News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by cabaalis on Monday September 14, 2020 @08:42PM (#24476736)
None of this would be important if social media gave us what they originally sold us: See updates from your friends, family, and people you want to see updates from, in chronological order, rather than based upon weird engagement algorithms and privacy-destroying ad networks.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by Consultant32452 on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:07PM (#24477222)
Why would they give up control of the world by doing something silly like that? Think about how much political influence Twitter has based solely on which tweets they show the President and corporate press. Consider how much untraced in-kind donations these companies can make by tweaking which news stories you see. The crazy thing about it is these things can be tweaked by humans, but it's largely controlled by AI now, which no one person will completely understand what's happening in any of these systems. We're in the early stages of AI controlling the global political future and it will tend to create whatever kind of future generates the most clicks. It's kind of like the game Universal Paperclips, except with clicks/rage/ads.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by throwaway13337 on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:12PM (#24477244)
This needs to be more understood by the population.

Our world-destroying-AI paperclip maximizer is here. It's called a "news feed".

The thing that gets the most clicks is outrage, as the AI has discovered. We're setting people against each-other in a more and more efficient fashion.

The result has been clear since the Arab Spring. Good things don't come from helping people hate each-other in the most efficient way possible.

Banning AI-driven-click-maximizing news feeds would be a healthy start. Right now, they're doing serious damage to our world.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:43PM (#24477401)
We are, but the blame has to be shared, too. In many cases the algorithm is being reinforced by your and everyone's actions. It may not even necessarily be specifically trying to prioritize polarizing content: that just might be the content you engage with the most, and the algorithm blindly follows your whims and preference.

I've used YouTube for many hours per day for several years. I've almost never seen a single thing appear on my home page that was polarizing or even clickbaity. The very rare times I do (always after I watch something that's kind of adjacent), I just click "Not interested" and I never see it or anything like it again. It's done a pretty good job of predicting what I would and wouldn't be interested in.

Same with Twitter. I just unfollow anyone I find tweeting polarizing or charged things. My Twitter feed looks pretty close to the HN front page.

Many people crave these things, whether they want to or even realize it. I think it's going to be this way for a very long time.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by cageface on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:57PM (#24477481)
Sorry but this is a very naive view of human psychology. The Social Dilemma on Netflix does a good job of explaining why asking people to just exert more willpower is not the solution.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:14PM (#24482990)
Maybe it is. I just am repulsed by stuff like that and try to get it out of my sight whenever possible. I figure most of HN is the same way. It pretty much never appears on any of my feeds, since I don't hesitate to click the "Not interested" button on the rare occasions it appears.

I'll watch that film, though.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by Consultant32452 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:13PM (#24483756)
The new AI is different than the algorithms of old. The old algorithms are one size fits all and everyone get exactly the same schlock. The new AI knows you individually and shows you as an individual the kinds of things that you are most likely to engage with. It doesn't matter at all if the kinds of things you as an individual are more likely to engage with have less inflammatory headlines. The system is still doing the same thing to you as it's doing to everyone else.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:01PM (#24489154)
Right. But that was exactly what I was saying in my initial post (above my previous reply).
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by licebmi__at__ on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:17PM (#24477576)
That is, until you click even accidentally on a single outrage clickbait video, then youtube would immediately suggest at least 20 other videoa of the same kind and you have to click “not interested” to videos for several weeks until your feed is sane again.

And IME, it doesn’t even have to be videos watched by most of the people, but a subset of “power users” who binge certain kind of videos are over represented on the recommendation engine.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:06PM (#24482877)
>That is, until you click even accidentally on a single outrage clickbait video, then youtube would immediately suggest at least 20 other videoa of the same kind and you have to click “not interested” to videos for several weeks until your feed is sane again.

For me it takes a single round of a few "Not interested" clicks. Definitely not weeks, or even days.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by coffeefirst on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:02AM (#24477760)
No, it’s being driven by the lowest common denominator for engagement, which is distinct from personal preferences.

For a self-contained example, spam in large Facebook groups always rises to the top, because many people comment asking it to be deleted, causing the algorithm to show it to more people, some of which comment, until a moderator finally kills the post.

These kinds of side effects do not happen in a voting based system or a straight chronological feed.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:07PM (#24482893)
For Facebook groups, yes, this is a big problem. That's one reason why I don't use Facebook. For one's personal feed, I don't think the same issue necessarily applies.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by nikitaga on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:03AM (#24478591)
> just might be the content you engage with the most, and the algorithm blindly follows your whims and preference

No, it's the content that other people engage with. Disregarding the whole "engagement is a good metric of how much you want to see something" bullshit, if you served me food based on what other people like to eat, it would be a weird mix of gluten free vegan stuff, and also coke, pizza and doritos.

I don't want any of that shit. I'm not "many people". I don't need to be fed the same irrelevant garbage as them. But the only way to achieve that is to unfollow everyone and not get many useful updates. Which is what I'm doing, but it's just barely useful, and the popular crap still seeps in at every opportunity.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by meowface on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:11PM (#24482949)
That just hasn't been my experience with Twitter or YouTube. (I don't use Facebook or other things.) I agree that would be very annoying if it happened to me, but for some reason it just doesn't seem to. I probably watch so many videos that it's just picked up my preferences well.

I do want to see what other videos are watched by large numbers of people who've watched things I've already watched. That's how I discover new and interesting things. I've found tons of great content that way, and pretty much no clickbaity or LCD / popular crap seeps in (maybe once every few months, but the "Not interested" immediately takes care of it). I don't know how common my experience is.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by r_c_a_d on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:59AM (#24479221)
Nobody likes to eat gluten-free stuff; unfortunately, some people like me have to eat it.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by rapnie on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:05AM (#24478926)
Joe Edelman wrote a nice article about algorithms that are driven by metrics:

"This talk is about metrics and measurement: about how metrics affect the structure of organizations and societies, how they change the economy, how we’re doing them wrong, and how we could do them right."

https://medium.com/what-to-build/is-anything-worth-maximizin...

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by 082349872349872 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:01AM (#24478296)
Yugoslavia was well before the Arab Spring. Of course, that was broadcast, not clicks, but outrage was stoked.

(In Lonnie Athens' theory of violentisation, there's a step where the to-become-radically-violent says to themselves, "I'll become the biggest badass and this will never happen to me again." Milošević has a famous TV speech where, after a spot of "spontaneous violence", he tells ethnic serbs he isn't going to let them be beaten anymore.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O_gcotWY3Y

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by sn41 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:07AM (#24479254)
Yes, this is something that I have realised of late. Very few people except maybe the most psychopathic, start by believing that they are evil. Most of us believe that we are being victimised. Maybe I am an unemployed youth, outraged at the fact that some minority got a job while I am unemployed. I completely ignore the fact that I am not as qualified as the other person and comfort myself with some victimhood myth.

These minor grievances are later amplified by demagogues. The reaction to this perceived victimisation is so out of proportion that the initial grievance looks minuscule in retrospect.

The main difference these days is that we don't need a visible demagogue. The various "engagement algorithms" play the role of an echo chamber which sends opinions into a positive feedback loop until it enters the regime of social collapse.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:13AM (#24479291)
Yup. The Rwanda genocide was incited by radio.

You could also argue that the original rise of Fascism was enabled by mass propaganda becoming possible where it wasn't really previously, but that's so overdetermined it's hard to attribute to particular causes.

Then there's the original SARS of bad memetic propaganda, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Piece of leafleting from the early 1900s that's contributed to the deaths of millions.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:23AM (#24479341)
And social media is actually less dangerous in this regard then past media like radio and books, because it makes it easy to comment in a way that reaches the consumers of the original media. You can run a radio channel where you rail against ethnic prejudice, but the listeners of radio rwanda are unlikely to listen to your channel. You can write a book refuting the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" but the readers of the original are unlikely to read your book. Social media is different. If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:51AM (#24479778)
> If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.

"Just tell people that racism is bad"

Somehow this seems to make the problem worse not better, because if you're one of the outsiders you just get added to their mental list of conspirators. And if you've commented under your real name you're at risk of reprisals.

Effective debunking is hard.

Oh, and algorithmic social media makes this worse - your act of commenting on a post tends to raise its profile and cause it to be shown to more of your followers.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:25AM (#24479973)
>> If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.

> "Just tell people that racism is bad"

What do you think "inciting ethnic hatred" means? Telling people that ethnic hatred is good? So that the only possible reply is that actually ethnic hatred is bad? No it involves conspiracy theories about an ethnic group, accusations against them, in short, empirical statements that can be refuted.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:27AM (#24482308)
They can be contradicted, but it's very hard to definitively refute them in a way that will convince somebody who wishes to believe it. Even people without a stake in it will often conclude, "I heard X, I heard Y, sounds to me like it could go either way." If anything, they're taken in by how short and empirical those statements are: it makes them seem more true because after all, if it were false I'd see the evidence myself.

There is no statement of fact so definitive that it can overcome a vast barrage of inflammatory conspiracy theory. If that's done in front of a crowd looking for a simple solution to their problems, they'll pay no attention to refutation of "short, empirical statements".

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:47AM (#24482609)
> "I heard X, I heard Y, sounds to me like it could go either way."

Still an improvement compared to "I heard X", which is the default with radio and books.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:52PM (#24483458)
I'm not so sure it is, when there are so many well-funded, concerted efforts to deliberately induce ignorance in people. Radio and books have at least some bottleneck where you can at least try to cut off deliberate falsehoods.

Obviously that doesn't always work, but social media makes it effectively impossible. Not only do you have official sources of propaganda, you live in a swamp of anecdotes that are impossible to refute or contextualize. The radio says "Group X is bad", and you yourself may never have had any trouble with X, but a flood of "X did [bad-thing] to me" stories on social media can make you think that you've got personal exposure to it.

Ultimately, I believe the problem rests with the individuals who are willing to be manipulated. The human organism has a massive security hole that has been very well exploited, and I've got no idea how to patch it. No amount of coherent, cogent argument will change the mind of somebody bent on having a target to hate, and people have gotten very good at insinuating those targets.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:36PM (#24484963)
> I'm not so sure it is, when there are so many well-funded, concerted efforts to deliberately induce ignorance in people. Radio and books have at least some bottleneck where you can at least try to cut off deliberate falsehoods.

I don't see how you can believe these things at the same time. If these efforts to induce ignorance are indeed so well-funded and concerted, how can bottlenecks be an obstacle? Indeed why couldn't these well-funded, concerted efforts use those bottlenecks to cut off people disagreeing with them?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:02PM (#24486673)
I meant to suggest that if you have a few large, expensive propaganda organs, you have some hope of running your own counterpropaganda campaign: disprove it at the source, and maybe you can convince people.

Of course if the money can shut you down entirely, you can't succeed. But it's hard to completely control radio and books. It can be done, but only by making your totalitarianism clear. It's more effective if people think they came to their conclusions on their own, and have been exposed to "all sides".

Today, they can bolster their organized propaganda with a sufficiently effective astroturf campaign (magnified by social media). The two provide confirmation for each other, and appear to be independent. They may even actually be independent; they don't need to formally coordinate if they roughly agree on the ends.

So people believe they're getting "all sides" of the story, and there's no need to shut down disagreement. Instead, people hear the message from two sources that affirm each other, and disregard any disagreement willingly.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by 082349872349872 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:29PM (#24484012)
some ideas on changing minds (not by coherent, cogent argument, but by providing attractive alternatives to hate?): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24373042

also, the remedies chapter of: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxxylK6fR81rckQxWi1hVFFRUDg...

still looking for more in this vein.

from HN, the discussions on https://theintercept.com/2016/09/07/google-program-to-deradi... suggest attempts to de-hate might not be uniformly well-received.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by mschuster91 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:44AM (#24479737)
> You could also argue that the original rise of Fascism was enabled by mass propaganda becoming possible where it wasn't really previously

Genocides and other war crimes have been a staple of humanity since Ancient Greece. Authoritarianism, of which fascism is a subset, only depends on one thing, and that is masses willing to be led.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by claudeganon on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:20AM (#24481463)
...and technologies, including mass propaganda, have extended their reach and scale. They didn’t have trains delivering millions to gas chambers in Athens, helmed by people listening to Hitler’s speeches on the radio.

Saying “x has always existed” is different from the scale at which x is present. That is, in fact, one way that we measure progress. Inarguably, we will never be able to stamp out our baser instincts and behavior, but we should strive to reduce their presence and impact.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by titzer on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:47AM (#24478805)
> We're in the early stages of AI controlling the global political future

If you just broaden your definition of AI a little to include the collective decision-making processes of a market-based corporate-controlled press and political system, this has been going on for decades, if not centuries. It's only recently that computers got added to the mix and inevitably bubbled to the top of the heap. Or, I should say, helped bubble some people to the top of the heap.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by toeget on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:00AM (#24477756)
This is exactly what I'm getting from twitter. My feed are the latest updates shared by the people I follow. I don't see clickbait, I don't see outrage, I have a curated feed aligned with my interests. It's true that about once in a couple of months Twitter decides to switch the order of tweets from the latest to the most recommended, but that's easily fixed in two clicks. The moment twitter removes the option to see the feed in chronological order is the moment I delete twitter.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by sriku on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:22AM (#24477855)
On a slight tangent ... the one thing about HN that lets me breathe is that the links that turn up are the same for everyone on the planet and is not "personalized". If it were, I'd be gone in a jiffy.

Maybe we should rename "personalization" to something with a -ve connotation - perhaps "bubblification"? "narcissization"? "comfortzoned"?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by dwaltrip on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:35AM (#24477916)
Spoonification
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by sriku on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:38AM (#24479098)
Ah yes! Let's just call it the "spoon feed".
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by rapnie on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:08AM (#24478941)
"Sheepified"
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by tareqak on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:16AM (#24478667)
Snowflakified
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by RandallBrown on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:40AM (#24478199)
Facebook had this but everyone decided to friend every person they ever came into contact with, leading to an unmanageable stream of nonsense. Then they introduced the algorithmic feed and it became more manageable.

I personally was fine curating my feed and only friending people I wanted to follow, but that's just not how it came to work socially and culturally.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by save_ferris on Monday September 14, 2020 @08:51PM (#24476809)
If only Facebook chose to make less money...

Seriously though, their choices to run the platform the way they have were fundamentally shaped by profit and the stock market. The type of corporate moderation you’re suggesting doesn’t exist.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by MaysonL on Monday September 14, 2020 @09:18PM (#24476957)
Well – Craigslist and Wikipedia come to mind as counter-examples but it is rare.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by danbmil99 on Monday September 14, 2020 @09:30PM (#24477033)
Just for the record, Craigslist is a for-profit company and makes quite a lot of money. Very different from Wikipedia
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by m463 on Monday September 14, 2020 @09:49PM (#24477118)
> Craigslist is a for-profit company and makes quite a lot of money.

I thought they just made a modest amount of money.

However I believe their benefit to society is significantly higher than fb just because of R number 2. (of "reduce, reuse, recycle")

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by save_ferris on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:02PM (#24477192)
They grossed $694M in 2016, according to Wikipedia[0].

I think Craigslist benefits from a transparent business model that doesn’t rely on capturing and manipulating consumer data. They charge for job ads, which is a pretty straightforward model. Contrast that with the miasmic, tailored advertising business that Facebook has created.

Craigslist isn’t necessarily leaving money on the table, they just operate a more transparent business that’s more closely aligned with the public good. It’s still not realistic to expect companies to not try to maximize their earnings potential, that’s like asking your favorite football team to score fewer touchdowns. Facebook as a business is fundamentally misaligned with the public good.

0: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craigslist

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by duskwuff on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:51PM (#24477446)
They charge for a couple other things, FWIW, but it's mostly commercial postings and certain other big-ticket listings (cars, real estate, services).

https://www.craigslist.org/about/help/posting_fees

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by geofft on Monday September 14, 2020 @09:54PM (#24477146)
Yeah, I think that saying that people are forced to optimize for profit and harm society in the process diminishes their personal agency. Even if you're starting a new venture, you have a lot of choice in how you do it.

Wikipedia and Craigslist are great examples. Craigslist is for-profit, and Wikipedia was originally a project of Bomis, a "web portal" (those words meant things 20 years ago) that tried various things to be profitable and had a good amount of success with softcore pornography. Jimmy Wales was quoted as saying, "You know the press has this idea that I am a porn king. I really wasn't a king of anything, frankly, you know? Because at the time, when we looked at it, we were just like, 'Okay, well, this is what our customers will want, let's follow this.'" And even he, the guy peddling pictures of naked women on the internet because it's what his customers supposedly wanted, ended up spinning off Wikipedia as a non-profit and winding down Bomis.

When you decide to make a company that values profits above all else, it's a choice. You cannot attribute the moral impact of that decision to the invisible hand of the market - the invisible hand cannot reach out and grab things that weren't given to it.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by newen on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:44AM (#24478792)
This is like a tragedy of the commons situation where there are massive, life changing incentives for people to break the commons. You can’t run a society where you hope that all individuals will be good.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by hash872 on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:22PM (#24477304)
What I've long wondered is- would it really be that hard/expensive to build an open source social media alternative that does exactly that? Updates & photos from friends & family, in chronological order, and little else. Social media has been around for a while now, I have to imagine that most of the hard problems around a customized feed and so on have been solved. Probably some idealistic ex-FB and IG engineers would join on, so we'd have their domain expertise. I bet some prominent, wealthy anti-FB types could kick in some seed money to get it off the ground. It could be set up as a non-profit, B corp or foundation of some sort.... You could run non-targeted display ads for brand advertising to help cover costs, with the added lure for advertisers that the site would be brand-friendly because it's non-controversial.

Of course it wouldn't have sophisticated features like photo tagging and such, and probably wouldn't be Hip And Cool for Gen Z, but it could be a functional bare-bones Facebook replacement. You'd have probably have to disable virality features, and maybe linking to external news sites just to prevent your racist uncle from posting Breitbart links, I don't know.

Would that really be so hard? Or do the servers, hosting, security and moderation costs just scale exponentially after some threshold of say 10 million users or what have you? Supposedly Instagram was running with a very small team when Facebook acquired them

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by icelancer on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:19AM (#24477842)
I think you misunderstand.

People want to be mad. They like it.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by SamBam on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:38PM (#24484985)
It's a serious problem.

I have two Twitter profiles. One follows only makers, tinkerers, artists and educators. I mark "do not want to see more posts like these" if anyone posts something political.

I have another one that follows people with strong political views and the latest outrage.

Guess which one makes me feel better when I view it?

Guess which one I find myself viewing more often?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by icelancer on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:33PM (#24486963)
100%. I do the same thing. On my "safe" account I have 80+ muted phrases (mostly political). On my corporate account I don't really have that luxury.

Same feeling.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by Clubber on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:28PM (#24477331)
Building the app is trivial, building the network of users is the hard part.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:56PM (#24477477)
The users are already fragmented and / or using multiple social networking platforms / apps.

Maybe you only need to have some tiny fraction on board to make it worth the effort?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by ByteJockey on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:29PM (#24477335)
Based on a quick glance at the fediverse sites, I think you're looking for friendica.

Link for the curious: https://friendi.ca/

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amelius on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:07PM (#24477527)
The reason I'm still on Facebook is "events". I want to see which events my friends go to. The problem is getting the organizations that host these events to post their events to other platforms.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by throwawayinfo on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:57AM (#24478011)
And what happens when people start discussing politics and advertisers don't like it?
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by falseAss on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:51PM (#24477714)
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by actuator on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:33PM (#24477640)
I think recommended order has its own place. If I go to a social media platform after a week and my friends have posted about 200 posts since then, will I be interested in every post equally? Isn't it better to give me what I will probably like at the top part of the list.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by ChrisLomont on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:48AM (#24479478)
>See updates from your friends, family, and people you want to see updates from

Those same people are often the ones sending misinformation and creating the problems. How do you allow people to post updates and not allow them to spread misinformation that damages society?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:08AM (#24478617)
If people were willing to pay, "privacy-destroying ad networks" which need to be fed by "weird engagement algorithms" wouldn't be necessary, but people demonstrably won't. Ergo...
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by skybrian on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:16PM (#24477263)
Blaming viral content on bad algorithms is naive. All that’s needed for fake content to spread everywhere unchecked are a few bad actors, group messages, and forwarding (the reshare button). In some cases this results in genocide [1]. No fancy algorithms are necessary to get exponential spread of rumors. Friends and family will spread any memes that confirm their biases themselves.

To prevent this from happening, it has to be actively suppressed, or at least there needs to be something slowing it down so it dies off. A hands-off attitude isn’t going to do it.

[1] https://gizmodo.com/facebook-still-working-on-the-whole-geno...

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by cageface on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:59PM (#24477496)
I think this is a good point. Recommendation algorithms exacerbate the problem but they're not the whole story. I don't see how you solve this problem without eliminating the virality that's at the heart of these platforms' profitability. They have a strong vested interest in not fixing it.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by stiglitz on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:50PM (#24477443)
They didn’t sell it to you, is the thing.