As you're riding along, if you notice the engine running out of fuel, you reach down and flip the fuel switch and you have access to a little more fuel (and you know to head to a gas station soonish).
Neither my MV Agusta nor my BMW S1000R have fuel gauges. The BMW does the odometer trick itself though to estimate remaining mileage. It's often way out of course, depending on throttle usage.
(It's possible the BMW has a meter but it doesn't present a level, only miles remaining. I still think it's a style thing - something you don't put on sport bikes.)
It never really made any sense, but now that race bikes have tire pressure sensors and full color LCD instruments it is really spectacularly dumb to not have gauges.
Any of the popular crotch rockets have had fuel gauges forever. I think it's mostly just crazy race/rep bikes like BMW and Aprilla (so i guess the guys that only make sport bikes in 300 or 1000+) that don't have gauges
- when you're in heavy complicated traffic and the engine starts cutting out
- when you forget to flip the switch back after filling up
- you more modern motorcycle with a "reserve" indicator below the speedometer (which is below your field of vision when riding and you don't notice)
For example, assume a 90% charge efficiency for a battery at 20C... or whatever makes sense.
See e.g. https://imgur.com/a/9LsrjIR
Right?
As far as aircraft goes, it's sufficient to put a lower bound on the remaining charge. Realistically, the poor (abysmal, really) energy density of batteries pretty much precludes their usage in any serious aircraft. For sustainable air flight I'm more optimistic about syngas or hydrogen.
They might be more palatable for aircraft.
Furthermore batteries don't get lighter as their charge is expended, as opposed to fuel that gets burned off. This means a plane powered by batteries has to land with the same mass of fuel as it does when it takes off. Many aircraft are worse at decelerating themselves than accelerating. This means they can actually take off with more mass than they can land, thus extending their range. This can't happen for battery powered planes.
Hydrogen powered planes is less far fetched than it seems. The Soviets built a prototype: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-155
Cryogenic storage of hydrogen is less difficult than it seems. Because the engines are constantly drawing fuel from the fuel tank, the tank's pressure is constantly dropping which cools it down. Most of the difficulty around hydrogen storage is in long term storage where hydrogen permitting through the vessel is a concern. The main challenge for applying it to aircraft is being able to make a vessel light enough and in a form factor suitable for planes, namely fitting it in the wing.
While Polonium-210 is incredibly toxic, it does have a half-life of 138 days. If you do have a crash then in <8 years you'd only have about a gram of it left.
The main tricky part is that we produce about 100 grams of it a year. But what's a little scaling up for a startup anyway?
(I'm sure I made a calculation error here somewhere.)
But yeah, I think it would need lots of development to get battery technology to do something like a ny-tokyo flight. It might only work for short hop service.
I guess that's how it has worked for battery electric trucks. The first one basically did short, known routes around town with lots of stop/start. That controlled the parameters and made it feasible. I don't know if battery powered trucks will ever replace long-haul trucks unless batteries get lots better or charging gets really fast.
Lithium ion batteries don't like crashing into each other either. The article mentioned that lithium sulfide batteries degrade differently than lithium ion, so fires as a result of heavy use may be reduced, but fires as a result of unscheduled disassembly seem likely, and could be worse than fuel --- you can dump fuel or circle to use it up, but you can't (probably) dump batteries, so you're always going to have lithium available. Not sure if the lithium sulfur compounds are less flamible than the compounds found in lithium ion.
I'm joking, mostly.
(and your idea is brilliant, it should jokingly be called "blue ice")
Have 10 small batteries, that you go through one by one, instead of the single big one. You only need to start worrying on the 10th one.
In RAID 4 you had a dedicated parity disk. What if you allocated one of your 10 batteries as the "parity". It would not be used until the others had ran out of charge (as originally expressed above)
And to prevent uneven wear levels, each time you plug in to charge, the parity battery changes to one of the other 10 randomly (or on a pattern but the end result is the same).
So over time, assuming your prng was decent, you would have an even wear level.
You'd probably want maybe two batteries as your parity in case of failure but it would still work.
I'm on my first coffee and it hasn't properly kicked in but it sounds plausible in my head :)
Reserving, say, 10% of your overall capacity would add much less strain on the system and still give you the most important part of the results. Conventional techniques such as Coulomb counting and estimation from voltage are still probably more practical but it's fun to consider alternatives. :)
It's also one of the reasons you get electronics that die suddenly at 5%- current gas gauges usually account for it, but older stuff wasn't always good at knowing when the voltage would drop off. Nowadays (and always, for the most part) the sudden shutoff is because electronics often pull very brief power spikes that drop the battery voltage below the minimum voltage temporarily. The chemistry takes a moment to recover after that.
The problem with Li-S batteries isn't just that they have a goofy curve- that can be charted and saved, even as the battery degrades (Note- I'm mostly up on conventional chemistry. Don't know much about Li-S). It's more have a couple phases they go through during discharge. Impedance and other properties of the battery change, which changes the discharge characteristics of the battery, which changes the voltage. Proportionally, the swing in voltage is also larger (although this kind of thing is always changing, so I may be out of date).
There's also a small amount of self-discharge and parasitic reactions that will consume electrons, but that number is necessarily fairly small and predictable. The main thing is that 50% of the energy variance is in the voltage, and you need to know a lot about the current chemistry inside the battery (as well as the future load profile) to be able to predict the voltage that all the remaining electrons will have as they leave the battery.
My 1990 Toyota never read full. The buffer on the fuel sender was so extreme that by the time the needle made it to the "F" I had already burned 1/8 of a tank! My current car warns me when I have about 50 miles of fuel left, I wonder how much historical data it uses in that calculation.
None of my motorcycles even have fuel gauges. I just keep an eye on the odometer and when I stop to stretch my legs I give the tank a shake or a peek.
For more than you'd ever want to know about the fuel systems in a modern airliner, see http://www.b737.org.uk/fuel.htm
They aren't. On light aircraft, the only thing they're good for is as a double check on a manual fuel reading (using a dipstick) or a time-based calculation, and to confirm during flight that the fuel cap wasn't left off. Beyond that, the needles bounce around so much during flight the only thing you can really verify is "yes there's some liquid there; somewhere between empty and full".
Many light aircraft owners have since retrofitted "fuel totalizers" which measure fuel consumption, and are manually reset by the pilot to a dipstick value when fuel is added. My group aircraft's fuel totalizer seems accurate to within at least about 10%. It can be calibrated better, but manual dipstick readings are only accurate to a couple of gallons anyway.
However, one key difference is that I do know, to within about half an hour, my fuel endurance before departure. I'd want the same from a battery.
I initially read this comment thinking you meant floating-point based...
"The upshot is that voltage is not a good proxy for the state of charge and, to make things even more complicated, the voltage curve is asymmetrical for charge and for discharge."
Since it would be bad if your battery suddenly died and you dropped out of the sky, they had to develop complex statistical and neural network algorithms to accurately determine state of charge to within a few percent. One black box for staying in the sky and another in case you end up on the ground!