News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by ThePinion on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:14AM (#2458176)
Amazing! Now let's get MySQL back!
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by haberman on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:07AM (#2458449)
I'm not understanding what the community has gained from this, or what would be gained if the same thing happened to other projects like MySQL.

You could fork before, you can fork now, right? How is ceasing of commercial development a net positive? It just seems neutral.

Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by bad_user on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:09PM (#2460941)
MySQL has the flaw that all dual-licensed projects have; trademark is owned by a for-profit, all copyright is owned by a for-profit -- Oracle is the only one who can sell commercial licenses, Oracle has the privilege to sell commercial support as the owner of the only branch/fork of MySQL that is called "MySQL", all other forks will be forever called MySQL-forks, unless some alternative fork emerges that's so groundbreaking that it will make MySQL irrelevant (or all channels of distribution, like Linux distros, align to stop distribution of MySQL). Basically, as a project, MySQL is mature and has enough clout that it might never exist enough incentive for forks to gain market-share, ever.

That's one of the reasons why I switched to PostgreSQL -- BSD-like license, trademark owned by a nonprofit, has much better popularity and support than all MySQL-forks combined.

Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by zacharypinter on Monday April 18, 2011 @10:03AM (#2459080)
It removes any vague sense of the main corporate sponsor being in charge.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by SriniK on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:44AM (#2458226)
+1 for the idea. Should do the same for Java too.
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by poundy on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:44AM (#2458225)
Are there any forks yet? Is it harder or easier to fork a project like MySQL?
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by cookiecaper on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:49AM (#2458235)
I don't think there were any forks as a direct result of the Oracle acquisition, but that's probably because there are several other prominent forks already and many of the MySQL people were displeased with the state of affairs under Sun, let alone Oracle. So most of the exodus had already occurred.

Check out MariaDB and Drizzle as starting points. :)

Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by gaius on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:09AM (#2458456)
Heh, the thing is, MySQL was always open source, and Monty et al have all quit, so Sun really payed $1Bn of their shareholder's money that they couldn't really afford and the only actual asset they got was the domain name mysql.com. And people wonder why they were bought by Oracle...
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by bruce511 on Monday April 18, 2011 @10:44AM (#2459240)
"...only actual asset they got was the domain name mysql.com"

Not true. Apart from the domain, they also got the MySql brand name. More importantly though than that they got the ability to sell MySql licenses.

But wait you say, MySql is free... Well, yes and no. It's free for a limited subset of cases, for the rest you need a license. Now the code can be forked forever, but only Sun (now Oracle) can sell commercial licenses.

MySql is a big deal for Oracle because they are effectively the only ones that can change the licensing conditions for MySql. All MySql forks have to be licensed under the GPL.

Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by riffraff on Monday April 18, 2011 @02:48AM (#2458233)
it seems there are quite a few: percona's XtraDB, OurDelta, MariaDB, Drizzle are the first that come to mind, plus HailDB that is a fork of the single InnoDB
Re:Oracle gives up on OpenOffice after community forks the p... by lawnchair_larry on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:25AM (#2458299)
Percona was not really a fork. That was a performance patch for InnoDB from long before the acquisition.