Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes
by toast0 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @03:14AM
(#24220718)
> I could make the argument that fuels that burn are unsuitable for automobiles which crash into each other frequently.
Lithium ion batteries don't like crashing into each other either. The article mentioned that lithium sulfide batteries degrade differently than lithium ion, so fires as a result of heavy use may be reduced, but fires as a result of unscheduled disassembly seem likely, and could be worse than fuel --- you can dump fuel or circle to use it up, but you can't (probably) dump batteries, so you're always going to have lithium available. Not sure if the lithium sulfur compounds are less flamible than the compounds found in lithium ion.
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes
by manfredo on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:21PM
(#24224858)
You're correct that batteries are much more suitable for cars, especially commuter vehicle and things like garbage trucks that have relatively limited routes and sit idle for much of the day. There's why were seeing electrification take hold in cars, way before it takes hold in planes (if ever).
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes
by fus on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:10PM
(#24237367)
Diesel fuel won't burn as gasoline does.
Gasoline is ok here to, if compared to a hydrogen-oxygen mixture explosion ;)
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes
by faeyanpiraat on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:08AM
(#24221359)
Look at some yt videos of li-ion or li-po fires, this will change your mind
But yeah, I think it would need lots of development to get battery technology to do something like a ny-tokyo flight. It might only work for short hop service.
I guess that's how it has worked for battery electric trucks. The first one basically did short, known routes around town with lots of stop/start. That controlled the parameters and made it feasible. I don't know if battery powered trucks will ever replace long-haul trucks unless batteries get lots better or charging gets really fast.