News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by darrylb42 on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:10PM (#25151627)
YouTube premium gets rid of all the ads, unless creators have embedded them in the video. There is lots of good content for toddlers on YouTube, but it is unwatchable with ads. I watch more myself now all the ads are gone, plus you get youtube music, not as good as spotify but good enough.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by IgniteTheSun on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:29PM (#25151886)
Cable TV started as paid ad-free TV also. It now has so many ads that it is almost unwatchable at times.

One wonders how much further YouTube can take this - it appears they are approaching the optimal point for extracting revenue from videos, so where is their future revenue growth going to come from?

I miss the YouTube of old rather than this commercialized version. To me, Tik Tok seems like more like the original YouTube than YouTube does.

I for one have become so annoyed with the level of ads that I have reduced my consumption of YouTube. To me, it seems like there is a much higher rate of advertising on a per-content-minute basis on YouTube than there is on TV.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by kazinator on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:30PM (#25152649)
> Cable TV started as paid ad-free TV also.

Not true. Cable TV started by simply sending a copy of broadcast TV over coaxial cable, giving the user a more reliable signal (better picture and sound) compared to a "rabbit ears" antenna, and access to programs from distant cities beyond the limits of good radio reception. That broadcast TV, of course, was a live signal which contained ads in the signal that could not be removed.

Cable TV also offered the end user a convenient box with a digital channel number display and remote control for changing channels. The user was able to flip among dozens of channels without having to fiddle with the UHF/VHF tuning controls of their TV: they tuned the TV to channel 3 (or whatever) and could just leave it, letting the cable box do the channel selection. Cable TV was a major upgrade to the TV set. In particular to a basic model or old TV with only knobs for channel selection, no remote.

Cable TV did offer premium programs also, requiring a "descrambler". Those channels were collectively called "pay TV"; separate from regular broadcast TV. These channels were satellite channels; the user could have obtained them alternatively by installing a dish, and paying for the descrambling.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by JMTQp8lwXL on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:54PM (#25152172)
YouTube will push the needle to the extent Cable did and a new platform will be born. It's the circle of technology. Then the next video platform will feel like the YouTube of ~8 years ago.

The maximally optimal value to the end user waxes and wanes throughout the business cycle, and unfortunately we're in the trough.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by Raidion on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:29PM (#25152640)
I'm honestly not sure we're in the trough. The value of Youtube is pretty tightly correlated to the amount of content on Youtube. While you could argue that the signal to noise ratio is worse, it's very hard to argue that there isn't significantly more 'good' (however you define it) content on youtube that makes it more valuable.

I find paying for Youtube premium an pretty great value, because it has some of the best content for any hobby I may be into. It doesn't have the pure depth of hard core educational content like udemy/coursera/khan has, but I'm really not able to consume that type of content enough to run out.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by majormajor on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:24PM (#25152577)
It's also key to note that had Cable NOT pushed ads as far as they had, they still would have been disrupted. It was a rational decision, since revenue today is often worth more than in the uncertain-for-so-many-reasons future.

It's part of why you can't rely on the market or competitive forces alone, if you think something is an issue of public good, you need regulation.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by neltnerb on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:36PM (#25152744)
If they didn't show ads I doubt they would have cared as much about time shifting and ad skipping would never have been relevant. Sure would have helped them avoid collapsing.

Let's not pretend they weren't incredibly hostile to watching shows you're paying for already, when you want to and without the ads you paid to avoid, even though they didn't need to even build any infrastructure for it.

Add the rest of their anti-customer policies like bundling channels and it seems clear that their campaign to get rid of all their cable customers simply succeeded.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by majormajor on Friday November 20, 2020 @07:58PM (#25166967)
And none of that would've prevented Netflix from being a more convenient option that let you watch on many more devices, etc. Especially because the early hook here for Netflix streaming wasn't "watch the stuff currently on cable" it was "watch back catalog stuff that isn't anywhere else right now." So that would still get Netflix in the door, and then once they start doing first-run content, game over in the same way. Nobody would want to buy and set up Tivos or Slingboxes and LAN setups and all just to turn their existing cable subscription into a Netflix subscription when they could just buy the streaming subscription separately.

Sure, the cable companies could've theoretically made Netflix streaming before Netflix did - and the broadcast networks kinda-sorta-tried-this with Hulu - but that had nothing to do with their ad load increasing over time. Hulu was way more convenient than watching the same shows on cable even with ads still! But to go all in on a reinvention towards streaming would've been a huge gamble even seeing the streaming train coming right at them.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by wolco2 on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:09PM (#25153149)
Those time shifting shows appear on broadcast tv across the nation in different time zones. They are not cable channels but broadcast channels appearing in cable. A tv antenia will pick them up.

The timeshifting is the tv stations defense of segmenting their ad market and protecting against local viewer loss that targets ads to markets.

If you in New York watch Denver's version two things happen. New York loses viewers. Denver gains viewers who's local ads are not relevant and those viewers not included when selling ads.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by neltnerb on Thursday November 19, 2020 @10:24PM (#25157051)
Sorry, there must be some overlapping terminology.

I mean time shifting as in what devices such as TiVo did where they would record your shows for you and allow them to play them back whenever you wanted. For some reason Cable companies really hated this idea, presumably because... ads I guess?

I think that if they simply hadn't fought against people trying to basically turn what they already provided into something more like Netflix, those tools would exist and be built with a cable package as a backend.

They provide all the shows in a datastream that they would otherwise provide via cable, let other people deal with paying for developing devices to make it easier to use, and price it more reasonably so that it can compete with a Netflix. I don't know if they'd be able to, but since they own the pipes and own the FCC it seems more likely than not. But they'd be doing a lot better than they seem to be now, they just priced themselves out of the market once networks realized that people would just download their content for free if it was too inconvenient to watch. Better a little than nothing...

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by xmprt on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:17PM (#25153228)
The way I see it, YouTube is already being disrupted by platforms like Tik Tok
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by mixmastamyk on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:23PM (#25152572)
Youtube should not be watched by kids, it even has a minimum age of 13 in the TOS. Then what?

PBS Kids FTW. No ads, no harmful content, and (probably much) less surveillance.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by psychstudio on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:58PM (#25153677)
Similarly, in Australia ABC kids (live and streaming on iView) has more content than any kid could ever consume in a lifetime.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by muro on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:07PM (#25153131)
Youtube kids does not have the age 13 requirement.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by mixmastamyk on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:25PM (#25153338)
It still has occasional inappropriate or dumb content and surveillance. Also unclear what % of parents bother with yt kids.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by beached_whale on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:57PM (#25153018)
My understanding, Linus Tech Tips did a breakdown of their revenue, is that Youtube premium subscribers get more money to the creators than ads.

With that, the day they bring adverts into Youtube Premium, is the day I stop paying for it. That would be them going the way of cable companies all in.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by lelandbatey on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:16PM (#25153215)
Indeed, I've seen revenue breakdowns from a number of content creators and each of them makes it clear that if you have YouTube premium, when you watch a single video you give the creator approximately 10x the revenue of a single free user who only sees ads.

Likewise, the day that they start putting ads into YouTube premium is the day I abandon the platform.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by zucked on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:27PM (#25151856)
Agreed.

I had Youtube Premium through Google Play Music until Google finally axed GPM. I was so disappointed by how poorly Google handled that process that I cancelled my subscription and lost my YT premium.

Youtube is completely unbearable without premium - I have no idea how non-subscribers tolerate Youtube content. The ads are so intrusive. I would totally pay $5-$10 per month for a Youtube only subscription but I feel like the $18/mo for a family plan is a bit steep.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by lstamour on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:24PM (#25152573)
FYI, YouTube Music received almost every feature of Google Play Music except the app design. An in-depth review of the two can be found over here: https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/10/24/google-play-music-t...

Personally I wish all these music streaming services could agree on metadata sharing such that I could enable apps like last.fm to review listening history across every service, and offer my listening history and playlists to every service to receive better recommendations. It feels odd that I can listen to the same song from 4-5 different services that I subscribe to legally, yet none of the services has a complete picture of what I like to listen to unless I pick one and use it as often as I can. I had thought that playlist sync would be a way to improve my recommendations, but it seems most services look at listening history rather than playlists. It's also irritating that every company has its own way of doing playback sync between devices, whether it's AirPlay, ChromeCast, Spotify Connect, Alexa, YouTube app, etc. There is no way things should be this fractured and hard to use for music playback and recommendation in the next decade, we need more standards. :)

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by Notorious_BLT on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:04PM (#25153733)
Youtube Music's handling of my uploaded music is really poor compared to GPM (sectioned off from everything else), so that alone was enough to make me dump my subscription when GPM was shut down.

Now I run my own Plex server on a Raspberry Pi with an external drive and get a better experience than I had before, minus discovery.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by jeffbee on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:32PM (#25154007)
I actually prefer the way YTM segments my uploads from the general catalog, as it gives me some possibly unfounded confidence in the idea that I'm going to be listening to the edition I expect, and not something like a 20th anniversary re-release with 15 extra tracks. GPM has this really bad problem where their treatment of my uploads was seriously broken and I would see, just as one example, multiple copies of every track on one album. I don't see this since the YTM conversion.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by benhurmarcel on Thursday November 19, 2020 @04:33PM (#25154653)
Exactly, I'd pay for Youtube Premium if it didn't come bundled with a music subscription, and the price reflected that.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by soperj on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:11PM (#25152396)
There's no good content for toddlers on youtube. Toddlers shouldn't be watching anything.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by 648d361 on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:34PM (#25153440)
I recently found this and use it to get and retain all the videos I like (not just from youtube), it's super simple which is exactly why I like it: https://github.com/tomszilagyi/copycat
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by pletsch on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:30PM (#25151903)
How is the mobile experience for YT Music? Looking at switching, I imagine they have the desktop experience down. I love Spotify, but I can't imagine a worse experience outside of their mobile app. The web player was nice but fails to load music two-three times per listening session (to be fair, they are usually 5-8hrs), the desktop application is slow, clunky, and will regularly not play music I have downloaded.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by tsycho on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:09PM (#25152355)
I hated it initially, but am fine with it now.

When YTM is better than GPM:

1/ Auto-created playlists, especially after you just search for a song and hit play. On GPM, it would play different covers on the same song (basically all the search results) by default, unless you started a radio, which is a cool concept but was hit and miss in practice. On YTM, it continues with similar songs, and I have liked their selection so far.

2/ The library seems to have increased; I guess they have access to more songs that were YT exclusive for some reason.

3/ While I normally never use video mode on YTM, but once in a while for a cool song, it's nice to be able to seamlessly switch to video and cast to my TV.

On the cons side, I don't like the playlist management and home screen UI (which is what I hated initially), but it's not bothering me much anymore now that I am getting used to it I guess.

Initially, I had planned to just cancel the subscription, but held on because using YouTube with ads was just plain intolerable. I get reminded of this everytime I open a Youtube link on my work account Chrome profile by mistake.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by lstamour on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:28PM (#25152628)
+1 on that last issue. I don't understand why Google doesn't include ad-free YouTube as part of a perk for using Google Workspace. Also I wish I could tell Chrome to open some links in other profiles at all times, and only those links, kind of like Firefox might do. Actually, come to think of it, I probably use Chrome too much and should try alternatives instead.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by pnathan on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:25PM (#25152591)
YouTube Music is so bad I shut down my use of Google for music, unplugged my Google home devices, and migrated to Alexa. Amazon Music is worse than Google Music, but better than YouTube Music.

There's a wide open market for a good music streaming company that integrates with your own albums, that is corporately stable enough not to dissipate after "An Incredible Journey Together". All the different services have weird lockins and major gaps, whether it be uploads, mobile app limitations, interop, etc.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by dublinben on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:47PM (#25153578)
Truly painful. On iOS it regularly fails to keep playing the next song in a playlist, which is pretty much unforgivable for a music app.

Here's a longer list of grievances from users who were forced to migrate from Google Play Music: https://www.reddit.com/r/googleplaymusic/comments/icmwdf/one...

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by natex on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:38PM (#25152006)
There are three deal breakers for me.

1) You can't organize Albums by artist. 2) Your Youtube (video) likes are included in the pool of liked songs in the music app. 3) Artists you are subscribed to in the music app are included in your Youtube (video) subscriptions.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by OOPMan on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:31PM (#25153989)
Vanced YouTube also gets of rid all the ads and doesn't involve giving money to Google.

Oh, and of course uBlock Origin works fine on proper computers too.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by zwkrt on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:34PM (#25151954)
I can't believe that you actually decided to be held hostage by google and pay them to remove content that they would otherwise only put in front of you if you were looking. Its like paying a restaurant not to harass you and then going to it when you could just go to the restaurant next door without the protection fee. There is also a lot of good content for toddlers IRL.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by nicpottier on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:27PM (#25152616)
> Its like paying a restaurant not to harass you and then going to it when you could just go to the restaurant next door without the protection fee.

No, it's like paying the restaurant for the damn food. YouTube hosting all the world's videos forever is not a god given right, nor is being able to watch content people create for free.

I despise ads, absolutely despise them, but gladly pay YouTube the $15/mo to remove them because I know good content needs to be paid for one way or another. There's still a few channels that I like that put in ads during the videos and that's still annoying, but otherwise I never see an ad.

And this is fucking fantastic! Imagine if the web as a whole adopted this. (I know there are efforts including Google's) If I could pay $10/mo to get rid of all ads (explicit and implicit) and have that go towards the creators that I consume content for, then we'd be in a much better place. (imagine if FB just got a cut of that for example, how that would change the dynamics)

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by zwkrt on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:33PM (#25152693)
I disagree that it is like it is paying for the food. If I had youtube premium and my entire $10 went to only the creators of the videos I watched using some egalitarian algorithm, then I would be into it. However, it is actually more like Spotify where some portion of my $10 (lets say $7, even though it is probably lower) gets put into a large pool and then distributed among all content creators on the site along with everyone else's premium money.

I have a patreon which I budget $20/mo to actually pay the creators that I care about. Don't kid yourself into thinking your YT premium money is going anywhere except unboxing videos and Minecraft screaming videos and the like.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by nicpottier on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:43PM (#25152843)
Do you have any source on how they distribute payments? All I can find is this blurb which could be read lots of different ways (likely by design):

"Currently, new revenue from YouTube Premium membership fees is distributed to video creators based on how much members watch your content. As with our advertising business, most of the revenue will go to creators."

I support some creators via Patreon as well, but honestly that's just more work for me as my interests change and some months I don't consume any of their content.

I imagine the truth is that it is likely something Spotify-like or some variation thereof. I'm still ok with that and YouTube does make it explicit that the majority of my sub goes towards creators. FWIW I suspect there are some reasons that are subtle, bug valid, that Spotify for example distributes subscription fees the way it does, which I agree does seem kinda BS at first blush.

edit: some anecdotal info here saying that creators are indeed paid (handsomly) based on views: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtube/comments/9agg5f/how_does_yo...

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by jefftk on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:37PM (#25152760)
I don't think Spotify is any different here: money goes to creators/artists in proportion to watch/listen time, no?
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by Eupolemos on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:30PM (#25152656)
> held hostage by google... Its like paying a restaurant not to harass you...

This level of entitlement is just staggering. You can pay for YouTube in two ways; watch adds or pay for add free.

Now, I get that the price for watching adds right now is too high. It simply ruins most content. But your metaphors are still just way out there.

In reality there are now 3 "tiers". - Premium. Pay with money. - Get a free taste. Choose if you want it. - Unwatchable content.

I don't think that is going to work out for YouTube in the long run. But shaming people for being willing to pay for actual loads and loads of quality content is not constructive.

On the other hand, I _am_ glad if this means that random, prudish advertising companies will hold less sway over YouTube at some point in the future, where subscriptions make up a bigger part of the revenue.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by anoncake on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:36PM (#25153455)
You can't "pay" by watching ads. Watching ads is a harmful and non-productive activity, so it's impossible to be obligated to do it.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by gumby on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:58PM (#25153678)
If you don't want to watch ads you can always do something else. There's no shortage of things to do, and YouTube need not be high on your list.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by anoncake on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:59PM (#25153690)
Of course I could, but why should I? Ad blockers work fine.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by gumby on Thursday November 19, 2020 @04:18PM (#25154480)
That’s good too: just because they sent you some bit doesn’t mean you are obligated to read (/watch/parse/etc) them.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by mox1 on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:12PM (#25152410)
I pay $15 / month for the youtube music family plan. That includes ad free youtube and ad free youtube kids.

Youtube kids (with proper video/channel whitelisting) is the main thing my toddlers watch. It has BBC shows (peppa pig), PBS kids, and 2 great kid friendly content crators (Blippi and Steve and Maggie).

Of course there is lots of good "IRL" kids content, but propery setup, Youtube kids is pretty good and fairly priced in my opinion.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by mythz on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:01PM (#25152259)
Most content is unbearable with Ads so I pay as I do every other entertainment service that I want to spend my time watching. With YouTube most of the revenue (55%) go to the creator which I'm also happy to support.

IMO it's a net positive that it has created new business models that's open to anyone with a camera/mobile.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by Cro_on on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:54PM (#25152169)
One could argue that all good content for toddlers is IRL and none of the content on yt.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by jeromenerf on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:08PM (#25152343)
Paying for content instead of being fed ads doesn’t seem unbelievable to me.

On the other hand, the method employed by YouTube is just akin to its contents. 90% BS.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by gist on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:16PM (#25152465)
> decided to be held hostage by google and pay them to remove content that they would otherwise only put in front of you if you were looking. Its like paying a restaurant not to harass you and then going to it when you could just go to the restaurant next door without the protection fee.

Unclear why the attitude. Youtube is a business. It doesn't owe users anything for free regardless of what it did in the past or others have done.

Restaurants? You pay them to dine there. They operate at a profit or try to. And restaurants who offer either (or both) better food or experience get to charge more like any other product or service in life.

Sure google or any business does not exist to provide free things to people.

Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by pnathan on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:12PM (#25152406)
Actually, it's about paying for service received. You pay by ads or you pay by wallet.
Re:YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators ... by mumblemumble on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:01PM (#25153073)
Paying a fee to disable ads is not new. I've done it so many times before, starting ages ago with Salon.com and continuing on into Patreon-supported podcasts. Why not for YouTube as well?

The best reason I can think of is becasue of this effect: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/13/156737801/the-...