That's the normal state of affairs. When you buy something to rent out, there's no profit unless the rent is higher than the time value of the money.
There's nothing inherently wrong with renting rather than owning. Fiscally it doesn't make sense to buy a home unless you plan on living in that location at least 3 years, and probably more. Heck, just selling the house will cost you 6%. Having the house sit empty between renters costs a fortune.
In a sane system, this wouldn't be the case. It's a problem the NZ government has repeatedly failed to solve, presumably because it would be politically risky. Instead it appears we've chosen by inaction to continue the course toward a real estate collapse. I guess perhaps then we'll learn hard lessons about diversification and tail risk..
How is that possible. Did you relocate or downsized? My impression of Auckland was it's 30-50% cheaper to rent. Maybe with new rates it's on par.
Last I checked house in North Shore rents for $700 while valued at some $1.3M - at current rates thats ~$1100 a week for mortgage.
Depends on how much you borrow I suppose. Our loan was smaller than typical most probably, so we wind up paying about 30% less. But we were renting for $2k a month just 2 bedroom place. Would have been millions to buy that place too. Just getting to the point it's stupid.
I don't really know how we did it but we managed to get a decent place for under 700k, but average price is now about 1.1 million or something crazy. My sister has been looking and for what they want it's all north of 900k and incredibly competitive. So, I'd imagine the loan on that would be quite a bit more, and 30% more expensive month to month might be realistic depending on your situation.
At one point we were on a single income when I was just starting my career and paying that high rent with a new born baby in the house. It was tough. I can't imagine what it's like in single income households with multiple kids. The math just doesn't check out.
It's definitely a great place to live if you can afford it though. Insulated from a lot of the worlds bullshit.
NZ's population is also a lot more evenly distributed than most Australian states. NSW has 4 urban areas with over 100,000 people while NZ has 7 despite a smaller population.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_New_Zealand_urban_ar...
I look out over a harbour, about 75m from Auckland. Microwave gets me Internet access. Life is good.
The crazy thing is my mortgage is cheaper than the rent I used to pay, so now I'm building equity and can get further ahead, yet ironically those who can't get a loan to buy a home can't save their way there either because the rent is too expensive and there's nothing left. I can sense it's becoming quite a bit trickier for those at the bottom end of society.
Still a fantastic place to live, but housing is likely to follow the same trend as other major desirable urban areas. It's basically regression to the mean.