Consider modeling the game of tic tac toe. You can prove that certain strategies always win. If you then proceed to play it with that strategy against the aliens, then you will certainly win the game, regardless of how their logic looks. (this assumes you're starting of course)
That just means proof is no different to an arbitrary set of rules defined acting like a compiler/interpreter for a programming language.
So just Infinite monkey patched classes of definitions... fun.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
Said another way, if you have a dictionary translating, it doesn’t mean the definition is equivalent. In fact, most definitions aren’t, as each one has its nuance. If following a dictionary to arrive at a result after some steps, it doesn’t imply anything other than a set of rules being followed to arrive at an arbitrary value.
Also interesting is the perspective of mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_brain
Universe as one mind depending on zoomed out vs zoomed in.
However this attribution of mind is simply anything that follows rules. So it’s better to call it “logics” and humans have a property of “bio-logic” abilities. But then what exists outside of logic that allows arbitrary definition of things to represent said logic? The programmer, the consciousness. In general I feel mind exists outside of logic but that’s perhaps a matter of perspective and definition. It gets hard to know where one has defined a conceptual space between continuum and borders and assigning it a range of values.
Rules are not what they are because a rule doesn't have any intrinsic property outside of imagination. It's dependent entirely on consensus and memory.
Without communication, consciousness wouldn't be able to distribute rules. It'd be limited to one mind per set of rules. Communication allows imaginary network effects. Distributed protocol message passing, yay!
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
Weird. Are we just playing games with ourselves? One programmer existing as the programmer of their reality fooling themselves into perspective?
That's what the aliens could potentially do as well, but that would also be math.
So maybe we just need yet another word? Discovented?
The universe exists as a geometry. That geometry has properties with different interactions. The geometry exists regardless, but we can give that geometry a name arbitrarily.
It’s also the difference between music and math which is equivalent to me as frequency and quantifying frequency.
Vibrations interact with each other. Mathematics is the observation and labeling of interaction(s).
Tricky because vibrations are continuous and now we’ve got a can of worms on continuous and non continuous numbers. Haha.
Tic tac toe doesn't have a forced win though ...
“A 3×3 game is a draw. More generally, the first player can draw or win on any board (of any dimension) whose side length is odd, by playing first in the central cell and then mirroring the opponent's moves.”
In the end does it really matter though? Is it maybe not just that inventions and discoveries have more things in common than some intuitively think? Tons of people are not really found of patents, or at least of some class of patents, because the line is arguably blurry (so yeah there is a practical way in which case it do matter, but only because of a completely arbitrary social organisation)
That isn't an approximation. It is a core principle, not just of math, but of the laws of our universe. It is so core, that it's impossible to imagine a universe without it.
or maybe it is an approximation. Maybe there is some essence of the universe that gives is additiveness - and maybe if you could see closer/bigger/faster, maybe that too would break down.
We should take nothing for granted.
1 river + 1 river = 1 river
1 stick - 1/2 stick = 2 stick
But try the first two with the following substitutions:
"drop of water" => "volume of a drop of water"
"river" => "flow rate of a river"
And you're back to addition and correct answers.
The point mostly being, any symbolic representation is only that. It is never universal. And to think it’s an objective representation of anything is serious error.
2 = 2 is true
2 ≠ 2 is false
But 1 river = 1 river is true
1 river ≠ 1 river is also true under some circumstancesMath is our reality, and not a universal reality/law/principal (while science conservation of energy/matter is universal). There are no addition/subtraction happening in the universe.
Addition is not conservation. But that's how we see it.
Then as 1 and 1 totaling two rivers they come together then exist as 1.
Representation is relative on an arbitrary border of quantity. The rules leak for any rule that exists.
One father and one mother have a kid. One and one make another one totaling three.
• and • make •.
Usually a person will substitute 1 for the observation of a “thing” so • will be father, and another • mother +1+1=+1
One unit and another one unit makes a third unit. Yet one unit plus another unit is two units.
Not really. If I look at a map and see the Amazon river, and then see the Nile, Amazon + Nile ≠ 1 river. They're still two separate rivers. Adding rivers means merging sets of rivers under consideration, not merging actual rivers.
All you're doing now is playing with different operations that are not what the symbol "+" stands for.
All definitions are nuanced and subjective based on path of least resistance heuristics.
It’s often miscommunication is happening because expected results are misaligned despite using same rules/language.
It’s quite complex. It’s really interesting but also leads to poor communication. Do we try to embed in our cultures to align on expectation and values to improve this or always doomed to potentially fatal inconsistencies? I guess the dynamics of any rules naturally incentivize behavior whether it’s negative or positive.
1 is an abstract concept applied to many things that share this "singleton property".
Nothing is equal in universe. Everything is its own thing. 1 drop of water != another 1 drop of water. Two different entities.
Only in math we have 1=1 or 1+1=2. And math doesn't work for universe, it works for science.
There’s different ways to count based on the dynamics of the system you’re interacting with.
One interaction interacting with another interaction can create a third interaction causing the system to interact as as pieces totaling 3 that came from a 1 and a 1.
1+1=3.
Also, my brain may be split into two spheres however is it better to reason about it as 1+1=2 me’s or 1^2? Funny joke if I use i^2 then I’m just imaginary. Hah.
Ultimately anything we describe as “is” isn’t anything other than agreement of some type of axiom which requires consciousness / imagination.
Lots to ponder. Ha.
If we can't agree on what the words mean, we can't really have a conversation.
More or less consistent enough is certainty.
Nuances exist, as well as unknown side effects.
When has any definition you thought were fixed expanded?
It’s a weird space.
When I figure out I have misunderstood something, it's not the definition that changes. It's my map of it. The map is not the territory.
Setting 1+1=2 creates patterns that often useful in real life (e.g. counting discrete objects). But it's by no means some universal law.
In this case setting 1+1=0 creates other patterns useful for error correcting codes.
Now, of course the symbols of math are invented. But math is the study of mathematical _objects_, and it’s very unclear if those are invented or discovered.
For example, the Curry-Howard isomorphism shows that math proofs and computer programs are the same mathematical object. Does this mean that they are a part of nature, and we discovered them because we invented a sufficiently powerful mathematical system? Or are they simply properties of the invented system?
We do not (and most likely can not) know the answer to that question. If someone is extremely convicted when offering an answer to it, consider me completely suspicious.
We use math based on the status of a sea of transistors to store it in other atoms with forces we're slowly discovering how to communicate about. It's all layers of finding new ways to describe something that was already there, spinning and bumping photons long before any of us had photon detectors in our heads or a chemical machine capable of deciding to call one pattern A and all the ways to translate it into sound waves.
One pattern is called "solid state drive," and we seem to have some say in what that pattern does from our frame of reference. Maybe it was always a solid state drive and we're the language the universe uses to describe its smaller parts.
I promise I'm not high, and probably not a Boltzmann brain. Though I'm not sure about the latter.
It seems fairly clear that the as yet uncalculated digits of pi are there to be discovered rather than waiting for someone to invent them.
We must do better! Good link for anyone really.
But if it is invented then could we not have avoided inventing some of the more gnarly bits? If math is invented then, say, irrational numbers were a terrible mistake.
The building blocks of math are entirely abstract, but once we define a circle in any half-satisfying way then all of the results in algebra, calculus and geometry are largely set in stone. After the invention of the circle in pre-written-history, most of the math that followed was discovery of the implications.
Rational numbers are arguably nice and easy. But if all we have are rational numbers, 2 doesn't have a square root. More in general, our number line has holes, and one of the most fundamental properties of analysis - that every non-empty bounded set has a least upper bound - goes away. We could do away with that (and arguably, irrational numbers don't really exist "in the outside world") but it would make all the calculations so much more complicated.
No model can ever represent nature. A model helps prediction which helps convergence to certainty through consensus.
Although this opens a can of worms of what “accurately represented” means. A threshold comes into account. Then it unpacks into what is existence.
Fun stuff...
I’ve been thinking a lot of “errors” in our models (language, ideas, etc) are emergent from not considering change. Nothing in the universe is still. Everything changes or vibrates. The only things that are still, don’t exist.
It makes me imagine that we need an evolution in our language and core reasoning that intrinsically embeds change and or perspective (relativity?)
I’ve had this thought recently again based on studying what numbers are. The definition of numerals vs numbers vs integers and number theory, etc...
Even the “numbers” that we try to reference seems to exist as non fixed value of infinite change. Also makes me think of what is that core “thing” that allows a number to expose itself within our frame of reality? It seems to consistently show itself through mathematics and information theory and computer science. Perhaps all related to geometry in some way?
but can you imagine such a set of rules?
(Edit: I am getting downvoted, so let me expand my answer a bit.
Nature is explained using Physics and Physics uses Mathematics for its models of Nature.)
This is part of Godel's discovery. Especially, his first Incompleteness Theorem.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompletenes...
That is to say, even if the incompleteness theorem hadn't been true, math still wouldn't have described nature with perfect accuracy.
Not to mention, the incompleteness theorem hasn't prevented any kind of modelling in physics that I have ever heard of. Indeed, physics is often not entirely constrained by formal methods, with ad-hoc mathematical models that can be shown to work even if they are not fully formalized sometimes being preferred (such as the Dirac delta "function").
Mathematicians use even fewer symbols to say things subject to even stronger internal constraints, so one must pay even closer attention than when reading poetry. (Indeed, almost all people write prose around the symbols as a guide.)
Some poets explore what happens with more, some with fewer, constraints.
Some mathematicians explore what happens with more, some with fewer, constraints.
(Viewed as a MMO game, mathematics introduced the parallel postulate in or before 300 BC and although many people said it ought to be nerfed, the nerfing wouldn't happen until 1830.)
Math, as we know it, is invented. It is one set of rules that we like to use to describe things. It is not the only way. I can imagine an intelligent species that has a structured set of logical rules that looks very different from our math but still be able to make useful models.