News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by BurningFrog on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:52PM (#24219064)
No clue how technically feasible this is, but conceptually I like it:

Have 10 small batteries, that you go through one by one, instead of the single big one. You only need to start worrying on the 10th one.

Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by taneq on Thursday August 20, 2020 @02:35AM (#24220498)
It could work, and it'd certainly give you a good 'ground truth', but there's a couple of reasons currently why it's probably not the best option. Batteries tend to wear out faster when they're deeply discharged, and when they're discharged rapidly. This approach would rapidly, deeply discharge some of your batteries instead of slightly discharging all of them. You could work around it with a sort of 'wear leveling' type battery management system but you'll still be reducing the life of the batteries compared with using the cells all at once.
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by _Understated_ on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:29AM (#24221489)
So it's kinda like RAID 4 then?

In RAID 4 you had a dedicated parity disk. What if you allocated one of your 10 batteries as the "parity". It would not be used until the others had ran out of charge (as originally expressed above)

And to prevent uneven wear levels, each time you plug in to charge, the parity battery changes to one of the other 10 randomly (or on a pattern but the end result is the same).

So over time, assuming your prng was decent, you would have an even wear level.

You'd probably want maybe two batteries as your parity in case of failure but it would still work.

I'm on my first coffee and it hasn't properly kicked in but it sounds plausible in my head :)

Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by taneq on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:13PM (#24230919)
This idea certainly has more legs than the first one. It's like a battery equivalent of the reserve tank that motorcycles (used to?) have. You run until the engine cuts out, then you flip the valve to switch to the reserve tank and you know you have at least 100km or whatever left to find a petrol station.

Reserving, say, 10% of your overall capacity would add much less strain on the system and still give you the most important part of the results. Conventional techniques such as Coulomb counting and estimation from voltage are still probably more practical but it's fun to consider alternatives. :)

Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by zensavona on Thursday August 20, 2020 @07:54AM (#24222284)
Also, lithium batteries which have a higher total capacity can deliver more consistent current with less strain and voltage sag, so it's advantageous both for performance and longevity to have bigger cells.
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by hvidgaard on Thursday August 20, 2020 @03:27AM (#24220775)
If you have the ability to tell when you get somewhere in the region of 10-30% charge, you could always switch there and not deep discharge unless you really have to.
Re:Ultralight lithium-sulfur batteries for electric airplanes by edaemon on Thursday August 20, 2020 @03:43AM (#24220861)
The discharge rate could still damage the batteries.