Re:It’s Not Just You: Garfield Is Not Meant to Be Funny (2013)
by t0mbstone on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:35AM
(#25199993)
"Then, he consciously developed a stable of recurring, repetitive jokes for the cat. He hates Mondays. He loves lasagna. He sure is fat."
Basically, Garfield is for people who like grumpy cats and relatable, albeit, repetitively dry and not particularly witty humor.
This is the more interesting question the article does not even try to explore.
My own theory: he's cute.
People love cute cats. Grouchy cats are cute. Ergo Garfield is cute, and lovable, even when not funny.