News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by caseyscottmckay on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:04PM (#24652508)
We need more of this. A criminal record in the US is a curse for life, leaving former criminals with little chance at success and little to live for. People without much to live for are dangerous. We should help our former criminals rather than condemn them for life--it benefits us all.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dfxm12 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:00PM (#24653351)
leaving former criminals with little chance at success

It's worth noting that it also leaves their children a smaller chance at success as well[0], and then the cycle continues. When you add this to the fact that Black male offenders received sentences on average 19.1 percent longer than similarly situated White male offenders [1], this adds up to one aspect of systemic racism in America.

0 - https://projects.sfchronicle.com/2016/captive-lives/

1 - https://www.ussc.gov/research/research-reports/demographic-d...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by NoImmatureAdHom on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:25PM (#24654418)
It's important to note that [1] seems to refer to federal sentencing, and almost all criminal law in the U.S. is state law. [1] is a small subset of what's going on, and it can't be used to generalize.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by whack on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:52PM (#24654750)
Election polls are a tiny subset of the general public, but they do offer very powerful insights into wider trends.

Is there any reason to believe that Federal judges are more racially biased compared to State judges? I'd be shocked if State judges as a group are more color-blind than Federal judges.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by NoImmatureAdHom on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:21PM (#24666112)
Election polls are designed to do exactly that, whereas this sample isn't anything even approaching a random subset that could be used for inference about the whole population.

It may be the case that in state courtrooms judges are the same, worse, or better, but making that inference on the basis of federal-level data is probably unjustified.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by shadowfox on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:58PM (#24654832)
Not the OP, but it is interesting that the US criminal law is so state dependent. Out of curiosity: do you have reason to believe that the sentencing disparity is better when considering states?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by samatman on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:19PM (#24655128)
I have reason to believe that the sentencing disparity is like the gender pay gap: easy to prove, if that helps your political goals, and also easy to disprove, if that suits you better.

Statistics is hard, and the entire reason there's leeway in sentencing is to account for situations which are resistant to statistical regularity.

There is, or was, a pretty obvious source of disparity in US law: freebase cocaine was a felony at much smaller quantities than cocaine salt, and the former was more likely to be used and dealt by black Americans.

Would that show up in such an analysis? They were different convictions, after all. So the only answer can be "yes or no", and so on ad infinitum.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sokoloff on Thursday October 01, 2020 @04:04PM (#24655595)
I'm fairly convinced that the fact that marijuana is illegal (federally) and alcohol/tobacco are legal without a prescription has more to do with the populations who typically used them than with any medical or scientific basis on dangerousness.

https://www.businessinsider.com/racist-origins-marijuana-pro...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by samatman on Thursday October 01, 2020 @04:45PM (#24655989)
Sure, and that's another thing that wouldn't show up in statistics directly.

Although it's important to note that alcohol was illegal, and tobacco is becoming increasingly low-status and accordingly restricted.

The end of Prohibition meant that the enforcement apparatus for it needed something new to do. I believe this was another contributing factor to continuing the broken logic of Prohibition with new substances.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by 737maxtw on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:41PM (#24656423)
That's... actually pretty interesting concept to consider.

Sometimes I do wonder how much better we could all get along if some substances had relaxed or dropped restrictions.

When you think about it, there's the mental toll on users about public disapproval amplified by the legal status. On top of that, the divide on the non user side about someone being a "lawbreaker".

Just seems to cause a lot of division. On top of the illegality of harder drugs leading to the rise of cartels and gangs.

Just thinking out loud. What if the US said 'screw it', try making everything legal for 5-10 years, produce what it can locally, and just see what happens. The hope with this idea is that one could starve out the cartels while perhaps providing a path to rehabilitation.

All of that said, I am still a believer in the Rat Park experiment. If we solved some of our more real problems people perhaps wouldn't need to turn to such substances, as examples by the reports of drug use increasing under lockdown conditions. Reality seems to match the experiment. The thing about that experiment, they found if the rat's other needs were met (food, shelter, socialization) they actually would start to prefer normal water to drugged water again.

Hmmmmm

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sokoloff on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:58PM (#24656574)
I worry that we have raised a bunch of people in the mindset of "if the government allows it, it's safe" and rather than thinking critically about it may assume that they just figured out it was safe. The more drug-tolerant cultures (such as the Netherlands and Portugal) have "evolved" an understanding of drugs culturally such that you don't see a bunch of locals stoned out of their gourds in the coffeeshops all day. I hate the "war on drugs" and the terrible costs it has imposed, but I think that flipping the switch to anything goes is unlikely to end well.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by fpig on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:37AM (#24678552)
If it’s just about social issues specific to the US, why is it exactly the same in so many other countries? In fact the US did try to make alcohol illegal but it was a shitshow. In my country they’d NEVER touch alcohol yet weed is illegal. Even though it’s the same ethnic group using both.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by mywittyname on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:12PM (#24655029)
Hypothetical reasons why this may be the case:

1. The most egregiously racist judges probably work in districts which they rarely encounter minorities.

2. Regions with large minority populations have to deal with much more crime in general, so may have lighter sentences for equally severe crimes.

3. Minorities are more likely to plead out and never go to trial, skewing sample size.

To be clear, I doubt that state judges are better than federal ones. After all, criminal justice corruption in smaller towns in America is staggering. Not too long ago, a judge was indicted for being bribed by the owners of a jail to hand down severe sentences to minority offenders.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:34PM (#24656876)
Is there any evidence that the sentences are longer after controlling for variables such as (1) differences in previous convictions which increase sentence duration, (2) severity of the crime?

If this evidence is provided, I am happy to agree with you that there is systematic racism in the justice system.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dhosek on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:56PM (#24657029)
Yes. There is abundant evidence of this.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @07:00PM (#24657059)
Link?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dhosek on Thursday October 01, 2020 @11:51PM (#24658671)
I found this with literally 30 seconds of googling. https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...

Don't be willfully ignorant and don't expect other people to do your homework.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dhosek on Thursday October 01, 2020 @11:53PM (#24658684)
Also, here's a lengthy summary of a wide variety of instances of racial bias in the justice system from policing to sentencing and so forth with links to primary sources. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/opinions/system...

Again, don't be willfully ignorant and don't expect other people to do your homework for you.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by centimeter on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:51PM (#24654731)
It’s funny watching people come up with all these complicated epicycle-ridden theories for why success is heritable, when the true answer is very obvious - most behaviors related to success are highly genetically heritable. This is the incontrovertible conclusion one draws when they critically observe the results of highly controlled and conditioned twin/sibling studies (on incarceration rate, among other things). Of course, this flies against the western “all men are created equal” soft-religious indoctrination most people get in school, so it’s less difficult for them to come up with these complicated (and relatively very unlikely) models.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by charlesu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:01PM (#24654866)
> most behaviors related to success are highly genetically heritable

And the implications of this are what?

See, that's the problem with these claims. They serve no purpose other than to suggest that some people are inherently better or more deserving than others. But we live in a liberal democracy based on equality before the law. It wouldn't matter if some people are more predisposed to crime or smarter or whatever. The law should be blind.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by jlawson on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:30PM (#24655232)
The implication is that if one genetic group is getting poorer outcomes than another group, you can't automatically assume it's due to discrimination.

This is an important implication because it completely undercuts many extremely important power structures, which use accusations of discrimination as their legitimizing argument. Which is why the science on this is resisted so hard.

The idea of anyone being inferior to anyone else is completely something you brought into the conversation. Normal people understand that being short does not make one inferior, nor does skin color, nor personality, nor intelligence. It just changes statistical outcomes. Not moral value.

If you think genetic differences between people make some people morally inferior, I would say that's a moral problem with you. Because even on the individual level, if not the group level, genetic differences are obvious and undeniable. Do you really think someone who scores low on an IQ test is morally inferior to you or deserves to suffer? I don't. If not, what's the problem with accepting the science on genetic group difference, especially given that it helps us reduce suffering in the world?

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by centimeter on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:03PM (#24656619)
If the law is blind, you expect people with heritable traits associated with criminality to get in trouble with the law more often. I.e. all is as expected.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by julianapostate on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:42PM (#24655362)
the implications are that a bit of gene pool control may go a long way.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by s_dev on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:17PM (#24652710)
>A criminal record in the US is a curse for life

The US system probably is overly harsh -- in Ireland it's probaby overly lenient and the pendulum affect is that we've criminals being called in to court with literally hundreds of prior convictions and then they're let off with suspended sentences and then go straight back to what they were doing.

Equally frustrating -- to see the guilty just walk off and laugh as it is to see the redeemed struggle having conceded their mistakes. Justice is very important, hard and complex. I don't doubt that but their clearly is room for improvement on both sides.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by saagarjha on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:36PM (#24653000)
> Equally frustrating -- to see the guilty just walk off and laugh as it is to see the redeemed struggle having conceded their mistakes.

That of course depends on your value system. There are many that consider sending an innocent person to jail far worse than letting a guilty person walk free, and I’m sure you can apply a similar worldview here as well.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by ponker on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:21PM (#24653619)
Getting guilt right and what punishment to dispense to the guilty are different questions. For example you could have 100-member juries with unanimous verdicts required, but also execute anyone convicted of any crime.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by avisser on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:26PM (#24653689)
> Getting guilt right and what punishment to dispense to the guilty are different questions.

I disagree.

If your legal system executes people, they are inseparable questions.

I would generalize to say that the more severe your sentences, the more those two questions are related.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by _jal on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:46PM (#24653959)
It sounds like you two are disagreeing over the unmentioned error rate.

If I get a parking ticket unjustly, it may piss me off, but it isn't a big deal. If I am convicted of a serious crime unjustly, it matters far more.

Whereas the grandparent, I think, is asserting the guilt or innocence is (or should be) an objective fact independent of what anyone does about it.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by bjt on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:47PM (#24653980)
I think you're arguing a different point. Sure there's a relationship, but these are not the same question:

"Did Joe kill Dave?"

"Given that we've decided that Joe did kill Dave, what should Joe's punishment be?"

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by unionpivo on Friday October 02, 2020 @04:44AM (#24660497)
They can become one.

For instance:

  1) Did Joe steal that apple?
  2a)Do we chop off Joe's hand, like law says? 
  2b)Do we make Joe repay the apple, and get community work?
There are people (myself included) that would answer the 1 question differently depending on the second question
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:35PM (#24653826)
The difference is that crimes are usually done against other people. I as a citizen can usually defend myself against wrongdoing by other people, but I can only defend myself against state wrongdoing in the state's courts, with the state's rules. Being imbalanced one way is not as equally harmful as being imbalanced the other way.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:22PM (#24654385)
Giving petty criminals a chance to reform is important since most petty crime is driven by factors other than inherent criminality of the individual but it should not be possible to just keep racking up petty offenses to the detriment of everyone who's victimized by them.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:08PM (#24654976)
Yes, but the argument of "detriment to everyone" is only used to further lengthen sentences, but never address any of the inputs that lead to such crime. And that's because of the draconian character of the US concerning law and punishment.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @04:57PM (#24656084)
I agree that we need to work on the frontend problems that are driving so much crime and that we should prefer to be rehabilitative instead of punitive in our approach to crime; however, it's not obvious to me how being punitive dissuades us from addressing inputs--could you elaborate?

(note that I'm a different 'throwaway' than the OP)

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by SquishyPanda23 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:59PM (#24654106)
> The US system probably is overly harsh -- in Ireland it's probaby overly lenient

The US system is overly harsh to some groups of people and overly lenient to others, and the imbalance creates its own set of problems.

I would love to see sane prison reform based on data and science.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by jonny_eh on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:31PM (#24652914)
As with everything, there is a balance. It requires everlasting vigilance.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by meheleventyone on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:32PM (#24652937)
Out of interest what proportion of criminals let off with suspended sentences have hundreds of convictions?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by s_dev on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:36PM (#24652995)
I don't have statistics but there are incidents like these that are regularly reported in Irish and International Media:

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/woman-most-c...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by meheleventyone on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:46PM (#24653154)
Sounds like that lady needs care more than she needs more prison time. Particularly after a 16 month sentence and the petty nature of the actual crime.

Incidents like these get in the national press precisely because they are rare and hence interesting. Do you think there are tens of people, hundred of people or thousands of people with >100 criminal convictions?

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by luckylion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:12PM (#24653499)
In Germany, that would Intensivtäter (literally intensive perpetrators). It's not rare to have young men with dozens of convictions for assault, breaking and entering, mugging etc. They typically don't get any jail time and will collect more indictments between being arrested and seeing a judge. For Berlin they're having a list of 500 people, almost all male.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by wsc981 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:47PM (#24653985)
The same is true in The Netherlands. Often these individuals share the same backgrounds: (illegal) immigrants from North Africa, mainly Morocco and Algeria. Countries that The Netherlands regard as safe, which means these individuals can’t get a refugee status. In case of Morocco, from my understanding, Morocco isn’t interested in accepting their former subjects [0], so it’s impossible for The Netherlands to send these repeat offenders back.

———

[0]: https://nltimes.nl/2019/11/22/morocco-refusing-speak-nl-taki...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by ponker on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:24PM (#24653662)
I wonder how much better you could make society if you managed to take the worst 1% of scumbags and remove them.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by tyho on Friday October 02, 2020 @07:56AM (#24661686)
Western Europe did pretty much that for hundreds of years.

> Through its monopoly on violence, the State tends to pacify social relations. Such pacification proceeded slowly in Western Europe between the 5th and 11th centuries, being hindered by the rudimentary nature of law enforcement, the belief in a man’s right to settle personal disputes as he saw fit, and the Church’s opposition to the death penalty. These hindrances began to dissolve in the 11th century with a consensus by Church and State that the wicked should be punished so that the good may live in peace. Courts imposed the death penalty more and more often and, by the late Middle Ages, were condemning to death between 0.5 and 1.0% of all men of each generation, with perhaps just as many offenders dying at the scene of the crime or in prison while awaiting trial. Meanwhile, the homicide rate plummeted from the 14th century to the 20th. The pool of violent men dried up until most murders occurred under conditions of jealousy, intoxication, or extreme stress. The decline in personal violence is usually attributed to harsher punishment and the longer-term effects of cultural conditioning. It may also be, however, that this new cultural environment selected against propensities for violence.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/147470491501300...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by saagarjha on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:20PM (#24656780)
Significantly worse, I'd say.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:46PM (#24653150)
> The US system probably is overly harsh -- in Ireland it's probaby overly lenient and the pendulum affect is that we've criminals being called in to court with literally hundreds of prior convictions and then they're let off with suspended sentences and then go straight back to what they were doing.

FWIW, it's not evenly distributed in the US. We have jurisdictions like Chicago where violent offenders are released on probation after a few months or years only to reoffend. Further, these violent crimes aren't evenly distributed across Chicago, but rather they disproportionately affect poor, typically minority communities. It's well-known that crime (esp violent) is driving businesses (and jobs) out of these communities and perpetuating the cycle of poverty. Presumably these light-on-crime policies (and similarly "defund the police") are a misguided attempt to help these communities, since the criminal justice system is biased against the poor and minorities (and men, but that seems to not factor into any calculus); however, they're exacerbating the very problem they purport to solve. Indeed, Chicago appears to be on track for its most violent year since the gang wars of the early nineties, after decades of consistent, remarkable, commendable progress.

For me, this underscores the importance of properly understanding the dynamics of the problem we're trying to solve--it's not sufficient to be well-intentioned or to have the right bumper sticker. It also highlights the importance of free-speech and open inquiry, since we can't collectively understand these dynamics without the kind of robust debate that proponents of political correctness and cancel culture aspire to suppress. And note that their intentions are presumably good--they don't want (at least some) hateful talking points to be espoused; however, the well-being of these communities isn't worth trading in exchange for the suppression of hateful talking points (never mind the more abstract reasons for preserving free speech, such as "what happens when your ideological cohort falls out of power and someone else gets to decide what speech is permissible?") and moreover prior to the mainstreaming of restrictive-speech ideals (let's say circa 2014-2015 but this is all pretty fuzzy), this really wasn't a problem--American society did a pretty good job of marginalizing those who would openly espouse hateful viewpoints (although some will advocate for a meaninglessly broad definition of 'hate' or would argue that any speech from anyone they don't like can fairly be considered a 'racist dogwhistle', but those kinds of bad faith arguments notwithstanding...) and things were gradually improving for everyone.

Anyway, I apologize for going a bit off track. Hopefully this stream-of-consciousness prompts productive discussion and introspection.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by infamouscow on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:58PM (#24654090)
> never mind the more abstract reasons for preserving free speech, such as "what happens when your ideological cohort falls out of power and someone else gets to decide what speech is permissible?"

Most people that I talk to opposed to net neutrality are opposed it solely because this point is deeply concerning to them.

Broadly speaking, people are quick to give the government additional power when it aligns with their interests, but are critical of the government when the additional power is used for things they disagree with.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:38PM (#24653872)
What's the objective of this comment? It starts off talking about "Chicago = War Zone" and then it devolves into the ground state of HN's favorite whipping children of "cancel culture", "free speech" and how "The well-being of these communities shouldn't be exchanged for free-speech(?)". I'm not even sure what the last point was meant to be about other than showing angst at the idea that racist comments are largely derided and marginalized.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:00PM (#24654126)
> What's the objective of this comment? It starts off talking about "Chicago = War Zone" and then it devolves into the ground state of HN's favorite whipping children of "cancel culture", "free speech" and how "The well-being of these communities shouldn't be exchanged for free-speech(?)".

Chicago isn't a warzone. Last year I bought my first home here. I wouldn't live here if it were a warzone. But it does have problems and I have a vested interest in their resolution (or more realistically, reducing their impact). I think I explained pretty clearly how I see cancel culture, etc relating to these problems. If you have specific questions, I'm happy to try to answer (I don't claim perfect knowledge, I'm only sharing my perspective).

> "The well-being of these communities shouldn't be exchanged for free-speech(?)". I'm not even sure what the last point was meant to be about other than showing angst at the idea that racist comments are largely derided and marginalized.

I don't know how you got "angst at the idea that racist comments are largely derided and marginalized". I explicitly noted that marginalizing actual racism is a good thing. The problem is that a lot of necessary debate is considered beyond the pale such that we are only allowed to talk about the solutions which (pretty obviously) are only going to exacerbate the problem, such as reducing policing in the communities most in need and letting violent offenders out without the necessary rehabilitation. Your comment (inadvertently, I'm sure) lumps these concerns in with "racist comments", illustrating perfectly my issue with political correctness. I understand the desire for a simple worldview with a group of purely good guys and a group of purely bad guys, but I'm interested in solving real world problems and the real world has a lot of nuance to be explored. We have to be able to talk about that nuance in order to solve these problems. We're not doing these communities any favors by avoiding unpleasant complexities.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:10PM (#24654239)
Okay, so tell us what these "unpleasant complexities" that we're avoiding are.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:30PM (#24654484)
As previously discussed, we can't improve neighborhoods plagued by violent crime simply by releasing offenders early or pulling police out of those neighborhoods. Anyway, this conversation seems to be veering toward an unproductive direction. I'll see myself out.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by cik2e on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:18PM (#24656243)
Perhaps things like crime rates amongst different segments of the population.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by nickff on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:09PM (#24652578)
People are losing their jobs because of offhand tweets completely unrelated to their occupation; how can we expect that a blemish as big as a criminal record will be overlooked?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by saithound on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:37PM (#24653021)
Unfortunately, I don't think that's it. The same subset of my coworkers who requested that we don't invite Scott Aaronson to our colloquium because he said something vaguely anti-feminist years ago are perfectly happy to praise (literal murderer and talented number theorist) Christopher Havens, and I'm sure would be happy to have him employed by our department.

edit: Of course, universities still don't hire violent offenders, but I don't think the reasons for not employing a Twitter-pariah and not employing a murderer are closely related at all.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:13PM (#24652638)
I'd rather hire a criminal (depending on the crime, obviously) than, say, a racist, especially given how many laws I disagree with.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:43PM (#24653107)
There's a problem though:

- The standard of proof in criminal law is very high. There are very specific definitions of most criminal acts and these must be proven "beyond reasonable doubt"

- The definition of "racist tweet" on the other hand is as fuzzy as it can be. Usually it drills down to "someone whom I don't like said something that I have interpreted in the way I don't like"

If we think that racist tweets should bear harsh consequences, we need a bit better criteria of what "racist" actually means.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:41PM (#24653906)
Proof of criminal law in the US is notoriously low. Police perjury especially concerning marginalized groups is routine business.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_perjury

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/18/nyregion/testilying-polic...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by infamouscow on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:28PM (#24664876)
Have you ever been on a jury?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by content_sesh on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:08PM (#24653457)
The vast majority of those incarcerated in America have taken plea deals. The only source I could find from a government agency is a 1984 report from the BJS but it's fairly staggering - median ratio of 11 guilty pleas for every trial[1].

More recent nongovernmental sources paint a very similar picture [2][3]

So whatever your feeling about the standard of proof in a criminal trial, the vast majority of those incarcerated never actually went through one.

[1] https://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=pbdetail&iid=3498 [2] https://www.innocenceproject.org/guilty-pleas-on-the-rise-cr... [3] https://www.themarshallproject.org/2014/12/26/plea-bargainin...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by minitoar on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:50PM (#24653208)
What do you think a good definition of “racist tweet” would be?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by bluGill on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:33PM (#24653795)
There shouldn't be one. Everything bad about a racist tweet is bad when race isn't an issue.

Society has switched what it is racist about many times in the past. Just 100 years ago (WWI was just over) it was worse to be German than black in the US. Someone told me that in the 1870s the KKK had many black members - the group was against Catholics not blacks, but they changed (I do not know if this is true, but even if false it isn't unlikely). It will switch again.

Whatever your law is needs to cover all cases, otherwise it will be worked around quickly.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by rmah on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:08PM (#24654212)
That assertion about the KKK is, in fact, a myth. The KKK was founded in 1865, just after the US Civil War, and had as a bedrock principal the re-establishment of white supremacy. It's initial actions were to frustrate Reconstruction-era policies through violent action. Today, they'd be labeled a terrorist organization. Their aims were inherently racist, political and their tactics violent. Through a variety of means, they more or less achieved their goals such that by 1876, the entire south was once again under Democratic control.

It wasn't until the revival of the "second wave" of the KKK during 1910's and 1920's that they even started taking on anti-catholic stances. It was during this era that the burning cross, anti-communist, anti-catholic and anti-jewish stances came into being.

Finally, I have no idea where you got the idea that the KKK had "many black members". As far as I'm aware, no credible evidence for that has ever been put forward.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by bluGill on Thursday October 01, 2020 @08:47PM (#24657694)
That is why I was clear that it wasn't a source I would trust.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:41PM (#24653902)
The definition can refer to any innate quality.

The whole idea of these rules is to avoid discriminating people based on something outside of their control: color, gender, height, age, country of origin and so on.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by GeoAtreides on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:48PM (#24653992)
"[Do bad things] to [racial minority|racial group]!"

The definition of "bad things" is left as an exercise to the reader.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by mistermann on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:27PM (#24655203)
I wonder, if one could go even farther in your generalization such that it would apply to ~all human activity, might people be able to semi-realize that "The definition of <X> is left as an exercise to the reader", where "an exercise to the reader" actually consists of the reader's conceptualization of reality (much of which is pure imagination, mistaken for fact), and from there perhaps realize that this is what lies at the heart of most human conflict and failures?

It seems like quite the tall order, but then humanity has a very long list of conquered tall orders, because some people were willing to pursue the "impossible", and we also happen to be blessed with some very powerful tools (some of which often work against us).

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by deelowe on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:54PM (#24653269)
I doubt there is one.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by minitoar on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:06PM (#24653433)
Does that mean the concept has no value, or that racist tweets do not exist (since they cannot be easily defined)?
[dead]
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by deelowe on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:14PM (#24656205)
No. I mean, I doubt we as a society could come up with a definition that's sufficiently specific and durable enough to apply this level of scrutiny. We can't even agree on the proper term for certain races.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:07PM (#24653442)
It's a tweet that explicitly promotes superiority or inferiority of one race relative to other races.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by lopmotr on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:46PM (#24657976)
What if one race really is superior or inferior to another? For example "Tibetans are better at surviving at high altitudes than Han Chinese" Fact but racist according to that definition. Harsh consequences for scientists talking about their work?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by rimliu on Friday October 02, 2020 @09:22AM (#24662291)
High altitudes are a social construct, duh.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by deelowe on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:18PM (#24656244)
Awesome. Now define all of the races such that they are specific enough to create legal interpretations of promote, superiority, and inferiority in such a way that relative comparisons can be made.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by FpUser on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:49PM (#24653998)
>"The standard of proof in criminal law is very high. There are very specific definitions of most criminal acts and these must be proven "beyond reasonable doubt"

This is nice theory which in practice often comes down to: you can not afford proper defense (unless you want government lawyer who will happily sleep through the whole case), you do not have enough to make bail so here is the deal: plead guilty to this lesser crime or we would f,,k you up royally later on.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:50PM (#24653198)
As with all things there is a judgment to be made, and as the one doing the hiring it is yours to make responsibly.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by TLightful on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:01PM (#24653365)
"Usually it drills down to "someone whom I don't like said something that I have interpreted in the way I don't like""

"Usually" ...

LOL ...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by nendroid on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:18PM (#24652720)
You say this, but most prison time is done for extreme crime that everyone agrees with. In addition this, prison time is usually reserved for not just crimes we agree with but crimes we all agree are extreme.

Case in point for this specific case it was violent crime, which I'm sure we can all agree is way worse than a racist tweet.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by rdimartino on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:32PM (#24652932)
I'm not sure your statements about prison time are accurate, at least in the US.

According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, 46.2% of inmates are in for drug offenses[1] and there is definitely disagreement about whether that should be a crime, let alone an extreme crime. Additionally, 78.6% of inmates are serving sentences longer than 5 years[2], which by necessity means that a large portion of those are for drug offenses.

[1] https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen... [2] https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_sente...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by iguy on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:40PM (#24653080)
But only about 10% of prisoners are in Federal custody.

Among those in state prisons, drug possession is about 3% of cases (about equal to DUI plus fraud cases). Other drug charges make up about 10%.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by qes on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:21PM (#24656786)
> in state prisons, drug possession is about 3% of cases

You're going to need to source that unbelievably low number.

In my state, drug crimes represent the second largest proportion of prison inmates - a bit fewer than criminal sexual conduct a bit more than homicide: https://mn.gov/doc/assets/Adult%20Prison%20Population%20Summ...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by iguy on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:10AM (#24659465)
Source is [1], 45k / 1290k for drug possession (and nothing harder), plus 145k for other drug charges (which I guess is closer to 11% not 10% as I said).

Minnesota's 17% isn't that far off the national number it seems. They don't give a breakdown for simple possession. Violent crimes at 55% are again a majority.

[1] https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:04PM (#24653414)
What percentage of those drug offenses are usage vs distribution?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by qes on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:23PM (#24656804)
If I had, let's say, less than $1000 worth of drugs - enough for a few weeks of personal consumption, but on occasion I sell a bit to one of my buddies. Does that make me a "distributor"? It did according to the law.

You're unlikely to find any realistic statistics on usage vs "distribution" due to that.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:51PM (#24657003)
That's a good point, I'd like to see some research into that question.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Jtsummers on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:26PM (#24652852)
> You say this, but most prison time is done for extreme crime that everyone agrees with. In addition this, prison time is usually reserved for not just crimes we agree with but crimes we all agree are extreme.

If only that were accurate. Prison time in the US is not given out in proportion to the seriousness of the crime, and the amount of prison time is highly variable depending on locale, race of offender, race of victim, and many other factors.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by heyoni on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:33PM (#24652949)
The two are not mutually exclusive. You can have a majority of serious offenders in your prison population that also happen to be from certain locales/race/etc...
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by VBprogrammer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:23PM (#24652796)
Isn't a huge amount of prison time in the US handed out for selling banned substances to other consenting adults?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by CobrastanJorji on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:39PM (#24653050)
In total, about a half million people are in jail or prison for having, using, or selling drugs. Drug crimes account for about half of Federal prisoners.

But percentage-wise, when you add up federal, state, and local prisons and jails, drugs are not as large a percentage as you'd think. Another half million people in prisons or jails haven't been convicted of any crime at all, either because they can't afford bail or because they're just being processed today. If you had to guess what someone went to jail for, and you only knew they were in a State penitentiary, violent crime would be your best guess.

Here's a bit pie chart: https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by joncrane on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:04PM (#24653400)
What's not captured here is that drugs are a contributing factor to many of the crimes committed. An old and rather tired example is the junky stealing to get his next fix. The crime is robbery, but the cause is drugs.

I would argue (having been in jail myself multiple times, and, by the way, thanks to a lot of factors, now very happily and gainfully employed) that drugs are at the very least a co-factor on the vast majority of crimes in the USA.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by vkou on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:58PM (#24654101)
I think most people understand this.

What I'd like to see is the junkie to just get drugs from the government. It's cheaper for society to pay for a $20 fix (That costs $2 to produce), then for $500 dollars in property damage, a stolen $200 item that gets fenced for $20, a cop to show up to do a police report, and then, months down the road, an arrest, prison time, etc, etc.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by CobrastanJorji on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:17PM (#24654320)
Same thing with prisoners and rehabilitation. Letting prisoners attend colleges for free is a remarkably good government investment.

The same thing is true about the homeless. Homeless services are expensive. It's cheaper to get them apartments, even if you still offer them all of the support services you were offering before.

But whenever you propose these things, social conservatives seem to come out of the woodwork and argue that it's not fair for prisoners or homeless people to get expensive stuff for free. Why should you get something good for doing a bad thing? Why should the homeless guy get an apartment that you'd paying $1000 a month for? Why should your taxes be buying drugs for that junkie? Even if you have to spend more taxes by not giving them these things, your sense of justice demands it be so.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by vkou on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:30PM (#24654482)
> The same thing is true about the homeless. Homeless services are expensive. It's cheaper to get them apartments, even if you still offer them all of the support services you were offering before.

We already do that, though, through things like food stamps and section 8 housing. It's expensive, but it works, because it keeps a lot of poor people fed and sheltered.

The visible homeless that you see are people who tend to have additional problems, on top of being poor (Untreated addiction and mental health problems are two big causes of this.)

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by iguy on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:30PM (#24654483)
When you say a co-factor, can you say more about what you have in mind?

For instance it could be a junky who needs to feed his own habit. It could be that the profits available from dealing in some area motivate gangs to take control of it. And it could also be just that people taking drugs have impaired judgement, and do things they would avoid while sober. Would you care to guess how much of each goes on?

For alcohol, I guess it's mainly the 3rd (DUI, and manslaughter, etc.) and a tiny bit of the 1st (shoplifting to buy a drink).

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by joncrane on Friday October 02, 2020 @09:58AM (#24662649)
Let me put it this way: if you were to create a Venn diagram of habitual drug and alcohol users and people who get incarcerated, 90+% of the incarcerated people would also be in the habitual users circle.

I know correlation doesn't imply causation, but that's not the argument I'm making here.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by ticviking on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:38PM (#24654586)
There's also a lot of people pleading to the drug offence to get off of the property crime.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:52PM (#24653248)
This is people in prison, not people sent to prison. Given that violent crimes have longer sentences, wouldn't that skew the existing count in prison considerably towards violent offenders, even if many more people are sent to prison for other offenses?

Further, because there would be shorter sentences, you're far more likely to encounter a candidate with a lesser sentence.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by iguy on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:30PM (#24652905)
About 10-20% of prisoners are in for nothing more serious than drugs, and if you try to exclude trafficking, then it's closer to the 10% end.

https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by nickff on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:27PM (#24652870)
Drug convictions make up a large portion of federal inmates, but federal inmates are a minority of the prison population.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by minikites on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:28PM (#24652874)
Yep. Drug laws (and the police/legal system in general) also disproportionately targets people of color.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by content_sesh on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:35PM (#24652983)
I'm having a hard time finding data for the state in question (California), but at a federal level this is very much not true. BOP stats show 46% of inmates are in for drug offenses, and 5% are in for property crime[1]

[1] https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by alex_young on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:32PM (#24652941)
There are nearly half a million people incarcerated in the US for nonviolent drug offenses [0].

Do you think we all agree that these are extreme crimes?

[0] https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2020.html

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:31PM (#24652917)
I would hope that all agree a violent crime is worse than a racist tweet. However, there is a sentiment of sympathy afforded to murderers (that they're somehow deserving of rehabilitation) which is not always extended to those who have tweeted racist things.

Perhaps this comes because a murder can be seen as a sad result of circumstances. Perhaps the criminal only had to murder because they had a bad upbringing and needed the cash and it was a horrible mistake. On the other hand, people perceived as racist are permanently marked as being ideologically dangerous. Mainly, I think this comes because racist tweeters can be seen as more directly responsible for their actions than a murderer.

Of course, this line of reasoning is nonsense, but it appears to be quite common.

Jon Ronson has a great TED talk about this, titled "How one tweet can ruin your life": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAIP6fI0NAI. I would recommend that the grandparent post watch this.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:57PM (#24653307)
I'm perfectly willing to:

a) Understand violent criminals have made amends and are rehabilitated

b) Believe that people who were once racist are no longer racist

Both issues are, to me, a 'sad result of circumstances'. So all of that seems fine.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:07PM (#24653438)
As am I.

The point I was trying to make was that there isn't really a "path to rehabilitation" for people who have made very minor missteps online. In the case of the linked TED talk, the persecuted woman made a mistake, and was not a "career-racist". I think even accusing her of racism is a distortion of the word — she made a bad joke in bad taste.

Meanwhile, there is an established, albeit broken path to rehabilitation for ex-convicts. There is also a certain faction of the left which seems to be more willing to accept prison reform than "tweet-reform".

I think it should be far more easy to rehabilitate oneself from a bad tweet than a murder, and that they are entirely different classes of offences.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:12PM (#24653503)
Oh I agree entirely that we lack paths to rehabilitation for both the (a) and (b) cases, couldn't agree more - it makes the judgment call to hire that much more difficult.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:44PM (#24655395)
I'm glad we can agree on that.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:09PM (#24653461)
While that's true, there's no comparison between (a) and (b) in terms of how bad the original offense is. One is murder and the other is a thought crime.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:12PM (#24653495)
I can compare anything I like, actually. That's my right and my responsibility as the one who determines who comes to work with me and my colleagues.

You can say that all "though crimes" are incomparable to legal indictments, and when you are hiring people that is your right as well.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by hnracer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:15PM (#24653536)
I didn't mean that there's no way you can make a comparison in a literal sense.

I mean that it takes a particularly screwed up and deranged individual to think that murder and racist thoughts are somehow equivalent on the moral scale. Also, I'm not claiming that this is the position you are taking, only that it would be deranged if it is the one you are in fact taking.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:23PM (#24653654)
This whole conversation started off with "any crime" vs "a definitively racist tweet", not "murder" vs "thought crime".

Trying to consider any of these things in isolation is worthless and not really something that makes sense to discuss, it's just a sillier version of the trolley problem. Context is going to be everything.

Could someone convicted of murder be worth hiring? Yeah, sure, I'm not willing to say that that's not the case - what if they had an untreated medical condition, just as one potential contextual element? It's not worth discussing because it will end up with a "but what if but what if but what if".

The point I will definitely make is the original point I made - that if I determine someone to be a racist that is important to me, and if I find that someone is a criminal I will need more context before I determine that it is important to me.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:21PM (#24653621)
Thanks for making this point. This is what I was trying to get at. Racist thoughts, to some, are seen as offences in the same way murder is, while they're not.

Murder is a very clearly defined criminal act, to tweet something racist is an expression of free speech. Racism is inexcusable, but in an entirely different way than murder.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by kyleee on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:20PM (#24653608)
Would you prefer to be murdered or to recieve a racist remark directed towards you?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:48PM (#24653991)
Do you think this question is relevant or clever? I would rather a racist remark me directed towards me. I hope that satisfies whatever you're after.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by kyleee on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:53PM (#24655489)
just trying to suss out if you thought there are levels of severity of various crimes / negative behaviors, which I was unsure of based on earlier comments.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by 205guy on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:08PM (#24653448)
> people perceived as racist are permanently marked as being ideologically dangerous.

I don't think this is necessarily true. We just haven't seen many racist people make amends and ask for forgiveness. I believe people can change and if they do, they should be reintegrated into the workplace.

I hadn't given it much thought before, but I asked myself if I would hire or work with a former criminal qualified for the job. It's a touchy subject, but I decided I would if they are rehabilitated: shown remorse, served a sentence, and working to integrate society.

And I realized the same goes for a racist statement (or sexist or anti-LGBTQ). Racism get tried in the court of public opinion, and then there is a sentence of being shunned in the form of unemployability. But if the formerly racist person shows remorse and publicly states they have changed, I would be willing to hire/work with them.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:19PM (#24653580)
My point is mainly that the two "offences" (if we are to class racism as an offence), are vastly different, and in entirely differently classes.

To rehabilitate someone who made a joke in bad taste should be far, far easier than to rehabilitate a murderer. The two just cannot be equivocated. One is a criminal act, the other is expressing an opinion, albeit a very bad one.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by 205guy on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:11PM (#24654254)
Obviously, they are different, and the length of sentences reflect that. A murderer is in prison for 10-20 years and a really bad racist joke makes you unemployable for a year or 2.

There's also a problem with the verb "to rehabilitate" because much of the rehabilitation comes from the subject themselves and can't be imposed by society. The murderer who serves time, shows remorse, and studies programming to reintegrate society is different from the racist who doesn't apologize sincerely or believably for the bad joke and complains that nobody will hire them.

Finally, look at the environment that the rehabilitated person gets put into. Someone who got into drugs and gangs as a teen, went to prison, and then turned their life around is not a threat in an office environment. A racist or sexist may still cause disruption in a diverse and gender-equal work environment. The ex-gang member can't go back to the 'hood, but the racist or sexist has made it much more difficult to work in any office--or with people so that's pretty much any job. Though like I said, if they apologize and repent, I think the racist should be given a second chance as well.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:17PM (#24653556)
> Racism get tried in the court of public opinion, and then there is a sentence of being

Placed in high government office?

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dfxm12 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:37PM (#24653858)
This talk is about Justine Sacco. Within 7-8 months of being fired, she got a new job and has continued to work her way up the corporate ladder ever since [0].

You're right. Your line of reasoning is nonsense.

0 - https://www.linkedin.com/in/justinesacco

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:53PM (#24654048)
Yes, a joke in bad taste is richly deserving of mass public humiliation, getting fired, and not having work for 8 months. I love our brave new world!
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by geofft on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:42PM (#24653095)
> On the other hand, people perceived as racist are permanently marked as being ideologically dangerous.

This is pretty demonstrably untrue. Cenk Uygur comes to mind, off the top of my head - he's lost out on opportunities from things he said in the past that were perceived as racist, but nobody in good faith / nobody who matters considers him to continue to espouse those views. It helps that he quite vocally criticizes those views.

What is probably actually true is that, statistically, many people who were racist in the past are still racist, and many people who murdered in the past and went to prison commit no further violent crimes (for many reasons).

[dead]
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:02PM (#24653378)
I never said it was universal to feel more sympathy for criminals, nor am I trying to apologize and/or gain sympathy for racists. How did what I wrote imply that?

The TED talk, now 5 years old, encapsulated what has now grown into "cancel culture" in a poignant anecdote. There's nothing generative or useful about this concept of prosecution (or persecution?) for making a misstep online.

I am fully in favor of implementing the Portugal drug model, implementing prison reform, and offering prisoners chances at rehabilitation. But to equivocate a racist tweet with a crime is ridiculous and, in my opinion, dangerous. This line of reasoning is barely different from the concept that speech can be violence, which is absurd. The foundation of every liberal democracy is the separation of free speech from criminality.

That principle assumes that a person's ideas can be reformed, which is what we should all hope is possible. Half of the time, alienating people for their views will only further radicalize and polarize them.

Now, to argue that a rehabilitated ex-convict is a better hire than someone actively tweeting racist things is a fine argument, but in an entirely different scope than the aforementioned comment, unless I misinterpreted it.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Klinky on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:40PM (#24654600)
You said it was common. I said "it was not universal or common".

Social media is often used to amplify a message, do not act shocked when it amplifies the response as well.

I am not sure what the Portugal drug model has to do with this topic or why you're pivoting away from murderers and to drug users. You specifically noted murderers(effectively the most heinous of crimes), as gaining more sympathy than racist tweeters. This "sympathy" being provided to these murderers is them rotting in a prison for the rest of their lives or being executed. Social media and "cancel culture" is not on the same level as being stuffed in a prison for the rest of your life or getting a lethal injection. That was my point, not that racist speech on twitter is an automatic crime(though keep in mind that free speech laws do not actually cover all forms of speech).

How do you rehabilitate a racist tweeter in a thoughtful and caring manner that doesn't alienate their sensibilities? For all the talk of toxic "cancel culture", ingrained racism is also extremely toxic, and should not simply be ignored.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sebmellen on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:53PM (#24654767)
The Portugal drug model (or similar scale legalization and decriminalization) has a lot to do with it. A lot of the people who end up committing murder or are nailed for egregious drug offences are only in the position they're in because of bad policy. This is something that can be directly acted upon and changed.

I am very, very sceptical of the idea of a "conviction" for a non-crime. Racism, though deplorable, is not a crime, and it shouldn't be. Thought and speech are necessarily divorced from action in the "world of atoms". These classes of offence are very, very different.

My argument isn't that racism should be ignored, either. Rather, I don't think that any of the "cancel culture" that seems so prevalent actually does anything positive. It doesn't change views, it further polarizes and solidifies what you refer to as "ingrained racism".

There is a strain of thought that some murder is justified in the name of political liberation (take Assata Shakur for example). Many of these same people will try to persecute people for perceived racism. This is the world-view I'm referring to. If you'd like more tangible examples, I could dredge them up, but I don't think it would be worth either of our time(s).

Edit: For that matter, how do you rehabilitate someone like Dick Costolo, who today tweeted "Me-first capitalists who think you can separate society from business are going to be the first people lined up against the wall and shot in the revolution. I'll happily provide video commentary." in response to Brian Armstrong of Coinbase choosing an apolitical company approach?

Edit 2: Can't reply to the child comment. I don't have the solutions, but I would propose:

1) Reworking or regulating social media to be less polarizing (see The Social Dilemma, a film that just came out on this).

2) Criminal justice reform and drug decriminalization, so violent crimes and murder become less commonplace, especially such crimes that could be easily prevented by better policy. Also, clear the criminal records of those convicted for non-violent offences.

3) Establish "free speech zones" or something similar on university campuses, to allow space to refute heinous ideas in open discussion (ala Chomsky).

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Klinky on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:12PM (#24655039)
Portugal drug model does not excuse murder. Again, no clue why you keep bringing this up.

Racist speech and thought is often followed through with racist action, and this can be overt, but much of it is subversive throughout a society/culture, especially one that openly tolerates racist expression.

Ignoring racism also doesn't do anything positive, and in some cases encourages it. There's also a view point that people speaking up about racism is "cancel culture", and there are people who want to cancel that "cancel culture". Sorry, but at some point there has to be some nuance and middle ground of tolerable/intolerable and this is always going to be fuzzy, especially in a dynamic environment of social media.

It doesn't really sound like you have a solution, other than "ignore it" or continuing the status quo, which includes "cancel culture". You cannot prevent someone from saying racist crap on twitter, but then you also can't ban the blow back that person gets. If nothing should be done, then you accept that social media has its positives and negatives, and allow the adults to be responsible for what they say and be willing to accept the blow back for any heinous crap spouted out on it, just like Dick Costolo will have to face, which you bringing it up seems to kinda be an attempt at cancel culture.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by secondcoming on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:16PM (#24652689)
> depending on the crime, obviously

Well, this is the big part that's missing from the story. 13 years seems like it was a big deal.

Is it even legal to ask someone who was in prison what their crime was during an interview?

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by chrisco255 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:26PM (#24652845)
The laws on this vary dramatically by state and sometimes even by city. For some they can't ask or run a background check until after an offer is made. For some jurisdictions they can't discriminate on that basis unless it's highly relevant to the job (i.e. convicted sex offender can't work with children). For some jurisdictions it's totally legal to run the background check upfront and to discriminate at will.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by dx87 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:26PM (#24652853)
The tweet says that it was a "serious, violent crime", and that they got out early on parole, so the 13 years wasn't even the full sentence. With that amount of jail time, it looks like she murdered someone.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_punishments_for_murder...

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by edbob on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:20PM (#24653613)
13 years served is pretty short for murder in most states. It's more likely aggravated assault, robbery, or less likely something like negligent homicide (e.g., killing someone in a car wreck while intoxicated). Assaults and robberies are far more common.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by richardwhiuk on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:19PM (#24652743)
Definitely in the UK. You can ask for full criminal records.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by michaelt on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:33PM (#24652943)
You can ask.

But UK convictions become 'spent' after a certain amount of time (Depending on the length of the prison sentence served, with 4+ year sentences never becoming spent) after which they leave the person's basic criminal record, and there's no obligation to tell a prospective employer about them.

Only a few jobs (such as teaching) are allowed info on spent convictions.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by richardwhiuk on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:30PM (#24655234)
The original article was a 13 year conviction, so would have shown up.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by VBprogrammer on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:27PM (#24652869)
Criminal convictions in the UK at least can be considered spent, after that point it doesn't need to be declared.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Nuzzerino on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:37PM (#24653016)
What percentage of the population do you estimate is made up of these racists?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:54PM (#24653270)
I don't know? I don't understand what you're getting at.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Nuzzerino on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:58PM (#24653328)
Many these days have got on a bandwagon of calling people out as racists if they don't fall in line with the Democrat party platform or support the censorship agenda of big tech. As that diminishes the real problem of racism would you be willing to commit to not hiring anyone contributing to that problem as well? (Obviously this is rhetorical)
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:06PM (#24653436)
If it's rhetorical why are you asking me? What do you want from this exchange?

I have no interest in discussing who is or isn't racist, I'm saying that an already defined as racist tweet would be something worth considering in a hiring process.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by eplanit on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:35PM (#24652975)
So, Thought Crime weighs heavier than statutory crimes? Who decides the guilt or innocence of the thoughts?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by sixo on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:42PM (#24653098)
you're trying to be clever, but statutory crimes are often either ridiculous (drug offenses) or can be put behind you and forgiven (if they were a product of circumstances or culture at the time.)

whereas what you're calling "thought crime" is more analogous to saying "i intend to commit statutory crimes in the future".

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:47PM (#24653159)
A thought crime is analogous to saying "I think that imprisoning people for drugs is unfair".
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by staticassertion on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:55PM (#24653280)
The one hiring gets to decide who works there.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by pkaye on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:07PM (#24654208)
So you are saying it should be the employers choice whether to hire the racist or criminal?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by nendroid on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:36PM (#24652996)
You can tweet racist stuff and still be president of the United States. The law protects him from the emotions of the masses. This law does not extend over to your employment at a commercial company.

The reason why people lose their jobs for racist tweets is because companies are reacting to the emotional sentiment of the masses and pulling a PR maneuver.

In short, for commercial jobs, it doesn't matter your crime, or the degree of your crime or whether you committed a crime at all, it's about business and a negative public emotional mood against you at this current point in time is usually bad for business (or stock prices).

Case in point, Let's say hypothetically that the OP could have mentioned that this woman's violent crime was repeatedly beating a 8 year old child for no reason and the public's emotional reaction would be drastically different. I'm not sure what her crime really was, but there is definitely a reason why it was omitted: The OP likely made a rational judgement about the crime and is likely very aware that the emotional reaction to the crime by the masses would be drastically different than her own rational judgement... thus from this line of reasoning she has chosen not to mention what the crime was.

It's a fine line here. I think if I really got to know a person and I can really understand a person, I feel even a child beater or can be redeemed in my eyes but I can see how in the eyes of the public this can never happen. (Also let's be clear here, I'm not saying the womans crime was beating a child, just using that as an example).

People are rarely rational and when you measure the reactions of people in response to stimuli in aggregate you will find that the bigger the aggregate the more emotional the reaction is.

This is how a criminal who committed a violent crime can get public support for finding a job, and an innocent man who made a mistake and wrote a stupid tweet can lose any prospect at finding a future career.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by geofft on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:34PM (#24652965)
I don't think anyone expects them to be overlooked. You look at the person and you see if they've changed for the better.

I would much rather hire someone who grew up poor and fell in with gangs and felt pressured to join in an armed robbery 10 years ago and understands that it's wrong than someone who had a demonstrated bias against some minority 10 years ago and still does today. This isn't about whether they're a "good person" or anything, this is a mercenary calculation based on business value. I don't expect the former gang member is going to engage in similar violent crimes if I employ them. I do expect the biased person is going to have trouble working productively with people in my company who are part of that minority or is going to negatively impact those folks' productivity.

I'm not in the business of determining the magnitude of your moral transgressions. That stays in the confessional. I'm in the business of hiring folks who will deliver business value.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by bzbarsky on Thursday October 01, 2020 @08:38PM (#24657656)
I think there's a wide gulf between "said something that someone on the internet construed as racist" and "demonstrated bias against some minority"...

But past that, the general principle you advocate seems to be "try not to hire people who will not be able to work with others", right? It doesn't matter whether they're biased against minorities or non-minorities, as long as they're biased and will be acting irrationally in ways that piss off those around them.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:32PM (#24652931)
You don't understand.

One is an accidental mishap due to the extreme cruelty and unfairness of our modern society.

The other one is a sincerely held unacceptable belief which endangers the progress of humanity.

/s

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Joker_vD on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:41PM (#24653088)
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by taneq on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:40PM (#24653064)
I guess merely being convicted of a crime isn't that bad compared with being sentenced without trial in the court of public opinion.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by clevergadget on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:11PM (#24652613)
pretty sure the people with criminal records have already been punished?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by UnpossibleJim on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:19PM (#24652739)
I believe what the person above was referring to is the dichotomy of the people cheering for prisoners getting jobs while cancelling people for a fairly innocuous tweet, however tasteless. While the prisoners may have paid for their crime, there isn't always as clear a path out of the purgatory that is becoming the social pariah of upsetting "the mob" in the Twitterverse (though, past a few professions, I'm unsure how much sway they hold).
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by cycloptic on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:51PM (#24653229)
I wouldn't say that's a dichotomy. Internet popularity was fleeting before twitter and it probably still will be long afterwards. In general, the path out of unpopularity is to do research before you post something. If you don't want to do it yourself, you can hire a PR firm.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by JauntyHatAngle on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:26PM (#24652838)
Because two wrongs dont make a right, and expectations are a poor way to calibrate justice.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by kazinator on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:23PM (#24653646)
> People are losing their jobs because of offhand tweets ...

Well, not sitting-in-the-oval-office people, but anyway.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by anemoiac on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:41PM (#24655348)
Smoke weed in Kansas - boom, criminal record. Walk across the Colorado border and smoke weed - no problem, it's completely legal. It's also completely legal to spend your free time carting your AR-15 and Nazi flag down to the village square and recruiting supporters for your "Turn America into a white ethnostate" movement. The point I'm making is that not all criminal behavior is even widely considered objectionable and plenty of legal behavior is.

Thus, why would you consider having a criminal record to be "a [big] blemish" that justifies employment discrimination, yet no personal views extreme enough to allow an employer to disassociate from their employee?

When you consider that the ratio of those affected by criminal record-based employment discrimination to those impacted by twitter-based discrimination is on the order of millions to one, it seems strange to be more concerned about the latter than the former.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by schoolornot on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:15PM (#24652670)
I wonder what kind of community reaction there will be if Hans Reiser submits kernel patches after getting released/paroled.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by jonny_eh on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:32PM (#24652926)
I think as long as he did his time and behaves in the community, he'd be accepted. At least that's what I'd hope.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Andrew_nenakhov on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:03PM (#24654159)
I, for one, would not mind him doing this while incarcerated, too. Who would be harmed if he would get a pc and internet access in prison?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:17PM (#24653559)
I don't see why they wouldn't accept his patches even if he somehow manages to submit them from inside prison. You can't murder someone with a patch file.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by guenthert on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:35PM (#24652979)
Who's going to dare rejecting his labor of love?
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Kalium on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:00PM (#24653360)
Once upon a time, an employer of mine was happy to work with people who had criminal records. Provided they were honest and willing to discuss the matter.

It became a problem when we hired someone with a record of fraud... who had not disclosed it. And who would have had access to credit card info. He was promptly fired.

We were willing to work with him, and said as much. He wasn't willing to take the risk. So he took a bigger one, and lost.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by stronglikedan on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:20PM (#24653607)
> A criminal record in the US

It's worse than that. I've been denied an apartment for having an arrest on my record, even though I wasn't convicted.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by ticmasta on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:10PM (#24654238)
I agree with you, but it is a really hard problem with huge, diverse, systemic drivers. The OP mentions how much work from how many people this takes - the entire process could fall apart at any of the steps, plus it required personal relationships and favors. There's also the measure of success; it's pretty relative. I've seen programs touted as huge successes when the recidivism rate is "only" 25%. This speaks about how hard it is to break the cycle, but also would your company be happy with 1/4 employees having a serious drug problem, or stealing or committing a violent crime, vs. (number pulled from thin air) 1/50?

We DO need more of this. It's going to take a lot of time and effort, and (sorry growth hackers) it won't scale.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by PascLeRasc on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:19PM (#24654341)
What's also being implied with background checks, even when they say it's relevant like with checking if a pharmacist has drug charges, is that prison does not work. If it reformed people, it wouldn't matter what your history is, because you went through a reforming process and learned to manage the root cause of why you committed a crime, like poor mental health. Instead we just send people to prison for our own sense of "punishment".
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by mmmBacon on Thursday October 01, 2020 @06:01PM (#24656600)
I agree. I think if you went to prison, you served your debt to society and are square with the house. Your punishment should stop. This includes inability to find work etc... with some sensible limits for certain high-trust related positions.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by mc32 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:21PM (#24652775)
I agree. We should definitely have more of this and trades training for people in lock up, so they can do something productive once they get out.

Instead of hitting the weights every day, they can engage in productive learning. We all benefit.

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by Master_Odin on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:40PM (#24653896)
Except for the privatized prisons who don't actually want to rehabilitate their inmates so that they're more likely to recidivate and end up back in prison. The prison system has to be completely overhauled and freed from capitalism at the expense of human life.
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by rootusrootus on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:40PM (#24654597)
Private prisons make up 8.4% of the total prison population. [0]

Interestingly, that's less than half what it is in Australia and UK.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#:~:text=Statist....

[dead]
Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by anoonmoose on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:53PM (#24654758)
[FARMER] You'll have to go/ I'll pay you off for the day/ Collect your bits and pieces there/ And be on your way

[VALJEAN] You have given me half/ What the other men get/ This handful of tin/ Wouldn't buy my sweat

[LABORER] You broke the law/ It's there for people to see/ Why should you get the same/ As honest men like me

Re:My friend starts her job today, after learning to program... by ehsankia on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:38PM (#24653873)
What's the point of serving time if you still have to keep getting punished afterwards. According to you, every person who's committed a crime should have a life sentence?