News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is Math? by koheripbal on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:46AM (#24598398)
1+1=2.

That isn't an approximation. It is a core principle, not just of math, but of the laws of our universe. It is so core, that it's impossible to imagine a universe without it.

or maybe it is an approximation. Maybe there is some essence of the universe that gives is additiveness - and maybe if you could see closer/bigger/faster, maybe that too would break down.

We should take nothing for granted.

Re:What Is Math? by codegladiator on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:49AM (#24598417)
1 drop of water + 1 drop of water = 1 drop of water

1 river + 1 river = 1 river

1 stick - 1/2 stick = 2 stick

Re:What Is Math? by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 26, 2020 @11:57AM (#24599732)
Now you're cheating, because + and - no longer mean "addition" and "subtraction", but merging and... well, weird division - the last example would be better as 1 stick / 2 = 2 sticks.

But try the first two with the following substitutions:

"drop of water" => "volume of a drop of water"

"river" => "flow rate of a river"

And you're back to addition and correct answers.

Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:29PM (#24599983)
You added additional axioms that require a quantity. Not all things exist as quantities with properties of addition, multiplication, division, or subtraction. Various debates can be had that any quantity is largely an arbitrarily defined border.

The point mostly being, any symbolic representation is only that. It is never universal. And to think it’s an objective representation of anything is serious error.

Re:What Is Math? by codegladiator on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:18PM (#24599891)
Sure we can measure something else to keep a track of whats happening and fit our definitions, but the math remain true, isn't it? It is still 1 river and 1 drop and 2 sticks.
Re:What Is Math? by Tagbert on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:29PM (#24599982)
But 1 river is not a defined measurement. It is has a range of meanings whereas 2 is defined.

  2 = 2 is true
  2 ≠ 2 is false
But

  1 river = 1 river is true
  1 river ≠ 1 river is also true under some circumstances
Re:What Is Math? by codegladiator on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:50PM (#24600213)
You are correct when you say its not a defined measurement. And that is the point. Not defined in math.

Math is our reality, and not a universal reality/law/principal (while science conservation of energy/matter is universal). There are no addition/subtraction happening in the universe.

Addition is not conservation. But that's how we see it.

Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:37PM (#24600065)
It’s one of something. When one of something and one of another thing are observed it’s expressed as 1 and 1 so two rivers become one they represent a quantity of observation.

Then as 1 and 1 totaling two rivers they come together then exist as 1.

Representation is relative on an arbitrary border of quantity. The rules leak for any rule that exists.

One father and one mother have a kid. One and one make another one totaling three.

• and • make •.

Usually a person will substitute 1 for the observation of a “thing” so • will be father, and another • mother +1+1=+1

One unit and another one unit makes a third unit. Yet one unit plus another unit is two units.

Re:What Is Math? by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:50PM (#24600211)
> It’s one of something. When one of something and one of another thing are observed it’s expressed as 1 and 1 so two rivers become one they represent a quantity of observation.

Not really. If I look at a map and see the Amazon river, and then see the Nile, Amazon + Nile ≠ 1 river. They're still two separate rivers. Adding rivers means merging sets of rivers under consideration, not merging actual rivers.

All you're doing now is playing with different operations that are not what the symbol "+" stands for.

Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @01:15PM (#24600421)
I don’t think that you’d be able to communicate the observation of units in a way that’s consistent as a written form of symbology in the rule space of mathematics and the language space used to communicate the mathematics and observation of reality around oneself which leads to relativity.

All definitions are nuanced and subjective based on path of least resistance heuristics.

It’s often miscommunication is happening because expected results are misaligned despite using same rules/language.

It’s quite complex. It’s really interesting but also leads to poor communication. Do we try to embed in our cultures to align on expectation and values to improve this or always doomed to potentially fatal inconsistencies? I guess the dynamics of any rules naturally incentivize behavior whether it’s negative or positive.

Re:What Is Math? by proc0 on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:56AM (#24604782)
1 does not equal "1 of <something>", the latter is a concrete example only (and as mentioned the quantity error, you would have 2 drops of water if the volume of 1 drop stays consistent).

1 is an abstract concept applied to many things that share this "singleton property".

Re:What Is Math? by codegladiator on Sunday September 27, 2020 @08:19AM (#24606090)
If you think about it really hard (since we are at abstract) "1 of <something>" is never equal to any other "1 of <something>"

Nothing is equal in universe. Everything is its own thing. 1 drop of water != another 1 drop of water. Two different entities.

Only in math we have 1=1 or 1+1=2. And math doesn't work for universe, it works for science.

Re:What Is Math? by proc0 on Sunday September 27, 2020 @06:56PM (#24610883)
I disagree, computation has equality, unless you think computer files are not real. Two computations can be equal, and as far as we know we are leveraging this property of the universe. Electrons move and produce patterns which have equality and gives rise to computer state and thus equality of values, not to mention electrons themselves must be indistinguishable given they behave the same.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:58AM (#24598472)
Yeah except it’s not that easy. 1+1=2 but could 1+1=3 too? Yes, even

There’s different ways to count based on the dynamics of the system you’re interacting with.

One interaction interacting with another interaction can create a third interaction causing the system to interact as as pieces totaling 3 that came from a 1 and a 1.

1+1=3.

Also, my brain may be split into two spheres however is it better to reason about it as 1+1=2 me’s or 1^2? Funny joke if I use i^2 then I’m just imaginary. Hah.

Ultimately anything we describe as “is” isn’t anything other than agreement of some type of axiom which requires consciousness / imagination.

Lots to ponder. Ha.

Re:What Is Math? by aliceryhl on Saturday September 26, 2020 @10:36AM (#24599158)
It is that easy. If you got the result 1+1=3, then you changed the meaning of either 1, 3, + or =.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:23PM (#24599938)
In that raw written symbolic form, perhaps. However the nuances exist where the symbols don’t apply but the language is still used. You can observe effects/interactions and say one thing added with another thing makes three things. There is not two things, there’s three things happening now. Also one can be added to another and make one. The “adult” costume for two kids hiding in adult clothing. Two became one interacting as three as a system represented by one. The values are relative. There’s a danger in having such zoomed in views. On one hand we must know when to zoom in, and on the other know how to capture vagueness.
Re:What Is Math? by aliceryhl on Saturday September 26, 2020 @01:09PM (#24600376)
That isn't really about mathematics anymore. With the meanings of the words/symbols that koheripbal intended, 1+1=2 is definitely true, and similarly, with the meaning koheripbal intended, 1+1=3 is definitely false.

If we can't agree on what the words mean, we can't really have a conversation.

Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @01:30PM (#24600547)
That’s kind of the kicker. Many are communicating all day every day with the assumption of equivalence to mappings of words to abstractions and largely get by but it is inconsistent.

More or less consistent enough is certainty.

Nuances exist, as well as unknown side effects.

When has any definition you thought were fixed expanded?

It’s a weird space.

Re:What Is Math? by aliceryhl on Saturday September 26, 2020 @03:08PM (#24601330)
> When has any definition you thought were fixed expanded?

When I figure out I have misunderstood something, it's not the definition that changes. It's my map of it. The map is not the territory.

Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @03:21PM (#24609402)
Precisely.
Re:What Is Math? by j7ake on Sunday September 27, 2020 @05:07AM (#24605270)
For error correcting codes (Hamming), you make 1+1=0 as a starting point.

Setting 1+1=2 creates patterns that often useful in real life (e.g. counting discrete objects). But it's by no means some universal law.

In this case setting 1+1=0 creates other patterns useful for error correcting codes.

Re:What Is Math? by willis936 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:55AM (#24598460)
Do you see addition in the universe, or only in an observer taking account of things in the universe?
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @09:01AM (#24598485)
I like this question. Addition is closer to experience sounds interacting. For example one person playing a note then two notes at once or maybe two instruments start interacting. Either way, it’s our experience of some dynamics based on observation.
Re:What Is Math? by JohnStrangeII on Saturday September 26, 2020 @09:03AM (#24598493)
The observers are part of the universe, too, as is my pocket calculator.
Re:What Is Math? by willis936 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @09:14AM (#24598571)
Turtles all the way down. I think we should try to nail down answers on simple cases before trying to unravel apparent paradoxes.