News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by 082349872349872 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:01AM (#24478296)
Yugoslavia was well before the Arab Spring. Of course, that was broadcast, not clicks, but outrage was stoked.

(In Lonnie Athens' theory of violentisation, there's a step where the to-become-radically-violent says to themselves, "I'll become the biggest badass and this will never happen to me again." Milošević has a famous TV speech where, after a spot of "spontaneous violence", he tells ethnic serbs he isn't going to let them be beaten anymore.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O_gcotWY3Y

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by sn41 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:07AM (#24479254)
Yes, this is something that I have realised of late. Very few people except maybe the most psychopathic, start by believing that they are evil. Most of us believe that we are being victimised. Maybe I am an unemployed youth, outraged at the fact that some minority got a job while I am unemployed. I completely ignore the fact that I am not as qualified as the other person and comfort myself with some victimhood myth.

These minor grievances are later amplified by demagogues. The reaction to this perceived victimisation is so out of proportion that the initial grievance looks minuscule in retrospect.

The main difference these days is that we don't need a visible demagogue. The various "engagement algorithms" play the role of an echo chamber which sends opinions into a positive feedback loop until it enters the regime of social collapse.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:13AM (#24479291)
Yup. The Rwanda genocide was incited by radio.

You could also argue that the original rise of Fascism was enabled by mass propaganda becoming possible where it wasn't really previously, but that's so overdetermined it's hard to attribute to particular causes.

Then there's the original SARS of bad memetic propaganda, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Piece of leafleting from the early 1900s that's contributed to the deaths of millions.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:23AM (#24479341)
And social media is actually less dangerous in this regard then past media like radio and books, because it makes it easy to comment in a way that reaches the consumers of the original media. You can run a radio channel where you rail against ethnic prejudice, but the listeners of radio rwanda are unlikely to listen to your channel. You can write a book refuting the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" but the readers of the original are unlikely to read your book. Social media is different. If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.
Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:51AM (#24479778)
> If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.

"Just tell people that racism is bad"

Somehow this seems to make the problem worse not better, because if you're one of the outsiders you just get added to their mental list of conspirators. And if you've commented under your real name you're at risk of reprisals.

Effective debunking is hard.

Oh, and algorithmic social media makes this worse - your act of commenting on a post tends to raise its profile and cause it to be shown to more of your followers.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:25AM (#24479973)
>> If someone incites hatred against ethnic groups on facebook you can respond and reach the readers of the original post.

> "Just tell people that racism is bad"

What do you think "inciting ethnic hatred" means? Telling people that ethnic hatred is good? So that the only possible reply is that actually ethnic hatred is bad? No it involves conspiracy theories about an ethnic group, accusations against them, in short, empirical statements that can be refuted.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:27AM (#24482308)
They can be contradicted, but it's very hard to definitively refute them in a way that will convince somebody who wishes to believe it. Even people without a stake in it will often conclude, "I heard X, I heard Y, sounds to me like it could go either way." If anything, they're taken in by how short and empirical those statements are: it makes them seem more true because after all, if it were false I'd see the evidence myself.

There is no statement of fact so definitive that it can overcome a vast barrage of inflammatory conspiracy theory. If that's done in front of a crowd looking for a simple solution to their problems, they'll pay no attention to refutation of "short, empirical statements".

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:47AM (#24482609)
> "I heard X, I heard Y, sounds to me like it could go either way."

Still an improvement compared to "I heard X", which is the default with radio and books.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:52PM (#24483458)
I'm not so sure it is, when there are so many well-funded, concerted efforts to deliberately induce ignorance in people. Radio and books have at least some bottleneck where you can at least try to cut off deliberate falsehoods.

Obviously that doesn't always work, but social media makes it effectively impossible. Not only do you have official sources of propaganda, you live in a swamp of anecdotes that are impossible to refute or contextualize. The radio says "Group X is bad", and you yourself may never have had any trouble with X, but a flood of "X did [bad-thing] to me" stories on social media can make you think that you've got personal exposure to it.

Ultimately, I believe the problem rests with the individuals who are willing to be manipulated. The human organism has a massive security hole that has been very well exploited, and I've got no idea how to patch it. No amount of coherent, cogent argument will change the mind of somebody bent on having a target to hate, and people have gotten very good at insinuating those targets.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by amadeuspagel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @02:36PM (#24484963)
> I'm not so sure it is, when there are so many well-funded, concerted efforts to deliberately induce ignorance in people. Radio and books have at least some bottleneck where you can at least try to cut off deliberate falsehoods.

I don't see how you can believe these things at the same time. If these efforts to induce ignorance are indeed so well-funded and concerted, how can bottlenecks be an obstacle? Indeed why couldn't these well-funded, concerted efforts use those bottlenecks to cut off people disagreeing with them?

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by jfengel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @05:02PM (#24486673)
I meant to suggest that if you have a few large, expensive propaganda organs, you have some hope of running your own counterpropaganda campaign: disprove it at the source, and maybe you can convince people.

Of course if the money can shut you down entirely, you can't succeed. But it's hard to completely control radio and books. It can be done, but only by making your totalitarianism clear. It's more effective if people think they came to their conclusions on their own, and have been exposed to "all sides".

Today, they can bolster their organized propaganda with a sufficiently effective astroturf campaign (magnified by social media). The two provide confirmation for each other, and appear to be independent. They may even actually be independent; they don't need to formally coordinate if they roughly agree on the ends.

So people believe they're getting "all sides" of the story, and there's no need to shut down disagreement. Instead, people hear the message from two sources that affirm each other, and disregard any disagreement willingly.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by 082349872349872 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:29PM (#24484012)
some ideas on changing minds (not by coherent, cogent argument, but by providing attractive alternatives to hate?): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24373042

also, the remedies chapter of: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxxylK6fR81rckQxWi1hVFFRUDg...

still looking for more in this vein.

from HN, the discussions on https://theintercept.com/2016/09/07/google-program-to-deradi... suggest attempts to de-hate might not be uniformly well-received.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by mschuster91 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @06:44AM (#24479737)
> You could also argue that the original rise of Fascism was enabled by mass propaganda becoming possible where it wasn't really previously

Genocides and other war crimes have been a staple of humanity since Ancient Greece. Authoritarianism, of which fascism is a subset, only depends on one thing, and that is masses willing to be led.

Re:A whistleblower says Facebook ignored global political ma... by claudeganon on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:20AM (#24481463)
...and technologies, including mass propaganda, have extended their reach and scale. They didn’t have trains delivering millions to gas chambers in Athens, helmed by people listening to Hitler’s speeches on the radio.

Saying “x has always existed” is different from the scale at which x is present. That is, in fact, one way that we measure progress. Inarguably, we will never be able to stamp out our baser instincts and behavior, but we should strive to reduce their presence and impact.