1. IT professionals absolutely do use such systems. In droves. It's true that we are more likely to be wary of them, but a large number of IT pros I know and work with do use Alexa/Siri/etc. for home automation and all kinds of other things. And no: smart speakers are not "inferior to any type of input mode", at least not in a wide variety of circumstances. I can turn my air conditioner on or adjust its temperature while lying in bed, without getting up, and without even waking up all the way. Try that with another "type of input mode". I can turn on lights while I am stumbling to the bathroom in the middle of the night, but I can easily use only 10% brightness so as to not wake up my wife. Try that with another input mode. I could go on for pages, but I trust the point is made.
2. There are at least 300 million smart speakers out there already, and the number is growing exponentially. Amazon alone already had 100 million sold by the beginning of 2019. I don't know the exact number right now, but it's a very big number.
3. See #2. 300 million units is not a "niche".
4. Brand loyalty, in fact, gives substantial benefits to the consumer, contrary to your assertion. Greater integration of devices and ease of use is the most obvious one.
Brand loyalty, vendor lock-in, financial leverage, etc. are all attempts to interfere with free market, to prevent a consumer moving to a competitor.
There is also no reason you can't have integration between different vendors, in fact thats what standards are for. Apple, etc. are notorious for refusing to integrate to protect their advantage.
The have the right to do that to some, limited, extent, but to advocate it as good for the consumer is just self-delusion.
> Brand loyalty, vendor lock-in, financial leverage, etc. are all attempts to interfere with free market, to prevent a consumer moving to a competitor
As I understand it, the only way to prevent vendor lock-in is regulation. Regulation is considered anathema to a “free market”. Subsequently, I’ve come to expect that a free market _guarantees_ that vendors will attempt to lock their customers in.
I suspect your “ideal market” is not merely an idealised fantasy but also self-contradictory and thus impossible.
I’d love it if you could explain otherwise because it’ll probably help me understand basic economics better.
We don't have actual war yet. But we do have a world of duopolies, in which two (or three or four) control almost all of the business between them. That's not good for customers or suppliers or retailers; it's only good for the rent-seekers who own those companies.
Unfortunately, the U.S. has for several administrations now basically not enforced the antitrust laws unless a short-term rise in prices is visible. Long-time rises in prices, as well as knock-on effects like reduction in quality, are simply ignored.
Ideal market is certainly a fantasy, we have an entire branch of behavioural economics dedicated to irrational behaviour.
On regulation, general consensus is that at least some regulation is needed to enable fair market to exist at all.
In most countries in a state of disorder you get market manipulation, Pump&dump schemes, monopolies, cartels, financial pyramids, snake oil salesmen, etc. That's not conductive to economic growth.
Obviously it is hotly disputed where is the line between ensuring fair competition or, on the contrary, stifling the market.
Cosider car repair - is it the manufacturer's right to decide who they sell parts to, or are they leveraging a position in market A (selling cars) to secure an unfair advantage in market B (car repair)
No, it's the other way around. I don't get updates on my 3 year old phone because I'm loyal to Apple, I'm loyal to Apple because I get updates on my 3 year old phone.
That IS brand loyalty, generated by delivering value, not just fancy advertising. And conversely, the experience customers have with their phone gives them certain expectations should they buy the matching AirPods rather than Bose or even B&O.
When it turns out that the AirPods have special integration with their iPhone, it sets up positive expectations for buying an iPad. And on and on.
The value creates brand loyalty, and the brand loyalty leads consumers to buy more products from the same brand, which increases their value because of the integration within the ecosystem.
When the brand is actually delivering the value, it's a virtuous cycle: value -> brand loyalty -> more value -> more brand loyalty.
Obviously, Apple stole mice and bitmapped graphics and GUIs from Xerox Parc. But a huge part of their pitch for MacOS in the early days was integration between apps on the platform.
Consistency of UX meant that there was lower friction for adopting new apps. Integration between apps such as being able to copy and paste text between apps from different vendors was a revelation by the consumer microcomputer standards of the day.
The only really hostile brands are preventing it to be honest(apple comes to the mind and so does nintendo).
Brand loyalty mattered in the past, where it was the only reliable way to judge new products in relation to each other. It only works to the merit of consumer if you were already subject to vendor lock in.
There are plenty of alternate input modes that work like that too - back in the 90s i had lightswitch that could change intensity of the light dynamically - no need to even utter a word so even less risk of waking your wife up. you can add module to AC and control it via smartphone/webpage, without risk of voice recognition getting it wrong. you can get lights that automatically turn on to 10% brightness when someone walks etc.
not to mention various privacy concerns for your guests - you did agree for amazon to collect the data, but did they agree too?
Speakers sold is kinda a bad metric - active users/usage would be much more interesting - as i wonder how many of them ended up in attic, or thrown somewhere because they were useless.
I agree with the poster you're responding to. The only true automation that hasn't been done in the home are those that are unimportant. I certainly don't need Alexa to open my garage door, regulate the temperature of my house, and so forth. If I really really want to be able to turn lights on and off without walking over to the light switch, I've had options for that for over 20 years now.
The software and wifi connecting has sort of been trash, but the WeMo Smart Dimmer and WeMo Three Way are GREAT pieces of hardware as far as being a LIGHT SWITCH is concerned. It's the apple of switch design. A single button for on or off. Slide your finger up the track for brightness. Long press to control other switches on the network (glitchier.)
https://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F7C059/ https://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-WLS0403/
The Philips ecosystem has a wide range of accessories, including smart dimmer knobs to control smart lights. https://www.lutron.com/en-US/products/pages/standalonecontro... LIFX now has a switch, but I've never actually seen it in stock so it may be vaporware. https://www.lifx.com/products/lifx-switch
It can be annoying when it glitches out, but overall its a positive change. Don't knock it until youve really given it a serious try.
I think what people actually uses them for is very different than what tech and marketing think its for, but there is a massive market and everyday people love it to play music, call another room in a big house, control the light, check what's on tv tonight and if it's raining tomorrow.
Having my 64 years old mom emptying her fridge and then randomly saying "Alexa, what can I cook with VEGETABLE ? [answer] Okay, remind me tomorrow morning" was something very opening, as was "alexa, where is my PRODUCT" to hear about when its delivered.
Especially since I - a tech user - was a first buyer of many of these techs but mostly don't use them.
My mom doesn't know how to use tech. She makes a face when the TV remote has button that are not numbers and arrows, she still doesn't understand nor care about what the 3 buttons at the bottom of her android phone do (home / back / ...), but she has fully integrated alexa into parts her daily routine, yet completly left it out of others that it could handle.
The last time I saw something that eye opening about tech for non tech user was chromecast/firetv.
So yes, I totally understand why those companies want that spot, because whoever gets my mom queries gets her ad profile, gets her delivery orders, her music subscription, dictates what compatible brands she will use, etc ...
This got me thinking —- are folks who can’t/won’t/rarely operate computers but are heavy users of voice control living in a post-ad world? Where would personalizes ads even be displayed? All the streaming services don’t have ads (at the right price point), and sure the buying products through voice devices could push particular brands, but amazon already does that with “amazon’s choice” products and I know many people who will only buy those, so nothing is really changing there. Similar for recommended content on streaming services.
Alexa, buy me the shoes that Kim Kardashian has on her latest instagram pic, size 7.
Amazon will control that gateway and can sell those answers to the highest paying advertiser. That's even better than paying for the #1 position on google search.
And the original comment was specifically about an “ad profile”, which only matters for personalized ads. Without personalized ads, the ad profile is meaningless, so getting one via voice devices is not all that valuable. (Again, for voice-only folks)
I just searched "shoes" on amazon and made a screen capture but you can't post on imgur without an ad blocker apparently.
This means the "ad profile" of folks who do not use screens and only interact with voice is relatively worthless: the best you can do is push them towards buying your brand when they're already looking for your product-class, and at that point the "ad profile" adds relatively little to the experience, probably just an idea of how much money you're willing to spend. Given Amazon doesn't currently adjust search results based on a prediction of how much you'll spend [1], this information is probably not that valuable.
Compare this to the value-add of traditional ad profiles: mine would say that I'm interested in, lets say, high end audio products, outdoor equipment, and dog products, which means anywhere I go online or on mobile apps I constantly get a barrage of ads for various products in these categories. If I see one I'm interested in, I'm likely to buy it right then and there. There's no voice-only equivalent of that, unless people start asking "tell me something I should buy" (Asking "tell me an item in {category} I should buy" is skipping over the ad profile)
All in all, this means folks without screens are post-ad: they will only be shown products they're already looking for (in adjusted order, sure), rather then being shown products they had no idea about but might be interested in. This is bad news for advertising firms and new product developers, though they probably weren't getting much money from these folks in the first place.
[1]: I only buy high-end audio products, I've bought many high-end audio products, and if I search "bookshelf speaker", I'll get cheap trash for the top results, telling me that Amazon is not interested in targeted whale-hunting, for whatever reason.
"Alexa, what's the most healthy butter" would be a better example of something advertisers might pay for.
If I search for shoes on Amazon and I see an advertisement for a different brand amongst the search results, that's fine. I'll ignore it.
If I ask someone what shoes Kardashian was wearing and they give me a single answer that's incorrect, that's an entirely different thing.
>There is vocal but relatively niche group of tech enthusiasts who are really into it, but they are already a brand loyalists.
Are you serious? My 97 year old grandpa even asked me to set up an Alexa for him, so he could shout at her to check the weather. My most tech illiterate friends LOVE those devices, because they're so easy to use.
https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...
What other information do you want?
Why is it so hard to believe that people can be different from you?
I know everyone has a different comfort level, but if you have an infosec background you have to admit you're giving away alot of information and potential control. Maybe you're ok with that.
Yes. My daily work is on vuln detection.
It's true that the field has moved since I graduated. But I still attend conferences and engage with academics for recruiting purposes.
As a detractor of these devices and someone who will never own one unless it does all the voice recognition locally, I found this to my surprise and regret.
First is when your hands are full. If you're in the kitchen, or working with tools, you can get a unit conversion, look up some fact, or change the music.
Second is as an input device to a TV. Particularly when there are a number of different applications you could open. Fidgeting around with a remote is difficult, and even if you had a keyboard it might be on the other side of the room from where you are. (Part of the problem being solved here is integration between apps and input devices, not just the voice input.)
Despite their advantages, the current situation is as if you could only buy a keyboard from 2 or 3 companies, and you were only allowed to type things that they allowed on it. And all your keystrokes were sent to their servers to be interpreted first.
In our household, my wife loves our Google Home's- and uses them constantly. Playing music, broadcasting messages, adding things to grocery list, and following recipes are among her main uses. I tend to use it too for playing music and the grocery list.
I'm not super impressed with any of the assistants "smart" features but in terms of being able to shout canned commands at it in a noisy environment it's top notch.
Alas you get a lot of extras to go with it: An algorithm decides that you then must be hungry so ads for Arby's (they really can't rely on word of mouth) keep popping up in your navigation.
After three such messages an algorithm decides your wife might be in the market for a divorce lawyer, because in 50%+ percent of the cases this might be a sign of marital disagreement. Your wife's newsfeeds change just a little because she is now deemed pro-divorce with messages about huge settlements and divorce horror stories, because those keep people engaged.
Safe driving...
I think you're sort of... following a slippery slope argument past what is reasonable expectable.
As what is reasonably expected (an this is old): https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targ...
It is not a slippery slope argument, because they have that data and can use it as they see fit. I just suggested 2 ways in which Google can make more money with information people shared with them. Why is it reasonable to expect them not to do it?
on the desktop app, I don't see ads, but I see an option to "Show nearby restaurants". If I click that, the map zooms out and shows me nearby restaurants, not ads. It's all informational, not selling me something. In my work computer, I don't have uBlock Origin installed.
Two nights ago, I had Maps tell me "turn right after the McDonald's" because there was a McDonald's at the corner.
Lets face it - IT professionals do not trust such systems, nor use them - they are inferior to any type of input mode at the moment.
Most normal people do not care about them, nor use them.
There is vocal but relatively niche group of tech enthusiasts who are really into it, but they are already a brand loyalists.
On a side note - the whole concept of brand loyalty is completely idiotic from consumer PoV. There is no merit for the customer in it.