That just means proof is no different to an arbitrary set of rules defined acting like a compiler/interpreter for a programming language.
So just Infinite monkey patched classes of definitions... fun.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
Said another way, if you have a dictionary translating, it doesn’t mean the definition is equivalent. In fact, most definitions aren’t, as each one has its nuance. If following a dictionary to arrive at a result after some steps, it doesn’t imply anything other than a set of rules being followed to arrive at an arbitrary value.
Also interesting is the perspective of mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_brain
Universe as one mind depending on zoomed out vs zoomed in.
However this attribution of mind is simply anything that follows rules. So it’s better to call it “logics” and humans have a property of “bio-logic” abilities. But then what exists outside of logic that allows arbitrary definition of things to represent said logic? The programmer, the consciousness. In general I feel mind exists outside of logic but that’s perhaps a matter of perspective and definition. It gets hard to know where one has defined a conceptual space between continuum and borders and assigning it a range of values.
Rules are not what they are because a rule doesn't have any intrinsic property outside of imagination. It's dependent entirely on consensus and memory.
Without communication, consciousness wouldn't be able to distribute rules. It'd be limited to one mind per set of rules. Communication allows imaginary network effects. Distributed protocol message passing, yay!
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
Weird. Are we just playing games with ourselves? One programmer existing as the programmer of their reality fooling themselves into perspective?
That's what the aliens could potentially do as well, but that would also be math.
So maybe we just need yet another word? Discovented?
The universe exists as a geometry. That geometry has properties with different interactions. The geometry exists regardless, but we can give that geometry a name arbitrarily.
It’s also the difference between music and math which is equivalent to me as frequency and quantifying frequency.
Vibrations interact with each other. Mathematics is the observation and labeling of interaction(s).
Tricky because vibrations are continuous and now we’ve got a can of worms on continuous and non continuous numbers. Haha.
Tic tac toe doesn't have a forced win though ...
“A 3×3 game is a draw. More generally, the first player can draw or win on any board (of any dimension) whose side length is odd, by playing first in the central cell and then mirroring the opponent's moves.”
Consider modeling the game of tic tac toe. You can prove that certain strategies always win. If you then proceed to play it with that strategy against the aliens, then you will certainly win the game, regardless of how their logic looks. (this assumes you're starting of course)