News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by randmeerkat on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:31AM (#24976676)
Between this and having Covid under control, New Zealand sounds like an incredible place to live right now.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by gamegoblin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:41AM (#24976723)
One downside is their housing situation is on par with the Bay Area in a lot of places and neither of the two major political parties have committed serious resources to fixing the issue.

The only two political parties with solid proposals on this front are the Greens and TOP. TOP didn't make it into parliament in the recent election, and Labour did so well they didn't really need to give any major concessions to the Greens.

I see where the big parties are coming from -- if they increase supply so much that housing prices fall, a lot of people will be upside down on their mortgages. It's a hard problem.

See https://www.rbnz.govt.nz/research-and-publications/speeches/...

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by sellyme on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:32AM (#24976962)
> if they increase supply so much that housing prices fall, a lot of people will be upside down on their mortgages

That doesn't make the house any less suitable to live in. You're still paying exactly the same price for exactly the same house.

The only people that will hurt are those who have gotten a mortgage on a property, rented it out to someone, used that rent as leverage to get another mortgage, rented that out to, and so on, and those people are all absolute scum directly contributing to mass homelessness and a generation who can't afford their own roof to sleep under, so I have absolutely no sympathy for any of them.

Not a hugely tenable position politically, but I can't pretend to give a toss about someone who profits off of contributing absolutely nothing to society undergoing the same hardship they've caused their fellow citizens for the past several decades.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by afarviral on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:18AM (#24978210)
As someone who just bought a 65sqm Unit (semi-detached) in a poor neighborhood near a city for half a million (first home) I'd be happy to see house prices drop... it will screw us in terms of a return on the investment but I can see past my greed. I feel tremendously privileged to be where I'm at and it shouldnt be such a privilege; your average income earner deserves this and better.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by WalterBright on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:47AM (#24978365)
Since those homes are rented out, how does that contribute to homelessness? Whether the owners live in them or renters, they are occupied.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by indigochill on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:11AM (#24978521)
Probably because when someone takes out a mortgage and then rents the property, it's with the expectation that the rent will offset the mortgage. Therefore the rent costs more than it actually costs to live there as an owner because of the landlord's markup. Meaning fewer people can afford to live there.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by edogg on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @10:33AM (#24980523)
The cost of the property reflects the value of the rents, the cost of financing, property taxes and maintenance. Rents are probably not that out of wack with the landlords costs. If the landlords revenue does exceed costs you could see it as either money the landlord needs to save for future major repairs like new roof, new appliances, payment for their labour, return on the down payment invested, etc. if you can’t beat them join them and if you can’t join them then maybe it isn’t quite so easy and cut and dry.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by WalterBright on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:13PM (#24982888)
But yet the same number of people are housed.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by sellyme on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:31PM (#24984778)
Because they're opposing the building of new cheap housing as it will decrease the value of their investment.

Additionally, artificially raising the price in this way will increase the amount of time for which the property is not occupied, but that's a relatively minor effect in comparison to the above.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:06AM (#24977175)
property rights is the basis of capitalism. the whole machine hums because there is an exchange of property, goods, services and money in a free market.

housing property is an immovable illiquid asset. it is not only an asset but it is also a speculative asset.

unaffordable property prices often benefit the governments more than property owners because its one way to extract hefty property taxes. so the only way to balance interest rates is to keep inflating the value of the homes. its like a ponzi scheme.

this usually happens where social programs are disproportionately shouldered by a narrow slice of productive earners vs a broader section of people who are benefit more from social programs than contributing to it..aka negative tax. imagine it like an inverted triangle/pyramid.

however, the solution to affordable housing is to build more affordable rental units. not create more home owners. if people can only buy the cheapest properties, how will they maintain it, pay interest on mortgage and pay property taxes? they are better off renting. why govts tries to create more home owners is the reason i mentioned above. to generate more property taxes.

the people who suffer most are the bottom most in the socio economic scale. home ownership is not for everyone. the saddest part is that they have them convinced that its a form of credit line and that ends up making it an even more potent speculative asset. throw in foreign investments in residential speculative housing market, it overheats. which will only make housing even more unaffordable. its a vicious cycle.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by gnat on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:11PM (#24982875)
Speculation is a choice, not a necessity. Investors make that choice, knowing that governments will choose whether or not to support it.

Your economic reductionism is blind to political realities: a government that implements unpopular policies will most likely be voted out. Governments don't just create more home owners to generate more property taxes, they create more home owners when enough voters want to become home owners.

You say "home ownership is not for everyone" as though that blesses the status quo as some kind of natural permanent state. Home ownership is for those who can afford it. A reduction in prices (lower construction costs, greater supply, etc.) increases home affordability, which increases home ownership. Yes, it may never be for everyone, but equally it can be for more people.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:00PM (#24984509)
Pension funds speculate on Wall Street. It’s all connected.

I am just saying that ..at least in the Bay Area..there is an incentive for the govt to keep home prices high.

Increase in home ownership doesn’t address affordable housing. It only addresses more tax collection and it also increases debt.

People can be housed if there are rental units. And yet that never happens in the Bay Area. Just talking about my zip code. And it seems to me that it’s by design.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by dzhiurgis on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @08:29AM (#24979424)
> build more affordable rental units

Try saying that to r/NZ

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:44PM (#24981936)
I feel the govt should build market rate affordable homes. Singapore does this. Germany doesn’t have an affordable housing issue. Most people rent.

My mother worked along with slum clearance board to build homes for low, middle and high income families by creating new townships. There are plenty of success stories.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:56PM (#24983338)
In SF Bay Area, we have spent over 350 million dollars in just one year providing ‘outreach’ to homeless people. That’s just for one year. The money would have been well spent creating employment, building rehab, mental health facilities and groups homes/homes for the unhoused.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by nullsense on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:48AM (#24976759)
It's basically last chance to get into the property market before that train well and truly leaves the station.

The crazy thing is my mortgage is cheaper than the rent I used to pay, so now I'm building equity and can get further ahead, yet ironically those who can't get a loan to buy a home can't save their way there either because the rent is too expensive and there's nothing left. I can sense it's becoming quite a bit trickier for those at the bottom end of society.

Still a fantastic place to live, but housing is likely to follow the same trend as other major desirable urban areas. It's basically regression to the mean.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by WalterBright on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:51AM (#24978391)
> The crazy thing is my mortgage is cheaper than the rent I used to pay,

That's the normal state of affairs. When you buy something to rent out, there's no profit unless the rent is higher than the time value of the money.

There's nothing inherently wrong with renting rather than owning. Fiscally it doesn't make sense to buy a home unless you plan on living in that location at least 3 years, and probably more. Heck, just selling the house will cost you 6%. Having the house sit empty between renters costs a fortune.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by mkingston on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:43PM (#24981923)
Yes, that is definitely how it should be. Unfortunately the normal state of affairs is not the state of affairs in much of suburban New Zealand. I left Auckland eight years ago, and at the time rent was cheaper than mortgage payments with a ~20% deposit. The housing market is speculative, profits are on capital gains, which until recently were untaxed on land, and still "enjoy" exemptions. I understand for example, that if one holds a property for more than five years, it becomes exempt from capital gains tax. This seems far too easy a loophole to exploit. I suspect, although I'm not certain these days, that there is also a considerable supply problem driven in part by (1) the Christchurch earthquakes (2) a subsequent reassessment of building safety in Wellington resulting in many buildings being deemed unsafe and consequently closed (3) zoning policies.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by WalterBright on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:12PM (#24982881)
Real estate is not guaranteed to always rise, as I've lost a lot of money doing that. Also, most people don't seem to figure in the cost of owning property when they calculate their gains, for example, omitting the 6% commission when you sell.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by mkingston on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:41PM (#24983181)
I agree that investment in an already very overvalued property market is unwise (except perhaps as part of a diversified strategy..?). Unfortunately, the capital gains tax status of real estate in NZ, and the leverage on your deposit (the bank charges 5% interest, you make 30% gains) and fast-rising real estate prices made and still makes it favorable to pay the 6%, rather than investing in the stock market, for example. This further inflates real estate prices as a speculative asset until you end up in a dangerous bubble that is difficult to escape from.

In a sane system, this wouldn't be the case. It's a problem the NZ government has repeatedly failed to solve, presumably because it would be politically risky. Instead it appears we've chosen by inaction to continue the course toward a real estate collapse. I guess perhaps then we'll learn hard lessons about diversification and tail risk..

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by dzhiurgis on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @08:10AM (#24979279)
> crazy thing is my mortgage is cheaper than the rent I used to pay

How is that possible. Did you relocate or downsized? My impression of Auckland was it's 30-50% cheaper to rent. Maybe with new rates it's on par.

Last I checked house in North Shore rents for $700 while valued at some $1.3M - at current rates thats ~$1100 a week for mortgage.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by nullsense on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @08:24AM (#24979390)
We actually moved to a bigger house when we bought, but different suburb.

Depends on how much you borrow I suppose. Our loan was smaller than typical most probably, so we wind up paying about 30% less. But we were renting for $2k a month just 2 bedroom place. Would have been millions to buy that place too. Just getting to the point it's stupid.

I don't really know how we did it but we managed to get a decent place for under 700k, but average price is now about 1.1 million or something crazy. My sister has been looking and for what they want it's all north of 900k and incredibly competitive. So, I'd imagine the loan on that would be quite a bit more, and 30% more expensive month to month might be realistic depending on your situation.

At one point we were on a single income when I was just starting my career and paying that high rent with a new born baby in the house. It was tough. I can't imagine what it's like in single income households with multiple kids. The math just doesn't check out.

It's definitely a great place to live if you can afford it though. Insulated from a lot of the worlds bullshit.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by abhinav22 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:32AM (#24976959)
Wow! My escape plan was to leave Sydney and chill out in NZ with a remote job, looks like it’s getting on par with Australian cities? Makes sense
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by postingawayonhn on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:06AM (#24977180)
Outside of Auckland, Wellington, and Queenstown it's not too bad.

NZ's population is also a lot more evenly distributed than most Australian states. NSW has 4 urban areas with over 100,000 people while NZ has 7 despite a smaller population.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_New_Zealand_urban_ar...

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by abhinav22 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @08:36AM (#24979498)
Yep agree. Queenstown is gorgeous though! But that tourist premium will apply. Maybe one of those towns near Queenstown I should consider..
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by gnat on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:19PM (#24982943)
If you're used to Australia, almost anywhere in NZ will offer beautiful surroundings. And, thanks to the broadband rollout, most towns have fibre and those without fibre have cellular that's fast enough for most things.

I look out over a harbour, about 75m from Auckland. Microwave gets me Internet access. Life is good.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by ezzaf on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:07AM (#24977190)
Is it really comparable with the bay area? A quick scan suggests that the most expensive city in NZ (Auckland) sits at around NZ$1 million. Compare that to US$1.3 million for San Francisco. The rest of NZ is substantially cheaper, the second city Wellington for example is NZ$0.7 million.

Median wages appear to be about NZ$50k (all NZ) vs US$75k (San Fran). So on both absolute price and price vs income, only Auckland appears to be in the same ballpark as San Francisco.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by lostlogin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:00AM (#24977799)
Keep in mind that NZ 50k is US 25K and that an NZ$1 million house will be very small or very far outside the centre. I don’t doubt that SF is more expensive, but it is bad in Auckland.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by postingawayonhn on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:07AM (#24977188)
For readers outside NZ it should be noted that TOP has never been in parliament.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by amacneil on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:07AM (#24977839)
Citation needed. It's completely hyperbolic to compare the housing situatation anywhere in NZ to the Bay Area.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by mkingston on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:48PM (#24981978)
Well, to call it completely hyperbolic without apparently looking for data yourself seems overstepping. Although perhaps this is a ploy to get the internet to do your research for you. In which case, well done.

Choose house prices against income at the bottom of the graph.

https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2019/03/11/global-c...

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by xupybd on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:20AM (#24977923)
I don't know about the bay area but Auckland is pretty bad. The average house price is over 9 times the average yearly household income. Auckland's incomes being higher than the rest of the country.

https://i.stuff.co.nz/business/110049950/auckland-ranked-amo...

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by primitivesuave on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:09AM (#24977197)
I was in NZ when the COVID crisis started. My flight home got canceled and a 3 week vacation turned into a couple months. The natural beauty was stunning and I got do a lot more canyoning/climbing than originally expected. Added to that was watching first-hand how Jacinda Ardern communicated with her country and a society that enforced strict social distancing. I got to travel around for a bit and never wore a mask once throughout the entire thing until I returned to the US.

And I saw many peacocks!

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by kenneth on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:54AM (#24977421)
Did you miss the absolutely brutal lockdown they imposed on everyone? I am staying far away from all countries that treated their citizen like prisoners until the pandemic is over — and I have forever lost respect for quite a few countries due to this.

I had the misfortune of getting stuck in Singapore on a 3-day business trip when things got locked down, and it turned into a 4 month miserable ordeal of house arrest and quarantines before I was able to make it back to my much more reasonable home of Hong Kong. Truly, from the bottom of my heart, fuck Singapore's lockdown.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by perilunar on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @03:33AM (#24977642)
> I am staying far away from all countries that treated their citizen like prisoners until the pandemic is over

Good — you're probably not welcome there anyway. The countries that did lockdowns and quarantine properly are the ones that have best controlled the pandemic.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by primitivesuave on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:46PM (#24981960)
I was there for the lockdown - it wasn’t that brutal. They publicly released the guidelines that police were using to deescalate and educate people on why they should go home. This is not to minimize what you are saying, as you are absolutely right that some regimes imposed some truly draconian policies.

This comment definitely should not have been downvoted. I am sorry you had to go through such an ordeal, and am sure you would have found NZ far more preferable.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by afarviral on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @05:31AM (#24978280)
It just wasnt like that. It was a logical step the majority of citizens gladly took to get to this comfy level we're at... balancing lockdowns and social/economic needs is a tremendous challenge. I dont know a single person who felt put-upon by the lockdowns, but I appreciate that there are people at the fringes who appose any and all restrictions like those of "lockdowns" but I'd pay that price again for this period of relative normality we get as a reward. Conspiratorial freedom-fighters... thanks for your service in guaranteeing that more lockdowns and disruptions are required.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by philliphaydon on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:28AM (#24977956)
As someone who lives in Singapore. The only 3 countries I would want to be in: Singapore, Taiwan, New Zealand.

Singapore's lockdown was fine. I feel safe with my family here in Singapore.

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by lostlogin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @04:02AM (#24977815)
Non residents can’t visit sorry.

I know I’d choose an NZ lockdown over a Chinese one. Why do you think a lockdown in China would be less restrictive?

Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks by joejerryronnie on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:16AM (#24980943)
A co-worker’s parents were visiting her in the Bay Area from their home in Vietnam. They planned to stay for a couple months to help with their new grandchild. Then covid hit and Vietnam locked down. They’re hoping to get home by Christmas.