News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Taek on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:05AM (#24331554)
I think this is a very good move for China and think the US should match it.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by _6fmb on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:47AM (#24331973)
If you actually read the article we already outspend them on R&D. We spent 2.8% of GDP vs their 2.2% of GDP. They failed to meet their target of 2.5% of GDP despite steadily increasing.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:27PM (#24333010)
Novel R&D is more expensive than incremental catch-up R&D; you can catch up by spending less money since by definition you at least know where you're going.

When you take into account that China's GDP is 70% of the US but has a PPP factor of about 1.6 (i.e. the same amount of US dollars goes 60% further in China than it would notionally in America) they're actually spending what amounts 2.6% of the US GDP in PPP dollars.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fred_is_fred on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:41PM (#24333176)
Also on a per output basis spies are cheaper than scientists.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:48PM (#24334007)
Yes.

(a) that changes nothing about what I said, and...

(b) do you really, truly, honestly, believe that if America were behind in tech the first thing they'd do wouldn't be to send in the spies? Of course they would. I know because that's what I would do. As a leader my obligation is to my people at the end of the day -- and this is true -- who's going to stop me?

In what world would you sit back and say, well, I think it'd be better if we just figured it out on our own, fair and square lol.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fred_is_fred on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:47PM (#24349530)
I never claimed anything you said in b).
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Hnrobert42 on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:30PM (#24334472)
No. The U.S. intell community does not do that, empirically. There isn’t even the apparatus for doing that. The US IC’s ties to industry, apart from defense contractors and communications, are very tenuous, hamstrung by clearance and classification problem and a very insular culture.

So, in addition to being factually incorrect, is very damaging to the national discourse to normalize CPC’s strategy of wholesale IP theft.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:01PM (#24334812)
The US intel community (a) doesn't need to do that because in general US tech is world-class and (b) wouldn't be very good at their jobs if they admitted to it publicly. I suggest you review your Cold War history for examples of when both sides were absolutely stealing each others' technology.

When you're top dog, your job is largely counter-intelligence.

> So, in addition to being factually incorrect, is very damaging to the national discourse to normalize CPC’s strategy of wholesale IP theft.

Hold on, at what point did I suggest it shouldn't be combatted - or that it was okay? I'm saying we should expect them to try and do so. I absolutely think the US should fight back. That's the game.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Hnrobert42 on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:48PM (#24360390)
You are normalizing CPC actions by stating that the US does it or would do it in the CPC’s position.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Friday September 04, 2020 @02:49AM (#24372370)
It’s normal in that every country would do it given half the chance. That doesn’t make it okay, and it doesn’t mean that countries on the other end should roll over and take it. I’m just saying we shouldn’t sit here gobsmacked that it’s happening. We should assume it’s happening at all times and beef up defenses precisely because it is so normal.

The US absolutely does it, has done it and will do it again. That doesn’t mean chinas not defending themselves against it.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by landryraccoon on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:55PM (#24335322)
> is very damaging to the national discourse to normalize CPC’s strategy of wholesale IP theft.

Can you clarify why? China is a state actor. State actors generally can be expected to act in self serving ways. What would be the basis for preventing espionage? Is this a moral argument that spying is evil?

Of course countries should protect themselves from foreign espionage if they can, but I don’t see what blame accomplishes, unless you are willing to have a hot war to stop spying.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Hnrobert42 on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:49PM (#24360392)
The moral argument is that theft is wrong. Further, it discourages innovation.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by nextaccountic on Monday August 31, 2020 @07:16PM (#24336847)
The US intel community engaged in industrial espionage against Brazil's Petrobras. A third world country.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/09/nsa-spying-bra...

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Hnrobert42 on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:56PM (#24360424)
That article foes not substantiate your claim. That article says Snowden-leaked data shows the NSA collected information on Petrobras. There is no indication why. There is no information suggesting the NSA provided that information to US businesses or gathered the information for anything other than national security purposes.

If you have something other than speculation that backs up your claim, I am happy to consider it. But this is not it.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by SuoDuanDao on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:32AM (#24332467)
Maintaining a lead could be a good idea all the same though...
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by kkylin on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:16PM (#24332898)
Genuinely curious: to what extent is that because the numerator didn't grow enough, and to what extent is it because the denominator grew too quickly?
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by _6fmb on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:46PM (#24333249)
If you read the article, it says the numerator grew faster than the denominator, and analysts think progress is good and not meeting the target this year is not a problem.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by kkylin on Monday August 31, 2020 @06:37PM (#24336580)
I didn't get a chance (almost always read HN comments first). Thanks for the summary!
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:28AM (#24332426)
I wonder how it would look if there was some magical way to view it on an ROI basis.

Rather than focusing on R&D (science & technology presumably), I'd like to see Western countries start approaching ~"the humanities" (culture, society, happiness, etc) the same way we treat technology and industry. To me it seems fairly clear that there are distinct differences at the human satisfaction level between different countries/cultures. I have the sense that Western countries are starting to fall behind in some categories, the consequences of which first began showing up in our political discourse/mood, which has now progressed to literally spilling out onto the streets. Rather than our current laissez faire approach to this aspect of life, could treating it as a serious first class intellectual problem yield positive results?

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by AlexTWithBeard on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:04PM (#24332759)
According to the world happiness report [1] first 20 places are taken by "western" countries.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report#2019_Wo...

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:12PM (#24333570)
It would be interesting to know how accurate that estimation is. It would also be interesting to know how many people deeply and unambiguously realize that such studies are speculative estimates (as opposed to facts), and why that is the case.

It is metaphysical-type questions like this that seem to get very little formal attention and funding. I would like to see humanity devote more effort to this type of initiative, and less towards optimizing advertising, making phones thinner, games more addicting, developing technology to send the ultra-wealthy into space, etc.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sct202 on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:14PM (#24332874)
China once had a large emphasis on humanities, the Imperial Exams used to be primarily tests and essays on classical books, philosophy, and poetry. Science, engineering, and math were not important. It did not turn out well for them.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:02PM (#24333441)
From a logical perspective, should one conclude from this that effort invested into the humanities is a waste of time? If not, what meaning should one take from it (and, how might we confirm whether that meaning is reasonably optimal from a "social engineering" perspective)?

The explicit mechanics of how society makes optimized decisions on public policy and spending seems like an area that needs improvement. Specific areas of what I refer to are global climate change, rules on wearing masks during pandemics, taxation, etc - the manner in which we currently approach such questions seems extremely sub-optimal to me, to the degree that I sometimes wonder if some approaches may be in part designed to be confusing and dysfunctional.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by justicezyx on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:49PM (#24333274)
Imperial exams only normally emphasize humanity.

Like any aristocracy, the ruling class is born and raised to care not the humanity, but their humanity's value to them.

Imperial exams amplify those value and ideology by enforcing a strict caste systems in the classic reading, etc. That's not emphasis on humanity, that's emphasis on human caste.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by smeeth on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:09PM (#24332820)
You said the "humanities", but the examples of research you'd like were from the "social sciences". The humanities deals with fields like comparative literature, poetry, history, Russian language studies, etc. I am personally quite happy my tax dollars do not fund a lot of that, though I know not everyone feels this way.

Psychology and sociology are the fields that study the human happiness or social dynamics issues you referenced, and both funded by the NSF[0], so is it just that you wish they had more funding?

[0] https://www.nsf.gov/about/research_areas.jsp

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:53PM (#24333343)
> You said the "humanities", but the examples of research you'd like were from the "social sciences".

If we're being pedantic, I'd like to point out what I actually said:

>> ~"the humanities" (culture, society, happiness, etc)

It appears I've made an error in terminology, but I would have anticipated the additional words I included would have rectified my error. Apparently my heuristics failed in this case.

> Psychology and sociology are the fields that study the human happiness or social dynamics issues you referenced, and both funded by the NSF[0], so is it just that you wish they had more funding?

Generally, I would like us to fund anyone who has novel ideas that may offer useful insight into the state of affairs on the planet, which largely derives from human actions and interactions. The quirkiness of specific forum conversations (this one, for example) is one class of interactions where I believe we could learn something useful that may shed light on broader trends we see in society, if we put some serious effort into it.

I'd have to review the specifics of what the NSF is studying and the results, but from an armchair commentator perspective (observing the general state of the world and the quality of public discourse) I wouldn't expect they are producing useful insights - although, it's completely possible they produce excellent results, and are completely being ignored (which should be noticed in a proper review).

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by smeeth on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:58PM (#24334116)
I apologize if my comment came across as pedantic, I certainly wasn't trying to be.

The way research in the humanities and social sciences are conducted are fundamentally different, which is why I think the lexical distinction is important in this case. Most social science research applies the scientific method (hypothesis testing etc.), most humanities research does not.

>The quirkiness of specific forum conversations (this one, for example) is one class of interactions where I believe we could learn something useful that may shed light on broader trends we see in society, if we put some serious effort into it.

I agree.

>although, it's completely possible they produce excellent results, and are completely being ignored (which should be noticed in a proper review)

If I had to bet on it I'd say this is the answer, though I'd add that in addition to being ignored the research is being used in ways you and I wouldn't like. I know for example that app/social media development 2005-today relied/rely heavily on psychological research pertaining to addiction, human computer interaction, etc. I'm positive some of that was NSF funded.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mistermann on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:14PM (#24334272)
What I'm getting at, in not a very effective way, is that I see low hanging fruit everywhere I look, and I don't think I'm the only one. Where I do think I may differ, is that I also sense a strong aversion to discussing this low hanging fruit in extreme detail and unconventional ways.

For example, plenty of people think climate change is a legitimate threat, and that prudent societal responses are hampered by imperfections in democracy, and that beliefs such as racism play a role in voting choices. Nothing very controversial (from an HN perspective) so far I don't think. But an invisible line that I sense cannot be crossed here is the underlying reasons why people "are" "racist", or the degree to which mass heuristic-based theory of mind estimations (~mind reading) like this are even true, or even happening. Introduce this style of thinking and one will surely be rewarded with downvotes, if not stern "culture war guidelines violations" warnings. But one thing you'll never get is any substantial justification or reasoning behind why there are peer-enforced guard rails on things like:

- what can be discussed

- how (from what perspectives) certain things can be discussed

- at what level of detail things can be discussed

I think there is something very interesting going on here, and that there seems to be this strong, almost universal/multi-dimensional aversion to discussing it (the phenomenon) makes me even more curious.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by smeeth on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:20PM (#24335520)
It sounds like you should pursue a PhD ;)

Yeah, I agree with you - those are important questions I wish we had better answers to.

I'm early into a research career though not in these fields and I'm starting to observe that knowing the problems that need solving/questions that need answering is often trivial when compared to actually solving the problems or answering the obvious question. That might be part of the issue here too, just my 2c.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by squidlogic on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:50AM (#24332641)
Unfortunately the humanities succumbed to postmodernism long ago. Since then it has been impossible to impose strict tests on veracity as you find in hard sciences.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by maedla on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:51AM (#24332659)
What do you mean?
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by squidlogic on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:26PM (#24336127)
Postmodernism teaches (among many things) that truth is not objective. Rather, the epistemological center in postmodernism IS the self. Each self has its own version of truth, rather than truth being perspective-independent.

In literature, for example, this means that authorial intent is supplanted by perspectivalism. That is, each reader interprets a text based on his or her own perspective, and each interpretation is equally valid. This plays out in the political realm most prominently in the supreme court's interpretation of laws (does it matter what the author meant to say or just what we now interpret them to have said?).

So when I say it's impossible for the humanities to impose strict tests on veracity, what I mean is that a strict test would yield true results that are perspective-independent. This is what the scientific method attempts to accomplish, and the hard sciences use this methodology. The humanities, however, have long ceded that it is impossible to arrive at a perspective-independent conclusion and IMO would therefore reject a similarly rigorous approach.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by chillacy on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:19PM (#24333642)
I can only guess but art is now considered to be inherently subjective. So you there's no way to make statements like "picasso is better than jackson pollock", or "cubism is not real art".

Going further there are a number of works meant to probe the exact limit of what we're willing to consider art. I recall a couple interesting ones:

1. An artist took a shit in a can and sealed it up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artist%27s_Shit

2. I recall there was an artist who took an existing book and changed the author name to their own, I can't find a link right now though.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by cma on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:25AM (#24332398)
But their purchasing power parity is way higher so presumably they get more for less, other than stuff they have to import to support research.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:34AM (#24332495)
I don't understand why this is downvoted. Money goes further in China than in the US, and the Chinese GDP PPP is indeed higher than the US, although barely.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Gibbon1 on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:20PM (#24335523)
A lot of what's spent in the US goes towards private rents. Money that goes towards rents is a waste. Most don't see it because it's everywhere. Either directly or indirectly. You pay more per sqft for an office, but you also pay more per hour for labor, because the guy you hires also pays rent[1]. Things cost more because the supply chain has to pay rents.

[1] Consider a lot of workers half their income goes to rent.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by newen on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:50PM (#24334028)
$27.8 trillion vs $20.3 trillion is not barely.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:16PM (#24334305)
Holy shit. Not even a year ago it was 23.4 to 21.4, not only did the coronavirus do a number on the US economy, but Chinese growth has been simply explosive.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Barrin92 on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:54AM (#24332684)
correct, it's also why the Chinese and Russian military are quite large and potent despite the fact that obviously they spend several times less in absolute terms than the US. In particular salary costs, which tend to be large factors in research or the military, are way lower in China or Russia.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by realradicalwash on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:51AM (#24332025)
indeed, an increase would be good. however, it is worth noting that China and the US are in different situations. the US spends about 2.7%-2.8% of its GDP on R&D and China is catching up to that, according to wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_research_...
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by tuesdayrain on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:02PM (#24335917)
China is increasing spending on R&D, meanwhile America is increasing spending on "diversity training". Top Chinese universities admit the most brilliant students who study tirelessly, American universities actively deny those students due to being "overrepresented" and pick the less competent purely on the basis of skin color. America's bizarre focus on equal outcomes at any cost has actually made it more communist than the CCP in some categories. Who could have guessed? What a tragedy.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by rvba on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:48AM (#24331400)
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by bserge on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:01AM (#24331519)
At the very least we know Chinese companies (and by extension, the government) do indeed spend a lot on research, development and production.

The sheer amount of tech made and shipped from China is astonishing. And the quality has massively improved, while prices stay low. Everything from amazing BGA reballing stations to high quality solar panels and power tools.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by rococode on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:31PM (#24333056)
Yeah, the specific numbers don't matter so much as the desired narrative behind the numbers. Clearly, the government wants to boost R&D.

Regardless of whether or not they have to "adjust" their numbers for one specific year, the fact is that they've set their goalposts at double the R&D growth of the west (both US and EU are at around 5% R&D growth [1]).

Unless in reality they're not even halfway reaching their goals, they're going to overtake the US and EU in spending at some point, probably pretty soon. The graph in the link below (published by the US gov) is quite clear. One of those lines is obviously not like the others.

[1] https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20201/global-r-d

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by gamblor956 on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:44AM (#24332595)
A lot of that IP was stolen from US and EU companies.

Cost isn't the only reason that manufacturing is moving out of China; companies are finally realizing that using Chinese factories is tantamount to giving the PRC access to all of your technical IP.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:31PM (#24333058)
That's an incredibly short-sighted way of looking at what's happening. If you want to become a Chef, you don't start by inventing new Michelin star dishes de novo. You copy your betters. Over and over and over. Then, once you learn how they do what they do, you innovate.

Japan did this. Do not underestimate China.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by frequentnapper on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:54PM (#24336290)
It's one thing to copy. It's another to send your own sous-chefs to work in another chef's kitchen, steal their yet to be released receipes, their research, their actual ingredients even!

Another thing is that Japan is friendly towards us and our values. China seeks to bully and topple every nation that does not bow to it. Not to mention the ongoing genocide and the rise of the superior Han mentality.

There are plenty of countries like India that could do it, but China tops the list not only for stealing from US, but also from every other western country including my own: Canada. See Nortel and how Huawei was created off of stolen tech and research from Nortel and thereby bankrupting Nortel. For the latest trickery, see CanSino covid vaccine.

China and collaboration with China or chinese scientists at this point cannot be trusted at all.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by xenospn on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:35PM (#24333102)
There's one major difference - Japanese companies took mediocre western tech (autos, transistor radios) and made it better. Chinese companies just copy.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by chillacy on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:25PM (#24333713)
Everybody copies at first, then they start making state of the art improvements.

It takes time though, Toyota was founded in 1937, they started by reverse engineering Chrystler cars (they were surprisingly open about this in the Toyota museum). Chinese companies got started maybe around the 1980s with market reforms.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by gamblor956 on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:05PM (#24334183)
The difference is that a chef-in-training works for the Michelin-star chef in the "better" chef's restaurant, and then leaves to start their own restaurant.

China's game plan has been to encourage companies to use Chinese factories based on artificially low prices (subsidized with massive PRC spending), and then to (usually openly) steal the IP and begin making competing products.

This cycle has already happened to over a dozen former clients. I went in-house years ago, but even before then my firm had begun discouraging companies from opening manufacturing facilities in China for any product with any sort of valuable technical IP.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by arcticbull on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:10PM (#24335437)
> The difference is that a chef-in-training works for the Michelin-star chef in the "better" chef's restaurant, and then leaves to start their own restaurant.

> China's game plan has been to encourage companies to use Chinese factories based on artificially low prices (subsidized with massive PRC spending), and then to (usually openly) steal the IP and begin making competing products.

"working for" then "starting their own" yeah. See, you get it.

Your analogy gets even better, just not in ways you expected, in that people who go work at Michelin starred restaurants in the kitchen do so for low-to-zero wages because the real benefit is the experience they're gaining initially.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by 0_____0 on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:56AM (#24332700)
was the same not true with Japan? at some point China may move past Western nations in practical sophistication, and start making better stuff.

example: you want a photography drone? Like, the best commerical one available? It's a Chinese product. Most of the other stuff on the market doesn't come close. The closest we had domestically in the US was 3D systems, and then went under if I recall correctly.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by justicezyx on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:51PM (#24333306)
This rhetoric is becoming more and more false with time...

https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/10/16/china-intellectual-prop...

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by godelski on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:01PM (#24335366)
Your source seems to support the gp's argument. It was written just under a year ago and is talking about a deal not struck.

> According to some reports, Chinese IP theft has cost the United States $225 billion to $600 billion a year. No wonder, then, that getting China to better protect IP is a point of rare consensus among both the White House and the Democratic leadership.

This isn't a small chunk of change. In fact, this is comparable to the R&D budgets the main article is talking about.

It then says

> But history tells us to be cautious; Washington’s demands are unrealistic. Countries do not enact strong IP rights systems until their ability to innovate at home displaces reliance on outside knowledge. The United States’ own century long drift toward strong protections is a case in point.

Which the tldr is: don't expect it to work. So I'm not sure why this becomes less true over time, as this is very recent and doesn't seem to have changed anything. Sure, other countries did it too, but why does that matter? Doesn't make it right.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by justicezyx on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @12:26AM (#24338554)
The subtitle literally writes:

The country is making the transition from net importer of ideas to net innovator, and as it does, it is finding that good patent laws matter.

[dead]
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by dang on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:35PM (#24335659)
> "We all know that Chinese are NOT capable of innovation"

That's a slur, you can't do that here, and we've banned this account.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. That means, at minimum, not posting unsubstantive comments and not posting nationalistic (or other) flamebait, both of which your account was unfortunately doing a lot of.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Aperocky on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:02AM (#24331525)
Most R&D are gov sponsored and comes with receipts, so they are mostly true.

Of course a decent amount get lost due to corruption, but that's always the case.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by BurningFrog on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:43AM (#24331946)
Not really.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mensetmanusman on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:55AM (#24331468)
In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by ardy42 on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:04AM (#24331543)
> In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression.

I wouldn't say it's that clear cut. Even if the R&D is not directly for technology for repression, it increases that power and prestige of a state that has few qualms with using repression for political ends. Those increases could mean that other states will come under its influence or emulate its repressive example (when they would have otherwise emulated less-repressive or non-repressive examples).

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:14AM (#24331628)
Can you give an example of a significant power, any time in history, that did have a lot of qualms with using repression for political ends?

Even the Athenians had slaves.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by gpm on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:44AM (#24331954)
The US?

They do it, but they have a lot of qualms about it.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:36AM (#24332511)
Nah, the US only has qualms at all at repressing their domestic citizens. No issues repressing foreigners and some minorities since ever.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by ardy42 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:23PM (#24345851)
> Nah, the US only has qualms at all at repressing their domestic citizens. No issues repressing foreigners and some minorities since ever.

No, that's false. An easy example is waterboarding. One administration used it (on foreigners), but it was enormously controversial domestically.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by detritus on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:17AM (#24331667)
The EU?
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by aloisdg on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:22AM (#24331726)
Each country of the EU has some dark corners, but I am still trusting them more than I would trust the USA, China or Russia.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by StreamBright on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:00AM (#24332119)
I used to think I could trust the EU more than he rest. No more. Wirecard story shows how much this trust is misplaced.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by bilekas on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:09PM (#24333530)
Well this is a ridiculous statement. That's like saying you don't trust the US anymore because ENRON messed up. Nonsense. The Germans are investigating it, and as always they will make changes to prevent the nonsense again. Ironically enough, it stemmed from the US model of too many lobbyists. :D
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by StreamBright on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:17PM (#24346510)
How is it going to help those people who lost their income in the middle of the COVID outbrake? Should I just trust the German authorities with the same trust as 1 year ago? Sorry but no.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:20AM (#24331703)
That's actually a decent answer, thanks. But they're an economic-only organization.

The EU didn't bomb Libya, France and Britain did.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by detritus on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:08PM (#24332804)
I'd wager that it's more of a Political Union (hence Brexit, to a degree?) and is still too young to have meddled much in an overall coherent military strategy. Time will tell.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by exdsq on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:41AM (#24331919)
One of the arguments for Brexit was that they’re becoming far more than an economic-only organisation
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:47AM (#24331981)
Yeah, and the handling of the Greece situation a few years ago proved that politics abound over justice or sanity in all arenas.

It'll be interesting to see how it develops, they're clearly more of a governing body than the UN, but also seem to have steered clear of anything close to a security issue.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by im3w1l on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:19AM (#24332340)
I think a reason that the EU is so well behaved is that the politicians know that they don't just compete with each other, they compete also with the non-existence of the EU.

With time, as it entrenches and everyone believes in their hearts that the EU is going nowhere, then it will be less nice.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by Hnrobert42 on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:31PM (#24334496)
Whataboutism.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:37PM (#24336195)
"What about Iraq" would have been whataboutism.

"What about literally everyone else, in all of time" is what I said.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by wintermutestwin on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:15AM (#24331653)
I wonder if anyone has tried to measure repression's "drag coefficient" effect on creativity.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by rmrfstar on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:01PM (#24333432)
The origin of Operation Paperclip [1] researchers is not heartening for the "repression research drag" thesis.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Paperclip

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fleischhauf on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:34AM (#24331837)
This is a very interesting question and one would hope that non repressive societies are more creative and have a higher scientific output. Im not 100 % sure thats the case, however.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by wintermutestwin on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:49AM (#24331993)
It seems to me that it would have to. If your society punishes/limits/eliminates divergent behavior and thought, you are throttling your innovation lever.

I think that rising D&I budgets are a recognition of this truth.

It seems like common sense to me, but I'd be interested to know if it has been studied/measured...

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by im3w1l on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:27AM (#24332425)
As long as you pay lip service to the right politics you can innovate as much as you want in science and technologies. You are free to use tabs for indentation or write your webservice in brainfuck if you want.

What can be a drag on innovation is if there is nepotism. If the leader appoints his good-for-nothing nephew to science minister. Or if there is corruption, and well connected incumbents throw up endless barriers for innovative upcomers. Or if organized crime steal too much value from the productive people.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:37AM (#24332530)
Indeed. That's why the USSR has some really good scientific research sponsored by the state while a lot of the good art was underground.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fsflover on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:23PM (#24333697)
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:02PM (#24334158)
In this context I wouldn't really include the social sciences, which leaves Biology and Cybernetics that were indeed suppressed for 20-30 years.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fsflover on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:16PM (#24334298)
why wouldn't you include the societal sciences?
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:23PM (#24334383)
Because the comment I was replying to was referring to hard sciences and technological fields, where you can pay lip service to the ideology and go do your research.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by fsflover on Monday August 31, 2020 @01:14PM (#24333590)
> As long as you pay lip service to the right politics you can innovate as much as you want in science and technologies.

Unless you innovate in some field detrimental to the government, e.g. education, anonymity, freedom etc.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by im3w1l on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:23PM (#24335047)
Cryptography is two-sided. It includes both attacking existing ciphers and inventing new ones which withstand attacks. I would think they will welcome your contributions but keep them secret.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:55AM (#24332075)
In China, professors have to periodically write essays about how they're ideologically committed to the party goals in order to keep funding and not be fired. These goals are all nice sounding things about national prosperity and such, everyone knows what they're supposed to write, it's a minor chore.

In the US, they're only doing this at hire time for D&I so far. We'll see where it goes from there.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by whoevercares on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:03AM (#24332162)
Don’t exaggerate it, people use template to do it. In China most of those are just a process thing, nobody even look at it
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by free_rms on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:06AM (#24332192)
Same in the US for the pro-diversity essays as I understand it -- I was trying to make a comparison.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by ardy42 on Monday August 31, 2020 @02:33PM (#24334520)
> This is a very interesting question and one would hope that non repressive societies are more creative and have a higher scientific output. Im not 100 % sure thats the case, however.

Even if the repressive societies have lower overall research effectiveness, it may be higher in some areas that really matter geopolitically (e.g. military R&D). IIRC, many talented Western scientists boycott military projects for moral reasons, because they live in societies that celebrate taking personal moral stands like that. The talented scientists in a repressive society have different social influences, any may be far less likely to have a problem with military research.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by mensetmanusman on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:12AM (#24332263)
It probably is, because the amount of distrust of others in places like China/Russia is off the charts hard for westerners to understand. That level of friction would be horrible for research.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by whoevercares on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:00AM (#24332127)
It really depends on the level of repression or how smart the authority imposes it. West media depicts China’s repression as if it’s the same level as North Korea and then people believe it —- it’s far from it and in fact has very little impact on student and researchers life. The China’s authority did it in a way that’s almost transparent, that’s not too hard given the the overall awareness for citizen rights among Chinese people
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by wolco on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:51AM (#24332018)
They would have a higher variety of output.
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by ausbah on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:49AM (#24331994)
the amount / fraction of money spent on R&D by militaries, especially by the US, would make me think this isn't an issue. most people don't think about the long term impact of their work
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by ComodoHacker on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:00AM (#24332124)
Is improvement in quality of face recognition 'good for humanity'?
Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by bilekas on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:56PM (#24333371)
This is one of those technologies that if in the hands of good faith actors could provide some positive results, like criminal tracking etc.

But in the real world, its never just in the right hands.. Sigh yet it will still be perfected.. :|

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by 8note on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:07PM (#24334863)
That doesn't sound like the good actor value.

The most obvious value I'd see is getting rid of the scan in for the amazon stores, so it's a real walk, in walk out experience

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by alfalfasprout on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:19PM (#24332936)
One thing I’ve noticed is that although eg; investing in R&D and STEM education in China has skyrocketed in the last 5-ish years in practice tech there still doesn’t seem extremely polished and talent coming to the US has been iffy on average (with the exception of the very top talent which is still excellent).

A good proportion of Chinese research is still rampantly fraudulent and of the legitimate research only a small fraction ends up being truly innovative. This implies a low return on R&D investment.

The same applies to software projects. At least in the OSS world you rarely see quality projects coming from China nowadays. The ones that do are almost always from companies with a US presence. Perhaps collaboration is difficult?

Re: Face recognition— this is something that is so clearly going to be used as a tool for oppression yet when I speak to those currently in the mainland they sing its praises in dealing w/ COVID. We will see how the cards fall when COVID is over. My guess is you won’t see ethnic Uyghurs living in mainland China 15 years from now.

Of course, every time a post about China comes up someone goes “oh but the US is the same”. No, it’s really not. The US has its fair share of issues with domestic spying and definitely some degree of repression but we still have a free and open internet, open discourse is permitted, and tools like strong encryption are widely available and even assisted in development by the government (eg; Tor).

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by bilekas on Monday August 31, 2020 @12:53PM (#24333340)
> there still doesn’t seem extremely polished and talent coming to the US has been iffy on average

What does this matter ? Can't they stay in China ?

> This implies a low return on R&D investment.

Whatever about the ethics of it, the work has been done by others they are stealing it from, im not sure how that's a low return..

> from companies with a US presence. Perhaps collaboration is difficult?

Or easier to do business in the US with offices there..

Honestly your whole point just seems to look for stereotype-ish grievances to air.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by xster on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:57AM (#24339198)
> My guess is you won’t see ethnic Uyghurs living in mainland China 15 years from now.

Considering the Uyghur population doubled in the last 50 years, they're not doing a very good job at it.

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by 8note on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:12PM (#24334927)
The ethnic Uyghurs bit is the same though?

The US has a lot of places with names like Sioux Falls, but where there's no Sioux living there anymore

Re:China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10% by tresCommatoso on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:04PM (#24334841)
What if - we hypothetical assume that china one day would become a normal nation, ruled by a democratic elected government - with power divided by checks and balances, and a rule of law. Now lets further assume that any company, that lost ip to the "old regime" gained a title in a international court that upholds, no matter the current regime. These titles would have value - that even would increase (after all its parked money). Thus a company, making a loss due to ip theft, could sell of those future earnings - for example to a bank.

A bank, could hold on to the title and use it to for example collect the owned money of the title from people who are involved in the ownership of the title - as ccp members or parts of a company owned by the ccp.

That way ip-theft, would be nothing, but debt taken from the international community.. and as the title collection would make it rather bad for those taking the debt..the accumulating debt would make the regime go bankrupt.