Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks
by mkingston on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:43PM
(#24981923)
Yes, that is definitely how it should be. Unfortunately the normal state of affairs is not the state of affairs in much of suburban New Zealand. I left Auckland eight years ago, and at the time rent was cheaper than mortgage payments with a ~20% deposit. The housing market is speculative, profits are on capital gains, which until recently were untaxed on land, and still "enjoy" exemptions. I understand for example, that if one holds a property for more than five years, it becomes exempt from capital gains tax. This seems far too easy a loophole to exploit. I suspect, although I'm not certain these days, that there is also a considerable supply problem driven in part by (1) the Christchurch earthquakes (2) a subsequent reassessment of building safety in Wellington resulting in many buildings being deemed unsafe and consequently closed (3) zoning policies.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks
by WalterBright on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:12PM
(#24982881)
Real estate is not guaranteed to always rise, as I've lost a lot of money doing that. Also, most people don't seem to figure in the cost of owning property when they calculate their gains, for example, omitting the 6% commission when you sell.
Re:New Zealand struggles with plague of peacocks
by mkingston on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @02:41PM
(#24983181)
I agree that investment in an already very overvalued property market is unwise (except perhaps as part of a diversified strategy..?). Unfortunately, the capital gains tax status of real estate in NZ, and the leverage on your deposit (the bank charges 5% interest, you make 30% gains) and fast-rising real estate prices made and still makes it favorable to pay the 6%, rather than investing in the stock market, for example. This further inflates real estate prices as a speculative asset until you end up in a dangerous bubble that is difficult to escape from.
In a sane system, this wouldn't be the case. It's a problem the NZ government has repeatedly failed to solve, presumably because it would be politically risky. Instead it appears we've chosen by inaction to continue the course toward a real estate collapse. I guess perhaps then we'll learn hard lessons about diversification and tail risk..