News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by carls on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:00AM (#25199587)
I didn't know how much of Jim Davis' motivations were commercial ones. It seems very at odds with folks like Calvin and Hobbes creator Bill Watterson:

> For years, Watterson battled against pressure from publishers to merchandise his work, something that he felt would cheapen his comic. He refused to merchandise his creations on the grounds that displaying Calvin and Hobbes images on commercially sold mugs, stickers, and T-shirts would devalue the characters and their personalities.[1]

I'm curious: what led to Garfield's immense popularity as a syndicated comic? Were there in fact legions of people who _did_ find it funny, or entertaining?

---------

[1] Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Watterson#End_of_Calvin_a...

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by Rallerbabs on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:03AM (#25199623)
As a kid, I always thought Garfield was absolutely hilarious. I'd cut the comic out of the newspaper and glue them into a book. Loved the cartoons. The Halloween one is my favorite. Up to my 40th birthday, I was given Garfield comics.

I love what a gluttonous, selfish and slightly malevolent pig Garfield is. I especially love it when he kicks Odie off the table.

I can't stand Peanuts, though.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by LeoPanthera on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:13AM (#25199747)
I don't have anything to add except that I wanted to make it clear that you're not the only one. As a child (80s/90s) I thought Garfield was hilarious. I'd always ask for Garfield books for birthday/christmas presents and I would often re-read them.

I don't find it quite so directly funny anymore, but it does feel very nostalgic. Read Garfield is very comforting.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by Rallerbabs on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:31AM (#25199950)
Oh, I almost forgot.

Every single agenda I ever had in high school, was a Garfield agenda.

No exceptions. Ever.

No regrets, either.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by barkingcat on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:35AM (#25199997)
Agreed. No regrets.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by dkarl on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:49AM (#25200176)
I was a Peanuts fan as a kid and still am. Rereading books of the old strips was centering and calming for me the way the bible is for some people. It reassured me that it was... safe?... to wish for justice in the world and to want to be a better person. I liked Garfield, too, but it appealed to something meaner in me. There's suffering in both strips, but the way the Charlie Brown endures despite his dignity being stripped from him again and again is realistic, while the fact that Jon always bounces back is meant to be understood as unrealistic. A realistic Jon would be a crushed, hopeless, miserable person. Often the only purpose of putting a smile on his face seemed to be to make it possible to enjoy the cruelty directed against him. (Same with Odie.) Not saying I'm above enjoying it, but it's hard to put a positive spin on it.

My favorite Garfield cartoons are the ones where I can read John as self-aware, like this one: https://www.mezzacotta.net/garfield/?comic=2351

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by sethammons on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:11AM (#25199714)
Similar. As a kid, I thought Garfield was very funny. We had a couple books of 'em. I also enjoyed Far Side. I should revisit them :)
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by brandmeyer on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:29AM (#25199925)
> I also enjoyed Far Side.

Gary Larson has started drawing again! He's still "retired" but has started self-publishing on an irregular cadence.

https://www.thefarside.com/new-stuff

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by sp332 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:13AM (#25199743)
Some Garfield strips are really funny. The first couple years had a higher density of actual jokes I think.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by bitwize on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:43PM (#25200819)
Oh, kids think he's a scream. But the humor wears thin as you get older. I've noticed the same about Mad Magazine. When I was 11 and 12, it was hilarious. But as I got older I realized that half the reason I found it so funny is because I was a kid. The nonstop puns, pop-culture parodies, and low-key raunchy humor pushed the envelope for me. But as an adult I realized that whatever wasn't forced obvious humor, was boomers who haven't moved on, didn't understand new phenomena like video games at ALL (certainky not enough to competently make fun of them), and were fighting 60s and 70s ideological battles in the 80s and 90s. They dedicated an entire section of one issue to moralizing about smoking, for instance.

That said, some of the art -- especially Al Jaffee's -- was excellent. I can't say the same about Garfield.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by ksaj on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:04PM (#25205213)
Mad Magazine was comedic gold for what goes on in the margins (the little mini-cartoons) and the self-referencing jokes. I was a fan of spy-vs-spy, too. It very well might have influenced my career.

The last page (the one you fold) was pretty innovative, too.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by polka_haunts_us on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:13AM (#25199739)
>Were there in fact legions of people who _did_ find it funny, or entertaining?

I'm sorry ahead of time if this comment comes off as strong, but I'm always confused by people who can't comprehend that there must be people who like thing it's popular to not like.

I hate Adam Sandler, I think he's among the least funny human beings on the planet. I also don't question whether anyone actually enjoys his movies, because obviously people do.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by carls on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:25AM (#25199876)
My question in the original comment is not meant to mock or poke fun at those who enjoyed it. I, myself, found it somewhat entertaining to read as a kid.

Rather, my question is more in reference to what seem to be incongruous facts: the article points out that the comic was not written with the intention to be funny, so then what explains its popularity as a comic strip?

I don't doubt that there are some (many!) who thought it funny. What I'm trying to understand is the discrepancy between its immense fame AND its apparent lack of humorous intention.

It'd be a little bit like if there was a famous band that was incredibly popular, yet in multiple interviews they reveal that they don't put a great deal of effort behind making appealing music. As such, I would be curious to understand what instead may be the other driving sources of their appeal (ex. good looks, marketing etc.).

For example, here are some other possible candidate reasons the Garfield comics may have been popular. I don't know if any of these are true, rather I would consider them hypotheses that I would be curious to hear others confirm/debunk:

* it was marketed very well and gave people the perception that it was _supposed_ to be funny, and if you didn't find it funny that was perhaps a result of _you_ not getting something. * there was a more limited selection of sources of comic strips, so the standards for what passed as an entertaining comic strip were lower than in our Internet age. * most people knew it wasn't funny, nor that it was meant to be funny. Rather they read it because it was the cultural meme of the day to do so.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by lukey_q on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:34AM (#25199983)
As someone who also remembers Garfield being funny as a kid, I don't read the OP as saying it was never funny, but that being funny was a secondary concern to Davis after being marketable. I just looked up a random Garfield strip from 1988 [1] and I have to say, it's kind of a funny visual gag. Nothing groundbreaking but for a daily strip in a newspaper, it's not bad, and I'm an adult now, as a kid I probably would have found it hilarious. Combine decent humor like that with recognizable and cute characters appearing in the newspaper daily and it's not surprising that the strip became so popular.

[1] http://images.ucomics.com/comics/ga/1988/ga880101.gif

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by bitwize on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:47PM (#25200867)
Adam Sandler basically ceased trying soon after leaving SNL. Like Jim Davis, he puts no effort into trying to be funny to a wide audience. He makes his movies as an excuse to goof off and hang out with his friends, while trading his name for cash from studios like Netflix.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:26AM (#25199886)
I don't find Adam Sandler that funny either. But as a dad, I recommend the movie Fast Forward to other dads.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by deberon on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:46AM (#25200133)
You might be thinking of the movie "Click"? If so, I also recommend it. Hits harder than you'd expect from a goofy Adam Sandler movie.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:52PM (#25203368)
Sorry, yes, I meant "Click". Thanks for the correction.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by mhh__ on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:39AM (#25200051)
Adam Sandler can actually act e.g. Punch Drunk Love and Uncut Gems
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by kgwgk on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:50AM (#25200202)
That's orthogonal to being funny anyway.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by mhh__ on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:07PM (#25200400)
Perhaps, but making a funny film isn't as simple as getting people who are "funny" and letting them run free.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by bitwize on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:49PM (#25200887)
Yeah. The difference between making a funny movie and just "being funny" is the difference between Ghostbusters (1984) and Ghostbusters (2016).
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by kgwgk on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:21PM (#25200581)
Maybe I misunderstood your comment and "Uncut Gems" was an example of a funny film :-)
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by ausbah on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:38AM (#25200045)
Sandler can play serious roles very well, check out Uncut Gems
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by incanus77 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:58AM (#25200283)
I had a bunch of Garfield books as a kid, too. IIRC they were about 9”x6” and mostly black & white. I found them hilarious, I think for a couple reasons:

1. John was such a clueless loser

2. Garfield got so enraged at Nermal

3. Odie kept bouncing back

This was not a deep humor. It’s the kind of humor where you see a dumb, funny video on the internet, snort a laugh, and move on, completely forgetting it ten seconds later.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by ksaj on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:11PM (#25205247)
I always thought of it as anti-humour, which is a form of humour in and of itself. A lot of almost-joke scenes that just sort of stop without actually going anywhere.

I liked Garfield because it dead-panned things that otherwise would have been funny. Hated the television cartoon version though.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by coldtea on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:24AM (#25199867)
I mildly like Garfield.

Never particularly cared for Calvin and Hobbes (always found it somewhat preachy, tacky, and emotionally kitch, the "I think we've learned something today", going-for-the-feels type), though the writer is nonetheless very talented (and a lot of its strips are great).

The post also mentions the New Yorker cartoons. Never cared for them either, not because I "missed the joke", but because I dislike their faux-high-brow attitude to humor, given that the content is more often than not trite observations about society.

I also like lots of webcomic strips (Cyanide and Hapiness, Dinosaur Comics, SMBC, The Parking Lot is Full, etc), and comics like Gosciny, Mafalda, Mortadelo y Filemon, and so on, besides "serious" comics.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by throw_away on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:09AM (#25199696)
Don't forget children. The television series are very child-centric and also the plush toys.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by cptnapalm on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:03AM (#25199617)
For those that do not know how enjoyable Garfield is when there is no Garfield, I present to you Garfield Without Garfield.

https://garfieldminusgarfield.net/

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by anon9001 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:11AM (#25199718)
Hah. I haven't seen that in so many years. Glad to see they're still updating.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by derwiki on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:29AM (#25199931)
I think I found Garfield without Garfield around the same time I found http://www.nietzschefamilycircus.com
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by Balgair on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:32PM (#25203212)
Amazing, thank you!
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by tombert on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:35AM (#25199991)
When people say this kind of stuff, I always wonder if it's post-hoc rationalization.

"Oh...so you don't like Garfield? Well, ummm, it wasn't meant to be funny anyway, I WIN!"

Doesn't Tommy Wiseau claim that The Room was meant to be a comedy now?

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by brundolf on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:54AM (#25200238)
I think it's more that he's embraced it for what it's come to mean to his audience, instead of what he originally envisioned. Which is honestly really admirable.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by nathanvanfleet on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:19PM (#25200541)
Did you read the article though?
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by waynesonfire on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:55AM (#25200245)
It doesn't matter what is claimed. See our current President.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by davidwhite on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:01PM (#25200330)
"Permanent Monday" is a blog that does an amazing job of teasing out and/or retrofitting the humor buried in the strip.

In its reading, there is usually a "surface level" joke that isn't particularly funny, but some visual detail of representation will point to a hidden meaning that is usually pretty vicious.

See i.e. http://permanent-monday.blogspot.com/2010/05/movable-feast-h...

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by alisonkisk on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:10AM (#25199709)
Smithsonian Magazine (!) Is just blog spamming a Quora post.

https://www.quora.com/Garfield-comic-strip/Is-Garfield-suppo...

And this Garfield Isn't Funny meme is absurd. Newspaper comics aren't "funny". Daily comics aren't "funny". reddit.com/r/funny isn't "funny". Newspaper comics are for kids, and kids think Garfield is hilarious, 30 years ago and today.

The idea that Davis would create an intentionally bad comic and that would make people buy his merchandise is ridiculous.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by tgv on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:22AM (#25199846)
And they say journalism is dead.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by barkingcat on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:34AM (#25199986)
I always found Garfield hilariously downright funny.

Maybe that's why most people don't get my sense of humour.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by mywittyname on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:12PM (#25200463)
Same. I find most of the comics funny, but there are a few that really make me laugh. I actually have a folder on my desktop dedicated to so some of my favorite cartoons.

Comedy isn't universal at all: I'm sure there are people who don't find Robin Williams funny. With Garfield, there are several layers to the strip, and the more of them you understand, the funnier the strip gets.

I think you have to ...

1) Understand the role of each character;

2) Empathize with Garfield (easy to do, he has many common failings);

3) Feel like cats in general are lazy, eat the same thing, somewhat anti-social, and prone to melodrama (i.e., be a cat owner);

4) Feel superior to Jon, as everyone else in the comic does, but also find him lovable (having a dorky dad helps);

5) Appreciate absurdity

...for the humor to translate.

Here's a random comic I chuckled at : https://www.gocomics.com/garfield/1986/03/22

The foundations of humor are certainly present in this strip, regardless of how much the reader knows about Garfield. It is absurd (a cat crying and watching a sad movie) and incongruous (turns out, he's not watching a movie at all; his reaction is not proportional to the situation). But I think what elevates the strip is the repetition of Garfield's struggle with diets and how Jon always tries (and fails) to cheer Garfield up, combined with the fact that Garfield acts exactly like real-world cats do (crying for attention/food).

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by pmoriarty on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:04AM (#25199634)
So what is it that makes Garfield popular?

This is the more interesting question the article does not even try to explore.

My own theory: he's cute.

People love cute cats. Grouchy cats are cute. Ergo Garfield is cute, and lovable, even when not funny.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by t0mbstone on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:35AM (#25199993)
"Then, he consciously developed a stable of recurring, repetitive jokes for the cat. He hates Mondays. He loves lasagna. He sure is fat."

Basically, Garfield is for people who like grumpy cats and relatable, albeit, repetitively dry and not particularly witty humor.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by cm2012 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:39AM (#25200057)
Come on now. This headline is so dumb. Both things are true:

1) Garfield is meant to make money.

2) Garfield is meant to be funny and the vast majority of people find it funny.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by dbspin on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:35AM (#25199992)
Interesting that the immediate counterpoint is the New Yorker comic strips. While certainly witty, I'd question whether these are even intended to be funny. As in, do people literally read them and laugh out loud, find themselves thinking back on a particular strip and laughing and so on. I always assumed the New Yorker panels were more of an acerbic, dry, 'aha' kind of observation than anything designed to be 'funny' in the traditional sense. Meanwhile, Garfield while hackneyed (as the article points out, even intentionally so) has its moments.

The classic New Yorker panel is perhaps 'On the Internet, no one knows you're a dog' - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_... Clever, timely and memorable, sure. But inducing of mirth? Questionable.

Comedians make the differentiation between 'funny' and 'funny, funny', as between a 'bit' and a 'joke, joke', something that follows the traditional structure of a joke book or cracker. It's an interesting distinction for something that isn't particularly well described by the subtleties of English.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by InfiniteRand on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:21AM (#25199839)
I mildly enjoy the Garfield comic strip, it gives a chuckle or two every now and then but is mostly forgettable (This article is a bit over the top though, written for commercial reasons does not mean not intended to be funny, I find it kind of silly to measure something by the purity of the artist's intentions)

I did greatly enjoy the Garfield and Friends TV show as a kid, I still remember the bit about "Wyoming" meaning no state here.

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by secondcoming on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:22AM (#25199847)
These guys did an amazing job with Garfield:

https://www.youtube.com/user/lasagnacat

I especially love: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_NeqMAAsBk

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by tyrust on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:00PM (#25200315)
> not posting their magnum opus

https://youtu.be/NAh9oLs67Cw

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by secondcoming on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:12PM (#25200462)
Ha yes, I forgot about that one. I watched it all the way through once.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by tyrust on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:18PM (#25200536)
Same, but while working, admittedly. It was fairly coherent throughout iirc.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by Grakel on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:16PM (#25200502)
Cut a slice and take the rest may be the funniest thing of all time (to me). https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CutASliceTakeThe...
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:37AM (#25200021)
Let's be honest: every comic artist is hoping to be a commercial success, at least once. To fund their other interests if nothing else.

Even Dilbert was a calculated commercial invention, leveraged for all it was worth?

Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by raxxorrax on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:50AM (#25200185)
Garfield and Dilbert have a lot in common aside from that. Don't know what the genre would be called, exaggerated cynicism?
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by bitwize on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:59AM (#25200301)
The thing about Garfield being a big orange ball of nothing is you can project anything onto him. Recently there was a phenomenon of turning Garfield into Lovecraftian horror -- exemplified by the ImSorryJon subreddit.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by dang on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:10PM (#25204120)
Garfield on the front page the moment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25188207
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by knolax on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @05:39AM (#25207805)
Wow the Smithsonian Magazine has resorted to reposting Quora answers.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by WesolyKubeczek on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:23AM (#25199855)
I frequent r/imsorryjon. Now, those things are funny.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by ouid on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:42AM (#25200091)
It's understandable that they would think that new garfield strips aren't being drawn.
Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013) by ChrisArchitect on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:15PM (#25200493)
2013? why share this??