM (#25335759)
There's a ton of crappy teflon&aluminum cookware out there. It's not that you need a special pan, but nor can you use just any old pan. FWIW, I've been cooking electric my whole life, and using induction or gas is annoying to me (though I've lived a couple years in apartments with either)
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by turtlebits on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:49PM (#25334695)
You can get a portable induction cooktop for under $50. My parents have 2 Ikea units which they often use instead of their Viking stove. (They place them on top of the stove so they can use the hood).

Pans are the same price as regular cookware, you just need to make sure it's compatible.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by klyrs on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#25334343)
> Why should the restaurant industry be allowed to continue to use gas but I can't use it at home to make my own meals?

Simply put, they shouldn't. But they have more money and thus more political sway to get carve-outs.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by jedimastert on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:32PM (#25334442)
I don't generally find "we've always done it this way" or "everyone else is doing it, why can't I?" to useful arguments.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by cactus2093 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:48PM (#25334687)
Gas use in homes goes way beyond the stove though. I just moved into a newly renovated house, it has a brand new gas stove which is amazing. But it also has a gas furnace, gas water heater, and a brand new gas washer/dryer. No idea why they'd install a brand new gas dryer in this day and age - likely the power bill is a little cheaper from it (which is itself a problem), but I plan to install solar panels in the not too distant future like many in my neighborhood already have in which case the gas version definitely becomes more expensive.

Plus even for the stove, it has an attached gas oven, which doesn't really bring me any benefit except maybe a marginally faster pre-heat time that I can live without. It's even a net negative to me because now if I want to do any kind of slow cook in the oven I need to worry about ventilation and it's hard for it to hold a steady low temperature. Heck even for the stove, I wish it had half electric burners and half gas, if I'm doing some slower process like making a stock or chili or something I'd rather use electric to again avoid the fumes.

So despite the fact that I love being able to saute over a flame now, I'd definitely support a tax that makes using gas much more expensive. A full-on ban would be extreme, I'd agree with you that's overly aggressive control, especially until electric burners get better. But ideally I could choose and in places where I actually get a lot of value from it I could pay the higher price to offset my environmental impact, but in all the other uses it would make more economical sense to avoid it so appliance makers, construction companies, etc would be incentivized to drastically reduce the use of gas.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by onecommentman on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:36PM (#25339868)
Gas dryers last longer and are easier to maintain, in my experience. Same with gas stoves and ovens. Slow cooking is better done in an electric slow cooker, electric pressure cookers are great.

NG v. Solar is a non-obvious environmental question to ask. If you are posting from CA (the reflexive support for an additional tax suggests Pacific coast at least), you have the sort of folks who can answer that in your own backyard, LLBL. Lawrence Berkeley Labs. Check their website and publications.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by etrautmann on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:03PM (#25334898)
This is not a good argument. There are plenty of advantages to cooking on electric induction stoves and most people can adjust their preferences to use a new and improved tool. Rapid temperature control, even heat distribution, with a bonus of being better for the environment (assuming renewable energy is used).
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by hyko on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:28PM (#25334404)
Hydrogen?

Obviously there are some cooking techniques that require flames, but heat is ultimately fungible when it comes to pans etc.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by cycrutchfield on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:27PM (#25334371)
Have you ever used an induction cooktop? Personally, it seems far superior to a gas stove
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by davio on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:29PM (#25334416)
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by drewg123 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:32PM (#25334449)
I have a builder-grade gas stove, and my gf moved into a new place with a fancy new high-end Bosch induction cooktop. I cook on both regularly. The induction stove is far slower to heat up, and very finicky to use (will sometimes shut off). Not to mention that my gf had to get mostly new pots and pans to use the induction, since most of her existing pots and pans were not magnetic.

Also, the gas stove will continue to work when the power is out. All I have to do is light it with a match, but the induction cooktop will be out of commission as long as the power is out. We regularly have electric outages, but I don't remember ever having a gas outage.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by hbosch on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:30PM (#25334419)
Funny that your comment is downvoted. Induction is both safer, more efficient, and easier to control. I can dial my stovetop into an exact temperature, and a pot of water boils under a minute.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by dna_polymerase on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#25334341)
> Humans have used fire for millennia to cook our food

Yeah, sure but certainly not from a gas flame.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by mlyle on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:28PM (#25334391)
A natural gas flame is much better for air quality than any other common combustion-based heat source (like, sure, hydrogen would be a bit better, but...).
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by dna_polymerase on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:13PM (#25340804)
Not arguing the air quality, just wanted to point out how stupid it is to argue for something just because we did it for thousands of years.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by jtms on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:27PM (#25334377)
Cool - let me just burn oak or pine everyday in my kitchen that sounds like a GREAT idea
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by klyrs on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:38PM (#25334534)
Right. And why did we end that time-honored tradition? Soot pollution, and deforestation. In other words, the environmental impact of those fuels.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by kleiba on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:28PM (#25334399)
Practice makes perfect. Electric stoves are in wide-spread uses all around the world. You're right that they require a different technique but I'm sure that you, too, would be able to master it.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by mlyle on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:05PM (#25334929)
Ordinary electric stoves are slow. I came from resistive heat to gas, and gas is way, way, way better in every way.

Induction cooktops largely fix this, though.

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by kleiba on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:54PM (#25335645)
Obviously they're not better in every way, that's the whole point of the article. When it comes to the cooking performance, though, have I claimed otherwise? All I said was that it is absolutely possible to prepare your meals with electric, as proofed by millions of people using them. They're different, of course, but absolutely usable.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by cma on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:23PM (#25334312)
This measure may not be the right thing, but isn't it also controlling in a different way to change the composition of other's atmospheric gases in a harmful way? Just because it is diffuse responsibility doesn't mean it is less controlling in aggregate.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#25334338)
We all exhale CO2? Is your breath controlling me!??
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by cma on Monday December 07, 2020 @06:09PM (#25339020)
Less than 1% of emissions are from breath, which we can all agree is necessary and not currently above the CO2 re-absorption rate.

Here we are talking about achieving a more even Malliard reaction on flapjacks. Cooking may not be significant enough to worry about first either, I don't know, but it is a form of control (free choice of more evenly browned flapjacks for no choice of of someone else facing faster timeframe to be flooded out of their nation or city).

Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by kneel on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:28PM (#25334400)
That's a great point, we should attempt to limit respiration.
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by macinjosh on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:38PM (#25334535)
You first ;)
Re:Should California ban gas in new homes? A climate battle ... by whiddershins on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:24PM (#25334336)
Affecting is a word that is distinct from controlling, I think the concepts have a relationship but aren’t the same.