News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by strawberrypuree on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:44PM (#24933972)
>The company also argued shoppers were made aware of the activity through decals it had placed on shopping mall entry doors that referred to Cadillac Fairview's privacy policy.

Do what now? Physical spaces have privacy policies? We're really sleepwalking into a dystopia. If you don't like the privacy policy of your shopping mall, you're free to shop... online, where they get even more behavioral data on you. Yikes.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by lhorie on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:05PM (#24934263)
> shoppers were made aware of the activity through decals

Indeed there's a huge glaring problem here: many of these malls have branded entrances (Shoppers Drug Mart, Best Buy, etc) through which a large portion of consumers walk into the mall, and these alleged decals are not present in those entrances. Here's an example [1]. Frankly I don't see said decals even in the non-branded entrances[2]

They're going to have a very hard time convincing the commissioner that people were in fact aware of these decals AND any "privay policy" therein. A simple survey would easily show that people are completely clueless about it (anecdote: I used to frequent CF malls quite a bit when I was in Toronto and never saw anything of the sort, even despite being the type of person that might actually read random stuff posted at entrances).

[1] https://www.google.com/maps/@43.7788812,-79.3447734,3a,75y,1...

[2] https://www.google.com/maps/@43.7789409,-79.3444783,3a,75y,1...

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by black_puppydog on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:41PM (#24936973)
Sorry but if you're taking their argument at face value that decals might be the way to go here and everything would be fine if only they were there, then they've basically won.

Don't get side tracked.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by lhorie on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:09PM (#24937185)
My take is that the claim that "shoppers were made aware of the activity through decals" fails on multiple levels: whether said decals were actually there, whether they would be capable of capturing nuances of scope if they were (e.g. there's different expectations between a mall entrance, the Shoppers entrance and the LCBO entrance), whether people noticed the alleged decals if they were there, whether they could be reasonably expect to understand it (e.g. non-english speakers), whether people could infer that legalese existed if they did understand it, whether they were capable of understanding the actual terms (e.g. tech illiterates), whether it is reasonable to expect that people would consciously agree to whatever terms are laid out in the legalese, whether all people captured by face recognition necessarily were actually aware of the terms, etc. It just doesn't stick on so many levels.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by mynegation on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:54PM (#24937531)
For non-Canadians here: Shoppers is pharmacies and LCBO is provincially-controlled liquor store that has near monopoly on hard liquor sales.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by koolba on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:09PM (#24937645)
“Near monopoly”? Outside of duty free, where else can you buy booze (not beer) besides the LCBO?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by mynegation on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:45PM (#24937910)
You can buy hard liquor in artisanal distilleries like Spirit of York or few in Niagara region. And talking about “not beer”, wine has been available in grocery stores for a while now.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by buildbot on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:06AM (#24939345)
Doesn’t this vary by province? BC has quite a few non- bc liquor stores, at least in Vancouver.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by shadowprofile77 on Friday October 30, 2020 @09:49AM (#24942138)
Every single one of those private liquor stores buys its stock through the BC Liquor Distribution Branch of British Columbia, so yes, the monopoly is still very much there, just hidden behind a few facades. I suspect something similar is the case in other provinces too.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by kortilla on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:20PM (#24937743)
A bar
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by buran77 on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:40AM (#24941599)
Any consent that isn't explicit should have no legal value. A "decal" on a door is about as useful as a size 2 font fine print, or an audio disclaimer played back at 5 times the speed.

This implicit agreement can be used to obtain quite literally anything without the other party ever knowing.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by black_puppydog on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:15PM (#24937229)
In that case I think we're in agreement. :)
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by smitty1110 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:34PM (#24937832)
Disclaimer: IANAL, caveat lector.

Taking the argument at face value is probably not the right conclusion [1]. The linked court case establishes what we would call in American law Informed Consent. If you can't read disclaimer at the door until you are in camera range, is that really informed consent? And if the disclaimer does not actually list the policy in question, but refers you to a website to read it, can it be considered sufficient? A quote from the ruling is relevant here - "The more onerous the exclusion clause the more explicit the notice must be". Now, this case was related to legal liabilities related to injury in a ski resort, but it's the closet thing I've found. I suspect a judge won't take long to rule in favor of the plaintiff.

[1] - https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcca/doc/2020/2020bcca78/2020bc...

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by zapdrive on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#24934574)
The decals might be installed on the inside doors that lead from shoppers drug Mart to the the mall.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by gruez on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:07PM (#24934291)
The streetview images are dated may 2019, but the article says

>CF suspended its use of cameras back in 2018 [...]

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by amelius on Friday October 30, 2020 @07:00AM (#24941014)
Even if there were large signs, people would just not care.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by vel0city on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:03PM (#24934240)
In Canada, do you even really have a right to privacy when in public spaces like a shopping mall? Is there even a legal expectation that there aren't cameras doing this kind of thing all the time? In most places in the US I know there isn't a right to privacy within a public space. If I as a shop owner put up security cameras in this same fashion in most of the US this wouldn't be against the law. There's no law preventing me from putting up cameras all along my home looking out into the street doing the same.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by dblohm7 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:15PM (#24936752)
> In Canada, do you even really have a right to privacy when in public spaces like a shopping mall?

Yes, you do, because while a shopping mall might be considered a "public space," it is private property owned by a private organization. In Canada the PIPEDA [1] covers this federally, though the law is written such that it is a backstop, and provinces are free to enact their own "substantially similar" (or stricter) laws if they choose. For example, in Alberta the PIPA [2] covers these issues.

And as the article states, both federal and provincial privacy commissioners found CF in violation of those laws.

[1] https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/privacy-topics/privacy-laws-in-can...

[2] https://www.alberta.ca/personal-information-protection-act-o...

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by vel0city on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:53PM (#24937963)
Personal information under these laws are defined as:

    age, name, ID numbers, income, ethnic origin, or blood type;
    opinions, evaluations, comments, social status, or disciplinary actions; and
    employee files, credit records, loan records, medical records, existence of a dispute between a consumer and a merchant, intentions (for example, to acquire goods or services, or change jobs).
How does video of people passing by meet such a definition?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by jellicle on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:27AM (#24941512)
Just to be clear (because the article isn't), what CF did was install a bunch of computerized kiosks to replace the information map kiosks, then when anyone used those kiosks (peering at screen from 2 feet away, tapping at it), a hidden camera (no external indication that there's a camera behind the black glass screen) recorded their face and what store they were looking for. This was intentional to collect and store info about individual mall users.

It wasn't some security camera overlooking the concourse from 30 feet up or anything like that.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by hibbelig on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:58AM (#24939579)
They stopped a representation that allowed them to identify that the same person visited again. That’s an id number. They guessed age and gender.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by YetAnotherNick on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:47AM (#24940340)
By ID, gp likely means government id, not identification by face. I can recognise my neighbours, but that doesn't mean I have their personal information.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by hibbelig on Friday October 30, 2020 @11:23AM (#24943199)
In Europe, data that can be used to identify a person is also protected. For example, IP address plus timestamp is protected. Because you could obtain customer information from the ISP.

That's how I understand things.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by 0xCMP on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:52PM (#24938276)
The intent to buy things in the mall (or not) for one
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by nitrogen on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:17PM (#24938776)
Age and (to a limited extent) ethnic origin can also be inferred from video. So can income and social status, via apparel, posture, etc.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by 8note on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#24934479)
A lack of a law preventing it doesn't make it good though. We can add new laws and regulations
[dead]
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by gdulli on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:46PM (#24934794)
What the fuck? Your position is that there's something virtuous about exchanging currency for goods as long as you can do it from home, but leaving your house to do it in person is substantively different at all, let alone worthy of disdain?

Are you so hopelessly tribal that it doesn't even take a political ideology difference to dehumanize people on a different side? It just naturally hits you that someone with different shopping habits is some kind of intolerable other?

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by dylan604 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:17PM (#24936770)
Not defending the GP, but we do have websites like peopleofwalmart. If they were coming out with peopleofcanadianmalls, then that be interesting. Honestly, I'd expect peopleofWhatevermalls would mainly be teenagers and senior citizens outside of holiday season shoppers.

edit: came to the party late and see that someone else also posted about peopleofwalmart

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by ada1981 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:53PM (#24934910)
Oh I find online shopping even worse tbh.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by p1necone on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:05PM (#24937161)
So uhh, did you build the computer you used to post this comment from first principles? Do you grow all your own food from scratch? I'm not really sure where you're coming from with this disdain for people participating in the economy.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by ada1981 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:25PM (#24937773)
I love this comment.

I think every so often I get the urge to make a comment that ultimate burns off a few Karma points.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by read_if_gay_ on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:42PM (#24936360)
And what’s your opinion on superiority complexes?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by HeWhoLurksLate on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:59PM (#24937118)
They're the worst
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by tacLog on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#24934572)
What kind of question is this? Are you intending to imply that some people are less deserving of privacy purely based on if they shop at malls?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by ada1981 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:36PM (#24934661)
More a sarcastic expression of my disdain for the North American Shopping Mall and those who call her home.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by ficklepickle on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:21PM (#24935272)
Fair enough. Rampant consumerism is a threat to our survival as a species. I personally find it revolting.

How people can derive pleasure buying low-quality clothes and widgets made by people in horrible conditions is beyond me. Never mind the impact on our environment.

I have a lot of compassion for addicts. I used to be an opiate addict. It's all the same phenomenon; trying to fill an internal void with something external.

I suspect that the majority here, however, do not feel the same way. I've seen too many posts where folks describe their love of amazon with a fervour best described as religious.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by nogabebop23 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:10PM (#24935951)
You'd think as a former opiate addict you might have a little more understanding and less emotionally negative response to something as mundane as shopping. If you feel this way about people who got to malls, how should I feel about junkies shooting up in my alley?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by bbarnett on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:41PM (#24937888)
I don't even get any part of this conversation.

A person needs a pair of pants. Maybe, they don't want to use Amazon, or online services. They go to a store. It's in a mall.

Now, they're idiots for some inane, bizarre, incomprehensible reason. Even the "cheap clothes" they use to keep themselves safe from the elements are worse, than the "cheap clothes" bought elsewhere, like from Amazon?!

What a weird thread.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by eznzt on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:52PM (#24934896)
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by ada1981 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:54PM (#24934924)
Ooo this is very important!
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by BigBubbleButt on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:25PM (#24934548)
Are you saying we shouldn't protect consumers?
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by mynegation on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:59PM (#24937581)
It is one thing to have cameras for security and store records for a limited amount of time for police investigation and what not. But applying facial recognition, biometric analysis, and storing it indefinitely is whole another ballgame.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by voisin on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:47PM (#24934014)
It’s crazy that their lawyers think that merely referring to a privacy policy via a decal on the door is adequate acceptance of this kind of intrusion. I thought the laws required explicit acceptance online, via a check box on sign up, along with emailed updates when the policy changes. Merely walking through a door cannot possibly be construed to be explicit acceptance.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by gravitas on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:17PM (#24934438)
> It’s crazy that their lawyers think that merely referring to a privacy policy via a decal on the door is adequate acceptance of this kind of intrusion

Very abstractly, legal precedent exists for the general implementation. Texas has what's called "the 30.07 sign" codified in the penal code (30.06 concealed, 30.07 open carry)[1] which prohibits firearm carry on that property with nothing more than a proper/legal sign. The responsibility lies on the entrant to notice and comply with the sign prior to entering the establishment, no explicit acknowledgement is required by that place of business for it to be enforced.

(not saying I agree with what's going on here, only that I can see lawyers using laws like this to support the action in the face of no laws saying it can't be done like this - a judge may throw the argument out, but it could be made as a good faith argument? My mind is thinking about how in the 90s "shrink wrap acceptance" was just a given - you opened he box so you accepted the license, but in 2020 many new laws have been developed to curtail that design and now require explicit acceptance by the end-user.)

[1] https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/PE/htm/PE.30.htm

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by texasbigdata on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:29PM (#24936159)
Interesting example.

Not super familiar but that’s a licensed activity right? As in there’s some training and/or test administered upon gun purchase? Sorry if that’s not the case. But that feels marginally different because if you had a handgun and you knew this door sign governed whether or not you could bring it into a premise, you would look out for it.

No one is staring at the door of the drug store, because we are not trained to do that.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by msla on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:09PM (#24937187)
Yes, it's licensed. There's a class and a proficiency demonstration:

https://onlinetexasltc.com/texas-concealed-carry/

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by gruez on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:02PM (#24934224)
Not sure about the privacy laws in Canada, but are there any laws against video recording and/or facial recognition? AFAIK by default they're fair game because there's no expectation of privacy while in public.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by scotty79 on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:59AM (#24940396)
I don't see it any more crazy than that you can legally agree to something by clicking.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by gnrlbzik on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:54PM (#24934114)
indeed, I almost fell off my chair : ) If we do not read it in comfort of our home, why would one do so walking into the mall.... and there is not even a precedent to do so....
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by reaperducer on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:39PM (#24936307)
Physical spaces have privacy policies?

I've seen TOSes on mall doors before. They've been white letters on clear glass at just about foot level written in letters about 1cm tall. They were usually about violence and guns and shoplifting being grounds to ejection and banning.

The only people who ever see them is the decal printing company, the guy who installs them, and mice.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by WWLink on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:29PM (#24937797)
A lot of malls I've been in have a "terms of conduct" sign near the entrance when you walk in. Similarly bizarre are the signs at the parking lot entrance that act similarly.

I'll take that one further! Every street that enters the city I live in, has a sign with text that you'll only be able to read if you park your car, get out, and walk up to it. I've lived here 5 years and I still don't know what the heck those signs say lol. My guess is it's something about parking enforcement? Sigh. It's completely absurd lol.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by sellyme on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:45PM (#24938597)
The ones here all say "No Roller-blading", which should be a good indicator as to how relevant they are.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by kevin_thibedeau on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:22AM (#24939418)
The best defense against hackers.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by qppo on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:41PM (#24934729)
When I was in college Fortinet pitched a capstone project for an automated doorman that tracked passersby, delivery people, residents, etc using cameras posted at doors.

We asked why they couldn't use other biometrics which were much more established at the time (eg fingerprint scanners at the doorway), they said because other biometrics required consent. They wanted to track people without their knowing or agreement.

When asked about the ethics they said something along the lines of "this is what our customers are asking for."

Point being you don't need a privacy policy when you don't have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the first place. They can take pictures of you, store them in a database, sell them if they want. You don't have a right to be forgotten. And there are people that don't see anything wrong with that.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by donmcronald on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:27PM (#24936858)
The tech capabilities have changed so much that I'd say it's closer to being surveilled than observed in a public place. Compare it to security cameras where you're recorded almost everywhere, but the video is relatively transient and often only reviewed / saved if a crime or disturbance occurs.

That's a lot different than companies tracking me via facial recognition, storing the data in databases that never get deleted, and combining it with behavioral data. It's going to lead to all kind of abuse. We'll end up with many variants of redlining, but digital.

What happens when that type of data is collected for today's youth and 20 years from now employers start using it to screen job applicants? What if the machine learning algorithms can't distinguish between correlation and causality? Does the "profile" of a successful person become someone from a rich neighborhood as a result of naive correlation?

I'm sure it'll be amazing for wealthy people and terrible for poor people. If I'm rich and walk into a mall, I get treated like a VIP. If I'm poor, maybe the doors don't even open.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by rz2k on Thursday October 29, 2020 @04:25PM (#24935306)
About five years ago there was a decal on the glass beside the entrance to the Stanford Shopping Center Neiman Marcus notifying customers that they were tracked by their phones.

I wonder if they stopped in response to complaints, or decided the notification was unnecessary. At the time, I figured their system judged me for browsing $800 jeans and not making a purchase.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by OzzyB on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:57PM (#24934165)
Hey, if you don't like what your local shopping mall is doing, build your own!
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by dave5104 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:59PM (#24934191)
Or even better, stop patronizing it and contribute to its crumbling real estate value.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by monkeybutton on Thursday October 29, 2020 @03:21PM (#24934490)
Though, the more malls decline, the more they will behave like this. Optimizing and squeezing more out of their shrinking value.
Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by a_imho on Friday October 30, 2020 @06:37AM (#24940891)
We're really sleepwalking into a dystopia.

Maybe some, but most people are aware. They have very little to zero power to fight back the abuse.

Re:Mall real estate company collected 5M images of shoppers by xwdv on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:58PM (#24937994)
I have a privacy policy for people entering my dwelling or using my guest wifi.