Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by gregschlom on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:22AM
(#2458295)
It seems that Oracle doesn't understand that the main asset of an Open Source project is it's community, not the code base. And this is not something that you can control at will.
Also, let's not forget that it's not only Open Office. This exact same story is happening to Hudson CI right now. The community has already switched to Jenkins, and I bet it's a matter of time before Oracle announces they discontinue Hudson, too.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by michael_dorfman on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:31AM
(#2458492)
I think that Oracle doesn't view Open Source projects as assets, full stop. They're cost centers, not profit centers.
I don't think Open Office factored into Oracle's analysis of the Sun acquisition at all, and I doubt they'd notice if it disappeared. They've got other things on their minds.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bad_user on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:52PM
(#2460877)
I think they care about Java, especially the standard -- since if you can force compliance by means of patents, trademarks and nebulous copyright-infringement FUD, then it doesn't matter if OpenJDK exists (on the contrary, does wonders for marketing purposes; a supposed "standard" with a reference implementation that's open-source? how can anyone not dig it?).
There is that alternative implementation, called Apache Harmony, that's like this huge elephant in the room of every JCP vote they have, reminding everybody that the Java standard is in fact a tightly controlled, proprietary farce, having nothing to do with standards that are controlled by real standard bodies (although regrettably, besides Google and Apache, nobody had the balls to vote against the Java 7 roadmap; although the members did express concerns, but for the JCP that's as natural as screaming when taking it in the ass forcefully, without consequences for Oracle)
I do hope somebody will fork Java SE (the standard). If Google gets away with Android, maybe Dalvik will evolve to be a drop-in replacement to Harmony's VM.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by keypusher on Monday April 18, 2011 @07:41AM
(#2458719)
Actually, they were working on a Google Docs competitor called Cloud Office that was going to be powered by Open Office. Project appears to have been canceled now and all pages are 404.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by rbanffy on Monday April 18, 2011 @01:28PM
(#2459855)
Ballmer must have called telling how unfortunate would it be if Oracle software were continuously broken by every new security update of Windows Server.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by flomo on Monday April 18, 2011 @04:26AM
(#2458400)
This doesn't surprise me as OpenOffice / StarOffice never really made sense as a business to begin with. Sun invested in it because it allowed them to "eat their own dogfood" (not use Windows) and arguably out of McNealy's obsession with taking down Microsoft.
It will be interesting if the community does anything with it. My guess is that it will be mostly small feature enhancements and integration changes. None of the corporate supporters seem to really want to be in the Office business, so my guess is that any major new release is probably years away, if at all.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by omh on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:31AM
(#2458578)
This only works for projects that Oracle can't see a profiy in. VirtualBox should be fine, maybe even MySQL, but Solaris and Java might be a bit tougher...
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by regularfry on Monday April 18, 2011 @08:01AM
(#2458753)
VirtualBox is significantly less useful (to me, at least) without the guest additions, and they're closed source. I don't know how much effort it would be to clean-room them.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by dspillett on Monday April 18, 2011 @10:42AM
(#2459232)
I expect it wouldn't be difficult for the right people. There would be three problems though:
1. Getting enough "right" people who have enough time on there hands and care enough together to work on it
2. Lots and lots and lots and lots of testing in many different environments to make sure the replacement code is at least as stable and correct as the closed stuff
3. The possibility of patent and other IP related problems
3 may not be an issue (other virtualisation options like KVM and Xen have not been attacked this way (yet)). 1 is an issue right now but would probably stop being so if Oracle starting being a problem in this area (in which case the right people would be affected and either want to work on this for their own needs or would just jump ship to another solution). 2 would be the biggie though. Given how core the code is it would take quite some effort to prove to its potential users (including the people working on it!) that it is at least as safe as that which it replaces.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by keeperofdakeys on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @06:29AM
(#2462176)
I'm suprised that the guest additions are not open-source, shouldn't be not that difficult to make them, as you have the api documented in the main VirtualBox software.
The one good thing Oracle did was put VirtualBox back into one version and make the extensions a separate package. Also adding usb 1.0 support into the main package.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ilikejam on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:22PM
(#2460983)
Is this really a surprise to anyone? Oracle have been pretty clear that they're only going for high-end infrastructure deployments, so they're probably glad that OpenOffice has been taken off their hands. They're likely waiting for someone to take MySQL off them in a convincing way as well to get the EU off their back.
Oracle are only interested in turn-key hardware-OS-DB-middleware stacks, and you better believe they don't give a flying toss about anything Sun owned that doesn't fit in that vertical. It wouldn't surprise me if they end up refusing to support anything that isn't mounted in an Sun/Oracle 19" rack (to be honest, that might not be a bad thing - Sun/Oracle racks are pretty nice).
To be completely clear: Oracle really, genuinely, absolutely, does not care about anything which doesn't fit into their model. I've been on the receiving end of a number of Oracle support (re)negotiations, and it never works out well for anyone that doesn't have a red O on their business card. Buy Oracle shares if you have the cash, but stay the hell away from their products if at all possible.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by Vlasta on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:20AM
(#2458294)
What bothers me is the trademark issue. Why should Oracle keep OpenOffice and the fork has to use another name? Trademarks exist to protect the public. Which of the projects is more true to the original one?
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bruce511 on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:37AM
(#2458316)
Trademarks are a legal thing - they are in effect "owned by someone". While the _code_ is open-source, that doesn't mean other people can come along and just use your trademark. Nor does it mean that a project originator should just have to "give up" the trademark to anyone who comes calling.
If you want the trademark to be owned by a neutral body, then by all means create a body to hold the trademark. That's a choice for the project originator (who usually holds the trademark). In this case there's no dispute that Oracle "owns" the trademark.
Leaving aside the legal implications of a trademark for the moment, your hypothesis is flawed at a social level. Who, after all, is "the community". Let's take an imaginary product - which was created by Fred and is now being developed by a "community" of 10 developers. There are say 200 users of the product.
Now 3 of Fred's developers decide to go and work on a fork. Does Fred give them rights to use his product name? What then does he call his product? How do customers differentiate between the two products with the same name? Since anyone can fork at any time, should we have 25 projects with the same name in the same product space?
Ok, 3 seems a little low - what about 6? What if 3 of those developers joined the project in the last month? Does their leaving count as more or less? What about if 9 developers leave?
How best then to determine which is best for the community of users? Who determines which project is "more true" to the original project? what criteria do we use to measure"trueness"? Does the language dictate trueness? Does the location of the original project lead?
In other words, your point is completely moot. Oracle gets to keep the name because they own it. period. (Although it seems they might now be prepared to give it up.) People have the right to fork the code at any time they like, but it's not in our interest to allow them to use the same name. The public is best served, and protected, by changing the name of forked projects. Anything else is just worse.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by Vlasta on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:45AM
(#2458325)
It is not that easy - that's why I added the comment - to start the discussion about open source and trademarks.
From wikipedia (sorry):
"Trademark law is designed to fulfill the public policy objective of consumer protection, by preventing the public from being misled as to the origin or quality of a product or service. By identifying the commercial source of products and services, trademarks facilitate identification of products and services which meet the expectations of consumers as to quality and other characteristics."
Trademarks exist to protect consumers, not the "owning" companies. In case of open source projects, this does not work so well and there are problems you have mentioned in your reply.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bruce511 on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:36AM
(#2458501)
The "protection" you speak of is that consumers can associate a producer with a product. In this case the producer of the original product was Sun which is now part of Oracle. Thus someone who gets an update for "Open Office" is getting it from the one true source for Open Office.
The freedoms provided by the Open-Source license allow someone to fork that code to create a "new improved product" - but that product can't be called "Open Office". In this way consumers can't think they're getting x and end up with y.
If the consumers are concerned about Open Office, then it's their choice to go to Libre Office. They are in effect opting-in to a change. Changes of this nature have to be opt-in, there's no way around that.
Allowing multiple people to use a trademark, or worse encouraging court battles over who is the "one true heir" to a trademark would not be in the consumers interest.
Clearly a fork can not have any claim on a product name because if it did there exists the possibility for infinite forks, and infinite products with the same name. This in no way serves the consumer, and specifically it does not facilitate the identification of the product, not does it serve to identify quality or other characteristics.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by Vlasta on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:43AM
(#2458596)
In some countries, when trademarks are transferred, there must be a continuity in the underlying product or the trademark is lost. (You cannot just buy a famous trademark and ship something completely different with a sticker placed on it.)
Anyway, as you stated in the last paragraph, there may be an infinite number of forks, and that is the core of the problem with trademarks and open source. At the moment of forking, the source codes is identical. Then they start to differ. Which one is truer to the original one? Software is not a shoe. I see the continuity of a software project in the philosophy behind it.
Who is the true producer (the one that guarantees the "quality" for the consumer) in this case? The organization or the community? Which part of the community?
In my opinion, this is a big problem that needs to be solved in the future. Maybe using a trademark are not a good idea for an open source project...
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bruce511 on Monday April 18, 2011 @10:18AM
(#2459133)
"In some countries, when trademarks are transferred, there must be a continuity in the underlying product or the trademark is lost."
If you say so, but it's certainly not the case in the US, or most other countries. Ford for example regularly resurrects names like Mustang, or GT40, and there is seldom any continuity in the underlying product. BMW bought Mini from British Leyland, and developed a completely new car, which pays homage to the Mini shape, but there is no continuity between the two products.
In software there are endless accounts of "complete rewrites" which ship under the same name as an earlier product.
I think trademarks work perfectly well in the Open Source space. The project originator (usually) owns the trademark - others are free to get their own name. In this case it's pretty cut & dried. Oracle owns the product Open Office. Anyone can fork it, but the one true "Open Office" is the one from Oracle.
Now you may argue the merits of the fork surpassing the leader, and if customers buy into the argument they can "opt in" to the new fork. That's their choice. I don't think this hurts consumers, and I don't think it hurts Open Source.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by roel_v on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:21AM
(#2458953)
"In some countries, when trademarks are transferred, there must be a continuity in the underlying product or the trademark is lost. (You cannot just buy a famous trademark and ship something completely different with a sticker placed on it.)"
[Citation needed]
In some ways you're technically correct I guess, but you're phrasing it in a way that leads to depictions of reality that are widely inaccurate. The thing is that you can't apply trademarks from one business domain to another willy nilly; but this has nothing to do with the transfer of them. (e.g. if I sell apples under the brand name 'chiquita', that may be a problem, trademark-wise; but selling tv's under the name 'chiquita' may not be). This has nothing to do with the transfer of the trademark.
Then again, I don't claim to know anything more than the generalities of trademarks in just a few countries, so I'm interested in examples of your points from specific legal systems.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by roel_v on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:16AM
(#2458937)
Wikipedia is incomplete here, or flat out wrong, depending on how you interpret the article. Trademark doesn't exist solely to protect consumers, it has multiple functions, of which protecting consumers is one, and protecting companies against unfair competition is another. So your last sentence is incorrect - it does exist, amongst other reasons, to protect the owning companies.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by gojomo on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:18AM
(#2458557)
I'd say LibreOffice is a better name. 'Open' is one of the most overused and diluted terms in tech. 'OpenOffice' sounds like a floorplan or an error state when the last person leaves without locking the door.
And, for the average user, does it matter more that the software is 'open' (whatever that means), or that it is 'free'/'Free' (as hinted by Libre)?
I'd say Oracle did the fork a favor by zealously guarding the old trademark.
In addition, the first 3 pages of a google search for "free office" does not turn up libreoffice (the first hit is OpenOffice). I'm sure this can be fixed with a bit of SEO, but I'm afraid TDF isnt thinking about its target demographic: non techies.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by sandGorgon on Monday April 18, 2011 @01:47PM
(#2459935)
native english speakers - by which I mean USA, Canada and UK - know what libre means.
It's like the word "bazaar" - even if you say "baajaar", you will get most Indians to understand the meaning.
close to 90% asians will not even know the meaning of Libre even if you write it down.
Please understand, I am not debating the relative merit of using the word "open" as opposed to "libre" as a branding exercise - people just dont know what libre is.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by scott_s on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:54PM
(#2460170)
They don't need to know - if they care, they can learn. How many people knew what "ubuntu" meant before the Ubuntu distribution? How many people know what "ubuntu" means now?
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by sandGorgon on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:52PM
(#2460368)
agreed - but the problem is two fold. I can say ubuntu to a person on the street and they remember it, because the word is phonetically easy. Libre isnt.
Again, this is not about branding - "libre" is a word that is extremely difficult to pronounce, read and remember for a lot of asians.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bad_user on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:09PM
(#2460941)
MySQL has the flaw that all dual-licensed projects have; trademark is owned by a for-profit, all copyright is owned by a for-profit -- Oracle is the only one who can sell commercial licenses, Oracle has the privilege to sell commercial support as the owner of the only branch/fork of MySQL that is called "MySQL", all other forks will be forever called MySQL-forks, unless some alternative fork emerges that's so groundbreaking that it will make MySQL irrelevant (or all channels of distribution, like Linux distros, align to stop distribution of MySQL). Basically, as a project, MySQL is mature and has enough clout that it might never exist enough incentive for forks to gain market-share, ever.
That's one of the reasons why I switched to PostgreSQL -- BSD-like license, trademark owned by a nonprofit, has much better popularity and support than all MySQL-forks combined.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by cookiecaper on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:49AM
(#2458235)
I don't think there were any forks as a direct result of the Oracle acquisition, but that's probably because there are several other prominent forks already and many of the MySQL people were displeased with the state of affairs under Sun, let alone Oracle. So most of the exodus had already occurred.
Check out MariaDB and Drizzle as starting points. :)
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by gaius on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:09AM
(#2458456)
Heh, the thing is, MySQL was always open source, and Monty et al have all quit, so Sun really payed $1Bn of their shareholder's money that they couldn't really afford and the only actual asset they got was the domain name mysql.com. And people wonder why they were bought by Oracle...
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bruce511 on Monday April 18, 2011 @10:44AM
(#2459240)
"...only actual asset they got was the domain name mysql.com"
Not true. Apart from the domain, they also got the MySql brand name. More importantly though than that they got the ability to sell MySql licenses.
But wait you say, MySql is free... Well, yes and no. It's free for a limited subset of cases, for the rest you need a license. Now the code can be forked forever, but only Sun (now Oracle) can sell commercial licenses.
MySql is a big deal for Oracle because they are effectively the only ones that can change the licensing conditions for MySql. All MySql forks have to be licensed under the GPL.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by riffraff on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:48AM
(#2458233)
it seems there are quite a few: percona's XtraDB, OurDelta, MariaDB, Drizzle are the first that come to mind, plus HailDB that is a fork of the single InnoDB
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ay on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:26AM
(#2458976)
If you are using only the open source edition of VirtualBox, kvm can do a reasonable job. I run Windows 7 on it in headless mode with VNC - primarily I need it for the presentations, everything else I do from Linux.
My perception was that it is a bit lighter than VirtualBox, and it worked very well so far for me. VBox had a couple of glitches when I was using it before.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ay on Monday April 18, 2011 @04:22PM
(#2460480)
...Then you install Linux and the problem becomes identical to the one we have just solved ;-)
I am saying this semi-seriously: have been using Linux as my primary OS on the desktop for the past 9 years, with half-year deflections to MacOS X and, lately, to Windows 7. But the fluxbox with 0-pixel borders and "focus follows mouse" had always dragged me back. Also in my latest experience, the perception was that Win7 on bare metal ran somewhat slower than Win7 under kvm.
With Windows, I used coLinux (http://colinux.org/). The MacOS X that I used was PPC-based, it was circa 2005, so no reasonable experience there - so if you're for freebies, I suppose VirtualBox is the only option (I just found this: http://www.kju-app.org/ - but since I don't have Mac, no way to see what it does).
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ebiester on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:43PM
(#2460833)
laughs -- As for myself, my (new) laptop dual boots currently, but linux has been a real drain on battery life as the current crop of sandy bridge laptops include two video cards, and I haven't figured out how to turn off the unused one yet.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by jwingy on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:15PM
(#2461338)
Should be an option in the bios to turn off switchable graphics (like optimus). If you're lucky, your laptop also has a chip to switch to discrete or integrated only.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by redthrowaway on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:49AM
(#2458239)
What's your suggestion? That they should have been more restrictive with the OOo community? Oracle screwed the pooch, not by "allowing" TDF to fork, but by driving them to do so in the first place.
If there's a lesson to be learned here, it's that you need to consider community management a top priority if you're planning on relying on open source for a core business product. Sun managed to annoy the OOo community, but it took Oracle to drive them away.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ahi on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:56AM
(#2458254)
I think the suggestion was that if you're going to be restrictive with the OOo community, you better be ready to pick up the slack when they fork. By waving the white flag, Oracle demonstrated that their demands of the open source community are likely bluffs. Oracle needs the community more than the community needs them.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by redthrowaway on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:11AM
(#2458280)
I think that's a fair reading of their post, and I agree with the sentiment. The "don't negotiate with terrorists" line is a pretty inflammatory one to use in this context, however.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by masklinn on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:56AM
(#2458255)
> That they should have been more restrictive with the OOo community?
That they should learn to engage and nurture their OSS projects/communities (or, alternatively, drop them outright/give them out early to their communities).
Right now, they're fucking up on all front: they're creating enmity by locking down projects and behaving as if the project communities were their enemies, and they're still losing the projects to forks.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by theBobMcCormick on Monday April 18, 2011 @11:03AM
(#2459321)
Actually, I'd say community management needs to be a top priority for any business product, it's just that for open source the community is a bit broader.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by ahi on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:50AM
(#2458240)
Their interactions with open source communities have been so hamfisted I would be surprised if they even realized the danger this creates for their other projects. They dropped a product with ballooning development costs. What this means for dynamic community efforts with competing interests is likely lost on the Oracle suits.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p...
by bluedanieru on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:55AM
(#2458248)
I think the comparison between the open source community and terrorism is a bit of a stretch, even ignoring the provocative implication that open source is somehow an act of violence against software development. Mainly, terrorists are necessarily adversarial, whereas the open source community doesn't have to be. I think a more apt comparison would be the police, or even government in general, and the community they serve. People tend to be happier, and more work gets done, when the government listens to and reacts to the concerns of its constituency, than when it doesn't. So it goes for open source.
Also, let's not forget that it's not only Open Office. This exact same story is happening to Hudson CI right now. The community has already switched to Jenkins, and I bet it's a matter of time before Oracle announces they discontinue Hudson, too.
I don't think Open Office factored into Oracle's analysis of the Sun acquisition at all, and I doubt they'd notice if it disappeared. They've got other things on their minds.
There is that alternative implementation, called Apache Harmony, that's like this huge elephant in the room of every JCP vote they have, reminding everybody that the Java standard is in fact a tightly controlled, proprietary farce, having nothing to do with standards that are controlled by real standard bodies (although regrettably, besides Google and Apache, nobody had the balls to vote against the Java 7 roadmap; although the members did express concerns, but for the JCP that's as natural as screaming when taking it in the ass forcefully, without consequences for Oracle)
I do hope somebody will fork Java SE (the standard). If Google gets away with Android, maybe Dalvik will evolve to be a drop-in replacement to Harmony's VM.
Larry must think Microsoft has enough enemies to keep it in check without Oracle having to devote resources to that.
It will be interesting if the community does anything with it. My guess is that it will be mostly small feature enhancements and integration changes. None of the corporate supporters seem to really want to be in the Office business, so my guess is that any major new release is probably years away, if at all.
1. Getting enough "right" people who have enough time on there hands and care enough together to work on it
2. Lots and lots and lots and lots of testing in many different environments to make sure the replacement code is at least as stable and correct as the closed stuff
3. The possibility of patent and other IP related problems
3 may not be an issue (other virtualisation options like KVM and Xen have not been attacked this way (yet)). 1 is an issue right now but would probably stop being so if Oracle starting being a problem in this area (in which case the right people would be affected and either want to work on this for their own needs or would just jump ship to another solution). 2 would be the biggie though. Given how core the code is it would take quite some effort to prove to its potential users (including the people working on it!) that it is at least as safe as that which it replaces.
The one good thing Oracle did was put VirtualBox back into one version and make the extensions a separate package. Also adding usb 1.0 support into the main package.
Oracle are only interested in turn-key hardware-OS-DB-middleware stacks, and you better believe they don't give a flying toss about anything Sun owned that doesn't fit in that vertical. It wouldn't surprise me if they end up refusing to support anything that isn't mounted in an Sun/Oracle 19" rack (to be honest, that might not be a bad thing - Sun/Oracle racks are pretty nice).
To be completely clear: Oracle really, genuinely, absolutely, does not care about anything which doesn't fit into their model. I've been on the receiving end of a number of Oracle support (re)negotiations, and it never works out well for anyone that doesn't have a red O on their business card. Buy Oracle shares if you have the cash, but stay the hell away from their products if at all possible.
If you want the trademark to be owned by a neutral body, then by all means create a body to hold the trademark. That's a choice for the project originator (who usually holds the trademark). In this case there's no dispute that Oracle "owns" the trademark.
Leaving aside the legal implications of a trademark for the moment, your hypothesis is flawed at a social level. Who, after all, is "the community". Let's take an imaginary product - which was created by Fred and is now being developed by a "community" of 10 developers. There are say 200 users of the product.
Now 3 of Fred's developers decide to go and work on a fork. Does Fred give them rights to use his product name? What then does he call his product? How do customers differentiate between the two products with the same name? Since anyone can fork at any time, should we have 25 projects with the same name in the same product space?
Ok, 3 seems a little low - what about 6? What if 3 of those developers joined the project in the last month? Does their leaving count as more or less? What about if 9 developers leave?
How best then to determine which is best for the community of users? Who determines which project is "more true" to the original project? what criteria do we use to measure"trueness"? Does the language dictate trueness? Does the location of the original project lead?
In other words, your point is completely moot. Oracle gets to keep the name because they own it. period. (Although it seems they might now be prepared to give it up.) People have the right to fork the code at any time they like, but it's not in our interest to allow them to use the same name. The public is best served, and protected, by changing the name of forked projects. Anything else is just worse.
From wikipedia (sorry): "Trademark law is designed to fulfill the public policy objective of consumer protection, by preventing the public from being misled as to the origin or quality of a product or service. By identifying the commercial source of products and services, trademarks facilitate identification of products and services which meet the expectations of consumers as to quality and other characteristics."
Trademarks exist to protect consumers, not the "owning" companies. In case of open source projects, this does not work so well and there are problems you have mentioned in your reply.
The freedoms provided by the Open-Source license allow someone to fork that code to create a "new improved product" - but that product can't be called "Open Office". In this way consumers can't think they're getting x and end up with y.
If the consumers are concerned about Open Office, then it's their choice to go to Libre Office. They are in effect opting-in to a change. Changes of this nature have to be opt-in, there's no way around that.
Allowing multiple people to use a trademark, or worse encouraging court battles over who is the "one true heir" to a trademark would not be in the consumers interest.
Clearly a fork can not have any claim on a product name because if it did there exists the possibility for infinite forks, and infinite products with the same name. This in no way serves the consumer, and specifically it does not facilitate the identification of the product, not does it serve to identify quality or other characteristics.
Anyway, as you stated in the last paragraph, there may be an infinite number of forks, and that is the core of the problem with trademarks and open source. At the moment of forking, the source codes is identical. Then they start to differ. Which one is truer to the original one? Software is not a shoe. I see the continuity of a software project in the philosophy behind it.
Who is the true producer (the one that guarantees the "quality" for the consumer) in this case? The organization or the community? Which part of the community?
In my opinion, this is a big problem that needs to be solved in the future. Maybe using a trademark are not a good idea for an open source project...
If you say so, but it's certainly not the case in the US, or most other countries. Ford for example regularly resurrects names like Mustang, or GT40, and there is seldom any continuity in the underlying product. BMW bought Mini from British Leyland, and developed a completely new car, which pays homage to the Mini shape, but there is no continuity between the two products.
In software there are endless accounts of "complete rewrites" which ship under the same name as an earlier product.
I think trademarks work perfectly well in the Open Source space. The project originator (usually) owns the trademark - others are free to get their own name. In this case it's pretty cut & dried. Oracle owns the product Open Office. Anyone can fork it, but the one true "Open Office" is the one from Oracle.
Now you may argue the merits of the fork surpassing the leader, and if customers buy into the argument they can "opt in" to the new fork. That's their choice. I don't think this hurts consumers, and I don't think it hurts Open Source.
[Citation needed]
In some ways you're technically correct I guess, but you're phrasing it in a way that leads to depictions of reality that are widely inaccurate. The thing is that you can't apply trademarks from one business domain to another willy nilly; but this has nothing to do with the transfer of them. (e.g. if I sell apples under the brand name 'chiquita', that may be a problem, trademark-wise; but selling tv's under the name 'chiquita' may not be). This has nothing to do with the transfer of the trademark.
Then again, I don't claim to know anything more than the generalities of trademarks in just a few countries, so I'm interested in examples of your points from specific legal systems.
And, for the average user, does it matter more that the software is 'open' (whatever that means), or that it is 'free'/'Free' (as hinted by Libre)?
I'd say Oracle did the fork a favor by zealously guarding the old trademark.
This is not an untested axiom, it is a reality that I face. Most people understand even a highly accented "open office". OTOH, listen to these vastly different pronounciations of libre : http://www.forvo.com/word/temps_libre/ http://www.forvo.com/word/libre/
In addition, the first 3 pages of a google search for "free office" does not turn up libreoffice (the first hit is OpenOffice). I'm sure this can be fixed with a bit of SEO, but I'm afraid TDF isnt thinking about its target demographic: non techies.
Which non-native english speakers are you talking about?
My pronunciation (as a native english speaker) is pretty much like the spanish version I guess.
That said I don't think it's a particular fantastic name.
It's like the word "bazaar" - even if you say "baajaar", you will get most Indians to understand the meaning.
close to 90% asians will not even know the meaning of Libre even if you write it down.
Please understand, I am not debating the relative merit of using the word "open" as opposed to "libre" as a branding exercise - people just dont know what libre is.
Again, this is not about branding - "libre" is a word that is extremely difficult to pronounce, read and remember for a lot of asians.
Would LibOffice be better or about the same?
How about LibaOffice or LireOffice? (I know both 'li' and 'ba' or 're' are chinese syllables that can be written in pinyin.)
Even if they can't change, maybe there could be an official alt-name for native Asian-language speakers.
LibOffice would be infinitely better in terms of pronounciation.
Not that anyone who would use the root and assume is a library wouldn't already know better, but just sayin :)
Are they? Not very, IMO.
Ask a German how to pronounce "Python" :-)
http://www.forvo.com/word/python
You could fork before, you can fork now, right? How is ceasing of commercial development a net positive? It just seems neutral.
That's one of the reasons why I switched to PostgreSQL -- BSD-like license, trademark owned by a nonprofit, has much better popularity and support than all MySQL-forks combined.
Check out MariaDB and Drizzle as starting points. :)
Not true. Apart from the domain, they also got the MySql brand name. More importantly though than that they got the ability to sell MySql licenses.
But wait you say, MySql is free... Well, yes and no. It's free for a limited subset of cases, for the rest you need a license. Now the code can be forked forever, but only Sun (now Oracle) can sell commercial licenses.
MySql is a big deal for Oracle because they are effectively the only ones that can change the licensing conditions for MySql. All MySql forks have to be licensed under the GPL.
Wonder what's next...
My perception was that it is a bit lighter than VirtualBox, and it worked very well so far for me. VBox had a couple of glitches when I was using it before.
I am saying this semi-seriously: have been using Linux as my primary OS on the desktop for the past 9 years, with half-year deflections to MacOS X and, lately, to Windows 7. But the fluxbox with 0-pixel borders and "focus follows mouse" had always dragged me back. Also in my latest experience, the perception was that Win7 on bare metal ran somewhat slower than Win7 under kvm.
With Windows, I used coLinux (http://colinux.org/). The MacOS X that I used was PPC-based, it was circa 2005, so no reasonable experience there - so if you're for freebies, I suppose VirtualBox is the only option (I just found this: http://www.kju-app.org/ - but since I don't have Mac, no way to see what it does).
Not that this comparison is 100% accurate, but they could learn from why the police don't give in to terrorist demands.
If there's a lesson to be learned here, it's that you need to consider community management a top priority if you're planning on relying on open source for a core business product. Sun managed to annoy the OOo community, but it took Oracle to drive them away.
That they should learn to engage and nurture their OSS projects/communities (or, alternatively, drop them outright/give them out early to their communities).
Right now, they're fucking up on all front: they're creating enmity by locking down projects and behaving as if the project communities were their enemies, and they're still losing the projects to forks.